I can not believe that people actually think that Nine Inch Nails wrote this song. This is not at all the type of song a man like Trent Resnor would right. Trent Resnor never wen't through pain like this. Only a man like Johnny Cash could have written a masterpiece such as this. Go ahead and argue with me. I have proof that I am right on my channel. You will admit I'm right after you have watched the videos on my channel that proove that Johnny Cash wrote the song Hurt.
First thing first : if you did not buy "The Downward Spiral", then go buy it, because it's a masterpiece. If you never watched "Fight Club" : go watch it, it's an amazing movie ! And both get along very well together.
I cant decide which version i like, NIN or the Cash cover.......thier both great. NIN wrote an amazing song, Johnny cash used it to say goodbye to the world.......this is a song that will stand the test of time regardles
P.S. At the begining I dont know why, but I started laughing smth is very funny about that scene HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAAHHA probably this is not a way that someone could hurt himself...hmph
"cantwaittostartlivin" i dont usually get involved in others arguments, but you are a pathetic person, your false impression of maturity is reflected in your ignorance of refering to cole108's age, your constant commentin even when no one replies, and the fact that you are inevitably goin to reply to this message with some smart ass gibbererish you think you understand, he's 22 (i think), i'm 16, we're both more intelligent than you, deal with it
its funny to mess with angry little people. trolls (like cole) that are so self absorbed with anger are easy to unbalanced. cole is like an angry dancing monkey that we all can sit back and laugh at and be glad we are not that small of heart
A troll is someone who tries to make others angry and entice arguments. They don't get angry themselves because they usually argue about everyone, everything and everywhere and are usually not passionate about the subject they are arguing about.
More to the point trolls will throw reasoning out of the window just to provoke the argument further. And an unreasonable argument has no end never mind a meaningful one.
I am not a troll, I've shown my appreciation for this song and movie many times, as I had stated earlier, oh by the way, I don't sleep with men bud, sorry to get your hopes up.. How does it feel not to have your own children? I mean..look at your name? Your name just dies.. Must be pretty fucking shameful. My heart is small for people such as you, the simple minded.. "I've got no soul, just this fucking hole." Rather suiting don't you think?
Your a fucking retard can't wait to start livin' due to your name it looks like you need to take some of your own advice. I don't live at home nor am I a virgin, OR am single...You REALLY need to get the facts before you insult someone you stupid fuck. As for rahma you can keep going with those fag comments.
where does your anger come from? the name i chose comes from an ancient poem about a life at sea! (correct spelling this time) i wish to see more of the world but i have made a commitment to my family! all i said was cigeratte burn from the movie and you attacked. was there a suicide of a good friend or family member? did you loose something that you will never get back? were you not cared for in your youth the way you felt was needed? what has caused this out pouring of rage and anger?
Thanks for the support raham4! Dealing with angry 22yo canadians that have yet to live a life away from thier mother and father is very annoying! All i was doing was posting some of my favorite lines from Fight Club and this duche felt the need to jump in and run it's mouth. Cole108 go and grow up! get laid, get in to a good realationship have some fun so your not so much of an angery little person any more. Write back when you have grow a better personality.
Are from planet duche bag or what? the two comments i posted above are from the movie fight club!did you even bother watching it before you started posting comments? who the fuck is katy perry? and trendy? im 34yo with a wife and a 14yo son! the 14yo is the trendy one ya pole smoker! Go emo yourself you little angry, depressed, angst filled fag!
I have watched it, infact it is a favorite and sitting in front of me in my entertainment stand, btw, are you happy you had a child at 20? Do you collect welfare and work at a call center?
no dip shit he is adopted and i have a great job with a financial firm that over see's the sale and maint. of heavy equipment. whats it like to be so empty and useless?
He didn't mean to spell "sea" you retard, "oversee" is a legit word, and part of common english vocabulary.
And who the f*ck said having a child at 20 was ever a crime, or something not to be proud of? My friend has 2 children, under training as a pilot for a respectable airline company, and he's doing just fine.
What can you boast of? Making a fool of yourself on the Internet? Seriously, blow me too. I'd love nothing more than watching your humiliated face service my manhood.
Yes you've pointed out a good point, his "Oversee" has a space fool. What is with you internet fags, all you want is for some guy to blow you. Fuck you!
your the one probaly gay or ignorant the only two reasons some one hates gays is the self hating gay or an ignorant dumb shit who has to get on the internet and start a fight instead of doing it face to face but you probably would end up sucking the guys dick because thats the kinda person you are and your kids will hate you so much trust me and the media doesnt make people gay it makes ignorent dumb shits like you
crazydogthing, you really are a first class fucking toddler.. the media creates homosexuals, look at Katy perry's latest hit, if you can't read between the lines then GO THE FUCK BACK TO SCHOOL YOU FOOL. btw, how do you know my sexual orientation? Obviously your gay if your posting to something that is nearly a week old. I don't plan to reply other than this post. Fucking imbecile, go do something productive.
You have got to be the biggest example of a little boy who's mommy and daddy did not love him. Remember your useless death on your back with eyes close? keep spilling your rage on a msg. board with a song called hurt attached to it.(how apropriate you wounded little man) one day if you dont start looking with in your self your infection of rage will become your religion and lead to that useless death of no meaning or value. try a little tenderness
It was fucking incredible, because I at a local bar here on monday night and they covered this song, one of the bartenders and one of my co-workers friend sung, they both did a great job..and it made me look back and think of this video. Oh, and ontop of that, I watched fight club afterwards with someone...well. we watched about 5 minutes of it..
Was that someone you watched five minutes of fight club with named todd or matt or any male for that matter????? and did you pitch or receive? i picture you an angry twink with power bottom issues!
I've been brainwashed by the media to be a godless fuck machine with extreme power trips, a pure megalomaniac at heart. You hit it right on the head you dipshit. It's hard to understand you with your broken sentences and your shitty typing!
how can any one person be such a duche bag? can i ask you a question??? are you a man of god? or do you just twist shit like your katie perry obsession in to fact so your 22 year old mind can make sence of the world? remember you started this fight with your small I.Q. and limited life experiences.
I thought you had more fight in you then this. You might as well waste your time with me. No one else is listening to you, but me. Including those who you think love you. they dont listen to your ramblings. Your broken thoughts are funny to me. Keep typing coward.
I am sorry cole108! I take it all back! Besides being pissed off. What other interests do you have? please forgive my grammer. I am a product of the public school system. I wonder. What could your interest be in? Geology, paleoanthropology, physics i.e. super string theory, oceanography, biochemistry, military science, aviation, world religions? What makes a cole108 interested? Besides fight club, nine inch nails, and being an all around pissed off youth.
Come on cole108 dont give up now! Your angry drive demands it! I thought there was more to you than just giving up after some weak exchanges on a msg board. P.S. what do you know of peace? what creates it? What keeps it going? What does it demand?
Blow what? You'd love to have some dudes lips around your dick wouldn't you..? I think you've been listening to far to much Katy perry if that's the case...you've been turned into a homosexual by the media, guess that would make you an incompetent fool..can't even think for yourself.. Don't worry...you'll assimilate and fit in with the next fashion trend...I'm sure.
we are a generation of men raised by women! if GOD was a model for our fathers and our fathers wanted nothing to do with us. whats that tell us about GOD!
wow give trent his credit for this amazing song they are both good its alll a matter of opinion it dont matter who you think made it famous dont mean its automatically johnnys
great song , fantastic movie,even like brad pit in this film even though he uses his same internal charater as he did in tweleve monkeys, i do like the Cash cover,but we all know he was dying etc and it does pull on the heart strings i know looking back on his life.
Please people. For the final time, just realize that Trent Reznor wrote this song in the 90's and was released on "The Downward Spiral." Johnny Cash covered this song on his COVER ALBUM "American Legend" which only contains one originial. Hey, and guess what.....HURT ISNT THE ORIGINAL. Jesus fucking christ....I swear half of you live to be ignorant through youtube comments. Get a fucking life and research your information before making a permanent post.
rosa, Johnny mentioned that NIN and Soundgarden were his favorites. Even before he released it officially, he would always cover Rusty Cage and Hurt. You are excused since you are a youngster.
People forget how good the mainstream music was from 90-94 (Rock Renaissance).
This version is way edgier and more more emotional than Cash's. People mistake loud singing for emotional singing, here Reznor is melancholy and pensieve, while Cash is merely full of regret.
@ascort106 you're absolutely right. just as long as we're all ok that cash never pushed his voice in his cover-. f%Wk the guy was litterally dying because his lungs were giving up. but this understood, yeah, you're right. completely.
Exactly. He sees that The meaning of a song can be a lot of different things. From some seeing it as just pure mastication,to others seeing it with good values, and this can be done with almost anysong.
But not in that shot. The frame of Tyler was originally standing next to the group leader during that scene. Someone must have chopped him out and added him in.
cah was at his crwative peak his whole life..anything that man does his brilliant...oh and he actually died two weeks after the mucis video was made...in those two weeks he was studying the WORD and talking to God...beautiful
that was fantastic choice of footage and great editing. inspired song choice, too. an amazing piece of work, man :]
Reclaimer117 3 months ago
1:15-16 its brad pitt
iolu4000 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I can not believe that people actually think that Nine Inch Nails wrote this song. This is not at all the type of song a man like Trent Resnor would right. Trent Resnor never wen't through pain like this. Only a man like Johnny Cash could have written a masterpiece such as this. Go ahead and argue with me. I have proof that I am right on my channel. You will admit I'm right after you have watched the videos on my channel that proove that Johnny Cash wrote the song Hurt.
DeliveryManBoy 4 months ago
First thing first : if you did not buy "The Downward Spiral", then go buy it, because it's a masterpiece. If you never watched "Fight Club" : go watch it, it's an amazing movie ! And both get along very well together.
carl13220 6 months ago 2
@carl13220 That album is what made me Like NIN
tonysoprano85 6 months ago
I cant decide which version i like, NIN or the Cash cover.......thier both great. NIN wrote an amazing song, Johnny cash used it to say goodbye to the world.......this is a song that will stand the test of time regardles
zero4666 6 months ago
His name was Robert Paulson.
Oli4drums 9 months ago
aahhh the fat from the lipo clinic hahaha!!! Best movie ever.
robin1734 1 year ago
Love how this was put together! One of my favorite bands and one of my absolute favorite movies!
BKool81 1 year ago 5
Highly dramatic and powerful the way it reflects the song... and yet, I couldn't help but ROTFLMFAO from 1:20-1:40.
JackRussellTerrier2 1 year ago
this is a great video for the song!!!
Bsp200387 1 year ago
Johnny Cash did a cover of this song in 2007 just before he died. NIN was the writer and original performers of this song.
hymwht 1 year ago
@hymwht Sorry, 2003 not 2007
hymwht 1 year ago
@hymwht 2002 but who cares
TheNineinchsnails 1 year ago
what the fuck that was a cover of hurt by johnny cash!
joshmiles09 1 year ago
great video, omg is so depressing, amazing
Alphoter 1 year ago
his name wuz robert paulson ^_^
bassn0te 2 years ago 3
ha you're great
Schneider6126 2 years ago
I think they really fit together, well is what i feel, the song is sad but strong just like the movie... btw amazing video
Alphoter 2 years ago
I like this song.. But there is something i don't like about it too.. I can't really put my finger on it :S
Occhublu1234 2 years ago
the best film and the best song ever ...
but they doesn't fit together... wheres my mind from the pixies fits much better
besterskater 2 years ago
Amazing!
P.S. At the begining I dont know why, but I started laughing smth is very funny about that scene HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAAHHA probably this is not a way that someone could hurt himself...hmph
kostas4444 3 years ago
I will let you down, I will make you hurt. ♥
Josenovich 3 years ago 3
This movie was fuckin freaky, but I LOVED it!
ksb78 3 years ago 8
Awesome movie and awesome song, great job with the video, i lovit
susipunkrockprincess 3 years ago 2
"cantwaittostartlivin" i dont usually get involved in others arguments, but you are a pathetic person, your false impression of maturity is reflected in your ignorance of refering to cole108's age, your constant commentin even when no one replies, and the fact that you are inevitably goin to reply to this message with some smart ass gibbererish you think you understand, he's 22 (i think), i'm 16, we're both more intelligent than you, deal with it
jimdivet 3 years ago
sure you are
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
The first rule about fight club is you dont talk about fight club!!I have a Tyler in my life but he is not really there!!Oh well im strong minded!!!
Jacolbee 3 years ago
Man, Johnny Cash makes any song better.
ShadowColossi 3 years ago
well, he didn't with this one that's for sure. NIN's version is much better.
delpiero47 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
No way, Johnny Cash version is better. That's why I said it. This one is just weird sounding. Reznor can write lyrics but his singing sucks.
ShadowColossi 3 years ago
great video man!
sk8er20984 3 years ago
whoooo cares about stark whatever he say... i love fc, and the song is amazing
Alphoter 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fight club was the most stupidest ass gay fuckin shit queer movie ever made
dumb fucks whoever think it was good.
StrakXT 3 years ago
And here is a typical example of a troll.
1. He uses offensive words in order to try and make somebody angry in order to entice an argument.
2. He makes such extreme accusations which can easily be proven wrong (so that everyone can be given the chance to argue with him).
3. He gives no reason what so ever to why fight club is a bad movie so that he can argue with you for all eternity if he likes.
Herbyy 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
if you think im a troll then i succeeded in offending you but im sorry to say no im not fight club was a piece of shit movie
pS. didnt bother reading what you said after first sentence.
suck a dick nigger jew spick etc.
StrakXT 3 years ago
lol strakxt has some childhood issues
davidholmes282 3 years ago
How do you know what my death will be like, your obviously a narrow minded cunt..
Cole108 3 years ago
What you've described to me is nothing to brag about...
Cole108 3 years ago
you are so empty! sorry that you will die a cold and useless death! on your back with eyes closed.
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
Cole is obviously a troll, why are you still feeding him?
Herbyy 3 years ago
Haha right!
KoGxCHAKRAx 3 years ago
its funny to mess with angry little people. trolls (like cole) that are so self absorbed with anger are easy to unbalanced. cole is like an angry dancing monkey that we all can sit back and laugh at and be glad we are not that small of heart
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
A troll is someone who tries to make others angry and entice arguments. They don't get angry themselves because they usually argue about everyone, everything and everywhere and are usually not passionate about the subject they are arguing about.
More to the point trolls will throw reasoning out of the window just to provoke the argument further. And an unreasonable argument has no end never mind a meaningful one.
Herbyy 3 years ago
I am not a troll, I've shown my appreciation for this song and movie many times, as I had stated earlier, oh by the way, I don't sleep with men bud, sorry to get your hopes up.. How does it feel not to have your own children? I mean..look at your name? Your name just dies.. Must be pretty fucking shameful. My heart is small for people such as you, the simple minded.. "I've got no soul, just this fucking hole." Rather suiting don't you think?
Cole108 3 years ago
Sounds like your missing out on that "Life"
Cole108 3 years ago
living a good life! but the human condition demands that the grass is always greener
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
Your a fucking retard can't wait to start livin' due to your name it looks like you need to take some of your own advice. I don't live at home nor am I a virgin, OR am single...You REALLY need to get the facts before you insult someone you stupid fuck. As for rahma you can keep going with those fag comments.
Cole108 3 years ago
where does your anger come from? the name i chose comes from an ancient poem about a life at sea! (correct spelling this time) i wish to see more of the world but i have made a commitment to my family! all i said was cigeratte burn from the movie and you attacked. was there a suicide of a good friend or family member? did you loose something that you will never get back? were you not cared for in your youth the way you felt was needed? what has caused this out pouring of rage and anger?
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
its funny how you chose the song hurt to launch your rage
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
Thanks for the support raham4! Dealing with angry 22yo canadians that have yet to live a life away from thier mother and father is very annoying! All i was doing was posting some of my favorite lines from Fight Club and this duche felt the need to jump in and run it's mouth. Cole108 go and grow up! get laid, get in to a good realationship have some fun so your not so much of an angery little person any more. Write back when you have grow a better personality.
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
Are from planet duche bag or what? the two comments i posted above are from the movie fight club!did you even bother watching it before you started posting comments? who the fuck is katy perry? and trendy? im 34yo with a wife and a 14yo son! the 14yo is the trendy one ya pole smoker! Go emo yourself you little angry, depressed, angst filled fag!
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
I have watched it, infact it is a favorite and sitting in front of me in my entertainment stand, btw, are you happy you had a child at 20? Do you collect welfare and work at a call center?
Cole108 3 years ago
no dip shit he is adopted and i have a great job with a financial firm that over see's the sale and maint. of heavy equipment. whats it like to be so empty and useless?
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
I don't know, ask yourself.. You have no offspring and you can't spell sea correctly... You must have it made with your monopoly firm.
Cole108 3 years ago
He didn't mean to spell "sea" you retard, "oversee" is a legit word, and part of common english vocabulary.
And who the f*ck said having a child at 20 was ever a crime, or something not to be proud of? My friend has 2 children, under training as a pilot for a respectable airline company, and he's doing just fine.
What can you boast of? Making a fool of yourself on the Internet? Seriously, blow me too. I'd love nothing more than watching your humiliated face service my manhood.
Choke on dick.
rahma4 3 years ago 2
Yes you've pointed out a good point, his "Oversee" has a space fool. What is with you internet fags, all you want is for some guy to blow you. Fuck you!
Cole108 3 years ago
Technically, since you're on the internet too, that makes you a fag also.
Ergo: Smoke my bone Cole-baby.
rahma4 3 years ago 2
your the one probaly gay or ignorant the only two reasons some one hates gays is the self hating gay or an ignorant dumb shit who has to get on the internet and start a fight instead of doing it face to face but you probably would end up sucking the guys dick because thats the kinda person you are and your kids will hate you so much trust me and the media doesnt make people gay it makes ignorent dumb shits like you
crazydogthing 3 years ago
to the dumb shit who cant come up with more than childish insults that realy shouldnt piss off any one
crazydogthing 3 years ago
crazydogthing, you really are a first class fucking toddler.. the media creates homosexuals, look at Katy perry's latest hit, if you can't read between the lines then GO THE FUCK BACK TO SCHOOL YOU FOOL. btw, how do you know my sexual orientation? Obviously your gay if your posting to something that is nearly a week old. I don't plan to reply other than this post. Fucking imbecile, go do something productive.
Cole108 3 years ago
You have got to be the biggest example of a little boy who's mommy and daddy did not love him. Remember your useless death on your back with eyes close? keep spilling your rage on a msg. board with a song called hurt attached to it.(how apropriate you wounded little man) one day if you dont start looking with in your self your infection of rage will become your religion and lead to that useless death of no meaning or value. try a little tenderness
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
P.S. cole108 BLOW ME
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
Oh I am very calm, until a moron such as yourself makes me turn into a ticking bomb. Don't you have something to do you little boy?
Cole108 3 years ago
I heard a woman cover this song of NIN's sometime ago. I remember clapsticks during the chorus (?). Her voice was sort of echoing.
I really like her version.
Has anyone else heard that version before?
JesterToy 3 years ago
It was fucking incredible, because I at a local bar here on monday night and they covered this song, one of the bartenders and one of my co-workers friend sung, they both did a great job..and it made me look back and think of this video. Oh, and ontop of that, I watched fight club afterwards with someone...well. we watched about 5 minutes of it..
Cole108 3 years ago
Was that someone you watched five minutes of fight club with named todd or matt or any male for that matter????? and did you pitch or receive? i picture you an angry twink with power bottom issues!
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
I've been brainwashed by the media to be a godless fuck machine with extreme power trips, a pure megalomaniac at heart. You hit it right on the head you dipshit. It's hard to understand you with your broken sentences and your shitty typing!
Cole108 3 years ago
how can any one person be such a duche bag? can i ask you a question??? are you a man of god? or do you just twist shit like your katie perry obsession in to fact so your 22 year old mind can make sence of the world? remember you started this fight with your small I.Q. and limited life experiences.
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
Your an idiot...I am tired of wasting my time on someone with mediocre grammar.
Cole108 3 years ago
I thought you had more fight in you then this. You might as well waste your time with me. No one else is listening to you, but me. Including those who you think love you. they dont listen to your ramblings. Your broken thoughts are funny to me. Keep typing coward.
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
I am sorry cole108! I take it all back! Besides being pissed off. What other interests do you have? please forgive my grammer. I am a product of the public school system. I wonder. What could your interest be in? Geology, paleoanthropology, physics i.e. super string theory, oceanography, biochemistry, military science, aviation, world religions? What makes a cole108 interested? Besides fight club, nine inch nails, and being an all around pissed off youth.
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
I daresay you are consumed with waiting for a reply..this will be my last. Peace.
Cole108 3 years ago
Come on cole108 dont give up now! Your angry drive demands it! I thought there was more to you than just giving up after some weak exchanges on a msg board. P.S. what do you know of peace? what creates it? What keeps it going? What does it demand?
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
CIGARETTE BURN >>>>>>>>>>>>0
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
To bad someone wouldn't use your face as an astray....it would be an improvement..
Cole108 3 years ago
blow me
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
Blow what? You'd love to have some dudes lips around your dick wouldn't you..? I think you've been listening to far to much Katy perry if that's the case...you've been turned into a homosexual by the media, guess that would make you an incompetent fool..can't even think for yourself.. Don't worry...you'll assimilate and fit in with the next fashion trend...I'm sure.
Cole108 3 years ago
P.S. blow me
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
we are a generation of men raised by women! if GOD was a model for our fathers and our fathers wanted nothing to do with us. whats that tell us about GOD!
cantwaittostartlivin 3 years ago
Qual o nome do filme ?
which the name of the film?
el nome qual de o hace el filme?
Por favor , please .
guheugenio 3 years ago
Film's name: "Fight Club"
whitoNet 3 years ago
awesomerific movie
wheenesslevel100 3 years ago
one of the greatest bands and one of the greatest movies ever
mezner1 3 years ago
awsome movie awsome song... just awsome
luisverkk 3 years ago
wow give trent his credit for this amazing song they are both good its alll a matter of opinion it dont matter who you think made it famous dont mean its automatically johnnys
darkhero584 3 years ago
WARN FOR SPOILERS!
blestemp 3 years ago
WARN FOR TIT-MAN!
VisitorY 3 years ago
I SAW MOOBS TOO!
Sephpwnsyoutonoend 3 years ago
great song , fantastic movie,even like brad pit in this film even though he uses his same internal charater as he did in tweleve monkeys, i do like the Cash cover,but we all know he was dying etc and it does pull on the heart strings i know looking back on his life.
VSMuadDib1973 3 years ago
perfect song for a perfect movie :-D
kain214 3 years ago
me amarrei nesse video mano, na musica tb...
konigtiger 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Yes It Is A Cover Its Johnny Cashes Song.. But Its Still Really Good.
RosaXOo 3 years ago
It's not a cover. This is the original. Johnny Cash's was the cover. This was recorded in 1994, Cash's was 2002.
adroitA09 3 years ago 23
Please people. For the final time, just realize that Trent Reznor wrote this song in the 90's and was released on "The Downward Spiral." Johnny Cash covered this song on his COVER ALBUM "American Legend" which only contains one originial. Hey, and guess what.....HURT ISNT THE ORIGINAL. Jesus fucking christ....I swear half of you live to be ignorant through youtube comments. Get a fucking life and research your information before making a permanent post.
TheUltimateHeretic1 3 years ago 11
the last sentence... youtube at its worst and finest lol
Spongebobsmycumrag 3 years ago
rosa, Johnny mentioned that NIN and Soundgarden were his favorites. Even before he released it officially, he would always cover Rusty Cage and Hurt. You are excused since you are a youngster.
People forget how good the mainstream music was from 90-94 (Rock Renaissance).
LostInTranslation78 3 years ago
Trent is a freakin' genious!
kallebaah0 3 years ago 4
dude... nudity haha... nice... love the song and the movie... first rule of fight club... dont talk about fight club
jastrat0009 3 years ago
This version is way edgier and more more emotional than Cash's. People mistake loud singing for emotional singing, here Reznor is melancholy and pensieve, while Cash is merely full of regret.
ascort106 3 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this version is really good, but johnny cash made the song and he kicks ass at it.
Lucifergab 3 years ago
he did not make it
bruno2324 3 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i meant he made it famous
Lucifergab 3 years ago
bullshit naw trent was already a god and made the song great and cash reconized his great song like many others and then made a cover over it
justin3455 3 years ago 5
@ascort106 you're absolutely right. just as long as we're all ok that cash never pushed his voice in his cover-. f%Wk the guy was litterally dying because his lungs were giving up. but this understood, yeah, you're right. completely.
AnthonyMishima 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Cash cover is way better :D tokens to reznor for the lyrics
IvanSorath 3 years ago
noway, at least not in this movie, this isnt a movie for country music..
JACKHEROR76 3 years ago
GREAT JOB, song and film fits so well!
squeaiker 3 years ago 3
UHHH Johnny cash covered it idiot.
Iguanaintrouble 3 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this song is a cover of the god johnny cash.. and of course it isnt emo.... fucking awesome video
Alphoter 3 years ago
Cash covered the song. Reznor put the song out in 1994 on The Downward Spiral, Cash covered it in 2002 (on American IV).
tormentes0ulx 3 years ago 18
Yeah Idiot!
KingXJoey 3 years ago
i dont fucking care.... i just like the song... dont wanna "investigate" about it...
Alphoter 3 years ago 3
it's not a cover you asswipe
kallebaah0 3 years ago
my cousin says this movie and JTHM are what fucked up my mind i don't see it though.
digitamer139 3 years ago
jthm can't fuck up your mind. it's a great story, but it's still pretty fucking tame.
gamer2021 3 years ago
lisin to it on aatchb albulm it the best version
spitfiremanlizerd 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i think the Johhny cash version shows more emotion and it fits in with his life cuz of his past and stuff
tjzippy 3 years ago
are you mentally challenged?
BellJH 3 years ago
I feel the 1 by Nine Inch Nails was better then Johnny cash's version
94Demonicangel94 3 years ago 8
Agreed.
tormentes0ulx 3 years ago
jap!!!
GiniAustria 3 years ago
okay so does this mean johnny cash listened to NIN???
noleznozbest 3 years ago 7
Yeah
meric2 3 years ago 3
nope it means i had magic powers :P
Dylan31007 3 years ago 2
i like the cash version better but you have to respect this version cause its the orignal
ozzyfreak999 3 years ago
Good job!
FarringtonECFU 3 years ago
pretty good,bravo
tator36 3 years ago
Without sounding too emo this song is really beautiful. The way the dischords work with Trent's voice and the passion behind the lyrics. Amazing.
thrillseeker9909 3 years ago 4
This song is 0% Emo. This song has deep meaning to Trent, which even is greatest fans probably won't understand.
Emos aren't sad, they just crave attention and are melodramatic.
megamushroom07 3 years ago 9
Actually if you look up about when cash re did the song, he did see it with Christian morals... just so you know.
InnEsCo777 3 years ago
like when he says, "I wear this crown of thorns" reffering to Jesus.
blackledpantallica7 3 years ago 3
Exactly. He sees that The meaning of a song can be a lot of different things. From some seeing it as just pure mastication,to others seeing it with good values, and this can be done with almost anysong.
InnEsCo777 3 years ago 3
before im about to fight someone i will picture this song in my head
andrewdingus 4 years ago
cash didnt make it into a christian song he just replaced shit with thorns it wa still about heroin
BigDaddyStefan918 4 years ago
yea seriously
RaidenTheAlmighty 4 years ago
i loke how cash made it into a Christian song...kind of neat to have two perspectives on one song!
hart846 4 years ago
edward looks much better in american history x imo.
RaidenTheAlmighty 4 years ago
fucking brilliant
DeLarge88 4 years ago
this song makes me feel so evil
justin3455 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I don't think I like this version...
I don't really like NIN either.
Don't yell at me and scream. It's just I like the Johnny Cash one better... NIN fans would like this one better.
ithinkkyouareparis 4 years ago
I agree with what ur saying but i like both versions and i like nin
ozzyfreak999 3 years ago 6
i acually...like this weirdly gothic and "im gonna kill myself" song
dying635 4 years ago
well cuz trent reznor made it and it isnt gothic u shuld really get into nin its not really gothic or emo its pretty cool
justin3455 4 years ago 2
who the fuck is the person at 1:16? Looks like durder, but doesn't... ... ...
jekiam 4 years ago
--durden, sorry.
jekiam 4 years ago
Its Tyler, he appears for split seconds throughout the movie before he meets Edward Nortons character
BenKealey 4 years ago
But not in that shot. The frame of Tyler was originally standing next to the group leader during that scene. Someone must have chopped him out and added him in.
Thenextspielberg1987 4 years ago
I just watched Fight Club the other day for the first time and it was amazing. NIN rules and so does Fight Club.
dedbird6595 4 years ago 6
Hurt.
One of the best songs ever.
bringxbulletsxbaby 4 years ago 7
all songs are a matter of interpretation, who cares what the band meant for it to be about
kitesflyhigher 4 years ago
i tend to like the original.
Johnny Cash really only simplified it.
The arrangements by Trent Reznor are nice.
Johnny did nothing.
belovedmakesmusic 4 years ago 4
true, but he was at deaths door, not exactley at his creative peak.
stu666666 4 years ago
cah was at his crwative peak his whole life..anything that man does his brilliant...oh and he actually died two weeks after the mucis video was made...in those two weeks he was studying the WORD and talking to God...beautiful
hart846 4 years ago
He died after his wife died, she died two weeks after, thats what I read.
Moondogy 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
True Trent wrote it but Cash did it a million times better.... this version is utter crap compared to Johnnys
FlawlessP401 4 years ago
Trent Reznor wrote this song dude..Not johnny cash. damn thats annoying.
But amazing song. Amazing preformer in general. Awesome.
nazieatingsandwhich 4 years ago 3
We're all sick of that argument.
Aorenai 4 years ago
fuckedupboy, don't start that.
LuckGuy 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
jhonny cash does this song MUUUUUUUUUUCH better!
fuckedupboy 4 years ago
that's real!:-)
xenia8777 4 years ago
ohh das is echt gut hab den link schon ner freundin geschickt
TheEndIsInSight 4 years ago
gud cover...i would lyk to see muse cover this song
pangetska 4 years ago
This isn't a cover. This is the original song.
LuckGuy 4 years ago 2
good song but im not into anal sex
jimmyhat45 4 years ago
Its nice for you to clean your conscience like that.
chaosbug 4 years ago
fikou foda
maxterixgaleraconga 5 years ago
wow, i never thought of putting NiN hurt to fight club. but damn this is good!
lostartofwar 5 years ago
Its sorta weird tho, cause hurts meant to be about heroin addiction, or have i been told wrong
BenKealey 4 years ago