This is so depressing! (cheerful hyper look) But, (turning serious) really pretty. Who was this arrangement by? I might "subtlely" suggest it to my choir director.
I love this version of it, we're singing it in my choir too! I love how the first soprano "loved - him" bit sounds like sobs. It's beautiful and so sad.
I'm singing this song in choir, and I'm wondering if we're the only ones doing the extra little bit after the first 'Johnny has gone for a soldier'. Anyways, there are 80 girls in my choir. You are great all on your own! :D
Wait, are those forget-me-nots in the background? How fitting.
cozycute 2 months ago
This is so depressing! (cheerful hyper look) But, (turning serious) really pretty. Who was this arrangement by? I might "subtlely" suggest it to my choir director.
cozycute 2 months ago
We're learning this in music class. Beautiful version of this!
RisingEagle121 4 months ago
I love this version of it, we're singing it in my choir too! I love how the first soprano "loved - him" bit sounds like sobs. It's beautiful and so sad.
FreyTown 5 months ago
i sound better
101DAlonzo 5 months ago
ten girls tried out for this song when i was in the fifth grade and only four were chosen..and i was one of them!! loved it
wellthatshilarious23 8 months ago
I'm singing this song in choir, and I'm wondering if we're the only ones doing the extra little bit after the first 'Johnny has gone for a soldier'. Anyways, there are 80 girls in my choir. You are great all on your own! :D
Lionstar123 1 year ago
Kinda creepy
r0y02 1 year ago
Lovely singing, but the recording is a little distorted. It could be so much more beautiful
sorakey44 1 year ago
We sing it a TAD bit faster.
CriminalMindsNCISaVT 1 year ago
I'm singing the same arrangement in my choir :) You guys sang beautifully!
yuyu4848 1 year ago 2
@yuyu4848 haha, thanks! (even though it's just me singing, I just sang it 9 times XD)
janiegirly07 1 year ago
@janiegirly07 Nine times good then, janie!
McGrenzer 1 year ago
@yuyu4848 me too but my concert was today
lilliana851 1 year ago
beautiful!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
catyvet 1 year ago
@catyvet thank you :)
janiegirly07 1 year ago
I like this song acapella! Must be all those Sundays I was at the Church of Christ.
ConfederateGypsy 1 year ago
you forgot ill dye my drees ill dye it red
coloma2009 1 year ago
that isn't anywhere in the music, I just read what was on the page...
janiegirly07 1 year ago
dis is the same arrangement i had to sing
ttvvll4lyfe9 2 years ago
Girls this is beautiful...I like this arrangement
Crystilwyn 2 years ago
We sang this tooo love it!!<3
redneckracehorse01 2 years ago
WOW great harmony!!!
JerryBarryLover 2 years ago
thank you :)
janiegirly07 2 years ago
this is gorgeous
kmarceau3 2 years ago
thank you! :)
janiegirly07 2 years ago
omg. wait !
i take that back.
it's not you guys are great.
this is you by yourself huh ?
YOU'RE GREAT !
iSHOTdiamondpainXTC 2 years ago
lol, thanks!
janiegirly07 2 years ago
you guys are great !
but i'm sorry the words
are actually Here I sit on Buttermilk hill :D
iSHOTdiamondpainXTC 2 years ago
actually, it is there, because that was what was in the music that we purchased for choir lol
janiegirly07 2 years ago
The lyrics are different for each arrangement...depending on what the arranger prefers
Crystilwyn 2 years ago
i loved it. it made me cry
i might sugest that to my singing teacher at collage to do for the class :)
well done.
did you do all those parts yourself?
bubblegumlol21 2 years ago
Aww, thank you so much!
and yes I did all the parts. In choir I learned only the alto part, but the other parts are simple enough :)
janiegirly07 2 years ago
I really like this Janie. This is so pretty. :)
thesingingMA 2 years ago
Thanks!
janiegirly07 2 years ago
This is such a beautiful song i love the harmonies great job!
kara30360 2 years ago
Thank you :)
janiegirly07 2 years ago