Added: 5 years ago
From: kotz1
Views: 39,212
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (201)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i am in love with tbs and circa.

  • Why would they write the vocal parts in a range that the singer can't reach.. Serously, if they would have downtuned their guitars or if the vocal parts were a third lower it would be fine

  • He's singing so horribly out of tune!!!!!!!

  • wtf hes fuckin great, honestly the best singer and my favorite band in the world no lie, its ok if hes def in tune, hes still great with his little raptor claw, fuckin greaaattt anthony keep it up

  • @TheeStupidCow i was at this show....come on i love the band too but he really is off key. their are days hes spot on and others hes not but you don't really notice much when your at the event but based on the video yeah it sounds off.

  • Comment removed

  • gotta love the raptor claew

  • taking back sunday sure had a hard act to follow :P

  • no hes def in tune. its the audio of w.e was used to record this. prob has an auto eq and is fuckin up his vocals.

    look at any other live vids in good quality, hes in tune.

  • I don't care how many thumbs down people give you, but you're right. Anthony is great in studio but he's shit in this video.

  • i didnt even know i was getting those thumbs down. haha. yeah man. hes off big time in this vid.. could be the sound. could be him. who knows. but i think its him.

  • When you're touring and playing live shows everynight, obviously your voice is gonna get thrashed on. Anthony pushes his voice to the limit every show so don't expect him to hit the everything he did in the albums. Because when you have months to record, your voice has time to heal and rest.

  • @Nicholass503 this is also a fact you can research it if you think im bs'in but anthony uses auto tuner up the wazoo while recroding.. which isnt a terrible thing you can tune a guitar why not your voice?

  • @timmunn1 What a load of fucking bullshit, you just fucking pulled that out of your ass.

  • @seij555 Are you fucking kiding me? why would i just pull that out of my ass anthony uses auto tuner and guess what! basicaly every other band you listen to probably does as well! Show me a video where anthony is singing 100 percent dead on hitting the notes perfectly... Go fucking look it up and read an interview.. im not bashing him i love anthony im just stating a fact

  • @timmunn1 Just watch any of his live acoustic shows, Ant Green sings better than on the album. One example is the Drug Dealer live video. Green does not use autotune as much as you say. He pretty much sounds the same live or even better.

  • @seij555 i know he doesnt use it much but he deff uses it as a touch up im not kidding i read it in a interview with him. obviously no ones perfect and theres certain notes he cant hit

  • @timmunn1 i agree with you dude..

  • anyone who goes to a live show and expect the singer's voice to be exactly like the studio is...to put it bluntly, an idiot. Going to a concert is about the energy you see from the band, the way they interpret their own music. It's not about if the singer can hit all the notes perfectly. Of course you have to be reasonable and expect a good vocal tho. Which this is.

  • they suck without anthony! his voice makes them complete

  • not at all, that was the stupidest fucking thing ive ever heard

  • RAPTOR CLAW

  • i love the beat at 1:00

  • that guy sings in a high pitch tone its kinda hard to do a whole while busting your ass off of getting the same note everytime

  • they are his lyrics, he can do what he wants

  • He should've stopped fucking with the original rhythm on the song, and actually sang the notes. I LOVE Circa, but I've been noticing more and more that Anthony Green isn't that good live.

  • i totally agree. hes OKAY live but im kinda glad someone else said it. i dont feel as bad now! ^_^ thanks!

  • you guys wouldn't know much about music, seriously.. he is a f**king beast live. the whole point of being a great artist is to be able to improvise and change tones/lyrics what so ever and still be able to make it sound decent.. i'd put four artists up there on that list of great live artists: anthony green obviously, jason mraz, dallas green, hayley williams.. they all somehow change songs while performing, it's just great.. you dont know what to expect next! brb

  • Very True

  • If you seriously think Jason Mraz is one of the best musicians at improvising then you're just another person who's fallen into the lazy crowd who can't look past the leader boards for true talent. Why don't you come talk to me when you've diversified your taste in music?

  • Search Living Together.

  • Anthony Green is fucking god live. I bet Act Apalled is your favorite song huh? fag.

  • Actually my favorite song is The Glorious Nosebleed. And if you can't hear the many parts where his voice is flat, then that's just your curse.

  • he almost got hit in the face with that guitar lol

  • ehhh... voice is off in this one

  • Not his best performance, but still amazing to see that anyone can sing that, and to see all of the passion he puts into his songs

  • Its not his fault that the producers made his voice high pitched in the real song.

  • it's not as good as anthony could be, but i still like it. he's fucking crazy.

  • Everyone bitches about his voice in this video, all I'll say is for anyone to sing this song anywhere near as well as he does after a few weeks on the road with their body taking a beating every night is a good singer. he does a great job, just becos he brought some of the higher parts down an octave or two doesnt mean he didnt sing he well, he just sang some parts different. his voice is still one of the most impressive in rock. He and Charles Furney (Secret and Whisper) are 2 of the best.

  • Jonny Craig sounds absolutely amazing at every fucking show.

    Always consistent.

    Always persistent.

  • ye but anthony doesnt

  • @FAJJZ i agree

  • Raptor claw

  • it's official...

    short haired anthony green is MUCH different than shaggy haired anthony green.

    not bad different...still 100% awesome.

  • theres one difference between short-haired and shaggy-haired anthony green.....its called cocaine

  • i actually enjoy this vid a lot. dont really get what you're whining about

  • Been watching other videos of the same songs and this seems to be an off night for anthony. hard song to sing and yes he does it really good in other videos but not in this particular one.

  • although i adore circa....the singing is ASS

  • 2:09 is ROCKING!!!!

  • fuck yes thats the main reason why i favorited this tip

  • I was there, and I was seriously shaking, his voice is just amazing to say the least.

  • omg they really sucked live O-o

    haha whatever I like their music

  • they are usually a lot better :p dont let this stop you from seeing them.

  • Ok just think about how many songs and times he has to sing this song, and think about how much his voice must strain. I think he's doing a hell of a good job for all the tour dates and songs he has to sing. haters.

  • his vocals seemed abit weak this time around. :(

  • yeah, anthony's bad.......BADASS! he's one of the only singers who actually plays for his fans while they wait for the actual show, and no one can do what he does on stage.

  • for some reason he's falling flat. and he knows it, that's why he keeps bringing it down. maybe he couldn't hear himself. or maybe his voice was fucking up.

  • I STILL DONT GET how anyone could say this performance is bad!!!!! this is his best!!!

  • ok i think this is his best performance yet.

  • word.

  • SEX

  • anthony is an amazing singer

    granted this isnt one of his best performances

    thats becuase this would have been on one of the end legs of the tour, anthony's voice takes a beating but instead of easing back he throws his all at the notes, making his voice worse and obviously hurting. bravery or stupidity?

  • you're a fucking idiot alexatyourfuneral....FUCK YOU!

  • calm down emo kid. calm the fuck down.

  • FUCK YOUUUU!

  • LMAO

  • He's killing his voice by singing like that.

  • wow I just lost a lot of respect for this band...

  • i love circa. but this is some shitty ass singing. like this is terrible

  • I agree the album juturna awesome anthony's voice on the album pure gold-every live act I've seen though he fckn sucks!!!! seriously it just go to show the miracle of "studio magic" for real if I booked this band and they performed like this I would kick their fucking ass!!!I was so dissapointed when I saw them at THE RAVE in MILWAUKEE what a waste of money

  • I'm a huge fan, but I'm not too proud of Anthony's voice during this performance.

  • his performance is like a baby on crack! i fucking love it. first time i saw them live i didnt know the music. so i stood there like...what the fucks wrong with this guy?

  • if you pay attention to the lyrics and where hes changing the song you see instead of singing "im sure its not like it was before" hes saying "im not so sure, no im not so sure". hes changing the lyrics to be 'not like they were before' by making them different than what was sung on the CD. hes emphasizing the meaning of the song. it just takes putting some thought into it to see what hes doing. Anthony Green knows his music, he isnt just fucking up on stage.

  • Anthony Green <3 I love his voice dearly.

  • *truly understand the meaning of the words

  • and his "acting weird" is probably one reason why they're getting big...look at marylin manson...the only reason he's huge is because he's a freak and tons of people talk about him...but i really think the way anthony acts on stage is because he's making sure not to hold anything back...and give the audience all he has while making sure they truly understand their meaning...ok...i'm off my soapbox now...thanks for listening

  • open your mind...think musically...and most of all...think emotionally...he's calling someone out for being fake...would you be delicate and careful...or would you tell it like it is?

  • honestly i think it's better when he's off-pitch...mainly because it seems like he's putting more emotion in it instead of worrying about that high note that's coming up...or the verse that's hard to remember...he's just letting his words overtake him and letting all of his musical instincts take over and remake the song every night...

  • cool...

    high tone...

  • I totally agree with lostxbloodyxromance and lumb.. he may be wierd but he hes good u dis him wen some people probably cant even get on stage

  • by weird you mean different. some types of different are good imo...

  • I have immense respect for his talent- just because he's not singing it exactly like it is on the album doesn't mean he's doing it wrong. It's his song, he can do what he wants with it. He's really not that pitchy, and he's ultimately singing a male alto part, and I don't know any people personally that can do that. Besides, Jeff Buckley is easily one of the most talented musicians to me, and his live performances were nothing like his record, and he's very weird on stage. Stay open-minded.

  • he is terrible at singing, and hes just weird on stage

  • ya, i agree w/ lumb, too. hes weird, but all of his lyrics are amazing. their metaphorical and u can relate to them. the only band that does that for me besides circa is the infamous zeppelin

  • shouldnt try to bust out to sing all out on an album when you can't do it live.

  • i agree with lumbayaodub

  • Taking Back Sunday RULES!!!!!!!!

  • on drugs or not on drugs he is still anthony green... can you sing his songs? are you touring the u.s.a? are you selling records more than his band? well i dont think so...so for those people who keeps on dissing anthony green just for being who he is... get a life losers.

  • okay,i'm gonna say this,but if you think he is doing such a fucking bad job get your dumb ass on stage and you fucking sing it

  • Anthony green is good. But he shouldn't record something he can't do live. It's that simple. I've seen tons of live videos and he fuck every single one of them up. He's good. But not a very smart move as a singer.

  • This is kinda weird, because I have seen some live videos where hes been off pitch, but I just saw him live the other day in person and he was spot on for nearly everything. ?!?!?! Crazy.

  • This is kinda weird, because I have seen some live videos where hes been off pitch, but I just saw him live the other day in person and he was spot on for nearly everything. ?!?!?! Crazy.

  • yeah, i love circa but dude is ruining the songs. not hitting the notes. what's up with that? every bit of live footage is the same way. i'll just stick to the cd's.

  • high as a fucking bird

  • ok so what if he is high....look how good he still is

  • terrible. not one note is on.

  • Then you do it better and we will all praise you on one knee bowing to your glory.... He's tired dude serious

  • dude hes anthony green he does what he wants. no one questions it.

  • Hes being creative...Hes not like other singers who just do there same words and shit they wrote..Just look at jam bands they do the same thing. But I'm not saying hes not fucked up. But I really have no idea, that might just be how he really is? Do we know for sure? Do any of you know for sure that hes high?

  • that's the music buisness for you right there.

  • wow hes stoned. i luv him and circa survive but wow. the singing wasnt that bad hes was definetley stoned. well im pretty sure.

  • I doubt it, Anthony has been off drugs for quite a while, and to the best of my knowledge he's still clean

  • this guy is definitely on something. i love anthony and all but he shouldn't be playing shows fucked up.

  • no offence to circa survive at all they know i love them all but this is one of their worst performances. i was actually at it and it was in syracuse ny at the new york state fair and it wasn't really good. their sound systems weren't very good at that concert. they are a lot better now, i saw them twice since this past august. very awesome. check out the recent stuff.

  • I'm sorry, I just had to check out if Anthony is as good as everyone says live...and this video doesn't quite show that. Hmmm... Off to find other videos then...

  • coked up? hope not..

  • he doesn't use vocal steroids...

    he just has a high voice, it comes from singing songs that high constantly andddddd just being born like that.

    someone make that up to make some noise guy's :)))))

  • That wasn't good.

    Hope they're better when I see them in February.

  • around 49 he almost fell of that amp!

  • this is fucking amazing

  • whoa, that looked like a close call for anthony during that half time at the end- that shit was heavy though, i love this band.

  • He definitely has a hoarseness and I suspect he's exhausted. Without it, Anthony has a higher voice than Craig - that's certain as hell. I'm covering Craig's melodies with no problem ( only the screaming parts are tough ). But I don't undestand this thing with steroids, that's peculiar and unbelivable. Can you explain further ? And can you give some proof couse it seems to be an absurd.

  • wait waht is this thing with steroids?

  • He cut his hair..nooooooo

  • is he drunk?

  • yah craig is the vocals in chiodos

  • wow his vocals here were a fail.

    but when I saw him, he fucking nailed this song. maybe he was having an off night.

  • hell no!

    he's still bada**!!!

    he's the best there is

    Stop hating just cuz ya'll cant sing

  • i really like this band..but man anthony is really sucking at singing this song live in this video

  • It's almost like he's having an out of body experience when he doesn't sing at certain spots, like the ending chorus, like he wants to be in the crowd and listen to it. Haha.

  • that's called being on drugs

  • It's called shut the fuck up, he's not on drugs.

  • haha, he's definitely fucked up. he can't even get the words right.

  • he's sick.

  • lol your dumb imo anthony green and the rest of circa are gods amount men and the most talented people ive ever seen and i listen to both their albums multiple times a day, anthony also used to be a coke addict and ive smoked weed with him so im sure he smokes. hes high

  • You're the dumb one who makes up stupid fucking stories

  • He's an awesome showman and he really gets into the music, but he's not as good live as I thought he was gonna be. He's still fucking awesome, but he's not like PERFECT which I was under the impression he was. Craig Owens is teh best high live vocalist :)

  • Craig Owens is my favorite high vocalist by far. = ]

    although i've heard rumors that he uses voice steroids, which bums me out, but he's still amazing.

    i saw chiodos and cinematic sunrise at warped tour this summer. = ]

  • voice steroids? i've never heard of those. they really have that? and they just make your voice higher?

  • In essence they make your voice higher.

    but the actual effect is that it relaxes and strengthens your vocal chords, which are basically muscles.

    but it doesn't matter, as long as he sounds good.

  • thats kind of dumb if you ask me. those notes can be reached naturally with not that much hard work. you just have to sing along to these kinds of songs enough.

    and craig owens is the chiodos guy, right?

  • Ouch man u got told synth drum, seriously u need to stop judging cause he does a better job then u ever will so grow up and stop criticizing.

  • I'm not criticizing. I aspire to be musicians like anthony and such others in bands, jazz groups, and orchestras. I've played alto saxophone for 6 and a half years now. Drums for 7 years. Guitar for 4 years. Keyboards now for about 2, and vocals now for about 2. I am a musician. I've played a dozen live shows in my band, play numerous venues with my jazz quartet.

  • hey synthdrum123

    you need a tall glss of shut the fuck up..

    stick to drums

    you dont know what the fuck youre talking about.

    anthonys got his original style.

    the little cracks he has are part of the reason hs so original

  • haha. don't get like that right a way, i'm just making an observation on my own behalf. i love anthony green. he's an amazing musician. i do vocals for the band i'm in and people like craig owens and anthony are probably my two highest role models. I'm saying this because i run into the same problem he does at certain times, that's all.

  • He is singing way too high for his capability. I've been to a couple of circa shows. He runs out of breath. He should train his voice to get that high consistently. He was amazing in saosin because he wasn't asked to sing all the time, and singing in key the majority of the time wasn't as necessary. In circa he needs a voice coach. It's easy to have your record sound a certain way, for example, anthony's high vocals because of the time he has to take breathers.

  • nah man you got it all wrong

  • Agreed.

  • anthony green can touch whomever he wants

    where ever he wants

    he's anthony green.

  • as hard as it is to movie around at a show, theres always the option to movie if you try, instead of staying and then bitching about it later.

  • yeah anthony green is amazing and ive seen probably more than 3/4 of his videos on here and this isnt the best one or nearly decent ouch

  • lmfao why didnt you just move his hand???? you probly havent washed your hair since. you could sell your hair to an AG lover for millions!!! circa is dope but he does dance like a queer.

  • He's not dancing, he's grooving. He's really into the music.

  • haha

    anthony green > you

  • anthony green is a fucking asshole.

    i did'nt really appreciate him having his hand on my head for like 2 min straight @ SXSW (i was in the very front)

    im not his fucking pet, and he cant dry his sweaty hands on my hair.....

  • i didnt know that touching someones head made them an asshole.

  • not touching, but resting and swabbing your hand is.

    dont get me wrong. AG is amazing, but if you have millions of people think that you are a fucking god, you tend to get a lil cocky, and stuck up....

  • yeah looks like he wasn't havin a very good night.

    this is a little dissapointing, but every other video i've seen he's amazing.

  • I'm not one to hate on a brother for customizing a song for a live performance, but I'm beginning to wonder if he really CAN sing the song the way it appears on the album. I still love them, though. The stuff they write is incredible.

  • hah you say that but do you realize anthony green is who made the screamo saosin?

  • haha ok yea i have to admit his little moves are kinda queer but i still love him and circa survive is still amazing

  • i meant screamo/hardcore/metal fan/musician, my fuck up

  • another lame vid of AG dancing like a queer, thats my opinion so dont frown upon it, Saosin's beat and aggression is better than this fairy music, sorry doods and duddets, This is Homo Shit, i respect everyone elses opinions, im just not a Circa Survive/AG fan at all, im more of a screamo/hardcore/metal genre fan/slash musician

  • you can tell even he knows he's have an off day. fucking love anthony...ever singer in the world has had a off day. he's still beautifull....im not gay...but ever fucking person gotta admit he's a good looking guy hahaha. and there just a really good band over all

  • anthony green is one of the greatest singers on this earth, in my opinion.

  • remember that the music in saosin is way different from circa survive music. Anthony dances according to the feel of the song. he went crazy when he sang for saosin cuz the music was faster and aggressive.

  • lay off the crack you faggot

  • he probably doesn't dance as much cuz its like harder to sing to circa than saosin even for him cuz saosin didn't ask for much just screaming like he had to move from screaming to higher tones which in my opinion is harder

  • he sounds sick.

    i dont think he gets drunk before every show when i saw him im pretty sure he was soberr.

    and he still dances.

  • THE CLAW! haha awesome!

  • he's still wild but i miss the dance moves like b4 in sao

  • he's still wide but the dance moves was gone.. wish he never left sao

  • anthony sounds like he is struggling during this performance. He is flat at times. It is none the less of incredible, but i have seen him sound better.

  • well, if you've watched most of his videos and/or seen him live, you know he sings that way on purpose. he can sound like the record when he wants. but what anthony does is make every time he sings a song different. he improvises. his screams are awesome. period.

  • This is a good quality recording.

  • He doesnt really look like he did in Saosin ;-D

  • yeah, im pretty sure anthony gets drunk before every show...kinda dissapointing.

  • na hes been clean for a few years

  • oh yea when hes leaning on the speaker its funny...if you have seend whats eating gilbert grape and you know leonardo dicaprios role...he looks just like him at one point hahah but still hes baddd asss

  • its funny how people are gonna be all over this guys nuts just like people were with chino and deftones...don't get me wrong they both have badd ass voices! but its funny people really fight over this ahaha