Yes tell that to all the civilian victims in China , Korea and the Phillippines. All the Allied women and children mistreated by the Japanese. Not to mention the awful crimes of the Bataan death march, Laha airfield massacre and killing of Australian and Indian troops at Palit Sulong.
Not to mention the countless other atrocities the noble Japanese committed.
The boy knows they are going to certain death so he is honoring their sacrifice and bravery. If you watch the Japanese Imperial officer he has tears in his eyes.
@cannywf1 because wales and England are both under the crown (english royal family) and were pretty much the same country for the past 600-700 years maybe more so for the english singing a welsh lullaby would be like catholics praying in latin (suo gan is a hym also sung in church) and if you look up the english translation its very simbolic for this moment in the film
Basically, if you tell a Welshman he's the same as an Englishman, he will not thank you. I'm sure he'll have no problem with being British, but he's not English. He's just as distinct as a Scotsman or an Irishman.
It's not an English royal family, no. It's the British royal family that comes originally from Hanover. They also aren't the same country, and haven't been for 600-700 years. Wales was a part of England, but it was never the same. It is now seperate. Also, the flaw in your point about Catholics and Latin being similar to English people and Welsh is that there are only 150 000 welsh language speakers in England. There are over 51 million English people.
In contrast, it's a sad fact that many English people (not all) consider the Welsh to be backwards, lazy, good-for-nothing "sheepshaggers" or "subsidy junkies", with similarly negative views being held by some of the Welsh towards the English. It's absolutely disgraceful how bad it can get sometimes. The English are also descendants of the Anglo-Saxons, so they are a Germanic group of people (and are proud of that). The Welsh on the other hand are Brythonic.
In short, the Welsh and the English are not the same group of people, nor is the Welsh language to English people in any way similar to Catholics and Latin. To some Welsh people however, it is similar to Catholics and Latin.
@SpeedingSolicitor Thank you. This is one of 'the' best movies ever, next to Schindler's List and Dances with Wolves; movies in our era. Wonder if Christian Bale is still around? Do you know?
@lissakr11 You are joking, right? Christian Bale has been steadily making movies since "Empire of the Sun." Ever ever hear of "Batman Begins" and Dark Knight," just to name two of the better known recent films? Just look him up on IMDB.
Beautiful clip, showing what being Cymraes/Welsh is all about - a need for everyone to put their toys down, but impossible, I know.
And forgot Christian Bale was in this. He was born in West Wales I believe, before him and his family moved away. Always like the stuff he does in movies.
Christian Bale didn't actually sing this, but it was another kid around his same age. You have to remember that this was the ideal for young boys - and still is in many ways. The Simpsons actually made fun of how traditional boy's choirs are supposed to have that high-pitched sound. (Homer was a choir boy, and then his voice changed.) But yeah, this film is one of my favourites, and definitely one of Steven Spielberg's finest achievements.
Lyrics: Hunan blentyn, ar fy mynwes Clyd a chynnes ydyw hon Breichiau mam sy'n dyn amdanat Cariad mam sy dan fy mron Ni chaiff dim amharu'th gyntun Ni wna undyn a thi gam Huna'n dawel, annwyl bientyn Huna'n fwyn ar fron dy fam Huna'n dawel hana huna Huna'n fwyn y del ei lun Pam yr wyt yn awr yn gwenum Gwenu'n dirion yn dy hun Ai angylion fry sy'n gwenu Arnat yno'n gwenu'n lion Titha'u'n gwenu'n ol a huno Huno'n dawel ar fy mron
@tongsongkiong If you Google Suo Gan you will find the words in the original Welsh, with English translations. The song is a lullaby; this is the 1st verse:
@harrison28514 A man can have more than one masterpiece. I think they both are. but definitly not E.T. i don't know why steven himself thinks that E.T was one of his best films.
@254002 Ya it was on RTE 1 Yesterday -- Realy great film -- this is a brilliant scene -- brings a tear to your eye --- no matter how many times you see the Film !! ..
@rumpastumpa lol, if you wanted to know it's actually what we singers call Counter Tenor or Mezzo Soprano. Lots of older men sing like that, including me.
@lakostal Doesn't mean that my voice hasn't fully developed. My point is that it isn't unheard of for men to sing this way. Look up counter tenors and you'll know what I mean.
@la2449lakers it's a Welsh lullaby, a mother singing to the child to go to sleep and not fear because angels watch over it. Here, you could interpret it as Jim singing to the pilots, overcome perhaps by their lack of fear, as they go to their eternal sleep
I was kinda dissapointed when I found out that christian bale didn't sing in the movie. But all I can say is that Christian Bale is one dang good actor. :) <3 Also this song gives you that feeling of a forgotten memory. How you want to go back when you had a pure innocence of a child. Before everything changes...
I watched this with my dad way back when and ever sense It's still hard to get over... the fact that the kid could grasp the American accent so well xD. "How ya doin Frank?"
@HGunner70 i didn't there was a difference but there is catholics honor the saints and our lady of Guadapule as were christians dont and in the catholic ver. of the bible it has both old and new testament while in christian ver. of bible only has the new testament
schultz0089 asks "Isn't the song a lullaby about a mother putting her child to sleep???"
Perhaps, without realising it you have hit the nail on the head –the kamikaze pilots are about to be "put to sleep".
Huno in Welsh can mean both asleep or dead; the thing that is poignant about the song is that one can't be certain if it is a lullaby to a sleeping child or an elegy to a dead child.
Esse filme é incrivel, pela belíssima atuação de Christian Bale, ele faz com tanta paixão, emoção ao representar tão bem a canção Suo Gan. Amo esse ator!
@communistjoe1 - Hi, the plane was shot down by the attacking P-51's - but you're right by being confused. In the film, the sun is rising and in the next immediate scenes (in broad daylight) the Americans attack the airbase. It confused me too, but something in the film's extras cleared up that confusion. Somehow they should have adjusted the light, or had a sound insert of attacking planes put in just before the Japanese plane blew up. BTW, the plane was a model Zero, not full-sized.
Dubbed. An English choir boy called James Rainbird sang the track used in the film but fair play to Christian Bale, he did a great job singing in time to it - the version he does at the beginning of the film in church you would never guess it was dubbed.
@andyrjs Oh - Thanks for the info... It did look like he was singing - i was convinced ( though i was amazed the voice was so true and seemed so controlled/well trained.) Kudos to the both : Bale and Rainbird.
People be of no illusion when declaring 'there is no good and evil' and similar, dangerous sentiments. The conduct of Japan during the war was disgraceful. Evil even. And although, as in any war, there are good men who conducted themselves well, there is no denying that it was an unjust war fought in a most unjust way and we must not forget this.
Poignant, touching. Movie genius, classic story. James Rainbirds stunningly beautiful voice, in a song that brings a tear always. Memorable performances by Bale and the whole cast.
It was "Kamikaze" plane, it was filled with explosives. Sometimes they exploded by themselves. Further on this scene in film you can see american fighters attacked this airfield.
It was "Kamikaze" plane, it was filled with explosives. Sometimes they exploded by themselves. Further on this scene in film you can see american fighters attacked this airfield. By the way - to this moment i thought Suo Gan it was some japanese song :D
one day people are going to realize all around the world that war and hate was just a waste of time it seems like the smarter man became the more deadly man has become poor world poor us ...I hope god forgives us for our stupidity ...
Hard to believe that's Batman singing Suo Gan.
TheBlake138 17 hours ago
Comment removed
singerchice 5 days ago
Yes tell that to all the civilian victims in China , Korea and the Phillippines. All the Allied women and children mistreated by the Japanese. Not to mention the awful crimes of the Bataan death march, Laha airfield massacre and killing of Australian and Indian troops at Palit Sulong.
Not to mention the countless other atrocities the noble Japanese committed.
takharov1 1 week ago
i never get tired of watching this movie
mgolata 1 week ago
Even though they were our enemy in world war II, i respect all of them for their honor and gratitude to their country!
SsgtVenere 2 weeks ago
It reharks the begining of the movie.
2drewbaker 2 weeks ago
The boy knows they are going to certain death so he is honoring their sacrifice and bravery. If you watch the Japanese Imperial officer he has tears in his eyes.
MrCaesarnapoleon 3 weeks ago
I really enjoyed that movie when I was a kid.
lolomixed64 3 weeks ago
beautiful movie!! a masterpiece
mcrmyjl15 4 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos
I didn't even realize that the high voice was Christian Bale
greengun37 4 weeks ago
this make me cry ever time
dopycman 1 month ago
Why does he sing a Welsh Lullaby when he's English...??
cannywf1 1 month ago
@cannywf1 because wales and England are both under the crown (english royal family) and were pretty much the same country for the past 600-700 years maybe more so for the english singing a welsh lullaby would be like catholics praying in latin (suo gan is a hym also sung in church) and if you look up the english translation its very simbolic for this moment in the film
TheFinchmonster 1 month ago
@TheFinchmonster Thanks for the explanation... :)
cannywf1 1 month ago
@cannywf1 any time, had this stuck in my head so i looked it up and got all this info on it XD
TheFinchmonster 1 month ago
@TheFinchmonster
Basically, if you tell a Welshman he's the same as an Englishman, he will not thank you. I'm sure he'll have no problem with being British, but he's not English. He's just as distinct as a Scotsman or an Irishman.
MarvellousMuffin 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
MarvellousMuffin 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
MarvellousMuffin 3 weeks ago
@cannywf1
I'm afraid a safer bet would be that the little boy sings Suo Gan in the movie because his actor is from Wales.
MarvellousMuffin 3 weeks ago
@TheFinchmonster
same as men of harlech even though only 2 welsh showed up in the battle.
RyanBrooksby 1 month ago
@TheFinchmonster
It's not an English royal family, no. It's the British royal family that comes originally from Hanover. They also aren't the same country, and haven't been for 600-700 years. Wales was a part of England, but it was never the same. It is now seperate. Also, the flaw in your point about Catholics and Latin being similar to English people and Welsh is that there are only 150 000 welsh language speakers in England. There are over 51 million English people.
MarvellousMuffin 3 weeks ago
@TheFinchmonster
In contrast, it's a sad fact that many English people (not all) consider the Welsh to be backwards, lazy, good-for-nothing "sheepshaggers" or "subsidy junkies", with similarly negative views being held by some of the Welsh towards the English. It's absolutely disgraceful how bad it can get sometimes. The English are also descendants of the Anglo-Saxons, so they are a Germanic group of people (and are proud of that). The Welsh on the other hand are Brythonic.
MarvellousMuffin 3 weeks ago
@TheFinchmonster
In short, the Welsh and the English are not the same group of people, nor is the Welsh language to English people in any way similar to Catholics and Latin. To some Welsh people however, it is similar to Catholics and Latin.
MarvellousMuffin 3 weeks ago
@cannywf1 Pam dim? / why not?
TheSchizopodcaster 3 weeks ago
Even I am Chinese, But I love this film.
Kylelee1988 1 month ago
BEST SCENE!!!!
AmazingWingedGirl 1 month ago
Was disappointed to hear that Christian didn't actually sing this.
EdwardNygma1 1 month ago
poignant, riveting, this child in times of war
JoaniMac1 2 months ago
Comment removed
dednrurc 2 months ago
music doesn't care about fences, nationalities, or war, why don't we listen to it?
newuncertainty 2 months ago
I forgot about this movie... one of my all-time favorites, brings tears to me eyes every time. Love the little boy.
lissakr11 3 months ago
@lissakr11 it's christian bale!!!
SpeedingSolicitor 2 months ago
@SpeedingSolicitor Thank you. This is one of 'the' best movies ever, next to Schindler's List and Dances with Wolves; movies in our era. Wonder if Christian Bale is still around? Do you know?
lissakr11 2 months ago
@lissakr11 You are joking, right? Christian Bale has been steadily making movies since "Empire of the Sun." Ever ever hear of "Batman Begins" and Dark Knight," just to name two of the better known recent films? Just look him up on IMDB.
wildfireintexas 1 month ago
james rainbird is the singer
peppermintful 3 months ago
I first saw this when I was about 15 or so, and it stuck with me. Not many films do. But this one did. I'm now 40.
claney01 3 months ago 5
bender
jackewacky 3 months ago
lol the end is funny.
1schwererziehbar1 3 months ago
This kid learns a great amount of crazy languages in this movie, welsh, latin, chinese, japanese...
yeclix 3 months ago 2
Wait... Christian Bale was a kid? IMPOSSIBLE!
spreilly481935 3 months ago 7
totally the best :p
Does anyone know where can I download this song mp3 ?
Nayomi007 4 months ago
@Nayomi007 It's available on iTunes.
kelleysweitzer 3 months ago
This song makes me cry
0emila1230 4 months ago
it is from my chilhood i love it
servenini 4 months ago
In case you're wondering-
The Kamikaze guys are singing a piece called "Umi Yuukaba". It's an old song, so old it's apparently pre-imperial, so I hear.
BarracudaSP1 4 months ago 18
I love these film and this is the best scene.
gallilis 5 months ago in playlist Musik 27
This has been flagged as spam show
It's not his voice you idiots.
barhamen 5 months ago
Comment removed
barhamen 5 months ago
he has a beautiful voice :]
xalicesmithx 5 months ago
@xalicesmithx not his voice, just lip syncing
celebrei 4 months ago
This scene gives me goosebumps. Chilling and powerful.
LexathonLA 5 months ago
BONZAIIIIIIII!!!!!!
jademakos123 5 months ago
this scene is haunting.
thesongstud27 6 months ago
this scene gives me major goosebumps. One of the greatest scenes in American Movie History.
m3talh3ad1994 6 months ago
beuatifull film and song, its sad aswell our forefathers fought in the war, it showa we all feel sorror god bless there souls
Oxycontin1000mg 6 months ago
1:25 I feel exactly what hes showing
aerotoxicosis 6 months ago
1:26 I feel exactly what hes showing
aerotoxicosis 6 months ago
in my top 4 movie
TheSpanky717 6 months ago
fajna piosenka pozdrowienia z polski
Dzyndzelek83 6 months ago
Only one word to describe the feeling of every character in this clip, clearly evident in Nagata's face- epiphany.
miahk2 6 months ago 3
Comment removed
miahk2 6 months ago
Spielberg's best film
Zinaxu 6 months ago
The singer is James Rainbird ... [in Welsh] Suo Gân literally means "Lullaby". The first few lines are:
Sleep my baby, at my breast,
’Tis a mother’s arms round you.
Make yourself a snug, warm nest.
Feel my love forever new.
Harm will not meet you in sleep,
Hurt will always pass you by.
Child beloved, always you’ll keep,
In sleep gentle, mother’s breast nigh.
Barry21stCentury 6 months ago 3
it's a Welsh lullaby
Leentjec1 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this movie is EPIC!!!!! deserves more views
copperhead88 6 months ago
SCENA STUPENDA, un grande films.
1ondalunga 7 months ago
No, it is not a lullaby. He is saluting them, honoring them.
acblueeagle 7 months ago
@acblueeagle it is a lullaby
ThePMAnimation 5 months ago
Good spelling *really
Napoleon8788 7 months ago
It does make sense. Unless i'm seeing it totally wrong, he's singing a Lullaby to 3 kamikaze pilots e.g. goodnight to 3 people who are about to die.
Rreally great scene. Watched the film a couple of nights ago since last seeing it about 12 years ago. Awsome film.
Napoleon8788 7 months ago 2
This scene never made sense.
brethynda123 7 months ago
Beautiful clip, showing what being Cymraes/Welsh is all about - a need for everyone to put their toys down, but impossible, I know.
And forgot Christian Bale was in this. He was born in West Wales I believe, before him and his family moved away. Always like the stuff he does in movies.
yippitydodah 7 months ago
Christian Bale didn't actually sing this, but it was another kid around his same age. You have to remember that this was the ideal for young boys - and still is in many ways. The Simpsons actually made fun of how traditional boy's choirs are supposed to have that high-pitched sound. (Homer was a choir boy, and then his voice changed.) But yeah, this film is one of my favourites, and definitely one of Steven Spielberg's finest achievements.
310245535 7 months ago
Great film- The book is even better
joeg171 8 months ago
Pfft! A school girl wishes she could sing like batman! XD
VioletteChevre 8 months ago
awesome,speillberg is a genius with music as well
Heulzie 8 months ago
This movie is Steven Spielberg's "underrated" masterpiece. It was such a beautiful film
moviedude1500 8 months ago 2
This is the most beautyfull movie i've ever seen. And this scene always makes me cry. Epic ;-)
Nalevka 8 months ago 2
chivaAngel 9 months ago
eventhough i dont understand one single thing but the song is so beautiful
tongsongkiong 9 months ago
@tongsongkiong If you Google Suo Gan you will find the words in the original Welsh, with English translations. The song is a lullaby; this is the 1st verse:
To my lullaby surrender,
Warm and tender at my breast;
Mother's arms with love caressing
Lay their blessing on your rest;
Nothing shall tonight alarm you,
None shall harm you, have no fear;
Lie contented, calmly slumber
On your mother's breast my dear.
lichtbroeder 8 months ago 2
@lichtbroeder Thanx. I always wondered what the words meant
foucault1020 8 months ago
Kamikazes! GO
ColdRegina 9 months ago
Can you please tell me, what's the name of the song which the Japanese are Singing at very beginning ?
Thank you in advance.
aislandiego 9 months ago
@aislandiego Umi Yukaba (If I go to sea)
Akira89M 9 months ago
@Akira89M
Thank you very much Mr. Akira
see ya.
aislandiego 9 months ago
There's hope for humanity after all
whatev6408 9 months ago
zajebiście że to wrzuciłeś :)
jakkobs1 9 months ago
Quality scene and film!
soon2fly 9 months ago 2
only people with soul undertand the meaning of a tear!!!! Realy amazing film and song! Touch our heart and spirit! ;-)
juniorcaxias 9 months ago
Tell the kids that we're skipping going to war this year.
Instead, we're going to where people can sing a Welsh Lullaby.
Tell them war sucks and Batman can sing.
Puronicth 1 year ago
@Puronicth That's stupid. Batman is a totally different character from a totally different movie.
ahauntedhistory 9 months ago
The end of the clip brings you right out of the daydream state that the song causes.
You want a hersheys bar?
chillmr 1 year ago
quanti ricordi! era uno dei miei film preferiti da bambina ed ero anche affascinata dal protagonista.
p.s la colonna sonora è stupenda sono contenta di avere la possibilità di poterla riascoltare.
MissFrida82 1 year ago
I watched this film when I was very young, but I have never once forgotten this amazing song, It's forever ingraved in my memories
MrBulelani 1 year ago 3
Ich liebe diesen Film und bei diesem Lied bekomme ich jedes Mal Gänsehaut. Christian Bale war als Kind schon ein Spitzenschauspieler^^
gallilis 1 year ago
my favorite movie. my parents sang me this lullaby
scotfreak 1 year ago
It means something like
Sleep my baby, at my breast,
It's a mother’s arms round you
Make yourself a snug, warm nest
Feel my love forever new
Harm will not meet you in sleep
Hurt will always pass you by
Child beloved, always you’ll keep in gentle sleep, mother’s breast near
I'm Welsh.
dimflamingo 1 year ago
I say this one should be remembered as Steven Spielberg's finest masterpiece, not Schindler's list.
harrison28514 1 year ago 96
@harrison28514 Totally agree. Perfection.
arbeitsscheuer 8 months ago
@harrison28514 I agree.
foucault1020 8 months ago
@harrison28514 I wholeheartedly agree.
WC3POchannel10A 8 months ago
@harrison28514 A man can have more than one masterpiece. I think they both are. but definitly not E.T. i don't know why steven himself thinks that E.T was one of his best films.
Alchemist1330 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Those are Kamikaze pilots. You can tell by the headband.
LordDarthVader5 1 year ago
Those are Kamikaze pilots. You can tell by the headband.
LordDarthVader5 1 year ago 2
love,love and love it!
smokerinnunavut 1 year ago
only watched the film today ..this song makes the hair on the back of my neck stand up..
254002 1 year ago 2
@254002 Ya it was on RTE 1 Yesterday -- Realy great film -- this is a brilliant scene -- brings a tear to your eye --- no matter how many times you see the Film !! ..
ospreymate 1 year ago
great war movie
JosephineNZ 1 year ago
Always when I see this scene I just cry
I never why
this is so beauty...
one's my 3 favorite soundtracks
greetings from Poland
dawidjoseph05 1 year ago 2
IT'S BATMAN! singing like a school girl
rumpastumpa 1 year ago 51
@rumpastumpa lol
TheDayfornight 1 year ago
@rumpastumpa
NOT his voice unfortunately. Aled Jones ... Welsh boy soprano - now grown up.
kafem57 9 months ago
@rumpastumpa
HEHEHEHEEEE...
StephanieMorelli 8 months ago
@rumpastumpa
he was 12 at that movie you smartass. How about u? Could you sing like pavarotti at that age? Or you still just shitting in ur pants?
evren1925 8 months ago 2
@evren1925 Calm down you fucking little queer, it was a joke, relax
rumpastumpa 8 months ago
@rumpastumpa
maybe evren1925 is the Christian Bale himself...who knows? He never forgive u.
adErsante 8 months ago
@adErsante lol, possible
rumpastumpa 8 months ago
@rumpastumpa s f up mouth shitter
evren1925 8 months ago
@rumpastumpa I don't think he actually sang that
dannacee 7 months ago
@rumpastumpa lol, if you wanted to know it's actually what we singers call Counter Tenor or Mezzo Soprano. Lots of older men sing like that, including me.
m3talh3ad1994 6 months ago
@m3talh3ad1994 bahahaha u can hit those high notes can you?
rumpastumpa 6 months ago
@rumpastumpa if you really care, I actually can. It has to be in falsetto, but I can.
m3talh3ad1994 6 months ago
@m3talh3ad1994 Lots of older men, you are 16-17 years old o.o
lakostal 6 months ago
@lakostal Doesn't mean that my voice hasn't fully developed. My point is that it isn't unheard of for men to sing this way. Look up counter tenors and you'll know what I mean.
TheM3talH3ad1 5 months ago
@rumpastumpa lolol
jademakos123 5 months ago
@rumpastumpa Nonsense :) It is tipical boy soprano, completely different from female/ girl voices.
2010wieliczka 5 months ago
@2010wieliczka lol, it's just a joke dude, relax, fuck, alot of u guys get worked up about this
rumpastumpa 5 months ago
What does the song mean??
la2449lakers 1 year ago
@la2449lakers it's a Welsh lullaby, a mother singing to the child to go to sleep and not fear because angels watch over it. Here, you could interpret it as Jim singing to the pilots, overcome perhaps by their lack of fear, as they go to their eternal sleep
AHafan1 1 year ago
@AHafan1
That's Welsh?! I swear to God, I though it was Japanese!
ConradInternational 1 year ago 2
@ConradInternational that is welsh ! :D waw! iv never noticed b4 either.
0shizznes0 1 year ago
@ConradInternational me to until i watched thefilm a few years ago and tried to find the song. I was quite shocked as I thought the exact same as you
pithie84 1 year ago
@ConradInternational Welsh songs sound like Japanese, and Scottish songs to Chinese. No joke. Ethno-musicologists are researching into it.
fujianprince 8 months ago
@fujianprince
Thank you for sharing that information. Very interesting!
ConradInternational 7 months ago
great escene, the best, thanks.
patocamion 1 year ago
I was kinda dissapointed when I found out that christian bale didn't sing in the movie. But all I can say is that Christian Bale is one dang good actor. :) <3 Also this song gives you that feeling of a forgotten memory. How you want to go back when you had a pure innocence of a child. Before everything changes...
the2KINaToR 1 year ago
That kid is Christian Bale. Wikipedia it.
peppertee 1 year ago
najlepsza scena w całym filmie
WlazlyPL 1 year ago
jak dla mnie najlepszy film o tematyce wojennej
ThePiskklak 1 year ago
the best scene
Bangsta187 1 year ago
naprawde piosenka bardzo piekna a film również piękny
yes32167 1 year ago
lovely... esp the last frame
irish89055 1 year ago
The juxtaposition of a lullaby with the reality of sending children on suicide missions is just brilliant.
jfpack 1 year ago
Basie is such a douche in this movie. "He gave me a freakin MANGO!!!!"
thejonin567 1 year ago
this movie is so underrated
Kenny9645 1 year ago
I watched this with my dad way back when and ever sense It's still hard to get over... the fact that the kid could grasp the American accent so well xD. "How ya doin Frank?"
Tallerus72hippie 1 year ago
one of the greatest films of all time.
crhymes 1 year ago
great scene
enricozou 1 year ago
偉大的一幕
enricozou 1 year ago
Who would have guessed that now he'd be yelling at people on set not singing to them.
deutschland08fn 1 year ago 3
@sillychad18 oh i know that but im just saying there are some differences thats all
xXxholydemonxXx 1 year ago
@HGunner70 i didn't there was a difference but there is catholics honor the saints and our lady of Guadapule as were christians dont and in the catholic ver. of the bible it has both old and new testament while in christian ver. of bible only has the new testament
xXxholydemonxXx 1 year ago
schultz0089 asks "Isn't the song a lullaby about a mother putting her child to sleep???"
Perhaps, without realising it you have hit the nail on the head –the kamikaze pilots are about to be "put to sleep".
Huno in Welsh can mean both asleep or dead; the thing that is poignant about the song is that one can't be certain if it is a lullaby to a sleeping child or an elegy to a dead child.
Abermaw1 1 year ago 3
Esse filme é incrivel, pela belíssima atuação de Christian Bale, ele faz com tanta paixão, emoção ao representar tão bem a canção Suo Gan. Amo esse ator!
Ele é dimaissssssssss!!! ; )
soupaulista36 1 year ago
Amazing Movie.
What the hell is Ben Stiller doing in it?
pothwei76 1 year ago
This tune is great on the pipes.
Stevedjdpiper 1 year ago
Why does the plane randomly blow up?!?
communistjoe1 1 year ago
@communistjoe1 - Hi, the plane was shot down by the attacking P-51's - but you're right by being confused. In the film, the sun is rising and in the next immediate scenes (in broad daylight) the Americans attack the airbase. It confused me too, but something in the film's extras cleared up that confusion. Somehow they should have adjusted the light, or had a sound insert of attacking planes put in just before the Japanese plane blew up. BTW, the plane was a model Zero, not full-sized.
plenum222 1 year ago
I always have chills when I watch this movie
dresX94 1 year ago
Did he really sing this or did they dub?
sunnyanemone 1 year ago
@sunnyanemone
Dubbed. An English choir boy called James Rainbird sang the track used in the film but fair play to Christian Bale, he did a great job singing in time to it - the version he does at the beginning of the film in church you would never guess it was dubbed.
andyrjs 1 year ago
@andyrjs Oh - Thanks for the info... It did look like he was singing - i was convinced ( though i was amazed the voice was so true and seemed so controlled/well trained.) Kudos to the both : Bale and Rainbird.
sunnyanemone 1 year ago
People be of no illusion when declaring 'there is no good and evil' and similar, dangerous sentiments. The conduct of Japan during the war was disgraceful. Evil even. And although, as in any war, there are good men who conducted themselves well, there is no denying that it was an unjust war fought in a most unjust way and we must not forget this.
samsoniite 1 year ago
does anybody know if this is christian bale him self who sings?
MacGyverBurger 1 year ago
@MacGyverBurger ,
if you look Suo Gan on wikipedia , it says Christian lip syncs it. Even so, his performance in this film is outstanding
antelectric 1 year ago
@antelectric Yes it is. Thank you for your reply.
MacGyverBurger 1 year ago
Poignant, touching. Movie genius, classic story. James Rainbirds stunningly beautiful voice, in a song that brings a tear always. Memorable performances by Bale and the whole cast.
baghend 1 year ago
why'd the plane suddenly explode?
geoffybellofiore 1 year ago
@geoffybellofiore
It was "Kamikaze" plane, it was filled with explosives. Sometimes they exploded by themselves. Further on this scene in film you can see american fighters attacked this airfield.
SandworMish 1 year ago
@geoffybellofiore
It was "Kamikaze" plane, it was filled with explosives. Sometimes they exploded by themselves. Further on this scene in film you can see american fighters attacked this airfield. By the way - to this moment i thought Suo Gan it was some japanese song :D
SandworMish 1 year ago
one day people are going to realize all around the world that war and hate was just a waste of time it seems like the smarter man became the more deadly man has become poor world poor us ...I hope god forgives us for our stupidity ...
malefrmbk 1 year ago
@malefrmbk there is no god, just stupidity
MAVsince1991 1 year ago