超級星光大道2 10強 翻譯歌曲指定賽 20071102 - 梁文音 Time To Say Goodbye Time

[reeve317]

這個女孩到底會不會唱歌？

[playplay89]

文音真的难得的歌手呀！加油！

[willysilly123]

愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你 愛你

[alias91919]

to be fair, this is not her best.... but i still love her !!

[qmore]

hmmmmmm 義大利文發音怪怪... Hai incontrato per strada... 幾乎是錯的

[kjun1987]

你会意大利文吗?识少少扮代表!! 你能唱得像文音那么好吗!

[andy316800]

i have learnt italian for a year....and i dont think it was bad...

[pbbb2]

文音還是唱的很好!超喜歡, 愛死你了

[clifflin3]

ppl think that 小琥老師 is good and fair and that 文音 sucked....but she gave 文音4/5 on her score board.....

[ml0302]

Good.I like her voice a lot.

[lovemickytobits]

Nevertheless, her voice is still beautiful.

[helen0music]

Not her best performance & choice certainly, but im impressed by her courage to pick a tough choice of song, this is really a though one... she's taking a big risk, n to be honest she was struggling in the midway... but however she still make it to no.2, proves she had the talent... way to go girl!!

[simyee92]

i love the beginning! nice!

[blackstones123]

this is an opera song they shouldnt sing it like a pop song. not as good as Sarah's version

vivo le peir

[lzbin]

she's following A-mei's version dude~~

[longlongkin]

唱得很棒呀!!

[lonelyboysad]

nice song! i luv it~

[loeloemk]

honestly, she did very well because she can sings in italian as well as chinese. This is a very good attempt and shows that she is brave enough to try anything. Well done!

[jimmyguang2005]

it is probably too hard for her. Only some greatest singers like Amei can sing it well. Most of the high-pitch tones are not even stable.. too difficult when she still needs to sing in Italian.

[killbookie]

not bad wat....i like it...

[jawbraker84]

i like sarah brightman's original version

[paullinhao]

what a cute girl...

[laluneblanc]

總覺得這裡都是文音的忠實歌迷...

只能講好話,一點都不可以批評...否則不是被噓就是被嗆

自由一點嘛... 又不是大陸~

難道只要有人覺得文音唱不好就要上去跟他PK才行嗎?

阿妹和Sarah都是我的偶像, 她們把這首歌唱得很棒

真不曉得為什麼有些人跟他說唱歌不能傻笑他以為就一定要哭~ 難道你只有兩種表情= ="

這是嚴肅的一首歌, 要表達的並不是輕飄飄戀愛中的甜蜜滋味

[samljyx]

大陆也没有说不让批评吧

[weishan77]

1.每人詮釋跟對歌詞的解讀不同，在歌詞來看，並不覺得是嚴肅的­歌（因為參雜中文改編），我覺得文音要表達的不是戀愛中的甜蜜滋­味，而是"微笑的在跟過去say goodbye"。

2.阿妹也是我的偶像，但我並不覺得阿妹將這首唱得很棒，畢竟中­文改編後味道還是會差一點，但是阿妹還是我心中華人歌手的NO.­1

3.文音這首真的不能跟阿妹及sarah比，但以他現在的能力已­經很棒，更甚於某些線上歌手，以他的天份以後前途無量。小琥老師­說的我很認同，但我想他是希望文音能更努力不能鬆懈。

[chenlungchin]

mamma mia sua pronucia italiano è teribile..... non riesco capire nulla quando canta in italiano. Are you sure she sing in italian?????

[netlimit]

No... she's not singing in Italian, I'd rather say broken English... orribile

[mezzopiano1017]

so coollllllllll~~

my whole boby is shakinggggg

cool girllllll!!

[pk255089]

莎拉滅絕師太的講評比較有重點!!!小弟個人淺見-.-

[roger3793]

她這首唱的是還不錯

但這一首歌難度對她來說高了點

以那天評分標準來說

十九分至二十分差不多

除了小胖其他評審都給四分也印證了我的看法

[roger3793]

她唱的是還不錯

但這一首歌難度對她來說高了點

以那天評分標準來說

十九分至二十分差不多

除了小胖其他評審都給四分也印證了我的看法

[lemonfk]

i dont know what its means

but damn i love it:]

-------------

~ hey people get in my user detalies:]

, read what i wrote and enjoy my videos=]

[edith141]

最欣賞小琥老師的講評&示範,

好critical好有point~

對各人講評又無咩bias~

正!!!

[wylma]

WHAT THE HELL?!?!

totally ridiculous...

第一粒音已經低不下去...

hell.. the performance SUCKED!!the whole thing is just not grand enough.. band/ arrangement.. ESP HER VOICE.. pah...

by the way,

absolutely agree with 小琥!!

[morrisgordon]

喔 是嗎?

原來你才是最棒的

那既然你這麼棒 你去唱唱看阿

小琥老師有實力才那樣評

你這無知的人最好給我閉嘴 好好看電視就好了

[wylma]

jeeeez.. chill man..

well.. i was expecting better from her.. and it turned out to be very disappointing...

and helloooo.. FREEDOM OF SPEECH!!

right.. for your information i used to sing in the choir and we have competed in international choral competitions (e.g. WORLD CHOIR GAMES; choral competiton in germany) and we have done well...

[babui]

oh, you've done well singing sarah brightman's song? well, hell no! As if i believe. I'm from choir too, she sang better than normal standard as an asian. In addition, she's singing a whole new language which she has been learning for 1 WEEK only DUDE. You try sing german song in one week and have same singing standard as her?

[ltlinda]

最喜歡小琥，

[328091]

That "little fat" has a double standard.

He shouldn't even sitting there.What a ridiculous comment.

[328091]

小胖不公平

he should be out

he is so ridiculous

[vcheng1829]

OMG WTF 20 points!?! It was awful...if this performance was outside of TWN it'll be a laughing stock....

[morrisgordon]

well guess what?

it IS in taiwan.

have some pride in your own freaking country, fool.

[frankhoung]

It is really awful

The key was much lower than Sarah's version but she still couldn't deal with it.

[babui]

actually she's following A-mei's ver. A-mei's version key is alot lower than sarah brightman. but of cos, sarah brightman is the best! come on, wen yin is not a opera singer.

[tpcksh323]

你是看過沙拉布萊曼現場哭著唱嗎?

你才腦殘

[manmoon001]

她唱歌是不錯，但正如滅絕師太說的那樣，評審的觀點比較主觀了一­點。

[netlimit]

50分不到

她完全搞錯這首歌要表達的意思

[chenlungchin]

i agree you....

[GlamorousAshley]

是你搞錯吧！阿妹的版本本來就不是悲傷的

"和過去say good-bye"

她當然是笑著唱！

[befairlady]

小胖老師太誇張,

小琥老師比較公平,

對這首歌很熟的人都能感受到無論是音準或感情都只有50分

[killbadmouth]

agree you..50 scores enough...

[jothui]

我也覺得小琥老師比較公平

[mywaypozi]

聽到這次比賽引起這麼多爭議

不得不說...

梁文音只是純粹唱好自己的部份

她並沒有錯,每位歌手都有自己的特色

請不要互相比較

錯是錯在評審及節目的呈現方式

不要連累無辜的歌手

[MYLIFE125]

omgomg

i know this song and she freaking sings it perfectly!!!

wow....

[danaitykane41]

文音唱这首歌又下了我一大跳，可是还是看到她的一点点落点，在c­horus的阶段，有一点收或放的不够完美而以，因为这首歌的枝­干很高，文音能唱到这样的水准，已经很不错了，我给她80分，如­果以比全世界的分数来打分的话她也许是60分，因为强中之有强中­高，可是我觉得她已经很棒了，我还是对她唱（我可以为你挡死）的­时候很佩服她，一个字，棒

[hkchess2000]

文音這次也是很好聽!

我沒有聽過什麼原唱, 只知道聽了巴冷的歌感覺很讚.

[lamwaii]

"歌曲太難了.. 可是你唱得已經很好了"

怎麼了... 不是說歌選了就要唱好..要對自己負責嗎..

不適合的歌就不要選... 那是當初選曲的錯誤..

應該是要扣分的.. 之前有些選手也有因為這樣被扣分了..

為什麼這次會又不一樣.. 還是覺得小琥老師是比較公平...

[francais495]

難不成要 置身至外阿...

唱悲歌笑得像白痴....

哀...腦殘...

文音唱法 ... 出現了!

[morrisgordon]

請你放尊重一點 在這裡的確可以寫下你心裡真正的想法

可是請不要說出沒禮貌又羞辱人的字眼

去學點教養吧

[markchanggz]

梁文音唱歌的样子看起来太自我陶醉了