Added: 4 years ago
From: BGF324
Views: 108,564
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (523)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This isn't really fair. The slayer version is really bad quality. It sounds a lot better on my itunes. I still think that the priest version is better, but I don't think this is an accurate representation of the slayer version.

  • Tom Araya should've done his "Reign in Blood scream" for this song.

  • Priest version is the best. Slayer's is good too, but Priest are just that good.

  • awwwwwwww judas yeahhhh!!

  • ...?...?...? Priest

  • @TopRamenKickAss: that's why Tom didn't try to replicate Rob's high notes...

  • Tom doesn't stand a chance against Rob's insane vocals.

  • 1977. Where were Maiden??? 

    Oh, they didnt even exist back then.

  • @tool619 Actually they did. Steve just hadn't formed a line up that stuck yet.

  • @tool619 oh yes they existed you idiot

  • I don't udnerstand why Tom didn't do the high screams,we all know he can hit those notes(or damn close).

  • Judas ruleia... msm com toda qualidade do slayer,n se compara

  • I can't decide on which is better

  • I am the Metalgod

  • @metalgods72 No your not, I am..

  • im suprised slayer didnt pull an angel of death on that intro lol

  • hey dudes both versions kickass!

  • EPIC!

  • both version are amazing, but priest FOR me its better

    i like how in slayer version the changed the high screams to guitar bends

  • Sorry I love priest but the Slayer cover is fuckin' killer!

    I'ma have to go with Slayer.

  • checkout ANOTHER version of Dissident Aggressor  numberonemusicdotcom/sevendead­ly

  • this cover has no soul and evry judas cover is bad ...... don't touch judas ..... they are perfect as they are

  • @arvensus dude it's slayer they have their own style it's perfect

  • @MuggerFugger665 did i said smt bad abouth slayer ??? only cover is bad 

  • @arvensus NO, IT'S NOT!!!

  • @MuggerFugger665 umm ... yes it is :) or you are deff or you dissrespect judas priest ....??? what is it ??? but if you diss them you are dumb :)

  • @arvensus Of course not even as a bigger Slayer fan than a JP I think that the original is better, but Slayer did a good job on the cover and that's why you are dumb =)

  • Yea and no one can match Tom araya voice eather..;)

  • Priest is THE BEST! KEEP UP THE FAITH

  • I love Slayer, but this cover is a shit. It's impossible to do a GREAT Priest cover.

  • No one can match Halfords Voice no one!!!!

  • Said it once, say it twice. Slayer converted it to some arrhythmic crime of a single tone, one single disgrace of scream. And that's all. No relation whatsoever to the heights of Priest, as we can hear later on this viseo.

    You know guys, it is not only volume and power. You got to know to play and to sing!! God damn it, you gotta do more than just screaming like slaughtered chickens!!!

  • @kickniko bullshit the song is perfect and matches the slayer style perfect

  • @KKEtokommasoulae

    Didn't notice that Slayer had a style, but now that you say... Yes indeed, a very special style. Arhythmic drums, dozens of mistakes of the guitars, inability to catch more than three tones while singing, and all that together in a single package of disgrace. Oh but I forgot, it is artistic freedom! Everybody grabbs an instrument, cratches the strings, and ready is another masterpiece of diletantism. OK, why not?

  • @kickniko so you are basically saying that slayer are "everybody"

    then why dont you get off my cock and out of youtube and start a better band fag?

    you dont have to reply that cause i already know the answer

  • @KKEtokommasoulae

    "then why dont you get off my cock and out of youtube and start a better band fag?"

    Why, are you looking for some better ass than mine?

  • @kickniko Every band has a style.And Rob sounds more like a Slaughtered chicken to me.

  • Originals are always better!

  • PRIEST!!!!!!!

    Slayer's version is excellent...but JP "own the tune" in more ways than one.

  • JUDAS PRIEST!

  • Funny that Slayer is using a high guitar note in place of the high-sung notes "bawl" and "crawl." Guess it's all they could do since their singer aint no Halford!

  • @patrickt1230 yes he is not gay

  • i don't wanna look like a loner, but i think slayer's version is better

  • fuck all napolitans

  • Is it just me, or is JP alot louder then Slayer? xD

  • @ParadoxLawful i heard that judas priest is ACTUALLY louder than slayer :D

  • im seeing priest in November going to kinda suck at the shaw conference center just i big cement block no acoustics what so ever :( tehy should be playing the event center!!!!!

  • @MrSkuldugery I will be at that show as well. Trust me, I have seen Priest over a dozen times, and the venue cannot contain them. The shaw will be no different

  • @Themetalgod1000 sweet see you in the mosh

  • the original (Priest) version is better

  • Going to see Slayer in August and Priest in October ^^

  • @xseb5x Im seeing Priest in October also \m/

  • Muito bom esse cover do slayer

  • i don't realy care for slayer's cover. i'll stick with priest.

  • They're both just so good.

  • As much as I love Slayer it's no contest. The Slayer cover is very good but the original Priest version had me saying holy fuck that's awsome.

  • lol swing Metal xD

  • kudos to Slayer for trying. But no one does Priest like Priest.

  • @SLASHdaROCKER you're right

  • I love both bands .Slayer had said countless times that Judas Priest are their main musical influence

  • 1:18, Kerry King looks like Macho Man Randy Savage

  • @dimlightbulb10 yeah but kerry woud probably beat his ass

  • As far as I am concerned Slayer is so overrated it isn't even funny. I can barely get through a whole Slayer song never mind a complete album. I am not joking...they get way too much credit for being pioneers of metal.

  • Everyone overlooks Simon Phillips drumming on this track. Very inderrated JP drummer and you can hear his excellence on this track.

  • Very good respect shown by Slayer to one of their idols . .

  • As with all cover versions it depends which you hear first - the original or the cover, whichever one you do hear first is the one you usually prefer. Doesn't make either version any better or worse for me.

  • @BuggritHall I disagree I have heard covers first or vise versa and it didn't make any difference which one I listened to first I listen to the one that takes more skill and sounds the best. The technical skill Robs vocals completely destroys toms hands down. I respect that they are giving credit to one of their influences but it is obvious which is better. I don't mind the slayer cover but I mean come on it is painstakingly obvious.

  • @ggriffinn1 so ture :D

    

  • Judas Priest can be proud about Slayer's cover.

  • Slayer's version is a thousand times better. I like Judas Priest but his voice doesn't fit the song in my opinion.

  • @14SlayerFan88 You are right, Araya doesn't have Halford's range. When I heard Priest and Halford singing it, I thought of an army marching in unision, trampling under foot. I don't hear it hear. Slayer is a great band, but nothing beats the original.

  • 3:16 kk with a mustache lol

  • priest in 81,82,or 83 cant remember,vancouver

  • saw Priest in 81' 84', 87'

  • saw Slayer in 88'... Metalica in 83'

  • haha KING is a legend, those oldschool glasses hes got on at 1;15 haha sick!

  • I like older Slayer, and love the album, but the Slayer version is monotone and flat. You gotta be tone deaf to think it beats the original, and I WAY prefer Thrash to classic Metal.

  • One was good, the other..Awsome!!!

    The Priest is and always will be.. The Best!

  • 1:52 lol

  • slayer bloke sucks shit compared to Rob the greates singer of all time

  • Slayer's version was heavy for 1988, but Priest's version is heavy for all time!

  • i like both versions how can you not i mean SLAYER AND JUDAS PRIEST lol

  • ROCK OUT MAN

  • Priest all the way.. And the drummer was like 16!! 

  • judas priest sounds better......alot better,theyer fuckin sick

  • not my song i would choose for slayer to cover...

  • Judas Priest owns this song. No band has come close. Heavier and more dynamic than Slayers for sure. hard to cover Judas Priest but I remember back in high school when that Slayer version came out. I loved it, still do, but Judas Priest did it perfectly.

  • @ShowNoMercy656 You wouldn't see the humor because you have a bug up your ass. It's just an opinion that he is the best singer. I can think of hundreds of other singers with better voices but that too is just an opinion. It's all a matter of taste and opinion so relax. I like Priest but they are far from the best. Eat shit.

  • @ShowNoMercy656 Obviously the problem is in your mind since I didn't say there was a problem with anything! I was making a joke. I knew there would be at least one idiot to comment seriously about a comment that wasn't serious. Did someone just get a lobotomy?

  • @ShowNoMercy656 If you had a cock rammed up your ass you'd scream like that too! Halford had a lot of practice. Fuck off all you hard-core Priest fans it's just a joke. I don't hate Priest it's just a joke so go easy.

  • I honestly think both are great creations. Instead of thinking that I need to draw battle lines between my favorite bands and defend one to the death, I actually appreciate both. Even though Slayer has to be my favorite band, I do agree Halford is BY FAR a much greater vocalist than Araya. I do, however, prefer Lombardo to Priest's drummer. Basically, hearing one after the other is perfect for me, because they're both perfect in their own ways.

    Open your mind guys.

  • lol priest pwns slayer...and not only this songs!

  • Hey nay-sayers, Halfords' a proper geezer now but the mighty-metal-poofter can still hold his own with any of these youngsters...His fucking voice codified Metal...Osbourne, later cats to follow, B. Dickenson(followed his better Paul Di'Anno), Dio muddled through after Ozzy, all they can do is try too hard to achieve a gift only Lucifer himself can grant...a set of pipes from hell and a chorus of a few thousand demons to supercharge it!! Robs' the uber-metal grand-daddy of them all, hands down!

  • @CHOGGIE23 paul di anno blows-bruce made maiden---ask anyone who the singer of maiden is and they will say bruce gauranteed.and your right--dio "muddled thru,in a way;after ozzy B.S.changed musically-R.J.D. fit that sound------But Halford,after all of these years can still RIP THE SHIT OUT OF VOCALS!most singers from that era(and later) sing lower cause their voices are fucked(example-tom araya,love slayer but he cant hit the highs any longer.point is ROB HALFORD had and has a phenom.voice.METAL

  • @marmjr77 -Yer right, but Halford tends to peter out during a tour-Voice begins to falter after about 15 dates, then even he can' hit the notes he could a few weeks back-Seen Priest several times, better to catch Halford at the beginning of the tour, his pipes are not as fresh as they were 30 years ago...as far as the Dickenson vs. DiAnno thing, personal taste mate...I think Bruce blows compared to Paul-hated maiden after he joined and I was front row for # of the Beast tour, Blew, blew, blew.

  • compare diamonds and rust to priest version and joan baias

    or however you spell it,,and see who shines!

  • Better Judas

  • @arketreyu you are the worst bitch ever

  • @pestrodus really ? me ? oh man oh god oh man oh man oh god oh man

  • @arketreyu Tom can pitch his voice so high Halford can't even dream of it

  • @vip1691 if tom can sing dreamer deceiver u are right if not u dont know about metal at all =_=

  • @arketreyu I was obviously joking...

  • O_O ._. i hope so..........................

  • @vip1691 listen to bloodline live.

    tom can't sing his own songs and you're comparing him to rob halford the metal god

  • @UjnaStara I already said i was joking.Obviously there can't be a comparison between these two.I know Tom's voice live isn't the ideal for the last few years.But Halford's isn't either to be fair.Of course you can't blame him, he's so old it's natural.

  • na początku Bóg stworzył Pieszyce by móc odreagować po koncercie Slayera w hadesie!:)

  • halucynacje Jezusa! Pogrążony w piaskach pustyni nawołuje do zemsty przy dżwiękach Slayera!

  • głos boga!

  • They are both awesome by 2 awesome bands. Covers aren't meant to sound just like the original. Slayer's has their own swing to it.

    Priest fucking rules though \^^/

  • Nice slideshow

  • Slayer... well, they slaughtered it to pieces, din´t they? I could´t even count their mistakes. Completely incapable to hold even a simple rhythm, they devastated it. They really fucked it up, I mean completely and not only the "vocals" - if one can name that "vocals". Simply horrible what they did.

    And so it turns even greater to hear it by Priest after that catastrophe by those amateuric wannabes of Slayer. Here we have some guys who know what they play, and they play it exacty!

  • @kickniko Ward you`re being a little hard on the Beaver. But of course no band could match JP`s original classic. Have you heard Judas priest (Halfords) Scorpions cover of Blackout its ok

  • @LordGandor3

    Yeah, I guess I spoke too... absolutely. Still, to my ears it sounds like minced meat from Slayer. I know that I go far too far demanding exactness and not only power from bands. Well, call it my personal screw or something. (Everybody has some.)

    Never heard of that cover of Halford, thanks a lot man! Just checked it out in youtube. Well... though I don't like the songs of Scorpions very much, I must say that it is very well played. Not just a foggy mixture of sounds.

  • Remember when it first came out in the US. Rocked then and now.

  • No one can scream better than Rob Halford, the only singer who comes close is Bruce Dickenson, and that's only in his song Number of the Beast, and that wasn't even intentional, so he can't repeat it as well.

  • \m/ - - \m/ Headbang! Awesome song!

  • I like Slayer for having done the cover, or I would never have heard the original song. However its unfair to compare Tom and Rob. Rob has a voice that comes to its right in this song, and its been described as being so unique with its span over 4 somethings, such that only 4 people in the world can sing like him...and the 3 others are doing Opera!

    The original is fantastic and I agree somehow more heavy than Slayer!..then again they tried to cool down the madness on the South record.

  • for some reason judas version is even heavier than slayers...

  • DA is the best Priest.

  • PRIEST PRIEST PRIEST!!!!!uncomparable version!judas priest kick ass!!!the best band of the world!!!the original version rules!!!!LOVE PRIEST!!

  • Priest's version rules over Slayers

  • slayers go to metal hell and priest go to metal heaven with dio

  • @themanthatlived that didn't make any sence at all.....

  • i say he broke the reworld record for hightest vocals

  • ROB RULEZ !!!

  • No fare Judas priest version was 10 years earlier(original)

  • JUDAS PRIEST!!!

  • judas is the best,,,,,,,sweden

  • i like slayers version when im boozing

    the original kicks ass anytime......

  • Slayer have been swept away

  • slayah bitchaaaas!!!!

  • just because its years ahead of its time

  • You have to listen to the previous song(Here Come The Tears) and then go into this classic to get the whole effect on Priest's Sin After Sin. KK Downing's solo is unmatchable!

  • Like them both but I have to go with SLAYERRRRR

  • 3:12-5:44 the most metal thing in the 70's

  • @houseshoesbto Symptom Of The Universe

  • @johnthegreek178 i argee but rob halford sings better than ozzy thats just a fact not an opinion

  • @houseshoesbto yup, thats a fact.

  • Don't even compare the monumental Judas Priest to some teenage garage band like Slayer.

  • @BellumSacrumBellum28 What the fuck? They're both great bands and Slayer respect Judas Priest as one of their best influences. Slayer has been around for many years and deserve as much credibility for Heavy Metal maddness as the other greats. They're Priest fans like you are, it'd be like them saying that to you if you covered a Priest song.

  • @SpicyDragoon did you know slayer started as a judas priest cover band?

  • @Coolroekoe It wasn't just Priest, it was Iron Maiden as well I believe.

  • @SpicyDragoon really, I didn't know that... all I knew abou the beginning of IM is that they wanted (or actually Paul wanted) to be a punk band

  • @SpicyDragoon They also used to play old Scorpions covers.

  • best ever slayer!!! KINGSSSSS SLAYERRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!!!!!!!!!!­!

  • REEEEEEEED CANYONS! Rob is God.

  • @blacksdocrack -GRAND CANYONS!!!!!

  • No hay comparacion: Judas Priest es el mejor!!!!!

  • @MrRipper9 no way amigo... slayer esta mas mejor de priest. halford esta un faggot!!! hahaahahaha

  • @adamw7641 Halford has balls of steel! Priest are the fuck'n METAL GODS!

  • @TheOgrelord slayer>judas priest

  • @adamw7641 juu, haista vittu..

  • both are great but the judas priest version is better

  • Know what?

    Obama kinda sucks..really

  • PRIEST all the fuckin way!!!!

  • Man, back in the day Rob could hit some seriously high notes. Fuckin' God, he.

  • Faaaack off....i love the original by priest

  • Judas Priest and Slayer should never play this song together on stage because that would be so Metal that the entire audience would be bronzed like baby shoes.

  • Priest's version is better, not because Slayer sucks or something, but simply because Judas Priest is the Heavy Metal band ever existed.

  • Slayers version owns. But Priest's justt fucking slays!!!!NWOBHM FTW!!!!!

  • i love slayer, and the cover is wicked. but seriously....this is like the most metal song ever. Priest are the gods, lets not get it twisted.

  • wow tipton owns ok king kings solo was garbage just a bunch of noise

  • @metalthrasher89 ALL King's solos are garbage. It's a well known fact he sucks and Hanneman is the really genius behind the Slayer guitars.

  • Preist sounds heavier

  • I like Slayer's better, but that's cuz i don't really like Priest's style that much

  • robs scream and tom's voice together....

  • halford is the best

  • I like both versions of it

    

  • The original is just so evil and simon phillips on the drums set the standard for heavy metal drummer to come.

  • judas priest is the best!