Added: 3 years ago
From: richarddawkinsdotnet
Views: 68,214
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (205)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • haha i have those vampire type teeth to hehehe this is the 1st i see

  • i love these old dudes lol, i want to see david attenbourgha have talk with them that would b fascinating

  • 9.30 the cat starts mewing :D He must be in the kitchen.

  • Really loving all these discussion series Dawkins is doing. I find it much more interesting than watching him debate theists.

  • I love Aubrey Manning, proud to say I was at his last lecture at Edinburgh University today, he's a legend :)

  • @mooglebob88 Hey, congrats! I guess he's retiring?

  • the question from 2:38...he should have just said, "weren't you just stating the obvious and wasting everybody's' time?"

  • Awww, a kitty! :3

  • Studying animal behaviour can be so interesting. Also anyone can do it, all you need is a bit of countryside and a pair of binoculars. 

  • @STEPHENWRAYSFORD33 That is soo going to be my profession,. I am going to mail profs to take me as their graduate student :D

  • What a lovely guy - and a cool house. I wish he were my dad.

  • I knew Dawkins was an animal person. 08:45

  • Aubrey is great

  • People, read the Lucifer Principle by howard bloom. amazing book about nature and how shockingly similar we are to our cousins

  • This is the sort of questioning, rational and urbane human being that the Neo-Cons in America wished to quash and replace with prayer groups and money-mad M-Ds.

  • dawkins said dodo

  • ""I'm an atheist with respect to the Judeo-Christian God, because there is not a shred of EVIDENCE in favor of the Judeo-Christian God."

    ~ Richard Dawkins

    ...Dawkins, that's because you have not visited my channel "

    er...no. It's because he's not a boring moron who posts the same crap on every Dawkins posting. Please go away you sad, pathetic, idiot.

  • I had the absolute pleasure and privelage to be given a lecture by Aubrey last week about play behaviors at Edinburgh Uni :)

  • How is it that any sensible human rejects the scientific evidence and rationale of evolution?

    Its bizarre.

  • @faithisfiction:- I wouldn't say it was bizarre mate. They're just not sensible humans.

  • *meow*

  • I hear *meow*

  • lol he's trying to hard to tempt mr manning into saying that intelligent design is moot...

  • I feel I have to say something intelligent, but......KITTY CAT INVASION!!!

  • Gorgeous, massive cat!!

  • I would like to know how animals/insects are born with camouflage, if not by design by chance?

  • Neither design nor chance. Genes control camouflage, and where there is variation, the animals with better camouflage will survive and reproduce, and pass on their genes to their offspring, who will survive better, and so on. Camouflage changes through life too - often young animals in particular will have better camouflage than adults, e.g. lions, tapirs. Nature will do just enough to make a difference, no more. There are no invisible animals, no matter how much an advantage that would be.

  • @stevebritgimp THIS IS PROOF THAT ONLY CATHOLIC CHURCH IS TRUE CHURCH OF JESUS CHRIST AND HIS HOLY SACRAMENTS!!!

    youtube. com/ watch?v =jqsRDD6kXWY

    While they were eating, Jesus took bread, gave thanks and broke it, and gave it to his disciples, saying, "Take and eat; this is my body." Then he took the cup, gave thanks and offered it to them, saying, "Drink from it, all of you. This is my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins." Matthew 26:26-28

  • @JezusSlave watching your link, I don't think it would tax any competent stage magician. Secondly even if it were miraculous, why would that indicate anything at all? Maybe that particular church in South America is the only true one, and no other church is. I suspect the people there are slightly more credulous than people elsewhere. For me, the Orthodox Church is likelier to be superior to the Catholic, tradition-wise, check it out! Comment is free here, unlike the video you linked.

  • @stevebritgimp nobody force you to belive but you can not deny the fact of miracle and existance of God and Bible if you truly objective!

    If you don`t want to belive no miracle is gonna convince you!

    Would you ever said that you werer wrong or you are too proud?

    You have very simple answer for everything you don`t understand / It`s ridiculous!

    You want to offer people selfishness and emptiness first on earth than in hell(exorcisms-prove of hell etc, but is it enough for you)!

  • @JezusSlave An effect without a cause would be a miracle - that would be hard, but not impossible to verify. Produce such a miracle and a lot of people will be convinced. A grainy video with edit jumps of something in a glass box on top of something large enough to conceal a person, or with access to another room will not convince.

    Simple answers are by far the best. No need for anything more.

    I want to offer people selfishness? Superstition is no road to selflessness. Knowledge is.

  • @stevebritgimp Electrons decomposing from excited enery levels to lower ones and emitting a proton is acausal.

  • @juikm There are a lot of things at that level that are spontaneous - I'm wondering if these are things that are truly acausal, or just that we know they happen but don't know why. My head spins when we get into quantum physics. (And I'm hoping that's photon, rather than proton :) ).

  • @stevebritgimp magician?

    youtube. com/ user/ najublessing#p/c/F549FDAB56E99­79D/15/S1tcWKCuWWY

    (remove spaces in link)

  • @JezusSlave Magician

    youtube. com/ watch? v= EwOecpMkHH0

  • See: Darwin

    ffs.

  • Darwin doesn't address it. I'm asking how the animal/insect have the brain power to think, hey if I disguise myself as a twig I'll be able to eat other insects as they walk toward me.

  • How does "thinking" come in to evolution???? Do you not understand how natural selection works?

  • "The insect either had this thought or was made like this" ? Like what? You sir, are either slow witted or are being obtuse. Go away and talk to somebody more on your level.

  • How it works is that it's neither just "made" and cognitive thinking also doesn't come into it - it's more a naturally evolved tendency, evolved over a helluva long time. If you read up some more on natural selection, you'll find it's because the creatures that tended to act in this manner (bear in mind they didn't just wake up one day and start acting like it!) out-survived or were more prolific than others because of such tactics, to put it basically. It's complicated, but worth the study.

  • The insect didn't need to think it. All it takes is one insect to mutate in some small but useful way, or for it to have an instinctual "glitch" as it were regarding how to catch prey. Those with the "glitch"survive more readily than those without it. Over a long period of time, and the breeding of those who survive more readily, the lasso becomes the evolved way to catch prey. Hence survival of the fittest. Very simplified way to explain it, but hey, I have 500 characters here

    Peace

  • The animal never thinks about it. As I understand it, the animals who just happen to look a bit more like a twig get eaten less. Which means they are more likely to have kids who will look even more like a twig, and so on and so on.

  • "Meow! meow!" ...fair point.

  • Cats are godless heavens!

  • I like cats, but I prefer the cats that are to small to eat me.

  • too*

  • My position on cat's is this.

  • I'm neutral regarding cats.

  • It's one of those issues where neutrality is not possible.

  • All cats...or just those that have been neutered?

  • I hate cats

  • I love cats.

  • cats taste good. yum yum for my tum tum.

  • Oh man! Yes! Manning rules!

  • lol the cat miaows near the end

  • Are you nuts

  • You're crazy.

  • I was replying to xredsandx.

  • You dare deny the power of our lord and savior? Jesus rapes babies.

  • I lol'd

  • You've painted quite a picture in my head. Thanks for the laugh.

  • Lmfao...

  • "Ah, we are joined by an animal..."

    That was so cute and funny haha.

    Aubrey Manning is one of those people that I just really really want to meet!

  • I like Dawkins, but brightest man on the planet is pushing it a bit, I think. Smart guy, sure, but smartest? Simply no.

  • Depends what smart is..

    Fast number computation is smart? Memorizing books is smart or what we don't know really..

    All subjective :D

    This is like almost over my head with all the proper name references to things.. I'll have to learn a few things to watch this right... meh...

  • I always admired Professor Dawkins for championing scientific ideas and rational thought against all the religious zeal and ignorance in the world.......but sometimes I forget that he's a truly great scientist with a deep understanding of nature.......just wish we had more people like him in the U.S. to do battle with Bible-thumping retards like G.W. Bush and his minions.

  • @Hunkola You do, Daniel Dennett, Shelly Kagan, Christopher Hitchens, Weinberg to name a few.

  • After watching this, you get the visceral sense these are two of the brightest men on the face of the Earth.......an intellectual breath of fresh air for our minds so welcome after the sickening Bible-thumping propaganda from morons like George W. Bush and Tony Blair!

  • there's little that's less annoying than scrolling back youtube comments hoping desperately that the inane dialogue between two people will at some point stop appearing - i'm afraid any newcomers will discover that 'emuholic' and 'yawnGod' have a lot to say - of which i personally cannot be arsed to read

  • Can I propose that YawnGod and emuholic get a room? Leave comments for how intriguing and insightful this interview is!

  • Aubery taught my friends mum at edinburgh, im hoping to go there next year as a mature student, pity he,s retired.

  • I love how the Aubrey and RD are discussing the subjective minds of animals when Mr Cat comes along and joins the debate! Nice. Very warm moment!

  • All comments before this one are not worth reading.

  • 8:45 is a great moment!

  • I am loving this discussion, it is so interesting and I love the way they speak.

  • Hmm. Aubrey Manning kind of looks like James Cromwell, don't you think?

  • Erm...You just described WHY Richard makes a stand against religion.

    If they respond with violence towards a gentle, evidence-based scientist who wouldn't harm a fly, therein is the definition of retarded.

    Worth causing a bit of friction for in the long run, wouldnt you agree?

  • He is not a homosexual, if that is what you mean. Why do you ask? Fancy him, do you?

  • Richard Dawkins petting a kitty, how very sexy. Wish he'd pet me.

  • the kitty didnt like it, tho. he shoulda let it be

  • Are you my twin? lol

  • lol @ the cat. Apparently its cognitive skills didn't quite reach far enough to understand there was an interview going on.

  • @7:40

    Dawkins says, "doodoo".

  • lol.  a cat.

  • Very interesting thought. "Reason is the devil," you might as well go on believing in fairy tales.

  • you can't be serious with that comment! so that makes your god anti-reason? explains everything!

  • OMG it's called trolling....

  • Praise be to ye, Saint Dawkins, Patron Saint of Reason. For tis thy soft word, and polite unoffensive manner that shalt bring peace and logic to these troubled times.

    Ramen

  • Even as a a theist/deist but especially as someone who hopes to work in zoology and ethology one day, I must say I love the work of Richard Dawkins as both a scientist and even for his aim of helping humanity with his theological work.

    I liked to see the tabby jump up and greet Dawkins, too. Cute moment.

  • edit after rewatching: Dawkins rather picks up the cat and the cat wanders off as they often do when you show them attention and then when theyre ready and youre busy, they come to cash in on their "attention raincheck."

  • I see them and I think they're a flaming old homosexual couple.

    WHAT'S WRONG WITH BEING A FLAMING OLD HOMOSEXUAL?

  • No, but seriously, Dawkins is awesome except for the fact that he wants to make money off of his intelligence. But then again, who wouldn't?

    Jesus. Lawl.

    But seriousl, Dawkins wins.

  • y...................die.......­..............

  • Intelligent people tend to be more gentle because they understand the futility in putting on the typical pretence of behaving like a strong characatuer of masculinity, and are secure enough in themselves not to be one of those idiots. Intelligent people who are like this are often misconstrued by these primitive insecure pretentious cunts as being camp, which is attributed to homosexuality by sheer ignorance.

  • Thats a very good way of putting it. I am doing a PhD, and everyone seems to speak very carefully about everything from work to what they did last night. I think people dont want to be unduelly offensive or misinterpreted.

  • Intelligent *persons*.

    Your attempt at win has failed.

    Next.

  • How's that relevant?

  • /facepalm

  • Think about it, what you said to me is 100% irrelevant and its as petty as correcting a spelling mistake. Why do people do this? It's because they're threatened by what I've said and have engaged defence mode. Side effects of this defensive attitude include irrational and nonsensical catty remarks like "your attempt at win has failed" and weak attempts to belittle to make it look as though you're somehow the intellectual superior.

    :) You're not.

  • You are indeed partially correct, however, I have not engaged my defensive mode, but my this-dude-is-a-lost-cause mode. There was no reason for you to comment my comment; the fact that you did shows your own...juvenile sense for what you perceive as righteousness. What you should have done is looked at it and laughed, and imagine Ian McKellen walking in on them while they were sucking each other off and then asking in that epic voice of his, "Well now, what have we here?!"

    Stay in school.

  • You've officially confirmed that you're clutching at very thin straws for no reason other than to feel empowered because obviously you don't have any counter-point to the ones I've already made, not one that isn't constructed purely to spite me anyway.

  • Son, you are not one to officiate to make anything official.

    As I have stated, stay in school. And leave me alone, God damn it. Heh, "God".

    What is attributed to homosexuality by sheer ignorance, I ask you.

  • What sheer arrogance. Leave you alone? You chosen to post on an open forum, I chosen to respond on an open forum. If you don't like it, don't respond. Simple logic really. Give it a go.

    I didn't make anything official... you did.

    If you want to speak to me like an adult all of a sudden at the end of your comment there, then speak respectfully - ask again nicely.

  • Son, all I can say is that at least you're trying.

    You're using words vulgarly, like when fools use the word "theory" instead of "hypothesis", and "people" instead of "persons". I did not make anything "official", officially or unofficially. I facepalm myself after every sentence. Do yourself a favor son: Get your dick sucked. By a girl.

    Honestly? I don't care what you meant. I just want the last word, and I shall get it.

    Stay in school.

  • Yo son,

    Love you buddy

    Love,

    Dad

  • I could turn it around on you and honestly say you're one of those fools that use spelling and grammar, sexual innuendos (creepy, considering you think I'm 14) and condescending attitude to build a fallacy argument to misrepresent me, as a lazy cop out, and to make you feel better about your insecurities. And as you've officially stated, you're a weak, petty individual who desperately needs to have the last word.

  • It doesn't matter if you get the last word, you haven't countered my points, you've only evaded them, hiding behind ridiculous assertions. Your position is weak and you're embarrassing yourself.

    There's a good chance you're projecting your own shortcomings onto me by advising me to get my dick sucked. It must be something you've missed out on for it to randomlybe inserted pointlessly into your comments to me (like everything else you've shitted out).

    Stay away from the school gates, predator.

  • And by the way, you're wrong about "persons". There are a lot more than a few people who are intelligent (unless you think you're in a vast majority vs minority of intelligent people) and I'm not referring to anybody personally which would be when "persons" would be used.

    So, in addition to all that, not only do you tap dance and skate around, you're also wrong about the things you nit pick at, too. Funny.

    You should facepalm yourself in embarrassment, you cringemakingly stupid stuck-up cunt.

  • Indeed, your opening paragraph in this post betrays a sad reality about language: the ignorant change language to accomodate themselves more than do the intelligent change language by adding to it and abiding by existing rules. I do not want to take a dogmatic stance toward language, but the majority of laymen *abuse* certain words, to the point where they lose their meaning or gain an entirely new meaning on their own, mearly by the ignorant concensus of the many. This is a problem, truly.

  • Actually, I'm projecting the shortcomings of my cousin who projects onto me. Indeed, "get your dick sucked" isn't really something I would state normally, but I thought it would be interesting if I put the idea out there. Oh, me and my sexual innuendos...or my sexual innuendos and I.

    What's interesting about the school gates part is that, ironically, I am a teacher. That's cute. You get more and more interesting with each post of yours. This is quite fun.

  • Must you prolong this?

    Could you now, turn this around on me? Explain to me what is incorrect about using correct spelling and grammar, what is incorrect about sexual innuendos that make the weak minded flinch (any fool can inspect anyone else's profile and, taking it for granted, assume what information posted is true; hence the "Stay in school, son"). As for building a fallacy argument to misrepresent you...I mean come on. Come on. I am more and more admired by your...spunk, however.

  • You're prolonging it by responding. If you don't like it, quit your whining, just don't respond. I'm having a great time myself.

  • The problem with you correcting my spelling and grammar is first and foremost its irrelevancy, but secondly because the stuff youre correcting it with is language in its "legal context". Only an ass could criticise the way someone says something in everyday conversation with legal terms. Cherry picking at perfectly good English is pointless and is as good as admitting defeat in an argument.

  • Lawl^2.

  • Lawl.

  • I can tell you're not registering what I say, hence the "turn this around on me?" like you haven't noticed at all the fact I already did (I won't bother explaining why, it's clear to anyone who's not in denial). I do agree with you that you're a fool though.

  • "Stay in school, son"

    You missed out the comma the first time you said it. Funny how I didn't bother to nitpick at that isn't it?

    "ironically, I am a teacher"

    You seem so proud! Must be why you feel the need to cherry pick at English all the time. You're the perfect example of how a job can screw up your personality over time. Saying the things you say to people is a symptom of how much your life has become the job. It's sad really.

  • Hurry back home from school, teacher. You must "get the last word in" with that kid on the internet during your spare time. How unhealthy does that sound?!

    "This is quite fun."

    Reverse psychology is making your position even weaker. A direct condtradiction of "must you prolong this". You're obviously not enjoying it, teachy.

    The simpler a language is the better it is. It's not intelligent to unnecessarily overcomplicate something, teachy, it's dumb.

    Game, set and match to the 14 year old.

  • emuholic: you mention getting the last word in but I can't help but notice a certain fact.....it is overwhelmingly your name attached to most comments on this page. Why don't you shut your mouth and give your arse a chance?

  • I can see you're already an expert at shitting things out onto a website, why would I want to do the same?

  • In 5 years you will be a frightening adversary. Until then, you have much to learn, my young padawan.

  • calm down, no need to flood the same word (lawl) in anger just because you can't live with yourself for being dumber than a 14 year old. And to think you're meant to be a teacher!? Whatever has the world come to!?!?

  • and by the way, "Lawl" is a word used by 14 year olds. How in the fuck did someone as obviously childish as you get to be a teacher? You're either full of shit (well you are full of shit, but I mean about the teacher part specifically) or you're an insecure old cunt who hasn't yet moved on past the childish need of getting things his own way.

  • You know another word used by 14 year olds? "The". Amazing, no?

    I have mixed feelings regarding you, son. On one had, you have the admirable quality of being extraordinarily aggressive, which has it's pros, yet at the same time, you're not...how can I put this..."relaxed".

    I suppose internet anonymity allows you to act thus, because if we were ever in the same classroom together, I would humble you. Ahh well, shit happens.

  • "On one had"? I don't know what you mean by this. Are you sure you're not projecting your uneasyness onto me?

    If we were ever in a classroom together I'm sure you would try to humble me physically, like you do other boys already (only a matter of time before you get caught by the way). Shit happens indeed, with your terrible breath and ugly face in my face... I'd knock you out to save me the bother of having to put up with that.

    Begone!

  • Arrogance and blissful ignorance gives a person certainty about themselves, but in YawnGod's case it's purely a delusional state of mind amplified by a desperate need to feel superior. It's probably why the silly man got into teaching in the first place, to become empowered by casting his control and influence over vulnerable children to continuously reassert that. Well, it doesn't work here, or on me.. the pervy little man is way out of his element.

    Somebody sack this cunt and save those kids

  • You're the only one who as of late has been putting others down, son. "Delusional state of mind amplified by a desperate need to feel superior." Lawl. The one with the desperate need to feel superior is you. You know this. I have been trying to exalt you above other children your age, but in reality you are the same as them, with the great difference in what tools you use to look like a fool, but at least a brilliant one. There I go again, complimenting you when I shouldn't. Ahh well.

  • You're cute, man.  I like that.

  • I bet you say that to all the young schoolboys you take a liking to.

  • Are you somehow implying that I have homosexual tendencies with underaged children?

  • You know it and I know it, you dumb bastard.

  • Is there something inherently wrong in being mute and born out of wedlock?

  • Log off.

  • I miss your long, semi-eloquent answers and retorts.

  • Think! You blathering idiot.

  • Ok.

  • Loser.

  • 100%

  • Are you a somebody?

  • Lawl^4.

  • Lawl^3.

  • ...And sometimes we're SO good at abstract thinking that we apply the principles of creativity to language and use "our" and "are" interchangeably. haha. whoops.

  • The cat steals the show! ;)

  • fat cat <3

    Cats make everything beter. I even have a theory about cats. I believe that if you were to place cats, and especially kittens, in the United Nations General Assembly hall we would have world peace in 24/h.

  • That is such a ridiculous idea.... it just might work. Get to it! :P

  • I love science, cool, rationale thinking can do almost anything

  • I agree. But don't underestimate the power of irrationality for us humans. Creativity is borne from irrationality. Music, for instance is a beautiful mix of rationality and irrationality together.