Beethoven - Moonlight Sonata 3rd Mvt

[Josbmusic]

Sooooooo fake

[jbuchan36]

Kid, that is fucking excellent. I would love to hear how you play now.

[chinchillamelee]

holy

[PJViolin]

well I guess since this video is from 2008 you've probably fixed the metronome issue..

[PJViolin]

great job.  I highly suggest working with a metronome.

[psiqgab]

Que valentina liszit ni que nada

[bak6856]

You so fast

[GibsonLesBud]

Bullshit , the piano is really moving cause you are so good!! Greetzz

[twigm]

Beautiful

[dianat81]

Aunque cometes muchos errores estás tocando muy bien para tu edad. Te recomiendo que la revises, toca lento y cuando la tengas aprendida a esa velocidad empieza a acelerar poco a poco, pero tienes talento....sólo es cuestión de estudiar más :)

[PHILIPP2787]

man ...shit..really?....its shit...come on you play false ..and more .--.-

[ranzkydaculogsky1]

wow his really fast

[Th4w]

Worst performance I have heard of this song ever.

I understand he's nine years old and whatnot. However if you're gonna do something, practice, practice, practice 'till you can do it perfectly.

And instead of being the "9 year old kid who could almost play Moonlight Sonata 3rd movement" be the "13 year-old prodigy, who nailed the MS 3rd mvt."

[mr9man9]

This was HORIBBLE if you want to upload on youtube u should play it alot faster and fix alot of notes up.

U had like 9999999 notes wrong lol.

[MrMisharos]

@mr9man9 play it better if you can asshole

[OmgLoLw2gLuvUidkROFL]

Cute as a button... lol

[EpicAsianTube]

Sorry you cant be asian. mexican is always mexican

[dianat81]

@EpicAsianTube racista!

[janjohandealgenman]

I'm sorry but when more than 50% of notes are wrong you should either play slower or don't post a video of it

[dship98]

I like it! :) It's definitely a hard piece! I'm playing it myself! Speed it up a bit and you'll sound even more amazing! :D

[mommydaddy7]

@dship98 I am 15 years old. Would you be so kind as to view my interperataion of this piece. Thanks much love. :)

[RandomCoked]

whenever someone young can play a technically advanced piece, it appears politically correct to claim that it is a robot -.-

[minecraftwithnickz]

i have a long time ago tryd to do this and i can`t even play the first view notes

[TheValounet]

that''s great, but the 3rd movement has to be played more fast

[myysteriousone64]

my god what is wrong with u people hes playing so great i bet u cant even play like that just stop being jealous of his incredible talent. shut ur damn mouths and enjoy

[Killerinka]

Why to play something you obviously don't have abillities(physical or mental) for? And then proudly present as something great. Isn't it better to play something easier, but play it properly than this...

[DaBeast20111]

@Killerinka why u no talk properly than this?

[haribo41296]

how old were you when you filmed this you are beast :D

[bandgeekchef17]

and hes also using short-hand or in other words skipping every few notes to make it easier

[bandgeekchef17]

he really butchered this beautiful piece my ears are still ringing from the destruction

[joanneelie]

Ben you are incredible!!! I need Fur Elise when you have the time. Thank you for sharing your Gift on YouTube . Joanna

[luigiperso]

well done kid.....this piece is difficult as hell even for professional players, don't listen to the ignorant haters....keep practicing, you have the passion and that's the first thing you need

[walesfails]

this is AMAZING.... how many hours did he practise.????????

and also... it must be quit difficult to play on a moving piano if it is in fact moving!!!

[JirkaHeyduk]

The piano didn't moved, the camera moved. The backgroud is "post-producted".

[eelnomtih]

FAKE

[mozartpiano23]

at 0:40 the piano moved

[GregorySelemidis]

i don't know why everyone is bagging this kid... he plays it really well... and he is like.. what? 8? maybe 9.

[MrVulpone]

I didn't know superman was Asian. Look at that strength!

[swordRUne24]

whats wrong with you guys??he just so awesome!..at least.he's trying his best..can you guys play this songs..i bet half of you cant..so just shut up..u choose to watch it..stop adding such comments to this boy..

[ParkourSkateMagia]

Fake



[HarisVsl95]

many errors....and he sucks..

[luigiperso]

@HarisVsl95 , he doesn't suck nearly as much as you do....

[heavymetaleroful]

that was just amazing, perfect, and actually you feel the song while playing it, keep rocking dude

[HarisVsl95]

@heavymetaleroful actualy...he plays without feeling many mistakes and like a person who doesnt know what is music sound....i have no words.....horible...

[heavymetaleroful]

@HarisVsl95 how old are you?? for that words i would say that you are a teenager, i want to see you playing this song, he is like 11 years and he kick ass with this piece, so i know that you have a very closed mind, so i know that i cant change your way of thinking, so is worthless to argue with you

[GeemuOtaku503]

It's Awesome... You can improve it more, but it's really great... Can't understand why 427 people can't appreciate your talent... God Job!!

[strrawberrygirl]

OMFG! you are gorgeous :-o

[Ravenclaw9564]

I do not think this piece was played like Beethoven would have wanted. Firstly, the left hand must be played with a staccato touch. Secondly, the right hand needs to be played a little less rigidly; it must be played with fluidity. Not to mention the tempo is slow. I do not mean to be overly critical (and I daresay to a few of you out there, I will appear that way), but I wish to improve your playing. I have seen your other videos and do not deny you have talent. I suggest you hear Kempff.

[TheSugarAndHoney]

Who the heeeeeell is so "98liasfn§2a&78e!ru?o8nv2" to "not like" this video??? the poeple are making me so angryyyy...!!!!!

I loooove the way he plays piano! Go on like that! You really can be proud! :-)

[justinsane11]

lol @ 1:23

[thepianistak]

Nice try! But is not that it should be!

[bestecimsi]

haha you little bastard

[zoidberg96913]

@armanyoo Have you heard of 3rd movement. He didn't destroy it.

[armanyoo]

@zoidberg96913 two words: errors. dynamics

[FreyrQAY]

incredible.

[gorilaterbang]

@Dzongkasorry...:(

[15grga]

What's that with your hed? I don't get it....:/

[gorilaterbang]

Asian in disguise!!!

[Dzongka]

@gorilaterbang So Beethoven was Asian. You don't have to be Asian to do well; in fact, even thought your comment was a joke, it can be taken quite offensively by the recipient of the comment.

[brycedavis98]

Great job, I like just a slight bit faster at some parts but still wonderful

[willigehtkackn]

hes good, fast and barely no mistake, but there is also the way of feeling and understanding the music, not just playingit. this what the boy is simply to young for. you need experience and maturity.

[littleripper312]

This kid is fun to watch he actually puts expression into his playing unlike some of these "pro" players who may play perfectly but they are boring as hell. Hope he keeps playing and still has the enthusiasm as he gets older.

[AinAngelina]

tempo was too slow

[LuckyApplehead]

@AinAngelina by now i'll bet he's got the tempo right! He's incredible, especially for his age!

[6souther]

@AinAngelina so you play it faster ..? its just a kid !!

[SheriffTanner]

@AinAngelina you're right. he also made a couple mistakes. BUT, given his age he is phenomenal.

[recipoldinasty]

U GUYS RETARDED HES AWESOME THIS MOV IS SOOO FUCKING HARD SO DONT BE FUCKING JELOUS AND GO FUCK UR SELVES HATES.

[mok5000]

@recipoldinasty HEY, TAKE YOUR FUCKING FINGER OFF THE SHIFT BUTTON. thank you.

[gribbenr]

Love the playing but the fact that someone made that horrid backdrop made me laugh far more than I should have xD was that some kind of green screen or something lol. Great playing dude!!!

[bozmajjeh]

Great job little man.... make your life extraordinary.. best wishes :)))

[kevinbezjak]

faster



[LUCYDANY4]

Wow so little but so talented! :)

[ForeverAyrtonSenna]

Is he trying to be like Wilhelm Kempff with those head movements?

[gypolike]

love the head movement

[0xRFMx0]

Haha i remember the days i used to bang hard on those octaves.

[Chookie369]

403 people are jealous :P

[TheMenoflego1]

bad :(

[clnc50]

You are an incredible talent, just keep going, your passion for music is inspiring. Can't wait to see you in concert in the near future. Please keep us posted.

[omers997]

Good Job mate.you just need to practice on the speed and you'll be a great piano man!

[CHmovie123]

well done keep playing u r awesome!!!!!

[thebigloc1]

forget the negative people they probably most of them could not play this piece I love your version and it is amazing. I like this and you are so talented do not listen to the negative people you put passion in your piano playing and it is so so good :)

[XingiteJP]

µFat

[TedEstStultus]

Really awesome :D I can't play this piece so please don't shout at me for criticizing, but it would really help your technique if you tried not to slap the piano as much on the big chords, if you get the power from the weight in your wrists and forearms it will sound better and help your technique, but that will come as you get older :)

[DonDragonJr]

esto es espectacular pero no creen que esto deberia ser para alguien mas avanzado como pianista?

[dualagenda]

dat face and body movements......lol

good job tho!~

[OfficialLena]

Go kid go! Woo! :D

[svenschaule]

this ia a fack look on the piano its do wackeln



[SmokingHotGuitar]

speed! speed!

[sandroygor1900]

complimenti

[Blub0r]

genius.. the most important aspect is that your in love with that music. you would play even if no one would ever listen to it. i can see that. and thats what music is all about. its not about playing right, loud or wrong. its about the feeling you put into this. and you have made it for you.

[pipex8748624]

388 people are envious about this kid

[charif234]

@pipex8748624 I think you never listen to a professional, listen to barenboim or other person and you can know why we say that

[newFranzFerencLiszt]

study heller

[victorwinbillion]

I am trying to think how Beethoven where he was at what is in his heart when he was writing this piece.

[armanyoo]

jesus christ he destroyed this piece

[TheRowingAndy]

@armanyoo

[NickF97S]

hes good, deffenatly talented, but the way hes usin the touch sensitivity in the keys is really bad..my opinion



[MuKo18]

it's great to see how he feels the music.

[jaja7414]

it needs a lot of work, but its not bad, review it slower and then play it at the right tempo, the part in g#m needs a lot more of work. keep on practicing

[Calvin8076]

@jaja7414 What? Im piano teacher, im mastering this piece, ive studied music and ive never seen a lil boy playin this one with that patience like this lil one. Its not that good played - it really needs a lot more practice - but u know, if he wants to - he will master that one like anyone else someday

[jaja7414]

@Calvin8076 yeah i feel the same as you, i know what you meancause i am also a piano teacher, and I also play this and other tougher than this one, and it is true that someday he will master it

[Calvin8076]

@jaja7414 I dont know if u remembered his far too small fingers.... Children at his age often have hard problems with that

[jaja7414]

@Calvin8076 yes they do, but the part I mentioned, doesnt need any big hands, that is what I would demand for, in the other parts I agree with you

[drgpandmrp]

how old are you?

[badman80]

lol bqadass/ :)

[adelhaide0506]

he needs some work to make it sounds better and there are parts that should be cresendo. but generally it's great for his age.

[omguanyin]

1960's evgeny kissin'?

[0xRFMx0]

um i think he did good on all of the mvts. except for this one i me he has emotion but whats up with the banging no offence but i feel bad for the piano.

[usmckeith]

and this one as well

[justcallmegrayson]

oh my dear Jesus.........

[irvin564]

we got a prodigy !

[harrisonli4]

ouch....the banging....that's not the way to play loud :)

and rather sloppy.

however, I believe that if your basic technique was reinforced, you would have extremely high potential.

please keep it up.

[poopybooty24]

oh. em. gee. O___O

[UmmYaaAboutThat]

you should work on your dynamics more. It was really good especially for your age. Nice job.

[FiatObscuritas]

Fantástico, me recuerda cuando un niño hace un 360 flip jeje

[elpianista11]

****!!!!! OMG the piano is moving!!!

[iloveyoubarney123]

@elpianista11 yeah!! :O

[RushRokker2112]

how old is he?

[euadorolivros]

between 0:38 e 0:40 the piano moves.

[manga292]

@euadorolivros he's in front of a green screen. the camera moved not the piano.

[rocketrobotzrobotz11]

watch?v=Gw9gRVKV8bk look how it matches

[euadorolivros]

@rocketrobotzrobotz11 is not the same.

[rocketrobotzrobotz11]

@euadorolivros see

[ems11131]

hmmm looks fake.....

[DICACIO1]

shredding a piano is fun ain't it kiddo? haha nice job little bro!

[Cadillacboy2]

Hahahaha kids.... when they do something good... they stop, watch the camera and make an innocent smile.

[yourCrazzyGirL]

You're good ^^

[teriyakipuppy]

YOU WERE SO GOOD SO YOUNG ;~;

[BSteezysnowboarder]

I wonder how much he shakes the room when he gets angry

[suezos]

@BSteezysnowboarder hahahahahahha

[waclawa1]

A big talent!

[dewman396]

gotta have guts to play the third movement of this piece!

[TheDannabis]

It was good for his age. But he has a face that was designed to be hated.

[BabyEater9000]

LOL this is really good actually

[calistapg]

Remember ppl he is just a KID.....lighten up!

[arwinvv]

no man this isn't fake 

[trombleyscat]

369 people are Asian parents who think this kid sucks compared to their toddlers on their violins.

[SAC25BATS]

@asdfxpert

I agree, this dude makes me a little ticked off because the piano isn't Like even tuned probably! Or he isn't using the peddles but otherwise I guess it's ok...

[xxmark93xx]

best fake ever!!!!

[steloose]

@xxmark93xx Lol the fake is your brain

[adrianeitor92]

Moonlight sonata mvt 3

[codmw2haloreachyeah]

tiny bit too slow, but good playing :D

[asdfxpert]

you make me mad.

[dankwarth]

not bad but keep practising

[lazyboy12238]

365 ppl r jealous that a special ed kid can play better then they can!

[Mega123miguel]

fake moonlight  :S

[onmywayto2200]

cut the kid som slack most people practice song for years and still can't play it.

[cjisavailable]

he must have learned from a different altered music sheet, well not all of the versions of this music are the same,

[onmywayto2200]

@cjisavailable he is playing it right, but that piano must not have been toned once in it's life.

[damonmaster999]

is it just me or is the piano going down slowly..

[ConanJana]

WOW, no score!!

[Commando303X]

Plenty of parts need lots of work, but plenty sound pretty damned good.

[lucent71]

It's no useful to try to play something so far beyond his possibilities.

Play something more appropriate, and try to play it well.

Keep studying, boy, a step after the other.

[GeForce1995]

@lucent71 jealous? 8)

[lucent71]

@GeForce1995

Not jealous, just sad.

He has a big potential, but this is not the right way to show and develop it.

He needs discipline (musically speaking), needs to go a long way. He can become an excellent pianist or keep playing pieces biggern than him in a sloppy way... just choose: the latter is the easier path.

[Aliouxie12]

@lucent71

Won't he become less sloppy when he grows up and his hands get bigger? He'll have more span by then and that should help him to be more precise. He's incredibly talented though, as you say.

[KevinBeethoven]

@lucent71 i totally agree with that. he has very little structure in his hands. and i can tell hes playing by ear not by music.

[agkres17]

LOL fast motion

LLLLLLLLLLLLOOOOOOOOOOOOLLLLLL AMAZING

[vsuripa]

no paper. amazing... hell of a genius voice memory.

bravo..

[xnatalyn]

Beast!!!

[pippo1234567890able]

non muoverti troppo pensa alla musica !!!!!

[csqaz33]

Keep going on your beautiful journey to excellency. Push on my friend. You're the best.

[tdubb82882]

WoW

[ChristiRich]

I like this tempo. At this age, it's an expression of his spirit; as a young man drives a fast car to the music in his head, and a rush of adrenaline that's a magical drug unto itself.

[MrPawany]

Wattefuck you are fucking amazing

[pippo1234567890able]

ke skifo :/

[davidyee]

cmon guys, chill out, i bet the kid is still in single digit ages, so calm down, its pretty damn phenomenal that he can play this. if anyone hating on it could play it this well at his age, call me on this, please.

[yumiko1219]

great



[RA3NM]

My only peeve is your left hand technique. In the beginning, you fan your finders up and lift your thumb and pinky too high off the keyboard. You should be keeping your fingers nice and close to the keyboard. Also, you raise your wrist, especially the left, far too high. You will cause yourself an injury if you continue to play like this. Don't poke the piano with straight fingers, curve them.

But I think you're doing really well, it is a great achievement to play this piece in any sort of way.

[privateprez6]

wow this is my thrid year and i can only start playing the first part of Moonlight Sonata but I don't think I can play it that good

[mylife1221]

7:31 made me cry...

[pianorocks123454321]

Wow.........talking bout a virtuoso when you grow up!! Your good! 

[meganstorey3]

Wow!! :O Your amazing

[axelin02]

Fix It!!! bad bad bad but good try

[markandshermanfan]

Man im so jealous, i can only play the first two movements!!>=(

[raulhernandez79]

Talking sincerely, he plays really nice for his age. Awesome.

[Tezcatlipoca94]

youre retarded çikın

[ThatChineseDude43]

bad tempo and ur barely touching the keys

[1234ghghghghgh]

*Blank expression*

[Jonathansernel1]

U Mad?