Proof that Miley Cyrus can sing

[RENNE1ROBERTS]

People need to stop with "what she has turned into" Jeesus its called growing up.

[JackyMuFFiin]

i think you can't compare miley with selena!they got totally different voices!i'm not a selena fan but it's unfair to says her voice is terrible.and well,it's a little bit unfair that the uploader of this video took a song where miley sings perfectly and selena sings not so good.every singer got songs where they are not so good in it.even miley!(and btw i'm a huge miley fan!)and i heard live songs of selena where she was awesome!so both are awesome on their own way.(:so please stop compare them!

[MissDanceMomsFan]

Its sad what Miley Cyrus has turned herself into. She was such a sweet girl with a bright future.

[chlooetayloorxo]

@MissDanceMomsFan what, just because she smokes, she's 'changed' wtf? She is still Miley Just an adult version. She's 19 don't forget.

[MissDanceMomsFan]

@chlooetayloorxo No, have you seen some of the pictures of her?. their disgusting.

[BlackLAHawk]

I'm not a major Miley fan because it's just not my taste in music, but every so often I can enjoy a miley song or 2. I will say she can sing much better than Selena though. Have you heard Selena's rendition of Cheryl Cole's Parachute?

[ladivina1820]

para mi ningunas cantan aviendo tantos talentos mira eso que desperdisio

[alwaysbeliebs]

@ladivina1820 y vos tenes que aprender a escribir

[jinize]

selena should stick with acting she is good with that.. but with singing it's just terrible.

[verocorp]

selena is so cute and all but she cant sing... miley can sing amazingly!!! she might not be the role model or anything but then the kids parents should be role models.... but miley can sing for sure and with age her voice will get even better

[000belieber]

she is a good singer im not denying it but selena gomez is better

[lydarin1]

AHHHHHH SHUT IT OFF IM DIEING!!!!

[computerjantje]

I like Hanna Montana, The movie. This was infact the first thing I ever saw and hear of Miley Cyrus. I like her songs, her voice, accent, appearance and I love her dancing. The hoe down is so great :)

[775bethany]

n miley is just a fake

[775bethany]

selena sing way better then u will ever would u cant sing at all so get over ur self

[vernicegirl8987]

@775bethany Selena sounds like crap when she sings. Miley has wonderful voice and its different from everybody elses voice.

[jinize]

@775bethany SELENA BETTER THAN MILEY?? HAHAHHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHHAHAHAHAHA­HAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHA are you crazy? just listen how she sings live it's just horrible.

[milesxsmiles]

miley has a beautiful voice

[ashwinchester]

I think Miley's gorgeous and I love watching and listening to her, but honestly I think Selena has a better singing voice. ;P

[canitbechristine]

I don't think there's a need to compare these two. They are two completely different singers in their styles. Very different and not really fair to say one is better than the other. We might prefer one voice over the other as a matter of taste but that's just our own opinion, it's not absolute fact that one is actually better. They are both talented.

[JuBouton]

I love Miley Cyrus, Selena Gomez not so much..Selena isn't a terrible singer like everyone says, i just think she fits into the Actor category more.

[littlegiant102]

@JuBouton that is very redundant to say, 

[littlegiant102]

@JuBouton that is very redundant to say,

[itmovesusall]

an artist shouldn't need a youtube video to prove that they can sing. It shouldn't even be debatable. That's why they are called SINGERS

[niedojebana123]

even I can sing it better

[JanetNeuer]

@niedojebana123 PROOF IT :)

[niedojebana123]

i don't really like it but she can sing

[BieberTeamSoCal]

STOP COMPARING MILEY TO SELENA! Because we all know Miley would beat her in everything.

[CatrinP8]

misleading title, this profs absolutely nothing.

[foerbeer]

I don't get why Selenators and Smilers hate eachother. I'm a selenator and I'm not a Smiler, but I don't hate Miley at all. What's the use of bashing on Selena or Miley? They're friends, I'm sure they don't like to read those mean things their fans say about their friend.

[ItsAntoOlmedo]

I just can't understand why the hell people say Selena sings better. Miley has this strong and sweet voice, Selena... well, Selena, SHE SINGS BAD!!

[BrandiChristinaaENT]

@ItsAntoOlmedo I Agree , well Selena cant sing at all . thats it . AUTO-TUNE & COMPUTER EDITED .

[SammieTheSinger]

@ItsAntoOlmedo LOL Your doing the same thing people are doing to Miley. Your just a hater :)

[BabyTweetyPie13]

ok sory compareing them SELENA - HORRID LIVE SINGER AND OK ACTOR

MILEY- AMAZING AT EVERYTHING STRONG VOICE AND AN AMZING SUCESSFUL LIFE

[TheAmandaFatimaShow]

Selena sucks, miley's amazing. and thats that ;)

[rmo22]

She has improved a lot over the years.

[MasterJamie751]

She is a talented young girl. But most of her songs are filled with notes she can't actually a hit. So when she performs them it sounds bad. I love both her and Selena. But Selena can't sing all her songs either. Not a lot of artists can. But they are both really good!

[ditzybomb123]

NO! my favorite part of the song was coming up !

[peacegirlz2928]

MILEY IS AMAZING! i will ALWAYS i mean ALWAYS b a Smiler! She's an amazing singer and she is honestly better than Selena! Like if u will always b there 4 Miley no matter wat!

[peacegirlz2928]

@xGuera7x EXACTLY! everyone says well selena is prettier so shes better but really she isnt she cant sing (in my opinion)

[buttface403]

that pic looks stupid

[wannaberckstrs]

@buttface403 well are you sure you didn't name ur account butface403 for a reason??? stop being rude or else people will return the favor.

[StopForAMinuteNSmile]

I need to see this song..

I love her voice in this video. <3

[sarinam99]

I do have to admit she's a good singer, but if she keeps on smoking, just say bye to half of mileys career!

[2xanga]

Proof she can sing huh?

wait, she got famous BEFORE the lessons.

hmm..

i guess we can all sing. and we're all meant to be famous. No talent required. :P

[RawrImStarCHAOS]

Selena voice sucks ass but her songs are amazing.

[katyrocks0708]

loveeeeeeee this ! (:

[hchappyful]

Why is there even a comparisson? Miley by a million times.

[lucylovesoned]

no miley cyrus is an amazing singer stop hating on her

[LadySmilerJonas]

@DestinedForLight hahaha only in your dreams! ;) 

[Astonloverlib]

Miley ,Cyrus Can Already Sing With No Proof , Would She Really Need It When She Is Really Famous For SINGING And Actiing Thumbs Up If You Agree x

[56tomboy56]

Don't compare Selena with Miley, Miley sings higher and Selena has a smoother voice. Thanks for attention...

[chadaelazzouzi]

thumbs up for nothing

[mschunkymonkey13]

who needs proof



[MsLexotic]

I've loved Miley Cyrus since the beginning and what I'm disappointed in is how awful people talk about her not what she's done.

[othlaholly1]

Miley all the way!

[RenesmeeCullen94ever]

Miley is the best singer in the world <3

[xGuera7x]

Juss cus Selena is pretty..doesnt mean she can sinq

[guicci9000]

she has that voice you just know. Like when she comes on the radio ur like o thats miley. She unique

[greenandblue444]

GO MILEY!!!!!!!!!!1 <3

[ObsessedMCyrus431]

@iGlamQur Ajaa yes, So if a make a show with my friend I am copying selena and demi WOW! If Miley dresses with shorts they call her slut but selena wears the same and people say to her you are cute... Yes Fake mileyy.... Selena is fake with Justin Bieber only for fame, same with Taylor L. Twilight was the best thing, selena goes with him.. Same with nick Jonas, Yes she is not fake ajajjaja Selena is just a copy thing, only for fame, slut SHE CANT SING Miley yes, she can sing high notes!

[DreamingMusic13]

SELENA GOMEZ CAN NOT SING I LOVE HER SONGS BUT NOT WITH HER VOICE. Miley songs are good to her voice Mileys is diffrent Selena is trying to hard to have a britney Spears pop voice But Honestly compareing them isnt right the only simalarity is they borth worked for disney Ther music style vocal range is all diffrent . . . BUT MILEY IS BETTER

[FernandaGtz1]

She is a member of the LITTLE group of SINGERS THAT CAN SING WITHOUT NEEDING THAT SOMETHING OR SOMEONE CHANGE HER VOICE....the same as DEMI LOVATO... I LOVE DEMI LOVATO AND MILEY CYRUS!!!!!!!!! <3 <3 <3 <3

[naeram]

miley is better at singing, selena is developing and improving but miley is better

[naeram]

@iGlamQur its not the truth, just your opinion

[tiggyrocks2]

OMFG YOU PEOPLE NEED TO GROW UP AND JUST STOP WITH THE HATE. Mileys over 18 and can wear what she wants to. Shes not a slut or a whore. Think before you say things because all this hate is just mean, dont you think Miley has feelings? EVERYONE CHANGES. Its life and if you cant except who Miley is now then how are you gonna every except who you will be? Think about it.

[chinchinrevolution]

Selena has the looks, Miley has the vocal range. Truth.

[1luvblu3]

She Looks Like Bella Thorne In That Picture.?

[emmaash15425]

So i dont like miley but she deffinatly has a voice. so i dont think anybody or haters should say she sucks. becuase im a hater but shes GOOD! selena sucks..

[jordansteavins123]

shes amazing idnt care wht any one else says or thinks and i dnt care wht or how many mistakes shes made shes amazing and always wil be so back off

[Jtlove911]

We don't need anything to proof that she can sing. She's a talent and beautiful. I don't care about what and how many mistakes have she done, I just care about Miley, she can be anyone that she wannabe.

[singerstar91]

@Jtlove911 Exactly, thank u, u r the only person that i have seen that believes that but myself. :)

[mschunkymonkey13]

@traceyblaze miley's vpice is so strong she can sing any voice selena has a small voice any1 can sing her songs but miley's require strength which selena lacks

[mschunkymonkey13]

who needs proof

[davidl1017]

@MsKittyCalico123 I agree, I think her logic is sound

[Juxitinha]

This song is live in Portugal Right?

I know it!

[MadAlice4]

I think there both great.

[tinkagirl29]

@haystackrox why do kids look up to lady gaga and rihanna who is much worst than her......smh. give her a break for crying out loud

[TheBEAutifulBJ]

Ok, we get it yeah she has issues and she sounds ok. But her accent is really prominent. She has a nice voice but it's still raw she may be a diamond in the rough but I guess we will see......

[xKhuzaymax]

Dear haters, Miley CAN sing.

Can you sing on stage dancing & wearing high heels and having heart problems?

Miley Can!

She's amazing ;*

[Inyunasha4545]

@MissLostx i agree with you A LOT!!

[foxylume]

selena has a really good voice....but not good enough....she needs to practice more....she can't keep her voice above....not like miley....

[ilovemilezzz]

awxw :"( amazing as always miley the best 4ever they can't compare it with selena miley's better

[QueenC1020]

I have loved Miley Cyrus since i was 8 i dont need proof, i like selena but shes not as good

[tylerlovekpop]

miley is 18 shes gonna make make mistakes in her life all i gotta say is im happy that she is acknowledging the fact that she is makeing them let her learn from them

[HeyItsIsabelle]

O__o I like her its just that she does BAD stuff...She used to be AWESOME Like when Hannah Montana or what ever was on I LOVED HER SO MUCH!(: Now I like her and i still think she sings good :) But i kinda like Selena Better :/

[ThoseSatellitesx]

Miley's a goddes. You don't need proof to show that she can sing. And Selena .. why is she a singer?

[MrsBrooks1000]

amazing singing what ya ll do to these cis turn the calume down add your own crapyness to them gheese there awsome singers

[LadyGagasMonsterFan]

@FawziyahR We're talking about singing and talent, and since when did Miley get loads of guys? Lol, shes only dated Nick Jonas and Liam from the Last Song. Selena can't sing, listen to her live :P

[caitlinsimerly19]

miley is better than selena. I'm better than selena. She isn't a good singer at all.

[ForeverStayStrong]

STOP COMPARE SELENA WITH MILEY!!!

THEY HAVE TWO DIFFRENT STYLES AND LIFES!!

so stop compare

[Ms15Monae]

@ForeverStayStrong

I Totally get where you're coming from !!

[StopForAMinuteNSmile]

@ForeverStayStrong Everybody compares them.. It's because they both used to be Disney, and now they're not.. So everyone wants to see who's the better one and who does this and becomes that. It's annoying \:

[wannaberckstrs]

@ForeverStayStrong well its hard not to. but u have to admit selena should have stuck to acting.... u can't stop people from comparing everything. it might be wrong or sound mean but there will always be those people. so don't make a big deal out of something that will never go away.

[BumbleBeeInATree]

@ForeverStayStrong stop comparing 

[merobeautifulsoul]

this is so true selena singin is so fake and all studio stufff while miley's the real thing

[mir3oles]

they both good!

[ILYSMniall]

SHE SINGSSS WAY BETTER THAN SELENA :B

[fluffekitty]

you forgot the ''t'' in cant :D

[sarahmariehutchins]

she has one of the voices that are annoying. shes a great actress tho. but she's one of those people who should stick to karaoke. god bless her heart tho. shes trying to do what she loves and i respect it.

[XAvrilLavigneRulesX]

I have ALWAYS hated selena gomez, but i used to love miley cyrus.. shes a h** now tho. but she is still always better than selena gomez.

[akviler1]

i thing that miley and selena is both good :)

[Gleek1able]

@klarutz Okay, Selenas songs are more appropriate and when you turn like 20 you'll think damn these songs are for 10 year olds. Selena doesn't sing live good.. When she sang fallin down she couldn't hit the high note.. lol

[periercito]

sometimes miley sings better and sometimes selena does .............. that's all i can say

[emilyandperi11]

@webshow135 it's not a radio version you idiot:L It's her performing LIVE on american idol, while she was sick might i add. She doesn't suck at singing.

[ABRainDreams]

I'm a Selena fan, not a Miley fan, but it's obvious Miley can sing better than Selena. Miley started out a singer, Selena's not a natural singer. Also, When You Look Me in the Eyes is definitely Miley's best song!

[TalishaMauro]

I don't like Miley but she sings better than Selena Gomez, I like Selena Gomez but she can hardly sing.

[mikageaya93]

Selena's voice isn't TERRIBLE, miley just has a STRONGER voice.

[Vikikeh18]

MILEY BETTER THAN selena so much! Miley live concert voice: AMAZING! Selena live concert voice: Nothing... Sorry.

[Bweapful]

She sounds so country. I think I'd prefer if she sang country or rock. The pop scene doesn't suit her. But that's just my opinion. She's still awesom.

[justaquickquack]

@klarutz True dat.

[CookisLove]

i liked the "old" miley much more that the "new".

[ifuckinscream]

it sounds like mileys sick

but selena sucks

[Miley3444]

@Rachelllislegit fack yeah!!

[AAN8881]

@Rachelllislegit SO TRUE <3xoxo

[xoShepardHarrisonxo]

@XxDearHopexX I It's not like MIley is ever going to see this, and if she does, she's not going to care. You are an ignorant.

[TheLoveissocruel]

She can sing,but she's not boss at it.Definetly,better than Selena(I know she has nothing to do with this,but every people on here are writing about her).And she become famous cause of her dad & Hannah Montana,she was the disney princess and loved by all the kids/children,which this made her a role model.But Selena was a better actress and I think she could be the disney princess at the very first.

[MissZoeyV]

I love her no matter what, så i don't need this video<3

[111pwolf]

Miley better sing than selana.. selena is can't sing!!

[missZZ1011]

@Zendayalover44 LOOL you got it the wrong way round selena uses autotune miley uses her natural voice...

[Kaylak67]

love the pic

[TheLadyBernal]

MILEY IS THE BEST <3

[vampirefreakgirl11]

She's a good singer I just hate her music..

[psynoy]

.___. Selena sings horrible...!!!

And she can't sing high notes, everytime she sing she avoid the high notes or use playback....

Obviously that doesn't happen with Miley, she had a great voice and sings really good (:

[333love2dance]

they both have their strengths!! i love both of them.. I don't think one of them is better than the other, but they are both extremely talented!! :)

[demiisthebest007]

miley is better then bothb of them demi and selena at singing

demi is better than selena

selena has no voice

[topazheaven110493]

They both suck lol

[james757live]

@loveyy92 Riiiiiiiiiiigggghhhhhttttt...

[MrSweetestloves]

Miley is the best vocalist I have ever heard and known.

[moma425]

@qwerty92966 she can sing LEAVE HER ALONE

[qwerty92966]

@moma425 I said DO NOT REPLY I DONT NEED ANOTHER OPINION YO HAVDE YOURS I HAVE MINE!!!!!!!!!!!!

[moma425]

@qwerty92966 whatever

[MegaZakeya]

Aww, Miley and Selena are cute and really good singers! But I like Miley better she's prettier than Selena, Selena looks like she's 6! No offense......

[phobet]

I just wish, when people post videos like this, *proving* that someone can sing, that they would use high quality recordings for the demo. There's no doubt that Miley can sing, but the audio in this video blows.

[Determinatepieify]

127 people are crap

23 people are smart

[LaluEspositoFaan]

Miley has a gorgeus voice

selena doesn't have voice,her voice is just WTF

[CudLifeDreamOn]

MILEY & SELENA CAN BOTH SING !!!

[belllagurl]

@zeldaxloveize then y go on this video

[NinaSmileyFace]

MILEY !!! :D <333 But I also respect Selena :) ( she is more for acting then for singing :P ), but....Miley ( in my opinion ) is still and always will be 1# :D

[miley0093]

WOO GO SELLY GO MILEY XD i luv them both :D

[miley0093]

That picture is gorgeous :O

[moviechannel1012]

She is so good! & selena sucks

[GirlsLikeFairies]

@Cuddlebear123456789 Very true.. I like her music.. the lyrics and also her voice suits but only her songs. I wish she learns to be a little moral though. I also like selena. :)

[johnnyluver178]

okay you all act like children I like Selena and Miley but arguing over who is better is childish and immature grow up people and stoping disliking miley and selena

[gogo00007u]

Miley always could sing,people just did not like the way she is living her life,and I do not, too but it is her life so what, she is talent and one of the best young sanger. I am not a fan of her, but why should I lie and say she can not sing? when she can

[samanthainzunza]

Everytime Miley sings, leaves me speechless. She is talented, and she can also sing. She really has talent. Selena is better acting, to be honest. This is my opinion.

[number1mileyfan4]

I love Miley!! She is so real-3 I like Selena but I think Miley has more talent

[lucaschermontsantos]

she's better in the climb performances

[Theawesome129]

She Famous of Her talents, not because of her dad. Jeezzzzzz!

[MsMaxi901]

@Theawesome129 only in the first place, later they saw that she is a great singer&actress :D

[Theawesome129]

@MsMaxi901 xD Yep, cause she is. :]

[erilovah]

people just think miley can't sing because the songs disney make her sing do not suit her at all but other than that she has real talent

[hhtwbps]

I am 32 and absolutely love this Miley, she's an old soul, so talented beyond her years

[1adriannaayles]

miley is better shes my favorite singer selena is also good but not as good

[ronjahaha]

Selena can sing but shes not a good artist or performer. But Miley is.

[TheChaimaa196]

look miley can singgg she is adorable

and selena too

but mileyy she is the bestt

soo if you're the fan of some of girls dont tell about the others theu can't sing

[MileyCyrusurthebest1]

@GirafXD no way! selena doesnt sing they put playback to her concerts, and miley doesnt she sometimes forgets the lyrics but thats a prove that she doesnt have play back!! miley is hilarious and sooo damn beautiful

[jolientjeh1]

Selena has a baeutiful voice but she can't really good sing live.

my English is not verry good ;)

[juchlocamillette]

MILEY

[LoboWarriorForever]

Sorry Selena you can't sing; Bieber only likes you because of your beauty not because of your voice or personality. xD

[Didika99]

BTW everyone can sing, but not everyone can sing beautifully.

[ToinyBoyZz]

this vid is useless, dont need to prove she can sing, she's not selena --'

[hannah42328]

@ToinyBoyZz you are right

[loveyy92]

@ToinyBoyZz Hhahaha right:)

[Fantage1123]

@ToinyBoyZz wow i was thinking the exact same thing

[iLoveYuuhJasmineV]

@ToinyBoyZz thank you!!!

[lolypopsMr]

ofc that miley can sing ;)

[GoGopinkGoGo]

Prettiest picture i've ever seen of her..

[nataliaestrellits]

MILEY THE BEST  selena buuuuuuuuuu das ascooooo