Remus/Tonks Why Not?

[Neumie7]

whats the talking that goes along with the song? it must have come froma movie or something?

[xXxfreddiemercuryxXx]

0:58 was soooooooooo wierd! i almost cried thats how sad the music vid was and the song was good 2

[JalexNSemmaLuver]

the nonsense such as that kick the flow or w/e it says ruins it kinda lol. its annoying. love the song though.

[LTrain2002]

nice vid. is that the chipmucks?

[poisonivy49]

lol, love the music! i wouldve cried, but it isnt really the kind of song you can cry to, is it?

[PiggyofGuinea]

Haha, I know what you mean. I get all weepy-eyed whenever this song comes on (its a class favorite) and everyone thinks im crazy.

[supersais123]

I think it was sweet that they died, they get to spend all their time together now and now Lupin doesn't have to suffer being a werewolf and live with the thought he might attack someone he loves like his wife or child.

+ Teddy, the child, will be loved by all those that knew Tonks and Lupin, and his parents will be watching in heaven. He will know they died to give him a better world, and therefore life. Also harry says at the end he spends most of the time with him in the future.

[jackdavenportsbaby11]

waaaaaa this song fits them perfect!!!! omg I cried *so* hard when I read about Tonks looking for him and Harry saying they'll be alright, but they knew it wasn't true I wanted them to survive the series ever since I read book 3. I can't believe she made Teddy an orphan! What was the point of that anyway?!

[SarineLewis]

that's cute! I don't think the music is annoying! it's cute!

[PiggyofGuinea]

Yea, at a release party, JKR said a couple came up dressed as Tonks and Remus, Saying they were their favorite characters. JKR said she felt SO guilty!

[ronhermione123]

its so cute!

[actress2be14]

I loved this it was great. I thought it was really harsh of J.K. to do that to them just to have another 'Harry like' situation. They didn't have enough time! Still things like this is nice.

[iluvbritneyandjamie]

at first i was kinda confused cause jk rowling said "Remus and Tonks, pale and still and peaceful-looking, apparently ASLEEP beneath the dark enchanted ceiling." i thought it meant they were sleeping! but that was before i finished the book! (don't worry i didn't just find out now)

[xSockBunnyx]

they're dead :(

i think i had to read the sentence in the book 5 or 6 times before it sunk in

great job :)

[piratesfan123]

I'm so upset my favourite couple are dead.

[GinnyWeasly0842]

me 2

[PiggyofGuinea]

Yea.... BIG sigh...BIGGER sob...

[iluvbritneyandjamie]

actually...i don't remember! lol. i think that it was this:

Oh, well, people who havnt read the book wouldnt

know who Tonks is... Alastor whispers "Tonks" and

says "nymphadora" but other than that...

That's what you said PiggyofGuinea. when does Alastor say that?

[PiggyofGuinea]

ohohoh, I remember!

When the advanced guard comes to Harry's room, she

comments on the neatness of the Dursleys, and he tells her "not Now, Tonks"

[iluvbritneyandjamie]

o thanx!

[kissylima]

I agree with erikasxoxo

we know that the are fictional characters, but we know them so well,as if the where real and to see them die is just awful

im sorry about the speling erros and then bad english

[Seady93]

i dont think the song is anoying, wen u acctually listen to the words its a cute song 'i wanna grow old wif u, i wanna die lying in ur arms' soo cute nd i luve the pics

[PiggyofGuinea]

Yea, but when I asked my friend Megan for the words, she said "I wanna die naked in your arms" and I believed her, so I ran around campus singing that for about a week...

[vjm74]

where did you get that pix of 01:28?

[honksfortonks]

She got them from caladan_dd (from her LJ.) She's one of my fave artists as well :)

[vjm74]

thx for the info n_n

[AngelPixieGal]

I know what you mean! When i said to my bezzie that I'd cried she was all ... Its a book. Get over it!

But you've practically lived half of their lives with them, it's like they're your friends!

[erikasxoxo]

I'm still devastated... I can't believe they died...

PS. Bellatrix killed Tonks, and *Dolhov killed Remus...

*sorry if I misspelled the name

[PiggyofGuinea]

OMG, Really??!! where the heck did you find that? and i thought Bella was kinda cool! Im gonna friggin

kill those two *$%#er $%#$% ^*( %$^$!!!!! Hehe

[erikasxoxo]

JO said it on a Live-Chat on Monday...

She answered more questions too... go to:

w w w . mugglenet . com

they have the entire transcript posted on their news!

[YuriFive]

nice pics! but the music was really annoying XD

but any way great job!

[TheNextRoseTyler]

Anywho, where did you get the pics from?

[TheNextRoseTyler]

Sorry, that sounds so rude

*is mortified*

Do you think you could possibly tell me where you got the pictures from?< that's much better:)

I LOVE this by the way:)

[PiggyofGuinea]

Lol... Mostly Deviant art

[TheNextRoseTyler]

Thnkies:)

[chenille88]

its cool. They married in the 7 book. and they has a children. but they died also in the 7 book.:-(

[TheNextRoseTyler]

Ahh!

You've spoiled it for people who haven't read the book now!

You probably didn't mean to, but...

[PiggyofGuinea]

Oh, well, people who havnt read the book wouldnt

know who Tonks is... Alastor whispers "Tonks" and

says "nymphadora" but other than that...

[iluvbritneyandjamie]

what part is that piggyofguinea?

[rubyremfear]

Jesus, that was awsome. But is it me or is the music going too fast and toohigh pithed? Anyway, awsome, fantastic artwork, good job, i loved it. Remus & Tonks shippers unite!!

[PiggyofGuinea]

Thanks! I Dont know how it was made. but when i rgoogled it, all them said something about stephen Spielberg, or someone like him... Hamster Love Dance!

[cazzykay23]

i LOVE THIS VIDEO TI SO CUTE AND LOV EIT

[PiggyofGuinea]

Thanks!

[StarfireUNDONE]

Wow, this was so cool. I love the Delirium Pic. and katie, i know that wasnt meant to be tonks... I love youre stuff!

[PiggyofGuinea]

omg Fred, leave me alone! lol! stop commenting my vids, anything you say doesnt matter cause your my bud!

[sicooray]

Wow....Its so sad that they both died....I cried so much...great video....love it and thanks for making it

[NoDoubtFan92]

i know. they were my two favorite characters. i cried hysterically when they both died. thank god it wasn't too dramaticised. (sp?)

[sicooray]

I fell in love with them....it was VERY VERY sad

[sicooray]

Yeah...but poor Teddy...well at least he got love in the end

[PiggyofGuinea]

yea, but it was really dissapointing that we didnt get more on them... when I read it, I thought that they just were asleep, and I couldnt figure out why Harry wanted to "Rip out his heart" it slowly sunk in and i burst into adolecent tears of hormones...

[NoDoubtFan92]

i was sitting at the pool in disney world when i read it and there were like 7 other people around me reading the book. when i read that they died, i screamed "oh my god, nooooooo." and they all just kinda looked at me with wide eyes like "oh my god what happened." i broke down into hysterics. i really didn't care that i was in public. that page has so many tear stains on it that it's hard to read now.

[erikasxoxo]

LOL! I would have done the same...

except I was at home, locked in my room, surounded by a mountain of tissues... I yelled at the book when that happened...

[NoDoubtFan92]

i brought tissues to the pool with me (just in case!) and i needed a whole lot more! then my mom yelled at me because she was like "they're fake, it didn't really happen, it's just a book" but i live within the hp books, so for me, it really did happen!

[erikasxoxo]

oh!! I know what you mean!!! "they're just fictional characters!"

I hate when ppl say that... like with any book, you develop a certain relationship with the characters, and their deaths obviously affects you! ...ppl just don't get it...

[NoDoubtFan92]

i know. i called my best friend (a non-HP fan) up when i finished reading the book, and i was sobbing on the phone with her and she was like "they're fake, get over it." i can't though. it's too depressing.

I <3 u remus!

I <3 u tonks!

rl/nt forever!!!!

[PiggyofGuinea]

yeah, I sobbed for about an hour then threw my book across the room...

[erikasxoxo]

lol... I threw mine when I found out that Harry was a Horcrux... I was all: "MUAHAHAH!!! I TOLD YOU SO!!!" and then i got very sad bc Harry would have to die :-(

[PiggyofGuinea]

NP. and I know... I bawled my eyes out on my

cousins shoulder when read it, but she hadnt

gotten there yet... her face was hillarious.