Indonesian Idol 4 : Rini - Emotion Mariah Carey

[rubisa1989]

gila, rini, ga bisa whistle tp berani nyanyi lagu ini

jurinya terpaksa muji

[rubisa1989]

@rubisa1989 + nadanya off dimana2, kebanyakan teriak2, pu

[rubisa1989]

@rubisa1989 sing

[morasinlove]

she cannot sing! -____-

[gilab90]

Rini gak cocok nyanyiin lagu ini,

[rasman623]

bagus bangat lah, orbitinlah rini, suaranya mahal itu jika ditampilkan, kan sayang klo dibiarin gitu, punya talenta lagi.

[ckk100]

one must really think 1000 times before attempting to sing Mariah's song.

it's not even within her vocal range.

this is horrible.

[lloyd3100]

Not bad.,.,!!

But its Boring

[JudeSantana]

she did it good. she brought it down to her level and excelled

[ALsadikin]

1:40 - seterusnya jelek bnget , kentara gak bsa nyanyi dgn suara tinggu.. :(

[Vargo0071]

SHE DIDNT EVEN TRY THE HIGH NOTE LOL!!!!!!

[ayu3359]

really not nice .....funny,,

[FIERCanlicious]

You need to know and recognize your own voice and how it sounds before picking up a song to perform..

[charmedones2009]

@FIERCanlicious she already does!! are u can't find the defrent the way she sing??? omg, if u can't , must be u deaf!!



[FIERCanlicious]

@FIERCanlicious unfortunately I am not. My point is that this song is too risky for her. By the way, watch out your grammar..lmao

[ThatsARandomNameLOL]

i want the instrumental of this song!!! i like this one better its up tempo :)

[charmedones2009]

she brought this song with his own style .. not like other singers who try to be Mariah Carey and failed ..

high musicality, and performed with ease and very entertaining .. the best cover versions of mariah carey emotion so far ..

[chilzful]

parah ga bisa whistle tapi milih lagu ini, mana jurinya juga cacad bisa dipuji!

[AddictKaskus]

harusnya gaby yng masuk 2 besar dong !!!!!!!!!!!!

[rickyaco0802]

i'm her big fans, and i hate this performance, VERY BAD !

[rahman77726]

lebai banget sih bawain lagu na... coba liat Mariah Carey nyanyi dlu... dia aja nggak gini gini amat... mending klo bgus... dinamika Rini ngga bgt.... apalagi english na.... AMPUN ANCUR...

[charmedones2009]

@rahman77726 tau apa lw soal dinamika?? bandingi MC dgn Rini?? jauh bgt lah.. lw bego kali ya, syp si yg bisa nandingi MC???

Rini itu nyanyi pake style n cara dy sendiri, beda dengan MC!! Klo lw gk suka dinamika cara bernyanyi Rini, mungkin telinga lw uda keseringan denger lagu HAncur Band kalee

[Rezuwan100]

i think our malaysian idol - nikki is muchx2 better from this...

[Rezuwan100]

still good n fresh .. suit with her ages .. 

[funnyfacerful]

hahaha so much enthusiasum though

[astawamacorps10]

lumayan... not so good and not so bad...

[zickyyombana]

tipikal suaranya malah kayak Christina Aguilerra

[ariccccccful]

waoww, she's great. loveee it

[jycnnzn09]

I'm from the Philippines and it made me freak out to see someone's post that went like, "Filipinos are wanna-be Americans." Oh, really? I'll give you props for that if you know EVERY SINGLE FILIPINO that was like that. How dare you single us out?

[MrHaminomaku]

how dare you to say that orensampemati pinoys are not trying to be american its just they are talented but by the way now i know not all indonesians are arrogant like you all i can say is i like rini she made this song her own version not too much power but excatly just fit to her voice i suggest her to sing more on cristina aguillera song because they have similarities in voice....good luck rini in your career....

[asnan]

huh ini baru namanya amazing rini rini rini ..ilove abang rini ..from medan

[orensampemati]

pinoys are fuckin posers! tryna be all american and shit! fuck pinoys!

[marioandreacarey]

at least he sings with his own style, not like the Pinoy who can only imitate, indeed bagu, but imitating ...... no character

[myhand2paw]

Don't make her age be an excuse for her not to do good in a song... she chose a rather difficult song so if she cant deliver that is her own look out....,And common guys there have been younger singers as young as 13 who can do a way lot better than that... so her age (17) is no excuse for her not to be able to do good in a song and deliver it well...

[jonjonmariah]

for me it's good because she did it on her own way...

[kvinz28]

this song is tooo biggg for her..

[ThisIsOrrick]

lebih rendah yak??

[kev7978]

1:00 - sucky version of "whistle register"

[jdsd1]

She was 17 at that time. And her technique of singing is very convincing for a 17 year-old! So you can't just compare her to Mariah Carey who is so much older and much more experienced!

[CyprusHot]

@jdsd1 mariah sang emotions when she was 19 or 20.... mariah is a legend

[hyday94]

I cant stop laughing.

[boysoul1]

ahahha oh my god...horrible and funny...she makes me laugh XD

[Ganjarmuhammadakbar]

she did her own way to sing it...good job

[J3LoCar3y]

if u have never seen Mariah perform this, then this one's okay. But this is nothing if uve already seen mimi perform this.. She did okay for me but Mariah is just untouchable.. =)

[ChERrYPiE209]

In my opinion, she did good. I mean, I'd be so happy if I could even sing that song in her version. And of course, no one can sing this song perfectly except Mariah because she's the original singer and has a one of a kind voice. I LOVE MC, but I personally think this girl did good. NICE JOB! =)

[imanem1000]

hahagha litle frog try hard to be MC......are u kdding..??

[lolqueto]

nooooooooooooo dont like it....  she sings it strong but not like the high notes of MC.. theres no other like MC....

[epiphany585]

low key for sure

[tjomirs]

I'm in love with the instrumental accompaniment!

[kelvinhallmon2010]

I think she did a pretty good job in her own way.

[deeoneyoyo]

@006hadynatha006

Mariah was 21 when she sang this song!!

[deeoneyoyo]

Owh my gosh!!

What she does just shows that she's outta her mind...

hahhaha

She embarrasses herself by singing this song!!

hahahahah

[pszlr]

@deeoneyoyo

-It was a poor song choice for Rini

-The song was given to her..Indonesian Idol contestants do not have the right to choose the song they want to sing themselves

-Watch Indonesian Idol 2010..Every week they have them sing Kangen Band,Wali,Armada and the like..What a waste of talent

[thedom]

I want an instrumental of this version so I can sing it :(

[jingjiec2]

it sounds so plain without the whistle cos the song is like more known for its whistle register ranges

[metallmasacre]

si no podias hacer el final hubieras reescrito otro patron

[namasayaialahtujuh]

This is a good attempt to prove that this song can be as great as Mariah's WITHOUT the whistles. I loved the arrangement she used but obviously, her voice is not capable of bringing out the beauty in this version.

[namasayaialahtujuh]

Mariah owns BOTH the whistle register and lower register. But yeah you're right. Rini and Mariah should not be compared with one another. They completely different. Mariah is a LEGEND. Rini is nothin'

[deonoxivar]

she was 17 when she performed this, lol

[RaciouS91]

Wrong song choice! Couldn't be an idol...

[MsBrowse]

lol ... shes Mariah Lambs!!

[bisexualbuffthug]

At least she did not try to force her voice to do something it can't.

[ramonhsc]

I like it! She would sing Xtina Aguilera`s songs better, tough.

[MglsVnGigls]

What on earth was she thinking when she picked this song...

[jdapimpplayas]

Horrible compare to mariah carey

[issunbouzu]

well...not bad^^;

[mistral017]

in terms of diction and pronounciation hahaha she can speak english but not that much but at least normal people can understand it she should do english lessons in terms of accent and diction thats all but everything is COOL :D hahaha

[mistral017]

ITS COOL!! rini did her best to make it her OWN!!! not within mariah's style if you sing any song it doesnt mean that you should do it the ORIGINAL WAY!! you can have your own style hahaha and she make it herself hahaha kala niu naman ganun kau kagaling kumanta para mag comment ng bad HAHAHAHA :D

[dalevhentetres]

she is funny.

she truly got emotions, but never sing emotions again because she looked she is finding it hard to sing.

[pap3rmate]

miley is that you?

[deonoxivar]

LOL!

[agammandalikaputra]

all of you is DUMB ! She's good singer from my country.Are you all can sing very well like this girl?all of you who underestimate this girl is FOOL! MOVOOO!!

[agammandalikaputra]

all of you is dumb! i think she's good singer. Are you all can sing very well like this girli?MOVOOO!!!

[darkraivscresselia]

the violins and the vocal are annoying....uhhhhssss

[lendrahboy]

she sing with her own technic...

[kbteo147]

noob

[sweetboniez]

Poor!! I don't understand how indonesian vote for her.

[musicmoneylove7]

NO NO NO NO NO CANT SAY NO ENOUGH

[LadyKirojihah]

owh shyt..dz is bad..*ouch my ears*

[Utube13467]

vast0lord3 and rendyironman

im not sure if ur talking to me LOL but umm

i never said she's a bad singer

and if she's good for an indonesian level, fine

im just saying she should have chosen a song appropriate for her. Mariah carey songs are too hard. and i agree with jjajangboi2713 that a christina aguilera song would have suited her better cause of her dark and thick tone.

u guys should check out charice pempinco. she's not a world diva, but a girl from philippines. i think she's really good

[rinkashizumoto]

WTF...

shouldn't that suppose to be a whistle...?

i can sing that part better that her with a whistle....

[Marc0Bla]

i wont even ask for the whistles i will ask just : sing in ENGLISH at least pliz!!!

[jjajangboi2713]

I think a Christina Aguilera song would have suited her better

[TotallyBabs]

GOSH ! Really good but the voice is...specially

[rendyironman]

for INDONESIAN IDOL , i think she's good... MARIAH IS WORLD DIVA, and SHE's only INDONESIAN IDOL... and, i think you can't do like a RINI..! she's better more than you.. :D, RINI :D

[vast0lord3]

hey man gtfo!

this girl has some skill to sing this song.

this is good for indonesian level!

watch ur mouth!u don`t even can sing all u do is just bullshit around with ur fcking mouth!

can u do better than her?i don`t think so!

[MrAGoh]

Oke,, she is not the best singer, but she has the looks ;O

[tjomirs]

I like this, it's a good interpretation if you can't hit that whistle register like Mariah. And it has a nice dance beat

[Utube13467]

she is a okay singer for this level

but if she won the indonesian idol, that's kinda sad...

she does hit the notes, but with absolutely no skill.

Besides, i can't believe that she lowered the key registered so much that me, a guy, can even sing this song. and she skipped all the whistle parts. I think she chose the inappropriate song

still she's okay though but she should practice or find a song that shows her abilities

[gretch165]

i think its because she has this dark tone that makes the key low? lol.

[lululiebtsingen]

she's very pretty (:

[ivelostmypjs1]

she has a good voice...but she shouldn't of sung this song...

[Muzicx44]

Sorry but shes got very poor chestvoice to sing this song...Awful words...Boring no whistles...Whistle what made this song more EMOTIONS...And the tempo was slower...The key was lower...Everything was not even in 50% from the standard

[ohanungsaya]

emotion w/o whistle? you got to be kidding me.

[totetotetot]

i think she's not that bad.

the music was really cool, she sang in her own way, has a good showmanship. what else? whistle? its important for carey, for rini? not really, she inteprets on her own way. ;-)

[sarahmc25]

lmao!

[metoo1018]

what a lame version! emotion without whistle is just a plain crap!

i'll credit for her showmanship!

but girl, never sing this song anymore! bad enunciation also! bad! tsk!

[hoyun]

what was she thinking when she chose this song and didn't do the whistle?

[theincreadible]

english pls (at least)

[novembersheep11]

poor thing ....she cant do the whistle part.. and she has diction problem.....thats what i think

[semutmerah1987]

haaaaah?????

[novelholic21]

she's so bad! Bad pronounciation, wrong notes, and i hate this version! EW! why did she win??

[10warbird10]

i hate this version!! so much!! yuck..cheap rini!

[xomalai17]

true that...

true that!!!

[IvyDiva]

mmmmmm i didn`t like that

[10warbird10]

are you guys kidding me??? of course it matters wheter you're whistling or not! shes singing the damn emotion song of mariah carey!! of course people and critics would be expecting her to whistle but the sad truth is she cant! she should have just chosen another up beat song than rather make an idiot out of herself! idiot rini!!

[ajoenski]

ngomong naon sih?

[xomalai17]

she can't sing...the performance was so amature and i'm also wondering how come she win this contest...

she's nothing but a second rate trying hard...copy cat!!!!

[Abstractionant]

No whistle. I think she's a cute singer tho... Not great.

[10warbird10]

this is a joke.

rini is a joke.

people should sing mariah song if they :

1.sing it better than the orig.

2.sing it as good as the orig.

2,Or completely make the song your own.

Ex david cook when he did always be my baby.you cant compare his version w/mariah. Plus mariah's the best.Rini should swallow the mike if she cant whistle and maybe she would be popular.Her version of the song emotions had her swallowing a mike whole!!!! hahahaha! die rini die!!

[sunni341]

that was sad....

this is amateur level in korea lol

[neptunehaixing]

lol how sad, can't whistle, blame your mum cuz that's how you're born like, and don't shout like Christina Aguilera, don't u don't she is not a good singer?

[sunni341]

it was mariah carey moron

[Utube13467]

no

neptunehaixing is saying that Rini is trying to sing like Christina Aguilera by making her voice thick and strong

[dwiagusbbb]

oh kupikir ada high note-nya, ternyata............

[azngirl2121]

ok, does it really matter if she has to whistle or not?

[nehcuf1214]

well she didnt do the whistle and she keep shouting...

[luisdhaniel]

it's a different version, and almost forgot mariah's version she's nice

[AkronZip07]

oh how sad, that was terrible

[nshinnosuke1]

geblek masa dbandingin sma christina aguilera....beli cotton bud lah buat korek kuping...-___-

[darkraivscresselia]

Pronounce jelek. No whistle. Tidak menggambarkan emosi dalam mengeluarkan kata2 nya

[kimnamoo]

no whistle lol..dahh

[kanazef]

but must hear winda idol..so fuckin cool voice.. :) !

[kanazef]

her voice lil bit, christina aguilera...i love rini.. :) !

[whitismygurl07]

i like how she compensated for not being able to go as high as mariah did

[stewardlie]

nikki from malaysian idol is much better than her..hahaha..too bad indo got nothing..i come from indo btw..hahahha...

[totetotetot]

but,nikki is so pitchy everywhere tho, her credit is on her whistling..

rini can make this song fresher, even she can't reach the highest note ;-)

[davguns]

tht's ryt...

[johnwade08]

Nikki's a joke.

[pszlr]

I wish to see Winda or Joy nyanyi lagu ini.

[darkraivscresselia]

lagunya koq jadi country

[diosa101]

she change the tune...

[siegestor]

oh, my god. Wrong choice. Not everybody can sing Mariah Carey's song. By picking this song and giving such performance she just makes the audiance feel awkward for her...

[rakistauno]

where's the whistle register??

nana...

[judeian12]

shes sound like christina..

[JoshuaHoFungLym]

no she doesnt. she sounds wayyyyyyy off!!

[Youboob99]

She's so hot.

[darkraivscresselia]

jelek banget. Mana mungkin orang indonesia yang bisa nyanyi lagu ini soalnya orang2 indonesia punya bad habit vokalnya nggak diextend sejak kecil

[beydereon]

lalong hindi ikaw...

[angbar27]

es cristina aguilera cantando una cancion de mariah.she is cristina aguilera singing a mariah´song,where are the high notes?

[dihocvelaemdihocve]

Handling low notes is impossible for this girl.

"Deeper than I've ever dreamed of ..." No one can handle that "deep" better than MC lol

[beydereon]

well do you have CHARICE PEMPENGCO? who apeared at ELLEN DEGENERES show? and invited twice by OPRAH WINFREY? and whos manager is DAVID FOSTER? and now she part of CELINE DION concert!!!! DO YOU HAVE SINGERS LIKE THAT????? HUH?????!!!!!!!!

[GGunouluvme]

top performance, regardless in english or in indo. All of Maria Careys notes require skill, skill that Sarah contains.

[kurniasan]

Are all indonesian chicks this hot? If so, I so wanna go to Indonesia.. LOL

[9raint]

haha! depends on which city u go to.. :D

where r u from btw?

[kurniasan]

yes, malay singer is th shit, especially that Mawi dude. I prefer other malaysian.. especially sabahan.

[Bernerker]

pretty good but holy crap she brought the key of the song almost an octave down

a man can sing this version

shes hot though

[jamesmaki19]

mataray xa in fernez di xa gaya gaya kay mariah... efek xa para saken!!!

[jalanglajang]

omg.

[dlgkrqja1991]

can't understand indonesian but i think the judges were pretty impressed by the performance. but why?

[hansmunoz]

its in english..she just sucks

[bluesonic24]

mga sira ulong english human eing dyan hayop kayo sa whistle no!!!!!!!!!!!!!!buti nga di sya trying hard no...........atleast she had a great style.

[kiheiboy8o8]

damn!!! i want an indonesian chick

[deeoneyoyo]

don't be daydreaming to be a great singer by singing this song...so far there are few singers who can sing that song good...and you're not even good...

[nindakireinahito]

I guess she's trying to cover up the whistles with her screaming COME ON!! LOL..u must be kidding..this is funny..

[nindakireinahito]

yea..she's not good enough to even try to whistle like Mariah Carey..she's an okay singer..tho there are so many more that are better..

[Zombiemuffins13]

its just not the same without the whistle register....

[divading]

she sang good infairness

[BelleCow500]

without the whistle register, the song is seriously dull.

[niceliem]

stupid qz.. why must english song's?

its to prove that she can sing english also,not only indonesian.. gosh.. u cant undrstand?? ahaha.. funny =p

[anncabisada]

nice.

[cutelix]

atleast she's way to pretty!! go gal!!