@Xarrin Good question. I am not sure myself, but what I can say for sure is: At least it should have evolved more. they added NPCs. they do nothing. Villages. Yeah, ok. I think they didn't add enough for a release. I am no game developer, but lets be honest there: with at least 33 millions of dollar, more is possible than what we have now. He made the alpha with way less money!
Bought it back in alpha as well. Honestly, I feel exactly the same as you do about this game. It's so fun, and I had such a great time with it, but the release was just such a travesty. It's still lacking in content majorly and is full of bugs, and I just don't see this as a finished project.
Exactly how I feel! I remember many months ago when I bought the beta thinking to myself "it's cheap, I support an indie dev, and I get all future updates for free?!", awesome, one might think. I expected some actual huge gameplay changes but no. We get this.
@TheBestGamersUSA I'm sure they will forgive you for your mistake ;) But still I have to thank you, you gave me many wonderful viewers, and they don't seem to think I do "shit".
I agree with all these comments. That was the perfect review of the game which could have been so much more, but unfortunately, wasn't. Notch seemed to never share the same passion that all of us had for such a game, and I often wonder why.
Wow I wasn't sure where this was going at the start, I thought it would be another NDF review but finally a non-bias truthful criticism of this half-assed game.
Also, this sums up the Minecraft fiasco the best way- It's a fine game, but it could have been SO MUCH MORE- and that potential is what people paid good money for.
Too bad Notch never tried to fulfill that potential, despite promising he would.
Finally a voice which properly reflects upon how I and other Minecraft alpha users feel about the game. I too remember fondly those many hours spent playing in alpha, fully expecting a great game to come about thanks to the financial support being sent to its creator. I paid 13 dollars for a neat little game with a huge amount of potential. Looking at that same product almost 2 years later, all I see is 26 dollars for an opportunity missed, and I'm sure that other alpha buyers will agree.
Great review, I really like your style. That, and I can tell you have great taste because Bloodlines kicks some serious ass. Subbed, liked, and I can't wait for the next video.
Very good 'review' about Minecraft. I like your style. You are neutral, reflective, philosophical and insightful. It's so refreshing to see someone like you wondering why and why not the game is not great and why it didn't be great. I have a feeling that you can make it to the top 10 of YouTube just by staying the way you are.
If you need any help or questions about how to make your show better, feel free to contact me. I work and study audio visual communications.
Apart from a great accent, your english is good! Subbed for the future. I like this first clip, and I anticipate good things in the future (not like Notch)
Please make more of these videos, this is the first time I've subscribed to anyone with one video, this is a fantastic first review I hope one of many to come.
This is exactly how I feel about minecraft. I bought back when creative mode was still the only available version because I saw so much potential in this little game. Its so disappointing to see a concept like this live up to only a minuscule amount of its full potential. Awesome video man.
Great review. Notch is a scam artist as far as I'm concerned. It's so disheartening to see publications hand out 10/10 like candy to such people, but reviews like this give me a little glimmer hope in humanity, and maybe gaming can actually be saved once people with integrity take over the reviewing process.
very good
Bobdd0 2 weeks ago
ARE YOU ME?
ThorkellTheTall 2 months ago
Interesting opinions, and I'm inclined to agree, but you left me wondering one thing. What was it that you wanted Minecraft to develop into?
Xarrin 2 months ago
@Xarrin Good question. I am not sure myself, but what I can say for sure is: At least it should have evolved more. they added NPCs. they do nothing. Villages. Yeah, ok. I think they didn't add enough for a release. I am no game developer, but lets be honest there: with at least 33 millions of dollar, more is possible than what we have now. He made the alpha with way less money!
ThePuppetplayer 2 months ago 3
Bought it back in alpha as well. Honestly, I feel exactly the same as you do about this game. It's so fun, and I had such a great time with it, but the release was just such a travesty. It's still lacking in content majorly and is full of bugs, and I just don't see this as a finished project.
MuhMuhMamaLuigi 2 months ago in playlist More videos from ThePuppetplayer
you are awesome!
LeevuskaRakastaa 2 months ago
This guy confirmed for visiting /v/.
1337BigBadWolf 3 months ago
Exactly how I feel! I remember many months ago when I bought the beta thinking to myself "it's cheap, I support an indie dev, and I get all future updates for free?!", awesome, one might think. I expected some actual huge gameplay changes but no. We get this.
robbyam 3 months ago
I like your accent.
Palamag1 3 months ago
@xXxCrAbCaKeSxXx no1 gives a FUCK about nerdchan
zilchowned 3 months ago
Love the video, and I'm so glad jeb is still gonna be working on it.
shizennoshi 3 months ago
nice video
flatronl1915SLG 3 months ago
DO SKYRIM! or something...else. If you cant put numbers at the end of your reviews, maybe a "strongly suggest" or something of that nature?
39jthm 3 months ago
i didn't mean to click like on this shit, sorry everyone
TheBestGamersUSA 3 months ago
@TheBestGamersUSA I'm sure they will forgive you for your mistake ;) But still I have to thank you, you gave me many wonderful viewers, and they don't seem to think I do "shit".
ThePuppetplayer 3 months ago 12
@TheBestGamersUSA
>/v/ loves you
>/v/ loves puppetplayer
>/v/ is your least awful demographic
>disagreeing with /v/
Get it together BestGamers
xXxCrAbCaKeSxXx 3 months ago
@xXxCrAbCaKeSxXx fat
TheBestGamersUSA 3 months ago
@xXxCrAbCaKeSxXx 4chan is for chubby nerd
FuckingDoug 3 months ago
Puppetplayer, you hit the nail on the head with this video. I look forward to more from you. ESPECIALLY if you review Bloodlines.
SSJ4Lunchbox 3 months ago
I agree with all these comments. That was the perfect review of the game which could have been so much more, but unfortunately, wasn't. Notch seemed to never share the same passion that all of us had for such a game, and I often wonder why.
ScottJohnCaile 3 months ago
lol chinks
MrBlooDudette 3 months ago
Wow I wasn't sure where this was going at the start, I thought it would be another NDF review but finally a non-bias truthful criticism of this half-assed game.
TehSithis 3 months ago
@TehSithis Watch the review on ThebestgamersUSA channel.
hurrdurr117 3 months ago
@hurrdurr117 I did, although I agreed with most of their points it was incredibly bias, more like a rant that a review
TehSithis 3 months ago
Also, this sums up the Minecraft fiasco the best way- It's a fine game, but it could have been SO MUCH MORE- and that potential is what people paid good money for.
Too bad Notch never tried to fulfill that potential, despite promising he would.
Metoollhead 3 months ago
Really nice review !
Jakuzevich 3 months ago
That was absolutely brillaint. The best review of minecraft to date.
fredi321 3 months ago in playlist More videos from ThePuppetplayer
Good stuff. Couldn't review MC better myself.
Metoollhead 3 months ago
Finally a voice which properly reflects upon how I and other Minecraft alpha users feel about the game. I too remember fondly those many hours spent playing in alpha, fully expecting a great game to come about thanks to the financial support being sent to its creator. I paid 13 dollars for a neat little game with a huge amount of potential. Looking at that same product almost 2 years later, all I see is 26 dollars for an opportunity missed, and I'm sure that other alpha buyers will agree.
kingkholera 3 months ago
This guy knows how to play it loud.
JohntheNonCultist 3 months ago
Great review, I really like your style. That, and I can tell you have great taste because Bloodlines kicks some serious ass. Subbed, liked, and I can't wait for the next video.
P.S.: Good english!
BaconPirate 3 months ago
Play it loud puppet, I really like your style. I'll sub ya.
mariomcp 3 months ago
Finally.
Something the "best" gamers thumbed up that isn't retarded!
dunejumpertwc 3 months ago
Subbed. It really is nice when people don't beg for subs.
Like it already, Go for vampire bloodlines im sure many people will be intrested.
Very good english by the way.
MrPolyamorus 3 months ago
subbed.
Good work dude.
CrazyMeCrazyYou 3 months ago
Wow, one video and I already like your style. Subbed.
rizzlecorn 3 months ago
I agree completely, which makes me a little sad.
You might want to check out Dwarf Fortress if you're after an indie developer you can have faith in.
MrWhothefuckever 3 months ago
keep it up man!
Gamefreak9001 3 months ago
Nice perspective, I enjoyed it.
jbootylol 3 months ago
I know this feel. Subbed.
hullo8D 3 months ago
Objective reviewing skills.. that's a good joke.
Subbed becauase I like the cut of your jib.
mahjongmonk 3 months ago
Very well said, you've earned a sub from me. Keep up the good work!
RussianWasabi 3 months ago
Very good 'review' about Minecraft. I like your style. You are neutral, reflective, philosophical and insightful. It's so refreshing to see someone like you wondering why and why not the game is not great and why it didn't be great. I have a feeling that you can make it to the top 10 of YouTube just by staying the way you are.
If you need any help or questions about how to make your show better, feel free to contact me. I work and study audio visual communications.
Regards from Finland
Razengani 3 months ago
PLAY IT LOUD
newdoom3 3 months ago
play it loud gamers
LamentOfInnocence1 3 months ago 22
Spot on. I'm also very disappointed in what Minecraft had become instead of what it SHOULD have become. This really was an excellent first review.
CharlesIsNifty 3 months ago
Apart from a great accent, your english is good! Subbed for the future. I like this first clip, and I anticipate good things in the future (not like Notch)
Adreiix 3 months ago
Great video. If I could offer some advice, I would say that you should loosen up a bit before recording yourself.
Apart from that the writing was good and your pronunciation was good too. I am so tired of UK/US games videographers.
TheWhitmore 3 months ago
Subscribed, Play it loud.
DownItplay 3 months ago
hit the nail on the head. play it loud
zilchowned 3 months ago
Excellent video. Your English is impeccable, by the way.
gwricr 3 months ago
Absolutely spot on commentary. Subbed.
Hbeal101 3 months ago
PLAY IT LOUD
Nif3 3 months ago
scrub gaem indeed
stickyluvs 3 months ago
I love your accent
TheFelixnr1 3 months ago
Great review. I have subscribed.
ekrenic 3 months ago
to bad every one is talking about your accent and not that you are 100% right
Spytron3030 3 months ago
your accent is fucking awesome
MPsa2000jo 3 months ago
you are just adorable
FloganFly 3 months ago 5
Just what I think of minecraft.. subscribed!
Tiirde 3 months ago
Somehow I managed to accept your accent. Great show.
anzonix 3 months ago
So true, I couldn't have said it better myself.
master2497 3 months ago
Please make more of these videos, this is the first time I've subscribed to anyone with one video, this is a fantastic first review I hope one of many to come.
AdmiralGoatse 3 months ago 4
This is exactly how I feel about minecraft. I bought back when creative mode was still the only available version because I saw so much potential in this little game. Its so disappointing to see a concept like this live up to only a minuscule amount of its full potential. Awesome video man.
JohnPebis 3 months ago 4
Good stuff
Tidermans 3 months ago
Great review. Notch is a scam artist as far as I'm concerned. It's so disheartening to see publications hand out 10/10 like candy to such people, but reviews like this give me a little glimmer hope in humanity, and maybe gaming can actually be saved once people with integrity take over the reviewing process.
plyestrhrt 3 months ago 3
Nice Video! Hoping for more Videos!
superabsorber 3 months ago 15