Added: 4 years ago
From: crumpetsandjam
Views: 93,814
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (191)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • God, I cannot stand Sarah. Never liked her.

  • though they did a very good job of making hannah look anorexic, seeing it would have made it look more realistc. of course health shouldnt be compromised for a tv role, but still. also whenever people say melissa is a bag of bones.... she isnt really. While she is very thin she doesnt look terribly bony.

  • Same here the videos help.

  • i did not understand all

  • WHAT the hells is Sarah wearing ?! lol

  • @soph60 Why is it all about looks? Doesn't even matter anyway.

  • I can understand an anorexic person perspective, but I am happy with who I am. No ones perfect, no one ever will be. Heck, if I could write down all my flaws, I'd have a whole list of them! But starving yourself to get that thin, it's just not right. I have sympathy for girls who have suffered from anorexia, but I just wish people would accept who they are...

  • @MapleAndAnimeCrazy I agree. I dont think its down to biology, genetics, television or fashion. Its not being good enough, I wish everyone knew how beautiful and wanted they were.

  • @MapleAndAnimeCrazy Well good for you. Some of us just aren't that lucky. Try being repulsed everytime you look in the mirror. No you dont understand the perspective at all.

  • @HuckleberryKae Excuse me? I'm just giving my opinion, so you don't need to respond like that. I just WISH, not think, that people should be happy with who they are, not what they don't have. This is just my OPINION so you don't have to agree with it.

  • "you look terrible"

    BEST thing to say to an anorexic person

  • I need my own Melissa :-( I am so stupid and weak minded x

  • @paigelynette me 2 =[

  • anyone rrealzine that this is like wintergirls, I'm only refering to Hannah seeing Melisa even though shes gone

  • melisia was 22? wow

  • Notice how she speaks then her mouth moves lol

  • @krazykook23 its called the syncranization is off

  • she reminds of sketch off skins

  • What is wrong with her face?

  • I watch these kind of videos too so I won't have anything to eat.

  • @vgirls2008 IKR,

  • I want to be strong too... i have bulimia, i'm really weak. I just want to be happy, maybe someone want to be "my Melissa"?

  • @xakirasxkiraix ill be your melissa, message me if yoou want?

    xx

  • i'm struggling with an eatind disorder at the moment. i want to get better... :( xx

  • @iloveeoghanandjls i wish u luck! it's always hard, i know.

  • brother in laws pants...eww

  • so melissa never died???

  • @tatulover2120 She died... I think... Watch the last seconds of the former episode...

  • ok thanks i was confused

  • @tatulover2120 Melissa did die,Hannah is just imagining her there.

  • I hate nancy x

  • Sarah is NOT a cow!

  • thank you for saying shes a cow I cant stand Sarah

  • Sarah is such a cow.

  • she aint stareved her self she jus stufed aload of food in her mouth n sicked it back up

  • Comment removed

  • wots the difference between the two i dont understand im only 14 :/

  • okay....

    1. ''bolemic'' is spelled ''bulimic''

    2. bulimia makes you gain weight in about 90% of the reported cases

  • @no1lykmeify are you stupid? hannah went weeks without eating, she first got bulimia that lead to anorexia. duh!

  • i've never known someone to die from anorexia, but i've known a few people who have had it.. i've seen so many fighters and they manage to stay alive, how come some of them tragically end up dying?

  • Comment removed

  • @happpydaysx i'm so sorry for your loss :(

  • Body can't take it anymore

  • @BarnicleHead the strain on the body is imense, especialy if they are purging (and that doesnt jsut mean throwing up) some take so many drugs (diet pills, laxatives, diuretics etc) and exercise excessivly till eventualy the muscles in the heart are so weak they jsut give up, or the kidneys or liver fail because of the pills, and because of this some die at what is considered a healthy weight and what is tragic is that the medical service wont help unless the person is underweight, so sad

  • you know what i' m a size 14 and i love being my size and i would never starve myself in order to be skinny, the media is to blame for this thinking that size zero is what you have to be but it's not true! you don't have to be a size zero in order to be happy!!!!

  • the ending when she sees melissa makes me cry so so much

  • What episode is the one were Rhys sees Hannah's stomach?

  • Hannah's Story 03/09/07

    thats when Rhys see's Hannah's stomach

  • I love watching these videos. It takes my mind off food. I know they covered eating disorders in the soap to reveal the harsh reality of anorexia but it still makes me want to lose weight more and more. Don't think I'll ever over come it.

  • @xRaaach I'm exactly the same, infact I relapsed by watching this storyline after 5 months of "healthy eating".

  • i find this really triggering

  • but if you get to the state of hannah and melissa you will no longer have a personality you will just be living as well as putting your future health at risk. you might not be able to have kids and lads dont like skin and bones. It makes me sick that sum people feel like that :S

  • @kateeemateee Your only arguments against eating disorders (a mental illness, by the way) is that boys won't like you and you can't have babies? What a laugh. I hope you have greater priorities and ambition for yourself in real life.

  • I think some of comments people have wrote on this are so discusting i feel sick...Its not about weight and if you think its good to be that skinny then you dont understand life at all. the person who said guys dont like fat girls. Well the only lads that are like that are the ones who are vein and obnoxious and obv not the boy anyone wud want to go out with. If you have a good personality then thats all that matters

  • I admire how hannah works so hard to become thin, I wish I could be like that. but it motivates me to be like that

  • does anyone kow how to change my the name you have on youtube.. like myn now is shinznay.. i want to change it....

  • dEnIaL3gIrL don't be stupid Work together what? Omg Anorexic is not good !

  • Shinznay Its not Funny to be anorexic you Could Die duh!

  • Comment removed

  • i LOVEEEEE the anorexicv look. so pail and week.. im only going to eat 46 calories for 3 months(and do u know the boyd can go withought food for a year.) anyway i am going to be so thin

  • i'm with you on that one! skinny is the only way to go, guys don't like fat girls they only like mini skirts and that! we shoudl totally work together! lol

  • hshs we totally should.. do you go on pro ana websites.. im a size 12.. urghh i know so fat.. and im 15.. a girl lol.. i need someone to do it with.. to do 64 calories.. an apple a day.. or sometimes 3 slices a day of apple.. i want to be just bones.. please write back! lol

  • I feel ya. My thighs are colossal. This show really motivates me so much though. Seeing how hard Hannah and Melissa worked to keep that weight off?

    I'm so there.

  • how many cals do you eat? iv boosted it up to 150 cals of friut now.. and excersise for 2 hours.. im so fat and groce..

    do you have a page on xanga?.. theres good tips on their.. im called 'loveproana'

  • I go 2 days a week of fasting, on just water only. The rest I just stick to as low as I possibly can with my mum around.

    ADD ME. x

  • oi! I'm 7st 11 and a size 10! That's not fat! You're oly a size higher than me, almost 3 fucking years younger!

  • so why dose she keep seeing mellisa evan though shes gone? I never got that. my restricting was going well till the scale read 110 on two scales. 7 days ago I was 100. I also got my period. for the last 4 days I have been eating wayy more

  • hannah is a really good actress

  • Are you joking. You need to talk to your GP. My friend does it and now she can't stop even though she wants to. You lose self-control if you do. It's definitely not something to be PROUD about. People have actually died from this...

  • i do too ...

    its horrible... but a good thing...especially for someone like me

  • You need help as quickly as you can. Please go to your doctor. This isn't just a minor thing you can switch off when you want. You need to take control as quickly as possible.

  • Even if you don't see a doctor you really need to try and stop. Cut down then after a week or two go cold turkey. You wont regret it and your health will thank you for it.

    Careful honey.

  • the girl that plays melissa is she naturally anorexic?or wat..

  • no, she is not actually anorexic, the actor is just skinny, although I beleive they both had to lose some weight to play the parts of anorexia sufferers

  • i'm not sure about that..

    i think they chose her especiallyy cos offfff her low weight. (apparantly)

    and i think i remember hannah had said in sum interview she never had to lose weight. i just think that sometimes they gave her baggier clothes but she's already kinda thin isn't she?

    also btw "lovewarpeace" i love the username lol

  • yeah, I'm sure the low weight had a part to play in the casting, as well as acting ability, but the poster asked if she was anorexic, which she wouldn't be.

    really? she never had to lose weight? hmm, I thought she did! well, that's good =)

    yeah, they did give her baggy clothes, and the makeup they gave her was scary sometimes, really showed how ill her character became. I think this was one of the best storylines, mixed with amazing acting

  • yeah i heard about the lighting too

    and yeah, it was great acting.

    kept me watchin from beginnin to start.

    so glad its all up on YT cos i forgot about loads of it!

  • erm so you think youre fat which is unhealthy...but you would rather be anorexic, which can make you just as seriously unwell? do you actually know anything about the illness? you emaciate yourself into an early grave? ok....maybe try just eating less chocolate and eating some salad and going for a jog that kinda thing...then you wont be fat or anorexic, but you will still be slim...makes sense to me and this is coming from someone whos suffered anorexia and bulimia so i know what im saying

  • were you talking to me if so yes I do know what its like, and I do know quite a lot about this illness...since I've been diagnosed w/ it. Sorry I wasn't sure if you were talking to me or not.

  • What´s song at the beginning, please?

  • blondie-heart of glass

  • Comment removed

  • you are one sad person!

  • i aint got that much determanation

  • do u no how many peoples lives are ruined by this?? you need help!!

  • wow ur ignorant.

  • are you kidding anorexic can kill you like what happened to melissa and a famous american singer from the 70's i cant remember her name but she died from anorexica its a killer

  • it was the lady from the carpenters! the band that sang close to you x

  • i know what u mean I used to want to be anorexic too. but now I am...and I can tell you it sucks, it's not worth it, you loose everything...and it controls you, i can't see myself ever living without it, and I want to sooo bad. please don't be stupid like i was don't wish your life away

  • omg how old are you and how much do you weigh

  • I'm 20, and weigh 105, I'm 5'6. I am recovering, but it's slow and hard. DOn't ever let yourself get caught in this cycle.

  • Are You Like Hannah

  • what to you mean do I suffer like her...yes, do I look like her idk I can't really see what i actually look like because my image is messed up, but proly if not worse.

  • I am starting to get worried about myself, i'm definatly not anorexic, but i have become so interested in it and i am keep imagine having it and it is cnstantly on my mind, the last few weeks i have lost alot of weight but i havn't been starving myself. I do get a felling when i am sitting with my dinner, that i just really don't want to eat it, but i sort of make myself. is this really a problem!?

  • I wouldn't say it is yet...but if your worried then go talk to a counselor NOW before it is too late! I wish I would've done that... good luck!

  • My friend started doing it and now she can't stop even if she wants to. It's not even an option to CONSIDER it. Boys don't even like the skinny look so I don't see why us girls are so desperate to be skinny. Just eat properly and get your regular amount of exercise. That's the way to get the best body shape.

  • it not all about boys...not all guys wanna be skinny for boys idk ehy everyone thinks thye try to get skinny for boys.

    [[im not liek trying ot be mean or anything]]

  • No, you're completely right. Anorexia isn't just about appearance it's also a mental thing. Most anorexics are depressed in some way, looking good isn't even the half of it.

  • haha yeah oww i spelled alot of things wrong i mean not all girls want to be skinny for guys...lol

  • i spelled alot of things wrong..lol

  • @StarryGlimmer Why do people keep talking about boys? It's heterosexist but also disrespectful of straight women. My eating disorder had to do with punishment and control, not looking good for boys. Group therapy also proved how little most ED patients cared about dating. Find a better line for recovery that sexual attraction.

  • omg that is EXACTLY what happened to me

    I kind of started to reduce my food intake and exercise a lot more after that, but I told someone, they didn't help much but I helped myself xXx

  • i agree with dixie.. get help before it's too late:)

  • @sarah1994x Because it's a mental illness, not a diet.

  • DAMMIT

    This is driving me crazy.

    The video won't work for me. :[

    I wanna watch thisssss

  • MElissa like represents the voice inside anorexics heads. Its really cleverly done.

    I use these videos sometimes when my friends ask for help to understand how i feel.

  • i felt berevment around this time

    a few days before this episode was aired

    this is all i watched when my grt nan died :(

  • OMG, im sorry to hear about your Gran, a few days before hand my Dad past away, When i watch these i get a strange feeling, espesially as it was around then that I started watching it. .

  • omg yeah i get the same :)

    at least i found some one else out there who suffered like i did thanks for your comment by the way

  • Power to me like the beginnings of videos. Music and performance.

  • Hannah looks ugly at 7:03,

    & she's pretty!

  • My family are like the Ashworths apart from we dont have Josh. Theres my mum who is exactly like Suzanne, my dad who isnt so much like Neville but in a way he is, my brother who is like Rhys (thinks hes amazing) and me who is like Hannah (suffer from bulimia and feel worthless etc) I suppose Josh could be my cousin who is very close to my brother. And we even own a shop lol strange but true

  • I LOVE SUZANNE

  • you don't get bruises on your face, i've been sick for a long time and the only thing that happens is that your face sinks in and your eyes get circles

  • People react different to being sick.

    everyone's different

  • I didnt realise until now that Hannah actually got down to a size 0! Wow, she got skinny - even skinnier than she was.

  • its supposd to be spots and stuff from her ed, but its quite OTT makeup-badly done lol! :)

  • that girl reminds me of hayden panetier or

    however you spell it. :P

    im just confused as to why she has

    bruises on her face. o_O

  • yeah me too, are those zits? and yeah she does look a lot like hayden--so weird!

  • wat did hannah say2 melissa in d flashbacks it a wat dress?? nd afta dat sh sed dnt tink i can do this 4 d hole year???wt did sh min?

  • She Said I Don't Think I Can Do This Without You.

    =]

    x

  • safe but i wana no wat sh sed bwt d dress? it a ---dress??? n i wana no do anorexicz starv 4 a certain amount of time? dnt really no much bet dem...fanx 4 d reply thou...

  • I Dunno What She Says About The Dress.

    But I Know That Anorexics Starve Themselves For As Long As Possible..

    They Don't Stop Until They Either Die Or Get Help.

    With Some Exceptions.

    =]

    x

  • She says it a Tarqui dress? Lol, thats what it sounds like =)

  • She says "Oh My God!! Your Target Dress" and Melissa replys with "Size Zero Oh Yes". .

  • hannah: omg! thts your target dress.

    melissa: size 0! oh yes!

  • tnnnxxx

  • Emma Rigby portrays anorexia nervosa amazingly. Seriously, when her friends come in she looks almost possessed.

  • hannahs voice is sooo damn high

  • melissa really has screwed with her head. the other two are better friends than she ever was

  • Lol i know Emma Rigby and her parents. Her dad believe it or not is actually Jewish and her mother is half Hungarian and the other half i don't know, probably English. She used to live over ther road from me but her parents still live over the road. I can't believe i'm seing what she gets up to on Hollyoaks.

  • you can want to be thin and not be anorexic, fear is what separates mental illness from self control and competence

  • what do you think is the difference? and yes you are right..I just want to see your opinion

  • gloria50us...anorexia has stolen 5 years out of my life. everyday i have to battle with my mind to try and lead a healthy lifestylr, to be normal like all of my friends. you dont understand how hard it is to sit there and constantly think about food etc whilst your friends and familys biggest worries are what theyre going to wear the next day, if they need to go food shopping etc. you do not want this disease. it destroys everything in your life and worse it destroys your soul

  • i feel your pain. 5 years the same with me, possibly longer according to my mum cuz I wuld refuse food wen i was only 7

  • Same, it has been 8 years for me. Of anorexia and bulimia (or purging anorexia as they call it).

  • Yea what the hell?! Fair enough, say you want to be thin,,, but anorexia Takes over your whole life nd it ruins it!! for you and your family!!!

  • lawlz. she does. xD.

  • "i wanna

    become anorxia"

    Wtf?

    First of all, you mean anorexic. And know you don't, you obviously have no idea what this illness does to you, I'm bulimic, although i was anorexic for a year, IT WILL NOT MAKE YOU FEEL BETTER! s:

  • Okay. First of all, anorexia is NOT a choice. You can't just decide to have it. It's a mental illness, not just something you 'do'.

    Secondly, if you think anorexia is going to make you 'feel better' then you need to grow up. If you want to feel better then dieting and exercising HEALTHILY might do that. Anorexia is a disease.

    Sorry.

  • guys i noe this sound #

    stupid but i wanna

    become anorxia

    i been true a lots

    a doing that will make me feel better

  • Becoming anorexic will NOT make you feel better. Starving yourself just makes you tired and moody, so that not only do you end up with the BMI of a a 7yr old but the attention span and temper of one too. Starving yourself over long periods of time often leads to clinical depression, which will also NOT make you feel better. Saying you want to be anorexic is basically saying "I want a mental illness that leads to mental and physical problems that I'll have to deal with for the rest of my life!"

  • it makes me so sad and angry when people want to have an eating disorder. Anorexia and bulimia have caused me nothing but suffering and runied relationships, it has taken over my life. it does NOT make you happpy or feel better. and you do not just become anorexic. its a MENTAL ILLNESS. You do not just chooose to have it. Yoiu should really inform yourself of the devastation that eating disorders can cause before making statements like "i want to be anorexic"

  • thanks Twiggy.. Anorexia is not a choice.. it is like saying 'oh i want to have depression' or 'i want t have migraines' it is not even about being thin.. it is about sometimes feeling angry, feeling powerless, feeling rejected. i cannot really explain it... people think it is all about a desire to be thin' altho this is true to some extent it is not often the central issue

  • i agree with both twiggy and galaxy. what really irks me is when people judge those who have it. "Oh my gaaaawd she is like soooo vain" Umm no not right.

  • Anorexia is not a choice!

    Its a mental disease!

    It takes over your whole life!

    For fucks sake!

    your right when you say it sounds stupid.

    You just sound like a wannarexic!

  • did the girl who died have anorexia, she talking like she's ana or something!=(

  • yes she had anorexia, she had a heart attack.

  • Made me cry...Poor Hannah...:(

    XXXX

    <33333

  • thats the song playing at the beginning?

  • blondie - heart of glass

  • yeah, the first thing you want to hear is "you look terrible." gah...

  • i think they handled this bit wrong bringing melisa back was bit weard! it seems to work tho!

  • i think they went a little over the top with the make up and clothes and stuff. Ive been pretty ill before and I know that the last thing i want to do is look sick - i was piling on the makeup and doing everything I could to hide my weight loss - but with layers and decent clothes - walking around like a bag lady looking ill and advertising was the last thing i wanted. Also - did any one notice how Hannah never got dizy or palps or anything ?

  • I agree with the dizy and palps (though she did faint once...but still...) well my sister was ill for a while and she looked dreadfull and just stopped carring for a while, she was wearing whatever and didn't bother with make up...so I don't know, guess it depends on the person

  • She does get dizzy and stuff in later episodes take "JP, Craig & Hannah 21/09/07 - Part 2" for one

  • can any one tell me the name of the show

    plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz like reply me pleaseeee

  • Hollyoaks

  • hollyoaks

  • yeah, you get hair all over your body, most noticeably on your face, thats your bodies way of keeping warm, as fat usually does this,

    it also damages your bones, it's an awful illnes.

  • oh gosh, tell me about it

    my bones are like 20% a normal person's density, and yea the peachy fuzz is annoying

  • that end bit with the girls in the room made me cry..

    this storyline is SO real. im going through it.. its so weird to watch