@salfaridz i blm pernah dgr Farah Diana Anwar nyanyikan lg diatas, yelah i percaya klw you kata dia punya quality yg sma dg Nicky. Syabas to both of them.
Lagu ini saat gue masih kelas 2 SD-an kalo ga salah. Sekarang gue udah semester akhir kuliah. What a good song! One of my favorite song. Mencoba search dan pengen denger lagi karena tadi lagu ini buat backsound infotaiment utk pemberitaan putusnya DP dan Nicky Tirta. Haha.
what is this.... why we can't live in peace and harmonoius..... ambil la pengajaran dari sejarah..... igt nabi kita satu kan ansar dah mujahirin.... even ader perbezaan diorang tolerate each other.... dan terbukti berjaya sampai sekarang.....bayangkan kalo kita bersatu....yahudi pun takut tgk kita
waw laguna teh nikcy aya keneh, teh come back atuh teh, pengen denger teteh nyenyong sama Tantri "kotak", kalo bisa nyenyong sama Anggun, pasti hebat deh teh, rindu pisan kita semua sama suara teteh, apa teteh masih aktip nyenyong? beuh pokona mah nya, sayah teh penggemar kelas berat sama teteh, suaranya wuiiidiiih bikin merinding sabu;u-bulu gading
huhu , apa nie gado2... aku x sokong mana2!! even aku malaysian aku still layan lagu nie!! hak3!! , dlm kes nie , aku xtaw mne toi mne slh , tp masakan pokok bergoyang kalo xde angin , so sape yg stat dlu pk rr sendiri eak!! xde pasal cari pasal.. huhu , malaysian n indonesian same ok , cuma data n budaya yg membezakan.. dun be racist pls~
we dun have to make this song as a conflict among us...all human being is the same...dun blame others when u dun even know between one another closely...how are we able to judge somebody without knowing them..so,just enjoy this wonderful songs together..
wherever we lived, whatever we heard, music is suppose to be a medium for us to be one...so,
I just want to know how it's independence without a fight against england, how it feels to have no heroes and no war that ought to be proud and tell the children and grandchildren, the last how it feels to accept the independence from kafir nations?
all INDONESIANS! i'm Malaysian. Love to see you suffer during tsunami and Gerakan Aceh Merdeka War! Hahahaha!!! INDON in Malaysia just like a scumbag!!! I'm alway feel happy and excited when i heard my people abused INDON MAID!!! WTF!!! INDON IS POOR!! EAT RUBBISH AND STAY AT THE STINKY VALLEY! OPEN THE SHOP WITHOUT PAYING TAX TO MY COUNTRY. Your People are true THIEF! BE Ashamed INDONS! We never feel comfort when you people come to my country. INDONS IS JEWS!!!
huhuhu..our people at indonesia work as engineer, doctor, actor, and 1st calss job. your people at my country work as garbage collector, cleaner, construction worker, sometime pickpocket, what a shame!!! Indons always thinks they are brother of malaysia but truly, nak makan pun harapkan dari malaysia.Stupid Indons..BENDERA ask your people come back to indons, but they refused because they know it hard to find a good job at INDONS..INDONS in MALAYSIA HATE HIS COUNTRY..HAHAHA
Who care we working at singapore..u should see the position or jobs we work at singapore..We dont go there and work and BURUH KASAR or maid..We go there as a bank officer, contractor or exec.u should know that.. i learn history about my country and your country too. Too sad, your independence is early than my country but your country still a bit slow in econimic, politic and technology..it doesnt matter if u has 100 heroes because u cant survive with the story..Sad to be INDONS
Yeah..Moving around to increase the economic..U mean INDONS move to M'sia to increase their social-economic rite? That means INDONS is poor country..U just agreed about it on your previous comment. Maybe u can sell ur heroes story to increase ur economic too..hahahaha..U think u has a glamour hero like Wong Feu Hong or Fong Sai Yuk? if u has, that mean u can make money from selling their story..If not, please choose which one u wannabe..1)MAID 2) BURUH KASAR..Dasar Pengemis..
so many malaysian here in US working as a maid and "BURUH KASAR" even my cleaning service in my fitness centre is malaysian ... so watch your mouth !!!!
@TheDbeckett don't make some random imaginary facts thedbeckett, everyone knew that "maids" and coolies in the U.S is of hispanic and latinos origin.... malaysians do not work in those sectors. tsk3
@jackjillmom so many malaysian here in US working as a maid and "BURUH KASAR" even my cleaning service in my fitness centre is malaysian ... so watch your mouth !!!!
Nicky Astria according to voice quality is the best in Asia. She has high tone vocal and in addition to that , not singing a cry baby song. She is a rock star. One of the best Indonesian Singer. This song was written by Indonesian best guitarist 'Ian Antono' from GodBless Band.
ehem...ehem...kalau dah beradab sangat kenapa perlu gaduh kat dalam you tube ni? korang bergaduh pasal artis pun tak akan tolong menaikkan ekonomi korang....org Malaysia pun dh lama bersabar...dh la warga negara korang berebut2 nak kerja kat Malaysia...aku rasa tak ada pulak Malaysia nak berebut kerja kat negara korang...so, fikir2 kan.....tak untung pun kalau bergaduh....kita sama-sama memerlukan..Malaysia ada penyanyi hebat...Indonesia pun ada...
ehem...ehem...kalau dah beradab sangat kenapa perlu gaduh kat dalam you tube ni? korang bergaduh pasal artis pun tak akan tolong menaikkan ekonomi korang....org Malaysia pun dh lama bersabar...dh la warga negara korang berebut2 nak kerja kat Malaysia...aku rasa tak ada pulak Malaysia nak berebut kerja kat negara korang...so, fikir2 kan.....tak untung pun kalau bergaduh....kita sama-sama memerlukan..Malaysia ada penyanyi hebat...Indonesia pun ada...
hello.. FYI.. mmg nicky ni orang indonesia... tapi korang tau ke tak yang lagu ni penulis lirik dengan lagu dia hasil ciptaan ORANG MALAYSIA.. iaitu LY/BAIDURI. kalau tak percaya cari bukti.. semua sama hebat jadi tak payah nak bergaduh cam orang xde akal..
hello.. FYI.. mmg nicky ni orang indonesia... tapi korang tau ke tak yang lagu ni penulis lirik dengan lagu dia hasil ciptaan ORANG MALAYSIA.. iaitu LY/BAIDURI. kalau tak percaya cari bukti.. semua sama hebat jadi tak payah nak bergaduh cam orang xde akal..
ok im da part who work in music industry n i know bout this song..yes true that nicky astria is indonesia..but thiz song wrote by malaysian composer..that clear..ok
penyanyi Nicky Astria org Indonesia. pencipta dan penulis lirik, LY dan Baiduri orang Malaysia (correct me if i'm wrong). kesimpulannya, manusia yg matang boleh bekerjasama tanpa mengira bangsa dan kewarganegaraan, menghasilkan lagu yang mantap. korang je yg bodoh gaduh cam org gila.
org lain yg nyanyikan..dia yg kecoh2..lantak la dia dari negara mana pown..bukan korang pown yg dapat nama...nak puji lebih2...nak angkat nama tinggi..dia ada dtg bg korang duit [rupiah]..rm [ringgit malaysia]???ada..??x der kan...cukup la kita sebagai penghuni dunia niew dngr jer apa yg diaorang [penghibur] sampaikan..korang x rugi..dan x menguntungkan sape2 pun..korang gaduh2...tp korang akan diPERBODOHKAN...fikir2kan...
pehal la, sal ni pon nk gado...x phm la org endon, nape suke mengamuk bnda yg remeh...& by da way, we, Malaysia r nt malayshit...wat da shit u talk bout, korg x layak ckp cmtu..sal artis pun nk berebut smpai hina kteowg malaysia, ape kes??? korg ni kna msk klas perbaiki akhlak la...kte ni sesama muslim, ape nk angin sal bnde2 yg x berbaloi ni...
Lu pandai aja mghujat..gue ngak pernah berminat mengelim hak lo..jangan pantas menyalahkan orang lain sama ngan gue..gue hanya mahu enjoy dengan muzik dan mnghormati orang seperti lo..tapi terserah jika lo ngak mahu..gue ngak rugi kerna gue juga punya ramai teman dari indonesia..yang tahu menghormati orang lain..
Jika lo ngak mahu keamanan,terserah..buang masa gue aja bermusuh dengan lo..lebih baik gue melayan dangdut..huh..
Aku hanya mahu enjoy dengan muzik..aku mahu keamanan..
Ayuh saudara2 ku dr Mlaysia..jangan dilayan sesetengah orang2 Indonesia yg brmodalkan isu kelim semata2..mereka2 ini ngak mahu akan keamanan..mereka suka kedua2 negara serumpun ini bermusuh sesama sendiri..
ape ni babi2, kita sama islam berjiran pun nak gaduh pasal benda kecik je, ambik la kat indon kalu nak sgt, peperangan kita masih menuggu dihadapan sana...grow up malaysia
keep watching... however, NICKY always belong to INDONESIA and all her songs too !!
if u can read this... SAYA TIDAK MALU SBAGAI WARGA NEGARA INDONESIA ! JIKA KAU BILANG KAMI BABINYA, KAU MALAYSHIT LAH YG JADI TAIK BABI NYA !! LOL TO DIE !
The problem here has been solved, The truth is .... Nicky Astria is Indonesian, and this song is Truly Indonesian. Wikipedia, Google, Yahoo, and all other Reputable Websites all around the world know Exactly Nicky Astria is Indonesian and the Song "Mengapa" is Indonesian song.
If you Malaysians like this song, that is fine with me, you can hear it, sing it, whenever you like, but CLAIMING is a stupid thing to do. Just because we are from the same root doesn't mean what mine is yours ...
@billyasik And here's the thing I've been arguing about: dwichagi -- racist extraordinaire. I'm fine with saying Nicky Astria as Indonesia -- didn't you read my comment correcting a fellow Malaysian that she's Indonesian? Guess not. But I'm here especially to argue against dwichagi's sentiments about Malaysia.
You guys are soooo IDIOT ! we are talking about Nicky Astria HERE ! why dont you losers go and search for "Nicky Astria" in Wikipedia or Google ! and see who Nicky Astria truly is .... INDONESIAN, and this song is also written by Indonesian Song-Writer with help from Indonesian Composer.
For God Sake ! I've been hearing her songs since i was in the Elementary School ! Nicky Astria is a Lady-Rocker from Bandung, West Java, INDONESIA !
oke, kita gak usah ribut... tapi jika kalian org malay TIDAK MENDENGARKAN lagu ini lagi.. bila kalian malay mau menghargai kami, dengan senang hati kami akan menghargai kalian !
HargaiLah Jerih Payah Orang Laen! iLmu itu Mahal HargaNya, SeCara SpesiFik ga Smua Orang Bisa! INGAT, BisNis is BisNis, KoNco yo KonCo,musuh tetp musuh,
yang mengganggu negara indonesia harus d beri pelajaran,hajaaaaaaaaaaaar malingsial,
INI ADALAH BARISAN TAK BERGENDANG BERPALU,KEPERCAYAAN TANDA MENYERBU,SEKALI BERARTI SUDAH ITU MATI
ini 100% lagu indonesia, klo gk percaya tanya bapakmu sono jangan asal ngaku ngaku punya malaysia. Mahathir aja masih ngakuin indonesia napa lu yang rakyat biasa gak ngakuin klo lagu ini milik indonesia
@sukma87 Lagu mmg dinyayiin oleh teh Nicky (org Indonesia) tp lagu tsb yg nyiptain Ly/Baiduri ( org malaysia). Saat itu setelah diciptaiin, dia mrasa hanya teh Nicky lah yg cocok dn bisa mnyanyikan lgu tsb, krn ckup sulit dn memerlukan nada suara yg tinggi.
HargaiLah Jerih Payah Orang Laen! iLmu itu Mahal HargaNya, SeCara SpesiFik ga Smua Orang Bisa! INGAT, BisNis is BisNis, KoNco yo KonCo,musuh tetp musuh,
yang mengganggu negara indonesia harus d beri pelajaran,hajaaaaaaaaaaaar malingsial,
INI ADALAH BARISAN TAK BERGENDANG BERPALU,KEPERCAYAAN TANDA MENYERBU,SEKALI BERARTI SUDAH ITU MATI
HargaiLah Jerih Payah Orang Laen! iLmu itu Mahal HargaNya, SeCara SpesiFik ga Smua Orang Bisa! INGAT, BisNis is BisNis, KoNco yo KonCo,musuh tetp musuh,
yang mengganggu negara indonesia harus d beri pelajaran,hajaaaaaaaaaaaar malingsial,
INI ADALAH BARISAN TAK BERGENDANG BERPALU,KEPERCAYAAN TANDA MENYERBU,SEKALI BERARTI SUDAH ITU MATI
HargaiLah Jerih Payah Orang Laen! iLmu itu Mahal HargaNya, SeCara SpesiFik ga Smua Orang Bisa! INGAT, BisNis is BisNis, KoNco yo KonCo,musuh tetp musuh,
yang mengganggu negara indonesia harus d beri pelajaran,hajaaaaaaaaaaaar malingsial,
INI ADALAH BARISAN TAK BERGENDANG BERPALU,KEPERCAYAAN TANDA MENYERBU,SEKALI BERARTI SUDAH ITU MATI
HargaiLah Jerih Payah Orang Laen! iLmu itu Mahal HargaNya, SeCara SpesiFik ga Smua Orang Bisa! INGAT, BisNis is BisNis, KoNco yo KonCo,musuh tetp musuh,
yang mengganggu negara indonesia harus d beri pelajaran,hajaaaaaaaaaaaar malingsial,
INI ADALAH BARISAN TAK BERGENDANG BERPALU,KEPERCAYAAN TANDA MENYERBU,SEKALI BERARTI SUDAH ITU MATI
Nicky Astria (lahir di Bandung, 18 Oktober 1967; umur 42 tahun ;terlahir dengan nama Nicky Nastitie Karya Dewi) adalah seorang penyanyi rock asal Indonesia.
This is Nicky Astria... She's Indonesian. Please keep that in mind she is INDONESIAN... She belongs to INDONESIA not malaysia... It's not the same you know. We love INDONESIA INDONESIA has a great singer and a great attitude We're very friendly, but it doesn't mean we cannot be HARD on a THIEF. We're democratic, but it doesn't mean we cannot be PERSISTENT about THINGS THAT BELONG TO US. PLEASE KEEP THAT IN MIND. THANK YOU. and I'm INDONESIAN btw.
hey malay,, kata kau negara yg maju dan punya IQ tinggi... so, show to us apa yg bisa negara kau banggakan?? !!! budaya?? apa? mana?? ooo, film yg judul nya "PISAU CUKUR" ? "JALANG"?? napa gak skalian "PISAU DAPUR"?? LOL !!
Udah lah, kalo punya IQ tinggi, ciptakan sesuatu yg bisa kami COPY juga donk! jgn cuman bisa jady COPY PUSSY CAT doank..
Aneh, gak habis2nya BODOH kalian tuh.. kita memang serumpun, tapi kita BERBEDA bro!
Saya suka lagu ini..saya menghargai karya dari mana2 negara....lebih2 lagi negara serumpun sperti Indonesia...Orang Indonesia juga orang kita...satu rumpun satu agama...
Jadi jangan lah kita menjadi orang yang tolol bodoh anjing menyalahkan sesama yang lain...Isu2 yang hangat antara Malaysia dan Indonesia jangan diperdebatkan dalam seni muzik...Guna Akal Dan Otak...Pikirin...
Keren
azaz099799 1 day ago
wah saya rindu sama nicky astria
esyttrsu 1 week ago
Nicky Astria,..., Ok ... bangeet ,Sip!
Budiman688 2 weeks ago
GREGETNYAA ...........
OK BANGET :)
Arini17 4 weeks ago
ora urusan ora urunan ora nduwe duwit...
AMONEARA 1 month ago
Im malaysian, i never hate the indonesian... in fact i love them.. esp the singer....... salam dari Malaysia......
MrBREWINEDWARD 2 months ago 3
Saya orang Malaysia yg suka lagu2 dari Indonesia...
ratnaliliosman 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
lagu kegemaranku nihhhh
heryhariono8 3 months ago
gw bangeeeeeeeeeet.................sorry dah buat lo kecewa.from me septy
etyseptiaty 3 months ago
would u ever do like wat tis song saying ?? and .. . ,,
vieVyi22 4 months ago
kemejanya et dah , btw lagu-lagu dulu jaman nya teh nicky keren2 ya. waw
asepdelapantujuh 4 months ago
mengapa dan mengapa. . . .musik rock indonesia ga adalagi kaya gini???
TheKepler89 4 months ago
@TheKepler89 menyedihkan ya musik indonesia sekarang
gymnastiar 3 months ago
Hingga kini blm ada yg bs mnandingi suara teh Nicky. The best.
Amyra703 5 months ago
@Amyra703 Ku enggak tau sama ada Farah Diana Anwar udah menandingi atau enggak sama suara Nicky.
Tapi Farah Diana Anwar ada pernah nyanyi lagu Mengapa ini. Bagiku memang seperti Nicky yang nyanyi dong!
I love Nicky voice! Very cool when she sing the high pitch part!
salfaridz 4 months ago
@salfaridz i blm pernah dgr Farah Diana Anwar nyanyikan lg diatas, yelah i percaya klw you kata dia punya quality yg sma dg Nicky. Syabas to both of them.
Amyra703 2 months ago
classic song always better than nowadays
belluga007 5 months ago
Masa lagu ini muncul aku kerja di Bandung
ae6606 5 months ago
i love this...
dhiyaniwirasati 6 months ago
kerennn banget suara nya,,,
lagu nya jadi dapet soul nya..
hmm--
kerennn---
asrisiregar20 6 months ago
i like this song
hendra838 6 months ago
i am a chinese in malaysia, all i can say to this song......... perfect!!!!!!!
steadykian 6 months ago 18
@steadykian : thank you
Ichifa 1 month ago
Suara yang powerful gini lebih enak dibandingkan singer2 cewek bersuara menderita yang muncul belakangan ini...
kurumbaya 6 months ago
@kurumbaya bersuara menderita...classs ko ckp kannnnnnnnn
KissMuahhh 6 months ago
jadi inget waktu jaman sekolah klo denger lagu ini
sugenklenong 7 months ago
inget waktu masih jaman sekolah klo denger lagu ini.
sugenklenong 7 months ago
like this,,,,bunda rocker indonesia
cublux1 7 months ago
like this,,,,,bunda rocker indonesia,,,
cublux1 7 months ago
ingat masa lalu jk dgr lagu ini, saat hati msh memiliki sesercah harap......
TheSumirah 7 months ago
bla2 bla2~
kaliamaklu 7 months ago
jdi ingat msa lalu,jika dngr lagu ini,,hemmmm
fyrasetya 7 months ago
I love this song....
MrDD076 7 months ago
Saya sangat suka lagu-lagu yang didendangkan Nicky, lagu-lagunya melegenda, benar-benar sangat bagus......
rudi1442 8 months ago
kelingan jeh jaman kelas 1 smp rek.......huuuhhhh...
galuh9866 8 months ago
STELLY KATILI ;SUDAH BEREDAR ALBUM KE-2 BERJUDUL :BIDADARI JGN LUPA BELI KASETNYA YA..AT KLIK ON YOUTUBE STELLY KATILI..THANKS..
lazzsmazzy 8 months ago
topppppp markotoppppppp
TheSudawirat 8 months ago
Lagu ini saat gue masih kelas 2 SD-an kalo ga salah. Sekarang gue udah semester akhir kuliah. What a good song! One of my favorite song. Mencoba search dan pengen denger lagi karena tadi lagu ini buat backsound infotaiment utk pemberitaan putusnya DP dan Nicky Tirta. Haha.
dhocull 8 months ago
terbaikkk...<3<3
tehaeureka 9 months ago
how can someone say this song is nice..this is hilarious stupid!!
revolvet 10 months ago
@revolvet
how is it stupid?
rezarahardian 10 months ago
gw lagi badung-badungnya nih... naik motor puluhan kilometer,malam hujan2an.. hehehe, likes this song !!!!
sicharley 10 months ago
..............
lelos001 10 months ago
inget mantan euy neng yuli di balikpapan tahun 1995 masih ingatkah?
herrysuoth 10 months ago
nostalgilaan :p
lilandbadwow 10 months ago
i loike nicky....best gile song die sume...
msjelajahdunia 10 months ago
memory lama bersemi lagi
purnamadewa 10 months ago
kangen lagu ini....
arkadilaga 10 months ago
Nie pas lagu kenagan buat Bini Q...
jaoh wak......bgus patah kaki dari pada patah Bini..
haaaaaaaaaaaa
Byyyyy : pelabuhan periaknan Patai
fahya1000 11 months ago
Lagu yang mengingatkan aku pada masa yang lalu... sweet memories.
BesarrPunya 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
enak didengari pada malam hari...sayu....achol 63
95Exiamar 11 months ago
enak didengari pada malam hari...sayu....
95Exiamar 11 months ago
thats best song from nicky astria in yeras 90an
79yes1 1 year ago
what is this.... why we can't live in peace and harmonoius..... ambil la pengajaran dari sejarah..... igt nabi kita satu kan ansar dah mujahirin.... even ader perbezaan diorang tolerate each other.... dan terbukti berjaya sampai sekarang.....bayangkan kalo kita bersatu....yahudi pun takut tgk kita
kep030028 1 year ago
i am malaysian, n i love indonesian music too.... n i really love music....4 me, music is 4 peace.
puputsession 1 year ago
alahai...kurang pandai pasal lagupun nak gaduh music kan universal..enjoy bersyukur pada tuhan sudahlah....
reoggal 1 year ago
itu pon nk sibuk..lgu indon ke malaysia ke lagu singapore ke
nyanyi je la.,,hehe
liacokelat 1 year ago
waw laguna teh nikcy aya keneh, teh come back atuh teh, pengen denger teteh nyenyong sama Tantri "kotak", kalo bisa nyenyong sama Anggun, pasti hebat deh teh, rindu pisan kita semua sama suara teteh, apa teteh masih aktip nyenyong? beuh pokona mah nya, sayah teh penggemar kelas berat sama teteh, suaranya wuiiidiiih bikin merinding sabu;u-bulu gading
we love Nicky
asepdelapantujuh 1 year ago
huhu , apa nie gado2... aku x sokong mana2!! even aku malaysian aku still layan lagu nie!! hak3!! , dlm kes nie , aku xtaw mne toi mne slh , tp masakan pokok bergoyang kalo xde angin , so sape yg stat dlu pk rr sendiri eak!! xde pasal cari pasal.. huhu , malaysian n indonesian same ok , cuma data n budaya yg membezakan.. dun be racist pls~
deathnote9317 1 year ago
@deathnote9317 Salut ama Malaysian seperti anda ;)
Chaingangz 1 year ago
@Chaingangz yes!! makasih dong.. hehe!
deathnote9317 10 months ago
@deathnote9317 Sama" Om (y)
Chaingangz 10 months ago
@Chaingangz aiyaaaaaa , kenapa om?? adik la. hehe
deathnote9317 10 months ago
@deathnote9317 hahaha , adik?? ngak bisa laa.
deathnote9317 10 months ago
@deathnote9317 bisa lah!!
deathnote9317 10 months ago
Comment removed
deathnote9317 10 months ago
NICK .... I LOVE YOR SONG SOOOO MUCHHHHH
gundemul 1 year ago
seksa sgt bila putus cinta, susah mncari erti cinta sejati.. huhuhhuhu
nak knl i? search manjalara alya di fb yew! tq... <3
pdgserai7 1 year ago
mengapa.....mengapa...mengapa semua masih menjadi misteri.... lakoni wae.... tetap semangat ....
joytambahoful 1 year ago
I am a Malaysian...and I LOVE Indonesian songs!! ~PEACE~
bozica888 1 year ago 31
@bozica888 i'm Indonesian and love Malaysian Music too...PEACE.
taryoxleyrey 1 year ago
@bozica888 im indonesia my vaporite nicy astria
marlina7624 1 month ago
Mantafff euy
hendis96 1 year ago
Comment removed
ayiriyanto 1 year ago
lagu nya bagus seperti apa yng telah saya alami saat ini thx nicky
nicky6147 1 year ago
Btul 2 x baik kita mengata 1 sama lain ingat kita d sisi nya smua sama..ez 2 talk no body perfect..
sury5158 1 year ago
we dun have to make this song as a conflict among us...all human being is the same...dun blame others when u dun even know between one another closely...how are we able to judge somebody without knowing them..so,just enjoy this wonderful songs together..
wherever we lived, whatever we heard, music is suppose to be a medium for us to be one...so,
peace no war..
(^_^)
1925elle 1 year ago
mengapa versi rahmat mega ada x? klu ada tlg share ea..tq
BeRRySyuR 1 year ago
lagu ini inget waktu abg...
coba eksis lg teh nicky....
banyak yg merindukan km....
danisuryo1 1 year ago
Kolosal! ;))
TyoPrasetya 1 year ago
thx for thiz song :)
mikoaling 1 year ago
ehh malaysia anjink !!!
aing keur puasa yeu !!!
bangsat siah !!!
kunib1 1 year ago
ehh malaysia anjink !!!
aing keur puasa yeu !!!
bangsat siah !!!
kunib1 1 year ago
Hay Malaysian,
I just want to know how it's independence without a fight against england, how it feels to have no heroes and no war that ought to be proud and tell the children and grandchildren, the last how it feels to accept the independence from kafir nations?
agluser 1 year ago
suaranya bagus banget.....
iyeppei 1 year ago
all INDONESIANS! i'm Malaysian. Love to see you suffer during tsunami and Gerakan Aceh Merdeka War! Hahahaha!!! INDON in Malaysia just like a scumbag!!! I'm alway feel happy and excited when i heard my people abused INDON MAID!!! WTF!!! INDON IS POOR!! EAT RUBBISH AND STAY AT THE STINKY VALLEY! OPEN THE SHOP WITHOUT PAYING TAX TO MY COUNTRY. Your People are true THIEF! BE Ashamed INDONS! We never feel comfort when you people come to my country. INDONS IS JEWS!!!
poma83 1 year ago
Comment removed
jackjillmom 1 year ago
@jackjillmom
huhuhu..our people at indonesia work as engineer, doctor, actor, and 1st calss job. your people at my country work as garbage collector, cleaner, construction worker, sometime pickpocket, what a shame!!! Indons always thinks they are brother of malaysia but truly, nak makan pun harapkan dari malaysia.Stupid Indons..BENDERA ask your people come back to indons, but they refused because they know it hard to find a good job at INDONS..INDONS in MALAYSIA HATE HIS COUNTRY..HAHAHA
poma83 1 year ago
Comment removed
jackjillmom 1 year ago
@jackjillmom
Who care we working at singapore..u should see the position or jobs we work at singapore..We dont go there and work and BURUH KASAR or maid..We go there as a bank officer, contractor or exec.u should know that.. i learn history about my country and your country too. Too sad, your independence is early than my country but your country still a bit slow in econimic, politic and technology..it doesnt matter if u has 100 heroes because u cant survive with the story..Sad to be INDONS
poma83 1 year ago
@poma83
u r rite....i hate dis fuckin indon around me.rubbish at Kl
alia89100 1 year ago
@alia89100
Thanks for support..
We should rip off the stupid INDONS who's this INDONESIA is better than our land
poma83 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@alia89100
Thanks for support.
We shoul rip off INDONS wo's think IndoneSIAL is better than our land
poma83 1 year ago
Comment removed
jackjillmom 1 year ago
@jackjillmom
Yeah..Moving around to increase the economic..U mean INDONS move to M'sia to increase their social-economic rite? That means INDONS is poor country..U just agreed about it on your previous comment. Maybe u can sell ur heroes story to increase ur economic too..hahahaha..U think u has a glamour hero like Wong Feu Hong or Fong Sai Yuk? if u has, that mean u can make money from selling their story..If not, please choose which one u wannabe..1)MAID 2) BURUH KASAR..Dasar Pengemis..
poma83 1 year ago
so many malaysian here in US working as a maid and "BURUH KASAR" even my cleaning service in my fitness centre is malaysian ... so watch your mouth !!!!
TheDbeckett 6 months ago
@TheDbeckett don't make some random imaginary facts thedbeckett, everyone knew that "maids" and coolies in the U.S is of hispanic and latinos origin.... malaysians do not work in those sectors. tsk3
fazzlan89 4 months ago
@jackjillmom so many malaysian here in US working as a maid and "BURUH KASAR" even my cleaning service in my fitness centre is malaysian ... so watch your mouth !!!!
TheDbeckett 6 months ago
love her voice!
Bungaiberduri 1 year ago
Comment removed
zarajulia 1 year ago
Nicky Astria according to voice quality is the best in Asia. She has high tone vocal and in addition to that , not singing a cry baby song. She is a rock star. One of the best Indonesian Singer. This song was written by Indonesian best guitarist 'Ian Antono' from GodBless Band.
endranesta 1 year ago
@endranesta
hey this song is compose by malaysian.....mengapa - by ly - song & baiduri - lyricts...husband n wife
boxerckpng 1 year ago
laid2 no d napatai lo tondu om...ohio you kow u yo...ohooo...ombiruooon no yokou ndo....
anakovilla 1 year ago
she is Indonesian, no matter somebody claim from other country.
cheers Indonesia.....
MOEJI07 1 year ago
some people are fucking lembu to fight over whether this song is malaysian or indonesian.
shinigami717 1 year ago
@fortegba : i agree with you..i love my own country ...just make it peace...actually we didn't know much everything...so plz stop to be smart ass...
meonkbe9 1 year ago
@fortegba : i agree with you..i love my own country ...just make it peace...actually we didn't know much everything...so plz stop to be smart ass...
meonkbe9 1 year ago
yeyehhh..both of country got a talented singer..HIDUP MALAYSIA N INDONESIA..!!!!!IDOP ASIAN..!!!!!
125itam 1 year ago
a'ala....kecohhh. sape2 pon sama jer
fyrafaheeraful 1 year ago
I love this song so much !!!!!!!
jayrabbitproductions 1 year ago
sshhhhh...pls stop all the stupid conflict.. all you guys need to do is sit tight enjoy this song and cheersssss... peace n rock! :P
Sensbudz 1 year ago 16
ehem...ehem...kalau dah beradab sangat kenapa perlu gaduh kat dalam you tube ni? korang bergaduh pasal artis pun tak akan tolong menaikkan ekonomi korang....org Malaysia pun dh lama bersabar...dh la warga negara korang berebut2 nak kerja kat Malaysia...aku rasa tak ada pulak Malaysia nak berebut kerja kat negara korang...so, fikir2 kan.....tak untung pun kalau bergaduh....kita sama-sama memerlukan..Malaysia ada penyanyi hebat...Indonesia pun ada...
fortegba 1 year ago
ehem...ehem...kalau dah beradab sangat kenapa perlu gaduh kat dalam you tube ni? korang bergaduh pasal artis pun tak akan tolong menaikkan ekonomi korang....org Malaysia pun dh lama bersabar...dh la warga negara korang berebut2 nak kerja kat Malaysia...aku rasa tak ada pulak Malaysia nak berebut kerja kat negara korang...so, fikir2 kan.....tak untung pun kalau bergaduh....kita sama-sama memerlukan..Malaysia ada penyanyi hebat...Indonesia pun ada...
fortegba 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hello.. FYI.. mmg nicky ni orang indonesia... tapi korang tau ke tak yang lagu ni penulis lirik dengan lagu dia hasil ciptaan ORANG MALAYSIA.. iaitu LY/BAIDURI. kalau tak percaya cari bukti.. semua sama hebat jadi tak payah nak bergaduh cam orang xde akal..
luvuhney 1 year ago
hello.. FYI.. mmg nicky ni orang indonesia... tapi korang tau ke tak yang lagu ni penulis lirik dengan lagu dia hasil ciptaan ORANG MALAYSIA.. iaitu LY/BAIDURI. kalau tak percaya cari bukti.. semua sama hebat jadi tak payah nak bergaduh cam orang xde akal..
luvuhney 1 year ago
ok im da part who work in music industry n i know bout this song..yes true that nicky astria is indonesia..but thiz song wrote by malaysian composer..that clear..ok
pinkyhusky 1 year ago
penyanyi Nicky Astria org Indonesia. pencipta dan penulis lirik, LY dan Baiduri orang Malaysia (correct me if i'm wrong). kesimpulannya, manusia yg matang boleh bekerjasama tanpa mengira bangsa dan kewarganegaraan, menghasilkan lagu yang mantap. korang je yg bodoh gaduh cam org gila.
swordylove 1 year ago
org lain yg nyanyikan..dia yg kecoh2..lantak la dia dari negara mana pown..bukan korang pown yg dapat nama...nak puji lebih2...nak angkat nama tinggi..dia ada dtg bg korang duit [rupiah]..rm [ringgit malaysia]???ada..??x der kan...cukup la kita sebagai penghuni dunia niew dngr jer apa yg diaorang [penghibur] sampaikan..korang x rugi..dan x menguntungkan sape2 pun..korang gaduh2...tp korang akan diPERBODOHKAN...fikir2kan...
XxaMizamxX 1 year ago
Powerful voice. I adore her singing talent very much.
msthien77 1 year ago
ya...she is indonesian....hebat sangat kew????
bob840620 1 year ago
pehal la, sal ni pon nk gado...x phm la org endon, nape suke mengamuk bnda yg remeh...& by da way, we, Malaysia r nt malayshit...wat da shit u talk bout, korg x layak ckp cmtu..sal artis pun nk berebut smpai hina kteowg malaysia, ape kes??? korg ni kna msk klas perbaiki akhlak la...kte ni sesama muslim, ape nk angin sal bnde2 yg x berbaloi ni...
jajadiba 1 year ago
Lu pandai aja mghujat..gue ngak pernah berminat mengelim hak lo..jangan pantas menyalahkan orang lain sama ngan gue..gue hanya mahu enjoy dengan muzik dan mnghormati orang seperti lo..tapi terserah jika lo ngak mahu..gue ngak rugi kerna gue juga punya ramai teman dari indonesia..yang tahu menghormati orang lain..
Jika lo ngak mahu keamanan,terserah..buang masa gue aja bermusuh dengan lo..lebih baik gue melayan dangdut..huh..
zenU27 1 year ago
Aku hanya mahu enjoy dengan muzik..aku mahu keamanan..
Ayuh saudara2 ku dr Mlaysia..jangan dilayan sesetengah orang2 Indonesia yg brmodalkan isu kelim semata2..mereka2 ini ngak mahu akan keamanan..mereka suka kedua2 negara serumpun ini bermusuh sesama sendiri..
Peace Forever!!No Maling Forever!!
zenU27 1 year ago
sudah2...ape niey gadow2 lk....as Malaysian,sy mengaku dye artis indonesia...bkn m'sia...tp lagu nie dicipte leh owg malaysia...kn senang....sudalaa..
13nash90 1 year ago 2
ape ni babi2, kita sama islam berjiran pun nak gaduh pasal benda kecik je, ambik la kat indon kalu nak sgt, peperangan kita masih menuggu dihadapan sana...grow up malaysia
pijat4026 1 year ago
wkwkwkwkwkwkkwkwkwkwkwwkwkwkwkwkwkwkkwkwkw
DreadAces 1 year ago
stupid uneducated indon. this is Malaysian song. Malaysian singer.
malayneum 1 year ago
hargai suatu hasil karya seseorang niscaya karya tersebut akan lebih enak untuk dinikmati
i love indonesia
idraussur 1 year ago
@idraussur bener bgt gan, Indonesia emang mempunyai banyak talenta2 dalam bermusik.
tianfengzhou 1 year ago
this is a lady rocker from Indonesia!!!
tianfengzhou 1 year ago
keep watching... however, NICKY always belong to INDONESIA and all her songs too !!
if u can read this... SAYA TIDAK MALU SBAGAI WARGA NEGARA INDONESIA ! JIKA KAU BILANG KAMI BABINYA, KAU MALAYSHIT LAH YG JADI TAIK BABI NYA !! LOL TO DIE !
minumankaleng 1 year ago
this is it ! greatest singer in Indonesia . no one greater than her !
rabonsir 1 year ago
The problem here has been solved, The truth is .... Nicky Astria is Indonesian, and this song is Truly Indonesian. Wikipedia, Google, Yahoo, and all other Reputable Websites all around the world know Exactly Nicky Astria is Indonesian and the Song "Mengapa" is Indonesian song.
If you Malaysians like this song, that is fine with me, you can hear it, sing it, whenever you like, but CLAIMING is a stupid thing to do. Just because we are from the same root doesn't mean what mine is yours ...
billyasik 1 year ago
@billyasik
hey stupid...this song is compose by malaysian....stupid indon
boxerckpng 1 year ago
@boxerckpng :
Oh Really ???
THEN SHOW ME YOUR PROOF !
Give me a trustable link from reliable Source,
Dont tell me to search for it in Google.
You said i was a stupid Indon ?
If You cant Show me your proof, you are a DUMBER MALON !
You FUCKING GAY !
billyasik 1 year ago
@boxerckpng So?
Chaingangz 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
we are MALAYSIANS and INDONESIANS.
and theres a VAST sea seperating us both.
but ONE THING, i don't really understand.
Most of us are muslims.
And yet, why are we behaving like the ISRAELIS and PALESTINIANS.
Get back to your senses guys.
This doesn't do us any good. If one of us was wrong.
We could simple say that "Hey dude, that's wrong.."
Rather than spreading these neverending comments of cursing and hatred.
Just think about it..
hookups88 1 year ago
we are MALAYSIANS and INDONESIANS.
and theres a VAST seperating us both.
but ONE THING, i don't really understand.
Most of us are muslims.
And yet, why are we behaving like the ISRAELIS and PALESTINIANS.
Get back to your senses guys.
This doesn't do us any good. If one of us was wrong.
We could simple say that "Hey dude, that's wrong.."
Rather than spreading these neverending comments of cursing and hatred.
Just think about it..
hookups88 1 year ago
i'm indonesian and i know well that this song and this singer is ABSOLUTELY INDONESIAN..
i even have the original tape cassete of her album which this song is included, i can prove it if you want
and let me clear this once again that this song (and the singer Nicky Astria) IS ABSOLUTELY INDONESIAN!!.. once more THIS IS INDONESIAN!!
TheWongwonosobo 1 year ago
come on... just STOP it... im sick of all of ur damn shit comments..... it really does mess up the comments column....
syedmukhtar41 1 year ago
DONT STOP SAY FUCK TO MALINGSIAL
KauTipuAku 1 year ago
@KauTipuAku mcm ckp diri sndri je.. ha3
raphy1399 1 year ago
And one more thing ... Please dont try to ESCAPE from what we've been arguing here : "Nicky Astria : Indonesian or Malaysian ?"
Some of you malaysian are trying to ESCAPE by bringing other topics such as the influence of Arabian and Indian Culture to Indonesian Culture.
Just to let you know ... YES ! WE INDONESIAN ADMIT THAT ARABIAN AND INDIAN ARE ALSO PUT INFLUENCE IN INDONESIAN CULTURE !
BUT WE NEVER CLAIM "ARABIAN KEBAB" AS INDONESIAN TRADITIONAL DISH,
billyasik 1 year ago 2
@billyasik And here's the thing I've been arguing about: dwichagi -- racist extraordinaire. I'm fine with saying Nicky Astria as Indonesia -- didn't you read my comment correcting a fellow Malaysian that she's Indonesian? Guess not. But I'm here especially to argue against dwichagi's sentiments about Malaysia.
Aprillis29 1 year ago
@Aprillis29 :
What ? okay, i'll take a deeper look into this ....
billyasik 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Malaysian ....
You guys are soooo IDIOT ! we are talking about Nicky Astria HERE ! why dont you losers go and search for "Nicky Astria" in Wikipedia or Google ! and see who Nicky Astria truly is .... INDONESIAN, and this song is also written by Indonesian Song-Writer with help from Indonesian Composer.
For God Sake ! I've been hearing her songs since i was in the Elementary School ! Nicky Astria is a Lady-Rocker from Bandung, West Java, INDONESIA !
Why dont you PROVE it by yourself ?
billyasik 1 year ago
"lebih baik tenggelam didalam danau prasejarah daripada menjadi penjiplak seumur hidup"
KauTipuAku 1 year ago
woi malingsit,kapan lo mw sadaaaaaaaaaaaaaar? sadar lo sadar
KauTipuAku 1 year ago
weeeeeeee,apa enaknya jadi maling? malu2in aja
KauTipuAku 1 year ago
mengapa? mengapa malingsial tak penah kapok curi pny indo? apa seniman malay udah pada mati yw?
KauTipuAku 1 year ago
wahai para pencuri,tak sadarkah kau bahwa dirmu tak punya wajah
KauTipuAku 1 year ago
hei.
this is Indonesian song.
Nicky astria was born in Indonesia
kesek 1 year ago
icemanfreak
kesek 1 year ago
MALU WOYYY ngaku2. . . .
waly30102 1 year ago
hohohoho MALINGSHIT. . .
YEYeyeyey MALINGSHIT
FUCK YOU. . . .
ALWAYS PLAGIAT
waly30102 1 year ago 2
oke, kita gak usah ribut... tapi jika kalian org malay TIDAK MENDENGARKAN lagu ini lagi.. bila kalian malay mau menghargai kami, dengan senang hati kami akan menghargai kalian !
thats all, sngat mudah kan?!
minumankaleng 1 year ago
Indonesia punya nih. . .
Wahai MALINGSHIT tidak malukah engkau, bisanya ngejiplak or PLAGIAT Karya Bangs kami INDONESIA RAYA. . .
waly30102 1 year ago
the only thief who proud of what they've done is just the malaysian people. never understand how can you people became this stupid...
ArisArdiantoPutra 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
HargaiLah Jerih Payah Orang Laen! iLmu itu Mahal HargaNya, SeCara SpesiFik ga Smua Orang Bisa! INGAT, BisNis is BisNis, KoNco yo KonCo,musuh tetp musuh,
yang mengganggu negara indonesia harus d beri pelajaran,hajaaaaaaaaaaaar malingsial,
INI ADALAH BARISAN TAK BERGENDANG BERPALU,KEPERCAYAAN TANDA MENYERBU,SEKALI BERARTI SUDAH ITU MATI
KauTipuAku 1 year ago
ini 100% lagu indonesia, klo gk percaya tanya bapakmu sono jangan asal ngaku ngaku punya malaysia. Mahathir aja masih ngakuin indonesia napa lu yang rakyat biasa gak ngakuin klo lagu ini milik indonesia
sukma87 1 year ago
@sukma87 Lagu mmg dinyayiin oleh teh Nicky (org Indonesia) tp lagu tsb yg nyiptain Ly/Baiduri ( org malaysia). Saat itu setelah diciptaiin, dia mrasa hanya teh Nicky lah yg cocok dn bisa mnyanyikan lgu tsb, krn ckup sulit dn memerlukan nada suara yg tinggi.
Amyra703 5 months ago
HargaiLah Jerih Payah Orang Laen! iLmu itu Mahal HargaNya, SeCara SpesiFik ga Smua Orang Bisa! INGAT, BisNis is BisNis, KoNco yo KonCo,musuh tetp musuh,
yang mengganggu negara indonesia harus d beri pelajaran,hajaaaaaaaaaaaar malingsial,
INI ADALAH BARISAN TAK BERGENDANG BERPALU,KEPERCAYAAN TANDA MENYERBU,SEKALI BERARTI SUDAH ITU MATI
KauTipuAku 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
HargaiLah Jerih Payah Orang Laen! iLmu itu Mahal HargaNya, SeCara SpesiFik ga Smua Orang Bisa! INGAT, BisNis is BisNis, KoNco yo KonCo,musuh tetp musuh,
yang mengganggu negara indonesia harus d beri pelajaran,hajaaaaaaaaaaaar malingsial,
INI ADALAH BARISAN TAK BERGENDANG BERPALU,KEPERCAYAAN TANDA MENYERBU,SEKALI BERARTI SUDAH ITU MATI
KauTipuAku 1 year ago
Indonesia memang keren, sampe-sampe ada yang "pingin punya" sesuatu yang asli indonesia, brarti ga punya apa-apa yang bisa dibanggain itu kan,,
94ZUMAZ94 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
HargaiLah Jerih Payah Orang Laen! iLmu itu Mahal HargaNya, SeCara SpesiFik ga Smua Orang Bisa! INGAT, BisNis is BisNis, KoNco yo KonCo,musuh tetp musuh,
yang mengganggu negara indonesia harus d beri pelajaran,hajaaaaaaaaaaaar malingsial,
INI ADALAH BARISAN TAK BERGENDANG BERPALU,KEPERCAYAAN TANDA MENYERBU,SEKALI BERARTI SUDAH ITU MATI
KauTipuAku 1 year ago
HargaiLah Jerih Payah Orang Laen! iLmu itu Mahal HargaNya, SeCara SpesiFik ga Smua Orang Bisa! INGAT, BisNis is BisNis, KoNco yo KonCo,musuh tetp musuh,
yang mengganggu negara indonesia harus d beri pelajaran,hajaaaaaaaaaaaar malingsial,
INI ADALAH BARISAN TAK BERGENDANG BERPALU,KEPERCAYAAN TANDA MENYERBU,SEKALI BERARTI SUDAH ITU MATI
KauTipuAku 1 year ago
Nicky Astria (lahir di Bandung, 18 Oktober 1967; umur 42 tahun ;terlahir dengan nama Nicky Nastitie Karya Dewi) adalah seorang penyanyi rock asal Indonesia.
by WIKIPEDIA
jelas2 Made In Indonesia!!!!!!!! OMG
bocahb0y 1 year ago
Teh Nicky salah satu Dieva Indonesia yang powerfull banget klo bernyanyi, ladys rocker Indonesia yang keren banget, tinggi bener suaranya....
tetep eksist Teh Nicky.., sukses terus
andykusumayadi 1 year ago 2
ini magh lagunya asli INDONESIA ..
Lagunya Nicky astria .. Hem..
INDONESIA memang kreatif bangetz...
Ya klo mau berkreasa mbok yo 'o bikin sendiri yach ...
papizoel 1 year ago
zoowana86 1 year ago 13
@zoowana86
TheXalvator 1 year ago
@zoowana86 but this song writed by malaysian composer...
widadishak 1 year ago
@zoowana86 but malaysian compose this song
widadishak 1 year ago
@dwichangi&the abbodd, belum sempat mau diskusi, liet komen para malingshit itu aja ane uda panas!
heran aja ama mrk... gak tau,apa para maling2 ini cuma ngembat di negara kita aja?
oke, kalo emang mau diskusi...silahkan... ane pantau dulu...
minumankaleng 1 year ago
ingat masa lalu kalo ndengerin lagu ini. luv ya nicky
pChrist12 1 year ago
ingat masa lalu kalo ndengeri lagu ini....luv ya nicky
pChrist12 1 year ago
dasar malingshit, budaya pencuri semua...
plunkzero 1 year ago
hey malay,, kata kau negara yg maju dan punya IQ tinggi... so, show to us apa yg bisa negara kau banggakan?? !!! budaya?? apa? mana?? ooo, film yg judul nya "PISAU CUKUR" ? "JALANG"?? napa gak skalian "PISAU DAPUR"?? LOL !!
Udah lah, kalo punya IQ tinggi, ciptakan sesuatu yg bisa kami COPY juga donk! jgn cuman bisa jady COPY PUSSY CAT doank..
Aneh, gak habis2nya BODOH kalian tuh.. kita memang serumpun, tapi kita BERBEDA bro!
LOL
minumankaleng 1 year ago
Saya suka lagu ini..saya menghargai karya dari mana2 negara....lebih2 lagi negara serumpun sperti Indonesia...Orang Indonesia juga orang kita...satu rumpun satu agama...
Jadi jangan lah kita menjadi orang yang tolol bodoh anjing menyalahkan sesama yang lain...Isu2 yang hangat antara Malaysia dan Indonesia jangan diperdebatkan dalam seni muzik...Guna Akal Dan Otak...Pikirin...
Peace Forever.... No Maling!!
zenU27 1 year ago 3