Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (29)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I dont understand when at " where are you my father" the chords is different for me like three side live

  • Oh my, this version is amazing!

  • I found this explantion on Can Ultilty:

    The multitrack isn't available, but 5.1 surround-sound mixes are. In 2007, all their albums except the very first one were released as two-disk packages: a 5.1 mix and a new stereo mix. Typically the center channel of the 5.1 contains only the vocals. An ingenious fan has pulled Peter's vocal from the center channel of this release, and added it to the instrumental version on the CD "Genesis for Two Grand Pianos" by Yngve Guddal and Roger Matte.

  • Please, who can help me??

    In Archive#3 are TWO pianos. The first one is TONY, clearly! But who is the second?? Peter?

    Where can I find more information about this "piano-archive"#3? ITS GREAT!!!

    Please answers if you are able.

    GRETTINGS TO ALL FANS from a BERLINER

  • NC DTS mono files ripped, plus the Two pianos version. Very nice idea and editing job... Wish I'd thought of it...

  • Very nice ... I really like it!

  • One of my favorite Genesis songs from Nursery Cryme which was the album that got me into Progressive Rock in the first place. This piano version is almost equally good. I like the piano over the synths but the overall band arragements are better in the album released version.

  • wowwwwwww!!!! this gave me goosebumps!!! ;) really catches the mood!

  • I have never heard or heard of these ever being made. I love this version. I absolutely love it! When did they do this version?

  • wanderfull job!!!! 

  • Where did you get this?? This is so awesome!!!! I want to get these versions

  • GREAT! but.... where are the lyrics,as in your other ones(I like to sing along,good practice!)?could you upload the lyrics,please?thanks!

  • My oh my... that is absolutely beautiful.

  • Gee! Whre did you find this rarety?

  • I've been searching for the Genesis Archive #3 album since I heard your version, but only just now I discovered you mixed it yourself... Too bad, I really like it and would have loved it to have it on cd!

  • THANK YOU...

  • THANK YOU...

  • Brillant work and footage!

  • That is not Tony....

  • Ahah! Quote from Steve Hackett: "Two Norwegian piano geniuses (Yngve Guddal and Roger T. Matte since you ask) have arranged some of those fiendishly complicated Genesis tunes for two pianos and recorded the result on two Steinways. "

  • Well, that could be Tony Banks? Not sure, it sounds a little too dynamically heavy for him & maybe a little too flowery? That's a really wonderful job of synching in the vocals. This is a wonderful piece of music. Genesis really outclassed everyone when it came to writing songs.

  • Thanks for this.

  • Very interested in where this version comes from... it doesn't sound like Tony Banks' style of playing. Any more info?

  • The piano is ripped off the CD "Genesis for two Grand Pianos" and the voice is mixed out of a remastered Album version.

    Peter's too quiet in some parts (and you cut some vocal parts... please try to correct)

    Sorry for my bad english.

  • the voice seems not to come from the album Nursery cryme, maybe it's from some live version. Or maybe there are more than one voice mixed...dunno :)

  • this is unreal...forgive me for what may be a stupid question but ..thats Tony Banks playing the piano, right!? wowoowowow!

  • brill :)

  • bellissima versione...

  • Forse anche più bella della versione al completo.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more