this is confusing to me... I have an audience bootleg from Landover 77, and the version of this song is MUCH better (probably the best i've heard them play it) with Plant and Page doing a bit of "You Shook Me" at the end before the "Oh won't you make it my dyin'.... dyin'.... dyin' be----ed"
who gives a shit!!! Zep rocks no matter what. I'll take them on a bad night compared to any of the shit out now. Jimmy had problems with smack on this tour and he still played over 70 cities and 3 1/2hr shows! They just did their thing, and didn't give a shit! Rock with balls, livin on the edge! It wasn't about sounding like the album. If you want to see the album note for note exactly like the album, just turn it up real loud in your living room. Playing live should be about feeling!
Brings back memories of the cloudy past. Saw Zeppelin the opening night of this 4 show gig on the 25th. It was my third concert and it ruined me for life. Never did I witness anything that great musically since. Lost two of my concert going companions 8 years almost to the date. Here's to thinking about both of ya, Rest in peace............Oh Lord, deliver me. All the wrong I've done. You can deliver me, Lord. I only wanted to have some fun............................
I agree with the person who seems to prefer Bonzo's drumming on the '77 tour (although '75 kicks ass too). But I would add that for all the injuries and handicaps and addictions, etc., we're dealing with 4 very serious musicians who were TOTALLY DEDICATED to changing and moving forward ("ever onward" was their motto). So, sometimes when you hear them trying out a certain style that's different than you like, you have to give them benefit of the doubt sometimes. They were trying to GROW.
Great audio quality. Thanks for posting this. Oddly, this is one of the few songs that was not better live. I think the other would be Trampled Under Foot.
@amstell13 I probably have 15 different bootleg versions of this song from the 75 and 77 tours and none of them (except for maybe Nassau 75) are very exciting. First of all they play it live in a different key and second Bonzo's drumming is boring compared to the track he laid down for the studio version. Also, Plant does not sing it very well either. These are my own personal opinions and I refuse to argue about Zeppelin as they are my favorite band. I am glad you like it live, just not my fav.
@Bonzosbadgeholder ,Bonham boring? Are you nuts? Check out Led Zeppelin live in Dallas 3/4/75, L.A. 3/24/75, Bonham's playing in both are wicked! In the Dallas 3/4/75 version, after the song, Plant says Mr. John Bonham. That's how awesome he's playing was that night. During the song, at one point Plant knows Bonzo is on, so he says over the microphone "take it John." Check that one out. It goes under the bootleg title of "Trampled Underfoot."
@amstell13 Just went back and listened to Dallas and I stand by what I said....boring. You also proved my point that Plant sounds bad on this song compared to studio. I would guess he had the surgery after the new songs on PG already recorded. His oh my jesus at the end is horrible. I do think Bonzo had a good show that night but I play the drums and I can tell you 75 was his worst tour. Go back and watch Earls Court on the DVD. He is definitely taking downers or something cause he is boring.
@Bonzosbadgeholder < BTW, Plant had throat problems after the 73' US tour. He even had minor throat surgery during the year of 74', which had to do with the way Plant sang the rest of his career with Led Zeppelin.
@Bonzosbadgeholder , I have every show from the 75' US tour, trust me, Bonham's playing was great throughout! He was awesome during The Song Remains The Same on this tour, as he was on the other songs!
I was there, I was there!!!! Nosebleed seats and too loud to tell one song from the other. Or I was too high!! Robert Plant you were my first!!!! -3
LolalynnThomas 6 months ago
this is confusing to me... I have an audience bootleg from Landover 77, and the version of this song is MUCH better (probably the best i've heard them play it) with Plant and Page doing a bit of "You Shook Me" at the end before the "Oh won't you make it my dyin'.... dyin'.... dyin' be----ed"
markbray72 6 months ago
who gives a shit!!! Zep rocks no matter what. I'll take them on a bad night compared to any of the shit out now. Jimmy had problems with smack on this tour and he still played over 70 cities and 3 1/2hr shows! They just did their thing, and didn't give a shit! Rock with balls, livin on the edge! It wasn't about sounding like the album. If you want to see the album note for note exactly like the album, just turn it up real loud in your living room. Playing live should be about feeling!
ledhedful 7 months ago 2
@ledhedful THANK YOU! you couldn't have said it any better! tight but loose!!! P.
MegaZephead 6 months ago
Brings back memories of the cloudy past. Saw Zeppelin the opening night of this 4 show gig on the 25th. It was my third concert and it ruined me for life. Never did I witness anything that great musically since. Lost two of my concert going companions 8 years almost to the date. Here's to thinking about both of ya, Rest in peace............Oh Lord, deliver me. All the wrong I've done. You can deliver me, Lord. I only wanted to have some fun............................
barefoot191 10 months ago
I agree with the person who seems to prefer Bonzo's drumming on the '77 tour (although '75 kicks ass too). But I would add that for all the injuries and handicaps and addictions, etc., we're dealing with 4 very serious musicians who were TOTALLY DEDICATED to changing and moving forward ("ever onward" was their motto). So, sometimes when you hear them trying out a certain style that's different than you like, you have to give them benefit of the doubt sometimes. They were trying to GROW.
mielazul 1 year ago 5
Think this cooks Live...specially earls Court
Maguirearch 2 years ago
What is wrong with this one other than Jimmy being smaked out?!
zed0469 2 years ago
Great audio quality. Thanks for posting this. Oddly, this is one of the few songs that was not better live. I think the other would be Trampled Under Foot.
Bonzosbadgeholder 2 years ago
I think the version at Earls Court surpassed the studio version
zoso7889 2 years ago 13
@Bonzosbadgeholder , WRONG! You haven't heard this song live many times then! There are great versions of this song in 75' & 77'!
amstell13 1 year ago
@amstell13 I probably have 15 different bootleg versions of this song from the 75 and 77 tours and none of them (except for maybe Nassau 75) are very exciting. First of all they play it live in a different key and second Bonzo's drumming is boring compared to the track he laid down for the studio version. Also, Plant does not sing it very well either. These are my own personal opinions and I refuse to argue about Zeppelin as they are my favorite band. I am glad you like it live, just not my fav.
Bonzosbadgeholder 1 year ago
@Bonzosbadgeholder ,Bonham boring? Are you nuts? Check out Led Zeppelin live in Dallas 3/4/75, L.A. 3/24/75, Bonham's playing in both are wicked! In the Dallas 3/4/75 version, after the song, Plant says Mr. John Bonham. That's how awesome he's playing was that night. During the song, at one point Plant knows Bonzo is on, so he says over the microphone "take it John." Check that one out. It goes under the bootleg title of "Trampled Underfoot."
amstell13 1 year ago
@amstell13 Just went back and listened to Dallas and I stand by what I said....boring. You also proved my point that Plant sounds bad on this song compared to studio. I would guess he had the surgery after the new songs on PG already recorded. His oh my jesus at the end is horrible. I do think Bonzo had a good show that night but I play the drums and I can tell you 75 was his worst tour. Go back and watch Earls Court on the DVD. He is definitely taking downers or something cause he is boring.
Bonzosbadgeholder 1 year ago
@Bonzosbadgeholder , You didn't hear the show from 3/4/75. The Dallas show you prbably heard was from the night after 3/5/75.
Bonham's playing in 75' was awesome, granted, not better than the U.S. 77' tour. On that tour Bonham's playing was impecable!
amstell13 1 year ago
@Bonzosbadgeholder < BTW, Plant had throat problems after the 73' US tour. He even had minor throat surgery during the year of 74', which had to do with the way Plant sang the rest of his career with Led Zeppelin.
amstell13 1 year ago
@Bonzosbadgeholder , I have every show from the 75' US tour, trust me, Bonham's playing was great throughout! He was awesome during The Song Remains The Same on this tour, as he was on the other songs!
amstell13 1 year ago