In the recording I have heard, Horowitz interprets this piece with much greater fluidity and sublety of expresssion than any other pianist I have heard--Neuhaus included.
I agree, but there is a distinct similarity in the interpretations and that can be no accident, considering how radically different this piece sounds from pianist to pianist. I think amongst those in the know, Horowitz is the 'ne plus ultra' of interpreters of this mighty work, and this has perhaps informed more recent performances by people like Kissin and Pletnev. Even still there is enormous variety in detail.
That is why I thought it noteworthy to remark on the interpretative similarity
Poetic playing, reminiscent of Horowitz and there can be no greater comparison..
Indeed Horowitz must have been influenced by Neuhaus, the similarities are too great. Horowitz is still the greatest interpreter of the work, if only because of his superior fingers (perhaps a little greater expressiveness and clarity of articulation in the allegro sections).
@ilovescarlatti There is a movie with Katherine Hepburn and a German actor whose name I cannot recall, however she plays the role of Schumann's wife, Clara Wieck. VERY GOOD, apparently she married him and he was a lot older than her. They had a lot of children and in the movie Brahms (of BRAHM'S lullaby) comes to live with them and to study with SCHUMANN. very good movie
In the opening Egorov clearly shows more contrast by painting the area of the second minute with some beautiful strokes of poignance that have more affect and dimension than Neuhaus which makes his return to the tumult all the more effective.Full details in my Comments section.
Later today Walter Gieseking shall battle Heinrich Neuhaus to see who will face Vladimir Sofronitsky,who vanquished Joseph Hofmann in a a tough semifinals match in the Kreisleriana tournament.
Dear alexongcs! i agree!! Oh my God !!! What a music.. I loveeeeee Schumann... Neuhaus too.. Full of sensitive, poethry, etc etc.... dreams and tears, sound and dream's sound... I'm getting grazy for this..Wishes from Como lake. italy
I AWARD THIS 3 CLARAS...as I feel that this performance while missing many attractive turns of phrase,still captures many things very well.I particularly love how he captures
the Queer combination Schumann has here of going nowhere in a big hurry.I also feel that he always not only knows the meaning of what this is,but that he is actually not lost in his pianism...and is trying to and succeeding at communicating the full psyche here..
@truecrypt Which years is it please? I gess it is one take! He has been one of the greatest teacher of all time. I read his book about playing the piano. Thanks for sharing.
Sviatoslav Richter was right.
gkollias14 2 months ago
Does anyone know how to properly pronounce his name? I'm thinking it's either Hyne-rich New-hos or Hyne-rick New-hos.
Clarification would be nice =)
Jazzadrin 10 months ago
@Jazzadrin Hyne-rich Noy-house
lollybuug 7 months ago
Neuhaus is the best. Thank you very much for posting this. VK
6558369 11 months ago
Richter's and Gilels teacher^^
loboris1995 1 year ago
nobody plays Kreisleriana like that today !!!!!! extraordinaire !!! just Horowitz may be... but I like.
nelassov 1 year ago
In the recording I have heard, Horowitz interprets this piece with much greater fluidity and sublety of expresssion than any other pianist I have heard--Neuhaus included.
buttsmellr 2 years ago
I agree, but there is a distinct similarity in the interpretations and that can be no accident, considering how radically different this piece sounds from pianist to pianist. I think amongst those in the know, Horowitz is the 'ne plus ultra' of interpreters of this mighty work, and this has perhaps informed more recent performances by people like Kissin and Pletnev. Even still there is enormous variety in detail.
That is why I thought it noteworthy to remark on the interpretative similarity
eusebium7 2 years ago
Poetic playing, reminiscent of Horowitz and there can be no greater comparison..
Indeed Horowitz must have been influenced by Neuhaus, the similarities are too great. Horowitz is still the greatest interpreter of the work, if only because of his superior fingers (perhaps a little greater expressiveness and clarity of articulation in the allegro sections).
eusebium7 2 years ago
My God, where do you find these?? Thank you once again, we piano-files are becoming dependent on your uploads!!
marcohorowitz8 2 years ago
what are the "smith comments"??????
kempff95 2 years ago
Neuhaus >>>> a god a god!!!!!! Iìm crazy for Schumann and this pianist too!!!!!
ilovescarlatti 2 years ago 2
@ilovescarlatti There is a movie with Katherine Hepburn and a German actor whose name I cannot recall, however she plays the role of Schumann's wife, Clara Wieck. VERY GOOD, apparently she married him and he was a lot older than her. They had a lot of children and in the movie Brahms (of BRAHM'S lullaby) comes to live with them and to study with SCHUMANN. very good movie
grace230608 1 year ago
@grace230608 Song of Love, 1947
jjdieffenbach 1 year ago
In the opening Egorov clearly shows more contrast by painting the area of the second minute with some beautiful strokes of poignance that have more affect and dimension than Neuhaus which makes his return to the tumult all the more effective.Full details in my Comments section.
ClassicalMusicReview 2 years ago
Later today Walter Gieseking shall battle Heinrich Neuhaus to see who will face Vladimir Sofronitsky,who vanquished Joseph Hofmann in a a tough semifinals match in the Kreisleriana tournament.
ClassicalMusicReview 2 years ago
We are anxiously awaiting....
caijpp 2 years ago
Dear Joyce,I made the review but YouTube censors are prohibiting it's posting.
ClassicalMusicReview 2 years ago
Guys, I just want you to know, that I have absolutely nothing to do with posting difficulties...
Smith, did you post many comments before posting here? Sometimes YT limits amount of postings... I can always post on your behalf if you wish.
truecrypt 2 years ago
Dear Viktor,It's not you and it's not I,as my account was very fresh when I tried to post.Some old arbitrary censor crap as usual.
ClassicalMusicReview 2 years ago
Awesome !
dmcII 2 years ago
Dear alexongcs! i agree!! Oh my God !!! What a music.. I loveeeeee Schumann... Neuhaus too.. Full of sensitive, poethry, etc etc.... dreams and tears, sound and dream's sound... I'm getting grazy for this..Wishes from Como lake. italy
ilovescarlatti 3 years ago
Oh MY GOODNESS>>>!!!! THIS IS A TREASURE. Music must be played this way. I LOVEEEEEEE SCHUMANN like crazy.
alexongcs 3 years ago
In what year was this recorded? Thanks for posting all these HN recordings, I'm having such a great time listening to them!
voolare 3 years ago
The best performance of "Kreisleriana"! Thank You very much for posting!
gromoglas77 3 years ago 3
I AWARD THIS 3 CLARAS...as I feel that this performance while missing many attractive turns of phrase,still captures many things very well.I particularly love how he captures
the Queer combination Schumann has here of going nowhere in a big hurry.I also feel that he always not only knows the meaning of what this is,but that he is actually not lost in his pianism...and is trying to and succeeding at communicating the full psyche here..
SCHUMANNasaSACRAMENT 3 years ago 2
you seem a dangerously disturbed individual
amyparking 3 years ago 2
Psychobabble.
hmagram 3 years ago 4
OMG Neuhaus! How'd you get this? Thanks for sharing!
prongated 3 years ago
This is an old but well known recording...
I'm glad you are interested - looks like you are quite serious about music! Good luck to you!
truecrypt 3 years ago
@truecrypt Which years is it please? I gess it is one take! He has been one of the greatest teacher of all time. I read his book about playing the piano. Thanks for sharing.
Kiarinadia 1 year ago
@Kiarinadia
Between 1947 and 1952.
truecrypt 1 year ago
Is it a piano roll?
amakrid 3 years ago
This piano (although modern)has been tuned and or voiced to approxiamate the vulunerable moonlit shimmer so common to the pianos of Schumann's day.
smithsherman 3 years ago
what nonsense!
gtimny 3 years ago 2
What nonsense?
caijpp 3 years ago
Dear Ghost,
I'm so sorry about your five thumb downs...
caijpp 3 years ago
sounds like the most beautiful musical performance ever.
nosferatusvampire 3 years ago