ბორჯომიდან წამოსვლის შემდეგ წერა: „ჩემი აზით, ეს არის ერთ-ერთი ყველაზე ლამაზი ადგილი მსოფლიოში“ / after leaving Georgia (Saqartvelo), Tchaikovsky said: "Georgia is one of the most beautiful place on this world".
You children don't listen to a piece classical music unless you hear it first in a movie soundtrack or in a stupid pop/rock concert? "Lady Gaga" LOL How utterly stupid that will sound to you in few years.
@kiannasutube He'll be remembered for longer than Lady Gaga will. If you don't like Tchaikovsky, don't bother watching this video and reading the comments. I don't go on Lady Gaga videos and make comments about Tchaikovsky.
@EternalClassicMusic I love Tchaikovsky, I made that as a joke.Tchaikovsky is dead, so he couldn't have brought you here. Don't take things so seriously.
Que aterradora y profunda sinceridad, que amargas y tristes lagrimas corren en cada una de las notas de una de las mas grandes sinfonias escritas despues de la coral. El compositor sabia lo que esto queria decir y cuanto significaba para el... fue su composicion mas amada, la mas lograda, la mas pura e intensa, la mas personal... se referia al mundo y a las futuras generaciones cuando le preguntaron que significado tenia y el dijo : " dejalos que adivinen".
How can we be sure that the cough didn't come from the percussion section?
Not that I'm saying we should take them out and shoot them, but the patrons in the house presumably paid to be in the audience while the percussionists.... well... we know....didn't pay.
@symphonyfirst I guess it all depends on what one finds in the programs of concerts that are given in our head-stuck arses elitist European concert halls. As far as I can see, any of the ones you named here don't appear very very frequently - better said, their appearances are few and far in between..What can the reason be, the conductors put those in so rarely??!!!
Gheorgyi: for someone who has so much to say about symphonic music and have the effrontery to determine for others what's good or bad , it is incredible you have never heard of Barber. Know what? You are an ignorant child.
Stop posting your ridiculous opinions. You aren't anywhere near capable of understanding the music, let alone understanding the history. In other posts you brag about how you walk out of performances (I doubt you ever visited a hall). You are a drag.
@smartingamerica Buster, 1, I have as much to say about symphonic music as anyone else on this "forum"; 2, I've never been didactic, nor had I "the effrontery" etc. etc. Quote an ad hoc a passage from me; 3. your "Barber", or "figaro", anyway you want to call him, is an insignificant american pygmee in a world of European musicalk giants; 4. I NEVER bragged to have "walked out", once again: I dare you to quote; 5. IF you really are 55, I'm 82, you're not qualified to call me a "child": BUFFOON
II – Conductors, too: the good ones, they had (and still have) to import them from Europe. Their Leonard Bernstein was grossly over-rated and imposed: he grew up to international standing too fast, pushed upwards with Madison Ave advertising techniques. Why don’t they adapt themselves to the idea that their real musical product is jazz: everybody will agree with that. Problem is, what nowadays is passed as “jazz” is anything BUT.
Pretty drastic, ain't you? Which one, the young one on the foreground? What's he doing so wrong he should be "fired" for??!!! C'mon, he's visibly very young, let him mature... I'm sure if he did something bad, Jurij/Yuri noticed it and reprimanded him, Those conductors have eyes like a lynx, a hearing like... like WHAT??!!! ;-)
@Gheorgyi lol dude. young or old he is a professional musician. professional string players should be able to play a note without sliding all over the place. Thats what he is doing wrong.
@Mizzles240 Well, you knew and I didn't: I don't play a string instrument (matter of fact, I don't play ANY), so just thanks for telling us, you must be a GREAT expert. I'm sure old Jurij/Yuri, as director, can chew his ass off if it is that bad. Problem is, he has to get back to Sankt Petersburg or wherever... But, FIRE him??!!! aaAA-R-R-R-ggGGhhHH, would you shoot a man for sayng f**k...??!!! :-)
@Mizzles240 Well kidd.-o, "fire" is exactly the word you used. I'm sure the conductor who has the great privilege of having YOU in the orchestra is doing his best to train you to perfection as a learner; but you might stop a moment and realize that young man is no longer a learner, but a professional in one of the greatest symphonical orchestras in the world, "La Scala Theater's in Milano, Italy.
I write letters to Pyotr in my diary. He has been my hero and friend since my father introduced us (his music) when I was 3 yrs. old. He seems to be the only soul that understands mine.
@luridplanet Isn't it funny, but I find the coughs and the pops to be so crucial in enjoying individual arangements of music... Even the clicking and fingering of the keys is beautiful, I love it all.
Saw Temirkanov yesterday in Rome, he conducted Requiem of Verdi... it is easy to be "great" with orchestra, that can play also without conductor ... but if he would work with orchestra that has a level not so high, and if thay play REALLY according to his hands, i have a lot of doubts about result!!!
He reminds me of Abbado when the latter conducted the BPO. A director of a play draws his vision on a stage. A conductor says, 'Come with me on this exciting journey! Trust me!' What a wonderful example of conducting in this video.
He reminds me of Abbado when the latter conducted the BPO. A director of a play draws his vision on a stage. A conductor says, 'Come with me on this exciting journey! Trust me!' What a wonderful example in this video.
Thanks to Galdo80 for posting this work, although I wish it had been in stereo (it is not), and he would not have cut off the last notes of the descending solo clarinet at the end of this part.
Please. Before interpreting a musical piece by linking it to the composer's biography, you first have to do an analysis, showing the interconnections of themes, motives, instrumentation, timbre and son on. If you leave this step out you will end in total pseudoromantic superficial "kitsch". This applies to any composition.
@MadMusicologist1 Let him have his say, he doesn't know himself. All these american kids are so conceited - they play in some high school or "youth" orchestra, get a smattering of technical notions and begin to spout opinions here and there - each single one of them a Beethoven-Brahms-Mahler-Verdi-Chaikowskij rolled in one. Conceited snotnosed brats. And america, from a viewpoint of symphonic music is an absolute NOTHING. They should stick to Madonna's and Michael Jackson's with their antics.
I - In comparison, those were musical pygmees. No comparison, number- and/or quality-wise. Gershwin: pretty, tenuous tunes, but no more that tunes. One can't compare his "Rhapsody in Blue" with serious symphonic work. The other one, "American in Paris", was made known by Toscanini when after WW-2 he came back to Italy to open up the new Scala Theatre in Milano - after they had destroyed it with bombings (and rammed down our throats to exhaustion thereafter). They identify it with Kelly.
@Gheorgyi What about Barber? Surely you cannot write off every single american composer ever. There are a few good ones. I'll admit kids in my country are conceited, but thats because they're KIDS. Have a heart.
@Dave308439 “Barber”, hm? Thanks for signalling this name, I didn’t know about him. Googled him up, found him in Wikipedia. "Barber, Samuel" . Rather obscure name. I can’t say I find it mentioned very often - matter of fact, NEVER - in the programs of our concerts over here, and I go to many.. Probably due to our auto-sufficiency in Europe, both quantity- and quality wise. Being just “kids” doesn’t justify raising them as the brats they are. Start straightening them out. Regards, Mister
@23skidoonk 1. If I "don't have" a place, I'll TAKE one as anyone else in this "forum"; 2. Certain people deserve to be dealt with arrogantly (and YOU seem to be to be included in their number); 3. I did NOT make any "nationalistic" remarks; 4. you keep yourself carefully non-descript in your YT profile, so I can't be sure whom I'm dealing with, I can only venture: a., you are ANOTHER conceited snotnosed brat; b.you are an anglo, or anyway you are in the USA; Do I get a cigar?
You are a buffoon who lacks both basic argumentation skills, logic, and the ability to formulate a coherent post. Further conversation will accomplish nothing: you're too far entrenched in your own misplaced, conceited, fantasies. This in itself is more of a reply than such a pathetic elitist such as yourself deserves--you've composed no music, you've played no music, so I hope at least you find happiness in your unentitled opinions about music. You are a leech, and nothing but.
@23skidoonk Clown, I don't lack anything else than - maybe - lots of money, and who needs it.. Your prose is so stuffy, stilted, stifled that one can literally see you scouring a dictionary in your anxious quest for some highfalutin words to write it. You RAVE, clown. I expressed no fantasies, I just bore a few holes into you, hyper-blown hot air balloon. No, I haven't composed nor played music, but I know more of/about it under my pinky's nail than you ever will in your bulbous self. PISS OFF.
this is a terrific performance! - the sounds, the playing, the pace, the musicians, il maestro - and the piece itself! communicating so many facets and layers of emotions and sheer music!... A thought - maybe provocative to some: it must have been composed by a very balanced person... To express so much and so subtle, I think Tchaikovsky must have been in a state of mind where emotions and reasons were in sound conditions to make the work evolve so grand and graceful.
I cannot stand to listen to pieces of this length, but thanks to my music lit class I must. but for something I despise as much as lengthy orchestral music, it's very good.
The feeling of this song is empty. For a fact five after Tchaikovsky performed this peice he died. Suicide was the suspicion. And this was considered this his suicide note. Most because of the off parts in the song, like the third movement being upbeat and happy, but not being the finale.
@TheCriticAceEvans Uh, no. Get your facts straight. Tchaikovsky DID suffered bouts of depression, but he died of cholera. In 1893 Tchaikovsky went to St. Petersburg, Russia, to conduct Pathetique. A cholera epidemic was raging in the capital, and he drank unboiled water. As a result, he contracted cholera and died. Hardly suicide. Tchaikovsky composed very emotional pieces, and no doubt they reflect his own feelings.
@TheCriticAceEvans Yeah... If anything, there were some SERIOUSLY intense feelings of despair and depression Tchaikovsky must have felt, for various reasons-emotional, spiritual, physical/mental/psychological, loneliness, etc. He must have felt such intense feelings of hopelessness as to just take the "plunge"...
When I have the time, I turn this up loud on my speakers, I stand in the middle of my room, I pretend to be conducting the orchestra. It's like I'm drowning in pure emotion.
I listened to a recording of this every day for months as a teenager... wish I still knew who recorded "my" version. Fifteen years later, I can still hear every note.
All the human emotions are encapsulated and enshrined in this great work... The turbulence of human emotions and their resolutions, all were masterfully described and expressed through musical notes... It is an amazement that never ends... ♥ ♥ ♥
I love this piece! it gives a chance for violists to play out :D
This piece is just wonderful! it's so beautiful.
Everything about this video is great, except for the fact that the cellist (the woman in the back at 2:04 looks so pissed of at the viola solo, which angers me, lol)
To be fair, it seems unlikely that he died of cholera (which was the official coroners conclusion). The facts (which are too numerous to state here...I encourage the interested to do some research) suggest that he used some form of direct poisoning (usually guessed to be arsenic, which apparently leaves a similar corpse to a cholera victim). Several theories abound as to exactly WHY he chose to die when he did (the 'court of honor' being the most popular right now...again, look it up.)
The deciding factor in almost all theories point to the potentiality of his homosexuality being made public. Homosexuality was not a crime in Russia, and in fact there were many famous Russians of that time that were not only gay, but publicly suspected of being so, but when suspicion becomes confirmed fact or scandal in any society, it changes the playing field. Tchaikovsky was extraordinarily sensitive and emotional, and the inevitable shame and humiliation was, it seems, too high a price.
Tchaikovsky crys from the depths of his despair in this symphony and said before died :" it is the most personal thing i have ever done"" . A tragic genius .......
@kitchenqueen70 No, but many music scholars agree that it does seem eerie considering the circumstances that he died only a few days after the premiere of this symphony. Basically, they (as well as I) believe that Tchaikovsky may have very well written his very own requiem without even realizing it. Maybe he did. Who knows? I agree with @TallisTriptych. This is Tchaikovsky crying from the depths of his despair. I also agree that it's the most personal thing he's ever done.
@JayOkan : i don't care even if he was doing himself .Althought , i din't have to know about this.I listen to his music since i was a little boy and he is like a godfather to me and i believe for many people .u don't have always to learn about the famous people's "kinky" habbits .
@JayOkan : (cont) and if you do, don't tell others!nobody's perfect,especially you. i just wan't to be able to listen pathetique symfony and close my eyes and see colours and emotions.don't destroy this . you remind me , gossip tv ... go get a life - peace
@thesilvershining listen he didnot die of sicknees he commited suiced by drinking poison because back then being gay(which he was and in poverty) was a sin he showed his whole life through that last symphony i 100% agree with u
7:46 :)
TheMinecount 1 week ago
Grandissimo Tchaikovsky !!!!
feurzauber 3 weeks ago 2
His last composition - such a tragical.
ბორჯომიდან წამოსვლის შემდეგ წერა: „ჩემი აზით, ეს არის ერთ-ერთი ყველაზე ლამაზი ადგილი მსოფლიოში“ / after leaving Georgia (Saqartvelo), Tchaikovsky said: "Georgia is one of the most beautiful place on this world".
NinoUrushadze1 3 weeks ago
oh man how can you :(( dont be it pls :P
roflmao9999 3 weeks ago
belleza!!! supremo!!
silvinalaeila 1 month ago
saquen al de la tosferina
cita requerida(bugs bunny por las dudas FBI)
marckvinc 1 month ago
Finding out that Tchaikovsky was gay brought me here.
So, suck it. ;o
IDontShine423 1 month ago
@IDontShine423 you gay? if so you're missing the most beautiful creature that God created...
roflmao9999 1 month ago
@roflmao9999 I'm bisexual. So, I'm not missing out on anything. ;D
IDontShine423 3 weeks ago
14 people thought it was to vote on the pre-video commercial... =p
LuizBHMG 1 month ago
@LuizBHMG surely, this is a masterpiece
giobia88 3 days ago
@giobia88 Yeah!!! I can't understand how a person can dislike such a good recording of this kind of so genial masterpiece!!!!
LuizBHMG 3 days ago
Oh my� I am on the odd a part of Youtube once more.
alenblake38g 1 month ago
@alenblake38g u are stupid. this isn't it... you must be so retarded... weird part of YT concerns boobs and shit
alain001 1 month ago in playlist 200 Most Popular Classical Music
Is'nt this 1st movement is used in the Howard Hughes western... 'The Outlaw'?.
I think it is.... and it is a bit more stirring than this version (good as it is).
MrPPKWalther 1 month ago
maybe they could play a little disco. thats what was big when i first heard this performed. all the friends made fun. now disco gone.
ub85zwq 2 months ago
3:09, gets me every time! Love this piece!
cgcheyne 2 months ago
Comment removed
cgcheyne 2 months ago
Hello
chesterlott821 2 months ago
If you need Lady Gaga to convince you that this is something worth listening to you should be shot.
tubamarc8891 2 months ago 3
الله
ammartrumpet 2 months ago
what's with the "Lady gaga sent me here!" comments? she's doesn't use this for marry the night, she uses BEETHOVEN'S pathetique piano sonata
SergeyRachmaninoff 2 months ago 4
@demifanperfect. Wrong piece, it was Beethoven's Pathetique in her video. But both excellent pieces! :)
murmaloo 3 months ago
lol after 2:00 soo sleepy ...
Vesivian 3 months ago
beast cough at 2:15
Sfrey000 3 months ago
stop being snobs and enjoy the music.
floatinroundmytincan 3 months ago
2:19 I hate when that happens :')
deansinghgill 3 months ago
I didn't understand. Did you write "Lady Gaga" on the search bar and pathetic was the result??? =P... Great composition, I really love this symphony
AlejosAlejuHo 3 months ago 4
You children don't listen to a piece classical music unless you hear it first in a movie soundtrack or in a stupid pop/rock concert? "Lady Gaga" LOL How utterly stupid that will sound to you in few years.
1banders 3 months ago
I am so proud to say that TCHAIKOVSKY sent me here.
EternalClassicMusic 3 months ago 3
@EternalClassicMusic No he didn't, he's dead.
kiannasutube 3 months ago
@kiannasutube He'll be remembered for longer than Lady Gaga will. If you don't like Tchaikovsky, don't bother watching this video and reading the comments. I don't go on Lady Gaga videos and make comments about Tchaikovsky.
EternalClassicMusic 3 months ago
@EternalClassicMusic I love Tchaikovsky, I made that as a joke.Tchaikovsky is dead, so he couldn't have brought you here. Don't take things so seriously.
kiannasutube 3 months ago
@kiannasutube My humblest apologies, I did take it too seriously. I'm just passionate about music and I took it the wrong way. Sorry
EternalClassicMusic 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Nach Borodins Anfangsthema aus Polovtsian Dances ist das eines der schönsten Kompositionen der Musikgeschichte.
LittleBanjoboy 3 months ago
Comment removed
LittleBanjoboy 3 months ago
MARRY THE NIGHT THE PRELUDE PATHÉTIQUE. Lady Gaga is FUCKIN amazing!
6MusicForever 3 months ago
Gaga sent me here:) she is AWESOME. I mean what other artist would send you here??
6MusicForever 3 months ago
Davide Formisano does an awesome job in his flute solo, his tone is marvelous. Awesome player. Awesome Orchestra.
MrFluteperson 3 months ago
LADY GAGA SENT ME HERE I MEAN.... WE GOT MUSIC CULTURE ;D
BritneySpollo 3 months ago 2
12 personas son fans de Madonna xD
ManuSheiBe 3 months ago 2
Lady Gaga sent me here
mpburns21 3 months ago 6
THUMBS FOR MARRY THE NIGHT!
demifanperfect 3 months ago 13
THE PRELUDE PATHÉTIQUE. Music Video Marry The Night ._.
sak747 3 months ago 5
@sak747 She said Beethoven
ussrsalinas1 3 months ago
Tenía que ser Tchaikovsky... que hermosura
MarceBonnie 3 months ago
Que aterradora y profunda sinceridad, que amargas y tristes lagrimas corren en cada una de las notas de una de las mas grandes sinfonias escritas despues de la coral. El compositor sabia lo que esto queria decir y cuanto significaba para el... fue su composicion mas amada, la mas lograda, la mas pura e intensa, la mas personal... se referia al mundo y a las futuras generaciones cuando le preguntaron que significado tenia y el dijo : " dejalos que adivinen".
josepablo1514 4 months ago 3
12 people disliked ! OMG !
MrGunterguerrero 4 months ago
How can we be sure that the cough didn't come from the percussion section?
Not that I'm saying we should take them out and shoot them, but the patrons in the house presumably paid to be in the audience while the percussionists.... well... we know....didn't pay.
RochesterHillsTV 4 months ago
definitely should show more of the violas in the beginning. :)
njjluvr93 5 months ago in playlist Tchaik 6
Realmente genera el sentimiento patético de una escena de cine... / Makes me feel the real sensation of a classic "pathetic" movie scene...
WhoLeeAnnita 5 months ago
Woohoo Bassoons!
Lamar933 5 months ago
Definetly my favotite piece from Tchaikovsky
ArminiusvanLand 6 months ago
I like the natural sound of the audience, coughs and all!
1eloi3 6 months ago
@1eloi3 i don't
raticon 6 months ago
¡Se escribe éxtasis amigo!
anagomzaxxx 7 months ago
I'm crying right now !!
MegaJanuary2011 7 months ago
Pura estasi!
Chopinilove 7 months ago
1:16 bassist "let's fix the right note. oh yes, now I can stop looking my fingers" : |
Monegatto94 7 months ago 18
Comment removed
Monegatto94 7 months ago
Comment removed
Monegatto94 7 months ago
Temirarov is the living proof that the robots have feellings aswell
ovyboiax 7 months ago
@ovyboiax Stimmt auffallend! Mieser Sound, mittelprächtiges Orchester, schlechter Dirigent, es klappert an allen Ecken und Enden.
60RP 7 months ago
This is one of my favorite by Tchaikovsky
MsTheconductor 8 months ago
10 people didn't click the 'play' button...
VacnaPaul 9 months ago 5
Comment removed
VacnaPaul 9 months ago
@symphonyfirst I guess it all depends on what one finds in the programs of concerts that are given in our head-stuck arses elitist European concert halls. As far as I can see, any of the ones you named here don't appear very very frequently - better said, their appearances are few and far in between..What can the reason be, the conductors put those in so rarely??!!!
Gheorgyi 9 months ago
5:20
hwuman 9 months ago
Comment removed
kianskiputz92 9 months ago
What happens at 6:48? Temirkanov drops his arms as in dismay. Was there some goof-up?
Gheorgyi 10 months ago
Gheorgyi: for someone who has so much to say about symphonic music and have the effrontery to determine for others what's good or bad , it is incredible you have never heard of Barber. Know what? You are an ignorant child.
Stop posting your ridiculous opinions. You aren't anywhere near capable of understanding the music, let alone understanding the history. In other posts you brag about how you walk out of performances (I doubt you ever visited a hall). You are a drag.
smartingamerica 10 months ago
@smartingamerica Buster, 1, I have as much to say about symphonic music as anyone else on this "forum"; 2, I've never been didactic, nor had I "the effrontery" etc. etc. Quote an ad hoc a passage from me; 3. your "Barber", or "figaro", anyway you want to call him, is an insignificant american pygmee in a world of European musicalk giants; 4. I NEVER bragged to have "walked out", once again: I dare you to quote; 5. IF you really are 55, I'm 82, you're not qualified to call me a "child": BUFFOON
Gheorgyi 10 months ago 2
un lavoro molto tosto
MsNichelino 10 months ago
II – Conductors, too: the good ones, they had (and still have) to import them from Europe. Their Leonard Bernstein was grossly over-rated and imposed: he grew up to international standing too fast, pushed upwards with Madison Ave advertising techniques. Why don’t they adapt themselves to the idea that their real musical product is jazz: everybody will agree with that. Problem is, what nowadays is passed as “jazz” is anything BUT.
Gheorgyi 11 months ago
emotional
DavidSmithMusic 11 months ago
SO MUCH AGREE:)
zvezdaNYC 11 months ago
look at the bassists pinky at 1:16. fire that dude. im serious
Mizzles240 11 months ago 3
@Mizzles240 Rather drastic, aren't you??!!! WHICH bass? WHAT's he doing so wrong??!!! Moving the fingers on the cords is part of his job... :-)
Gheorgyi 11 months ago
Pretty drastic, ain't you? Which one, the young one on the foreground? What's he doing so wrong he should be "fired" for??!!! C'mon, he's visibly very young, let him mature... I'm sure if he did something bad, Jurij/Yuri noticed it and reprimanded him, Those conductors have eyes like a lynx, a hearing like... like WHAT??!!! ;-)
Gheorgyi 11 months ago
@Gheorgyi lol dude. young or old he is a professional musician. professional string players should be able to play a note without sliding all over the place. Thats what he is doing wrong.
Mizzles240 11 months ago
@Mizzles240 Well, you knew and I didn't: I don't play a string instrument (matter of fact, I don't play ANY), so just thanks for telling us, you must be a GREAT expert. I'm sure old Jurij/Yuri, as director, can chew his ass off if it is that bad. Problem is, he has to get back to Sankt Petersburg or wherever... But, FIRE him??!!! aaAA-R-R-R-ggGGhhHH, would you shoot a man for sayng f**k...??!!! :-)
Gheorgyi 11 months ago
@Gheorgyi im not saying they should literally fire him. its just atrocious. my conductor would yell at me if i did that and im in a youth orchestra
Mizzles240 11 months ago
@Mizzles240 Well kidd.-o, "fire" is exactly the word you used. I'm sure the conductor who has the great privilege of having YOU in the orchestra is doing his best to train you to perfection as a learner; but you might stop a moment and realize that young man is no longer a learner, but a professional in one of the greatest symphonical orchestras in the world, "La Scala Theater's in Milano, Italy.
Gheorgyi 11 months ago
I didn't know John Lithgow played the bassoon.
TheKittenButcher 11 months ago
Una de las sinfonias mas hermosas que existen, y del compositor, ni hablar ¡¡¡¡MARAVILLOSO!!!!! su obra en general es bellisima.
reydeloshunos3 11 months ago
Profound. Tragic. Heart shaking. The musical equivalent of a person going through analysis, or the dark night of the soul.
windstorm1000 1 year ago
Tchaikovsky is my favourite composer. For those who're interested, I have uploaded a moving docudrama about his life. Check my playlists.
turxxx 1 year ago
@turxxx thank you, sir.
mimenorcomsetima 1 year ago
@turxxx I couldn't be interested less.
Gheorgyi 11 months ago
I write letters to Pyotr in my diary. He has been my hero and friend since my father introduced us (his music) when I was 3 yrs. old. He seems to be the only soul that understands mine.
susanfaustina 1 year ago
Concert coughers should be shot on the spot
luridplanet 1 year ago 125
@luridplanet haha holy shit yes!!!
DanielDFizzle 11 months ago
@luridplanet Or, given a lozenge.
Gheorgyi 11 months ago
@luridplanet Isn't it funny, but I find the coughs and the pops to be so crucial in enjoying individual arangements of music... Even the clicking and fingering of the keys is beautiful, I love it all.
RustDemon79 10 months ago
@luridplanet try having an old guy breathing from a noisy respirator while seeing the vienna philharmonic
falorethegreat 9 months ago
@luridplanet yeah but that would probably be even louder... maybe silently strangled.. : D
poetryiscool 8 months ago
@poetryiscool suppressed weaponry ;)
TheEternalLeader 8 months ago
@luridplanet not on the spot...That would ruin the concert...They should be dragged outside (quietly) and shot there (loudly)
verbamusica 4 months ago 3
Saw Temirkanov yesterday in Rome, he conducted Requiem of Verdi... it is easy to be "great" with orchestra, that can play also without conductor ... but if he would work with orchestra that has a level not so high, and if thay play REALLY according to his hands, i have a lot of doubts about result!!!
anstasia189 1 year ago
He reminds me of Abbado when the latter conducted the BPO. A director of a play draws his vision on a stage. A conductor says, 'Come with me on this exciting journey! Trust me!' What a wonderful example of conducting in this video.
elzbieta52 1 year ago
@elzbieta52 Kind of repetitive, ain't you??!!!
Gheorgyi 11 months ago
He reminds me of Abbado when the latter conducted the BPO. A director of a play draws his vision on a stage. A conductor says, 'Come with me on this exciting journey! Trust me!' What a wonderful example in this video.
elzbieta52 1 year ago
He reminds me of Abbado when the latter conducted the BPO.
elzbieta52 1 year ago
Thanks TCHAI!!!!!!!!!!!!!
pfc2010pfc 1 year ago
Thanks to Galdo80 for posting this work, although I wish it had been in stereo (it is not), and he would not have cut off the last notes of the descending solo clarinet at the end of this part.
MadMusicologist1 1 year ago
Please. Before interpreting a musical piece by linking it to the composer's biography, you first have to do an analysis, showing the interconnections of themes, motives, instrumentation, timbre and son on. If you leave this step out you will end in total pseudoromantic superficial "kitsch". This applies to any composition.
MadMusicologist1 1 year ago
terrible flute at 06.38
this is a bad performance
pointreyes6 1 year ago
@pointreyes6 what's wrong about the flute?
MadMusicologist1 1 year ago
@MadMusicologist1 Let him have his say, he doesn't know himself. All these american kids are so conceited - they play in some high school or "youth" orchestra, get a smattering of technical notions and begin to spout opinions here and there - each single one of them a Beethoven-Brahms-Mahler-Verdi-Chaikowskij rolled in one. Conceited snotnosed brats. And america, from a viewpoint of symphonic music is an absolute NOTHING. They should stick to Madonna's and Michael Jackson's with their antics.
Gheorgyi 11 months ago
@Gheorgyi: Well, they had Scott Joplin, Goerge Gershwin, Charles Ives, John Cage, but how many did have Europe in the same span of time - !
MadMusicologist1 11 months ago
I - In comparison, those were musical pygmees. No comparison, number- and/or quality-wise. Gershwin: pretty, tenuous tunes, but no more that tunes. One can't compare his "Rhapsody in Blue" with serious symphonic work. The other one, "American in Paris", was made known by Toscanini when after WW-2 he came back to Italy to open up the new Scala Theatre in Milano - after they had destroyed it with bombings (and rammed down our throats to exhaustion thereafter). They identify it with Kelly.
Gheorgyi 11 months ago
@Gheorgyi What about Barber? Surely you cannot write off every single american composer ever. There are a few good ones. I'll admit kids in my country are conceited, but thats because they're KIDS. Have a heart.
Dave308439 10 months ago
@Dave308439 “Barber”, hm? Thanks for signalling this name, I didn’t know about him. Googled him up, found him in Wikipedia. "Barber, Samuel" . Rather obscure name. I can’t say I find it mentioned very often - matter of fact, NEVER - in the programs of our concerts over here, and I go to many.. Probably due to our auto-sufficiency in Europe, both quantity- and quality wise. Being just “kids” doesn’t justify raising them as the brats they are. Start straightening them out. Regards, Mister
Gheorgyi 10 months ago
@Gheorgyi
You have no place to be calling anyone "conceited snotnosed brats." Take your pathetic arrogance and nationalism elsewhere.
23skidoonk 8 months ago
@23skidoonk 1. If I "don't have" a place, I'll TAKE one as anyone else in this "forum"; 2. Certain people deserve to be dealt with arrogantly (and YOU seem to be to be included in their number); 3. I did NOT make any "nationalistic" remarks; 4. you keep yourself carefully non-descript in your YT profile, so I can't be sure whom I'm dealing with, I can only venture: a., you are ANOTHER conceited snotnosed brat; b.you are an anglo, or anyway you are in the USA; Do I get a cigar?
Gheorgyi 8 months ago
@Gheorgyi
You are a buffoon who lacks both basic argumentation skills, logic, and the ability to formulate a coherent post. Further conversation will accomplish nothing: you're too far entrenched in your own misplaced, conceited, fantasies. This in itself is more of a reply than such a pathetic elitist such as yourself deserves--you've composed no music, you've played no music, so I hope at least you find happiness in your unentitled opinions about music. You are a leech, and nothing but.
23skidoonk 8 months ago
@23skidoonk Clown, I don't lack anything else than - maybe - lots of money, and who needs it.. Your prose is so stuffy, stilted, stifled that one can literally see you scouring a dictionary in your anxious quest for some highfalutin words to write it. You RAVE, clown. I expressed no fantasies, I just bore a few holes into you, hyper-blown hot air balloon. No, I haven't composed nor played music, but I know more of/about it under my pinky's nail than you ever will in your bulbous self. PISS OFF.
Gheorgyi 8 months ago
@Gheorgyi
Well played sir. Wrong, but well played.
I'll bother you no more, clearly your ego is hurting.
23skidoonk 8 months ago
Comment removed
23skidoonk 8 months ago
terrible flute at 06.38
pointreyes6 1 year ago
@pointreyes6 i think someone has it in for the nice flute player..
baiba6 1 year ago
Bravissimo Yuri Termikanov!!!!
MrBallarin23 1 year ago
From my point of view, the best language which conveys emotions is music.
coolest813 1 year ago 3
It was amazing, minus the coughing... but you'll always get that I guess
UserID20 1 year ago
this is a terrific performance! - the sounds, the playing, the pace, the musicians, il maestro - and the piece itself! communicating so many facets and layers of emotions and sheer music!... A thought - maybe provocative to some: it must have been composed by a very balanced person... To express so much and so subtle, I think Tchaikovsky must have been in a state of mind where emotions and reasons were in sound conditions to make the work evolve so grand and graceful.
vnpei 1 year ago
PUDDI PuDDIIIIIı!!!!!!
michelvieillot 1 year ago
I cannot stand to listen to pieces of this length, but thanks to my music lit class I must. but for something I despise as much as lengthy orchestral music, it's very good.
SilvurR5 1 year ago
The feeling of this song is empty. For a fact five after Tchaikovsky performed this peice he died. Suicide was the suspicion. And this was considered this his suicide note. Most because of the off parts in the song, like the third movement being upbeat and happy, but not being the finale.
TheCriticAceEvans 1 year ago
@TheCriticAceEvans Uh, no. Get your facts straight. Tchaikovsky DID suffered bouts of depression, but he died of cholera. In 1893 Tchaikovsky went to St. Petersburg, Russia, to conduct Pathetique. A cholera epidemic was raging in the capital, and he drank unboiled water. As a result, he contracted cholera and died. Hardly suicide. Tchaikovsky composed very emotional pieces, and no doubt they reflect his own feelings.
ProgramTerminated 1 year ago
@TheCriticAceEvans Yeah... If anything, there were some SERIOUSLY intense feelings of despair and depression Tchaikovsky must have felt, for various reasons-emotional, spiritual, physical/mental/psychological, loneliness, etc. He must have felt such intense feelings of hopelessness as to just take the "plunge"...
BenjaminGessel 1 year ago
Sadness, happiness, loneliness, all the feelings are acting in this Symphony....as if it was part of our lives.
Architecture4PFC 1 year ago
Lovely. I would like to know what the 2nd bassoonist is smiling at around 7:00...
bubblybassoonist 1 year ago
ain't this beautiful? can't belive i'm going to see/hear this on live this next saturday!!!
funeralincarp23 1 year ago
When I have the time, I turn this up loud on my speakers, I stand in the middle of my room, I pretend to be conducting the orchestra. It's like I'm drowning in pure emotion.
Treijim 1 year ago 33
@Treijim I ll try that!!
simkimon 1 year ago
GRAN SINFONIA Y GRAN COMPOSITOR
jorgealbertobaron2 1 year ago
@jorgealbertobaron2 si, que bonita la emocion que esta presente.
mexifrida 1 year ago
I listened to a recording of this every day for months as a teenager... wish I still knew who recorded "my" version. Fifteen years later, I can still hear every note.
MrsCeeBeeBee 1 year ago 2
now thats my type of bassonist! too little time to waste time wrapping up his reeds lol
caper7oo 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
yokee1991 I agree with you more than you could ever know
TheRiverMusic 1 year ago
All the human emotions are encapsulated and enshrined in this great work... The turbulence of human emotions and their resolutions, all were masterfully described and expressed through musical notes... It is an amazement that never ends... ♥ ♥ ♥
roelallen 1 year ago 3
I love this piece! it gives a chance for violists to play out :D
This piece is just wonderful! it's so beautiful.
Everything about this video is great, except for the fact that the cellist (the woman in the back at 2:04 looks so pissed of at the viola solo, which angers me, lol)
thanks for the upload! <33
IVIusic 1 year ago
To be fair, it seems unlikely that he died of cholera (which was the official coroners conclusion). The facts (which are too numerous to state here...I encourage the interested to do some research) suggest that he used some form of direct poisoning (usually guessed to be arsenic, which apparently leaves a similar corpse to a cholera victim). Several theories abound as to exactly WHY he chose to die when he did (the 'court of honor' being the most popular right now...again, look it up.)
aswallom 1 year ago
The deciding factor in almost all theories point to the potentiality of his homosexuality being made public. Homosexuality was not a crime in Russia, and in fact there were many famous Russians of that time that were not only gay, but publicly suspected of being so, but when suspicion becomes confirmed fact or scandal in any society, it changes the playing field. Tchaikovsky was extraordinarily sensitive and emotional, and the inevitable shame and humiliation was, it seems, too high a price.
aswallom 1 year ago
@aswallom Thanks for the comment. I couldn't agree with you more!
vk92007 1 year ago
some retards actualy gave it dislike
SalmonelaKid 1 year ago
Tchaikovsky crys from the depths of his despair in this symphony and said before died :" it is the most personal thing i have ever done"" . A tragic genius .......
TallisTriptych 1 year ago
@kitchenqueen70 No, but many music scholars agree that it does seem eerie considering the circumstances that he died only a few days after the premiere of this symphony. Basically, they (as well as I) believe that Tchaikovsky may have very well written his very own requiem without even realizing it. Maybe he did. Who knows? I agree with @TallisTriptych. This is Tchaikovsky crying from the depths of his despair. I also agree that it's the most personal thing he's ever done.
celinedionfan 1 year ago 3
this is music, my friends
iburnedmyfingers 1 year ago
Comment removed
Rumozamonien 1 year ago
Did u know Tchaikovsky was homosexual with his nephew?
JayOkan 1 year ago
@JayOkan : i don't care even if he was doing himself .Althought , i din't have to know about this.I listen to his music since i was a little boy and he is like a godfather to me and i believe for many people .u don't have always to learn about the famous people's "kinky" habbits .
fylactos 1 year ago
@JayOkan : (cont) and if you do, don't tell others!nobody's perfect,especially you. i just wan't to be able to listen pathetique symfony and close my eyes and see colours and emotions.don't destroy this . you remind me , gossip tv ... go get a life - peace
fylactos 1 year ago
@JayOkan grow up.
BernardProfitendieu 1 year ago
@JayOkan many composers were and are homosexual, so what? jelous?
amatorynumber 1 year ago
@JayOkan many composers were (and are) homosexual. So what?
amatorynumber 1 year ago
I love you Tchaiko!
ANYULA 1 year ago 2
is this a requiem?
kitchenqueen70 1 year ago
@kitchenqueen70 yes it is. few days after he had the premiere for this song , he died from cholera.
iburnedmyfingers 1 year ago
What an unlikely and intriguing conductor-orchestra pairing. It produced wonderful results!
MikeDrewYT 1 year ago
Rabbrividisco ogni volta...
rosalbanappo 1 year ago
Absolutely magnificent !!
ecasrevmx 1 year ago 3
i played this in the Nevada All State Orchestra. SUCH a fun piece! and this is AMAZING!!!
MusicMan120071 1 year ago 3
Heard last night in Milan, by Temirkanow, of course... =) simply wonderful!!
KNOceanSoul 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Eight centuries of musical investigation and development get rewarded and justified and were worth if they had to lead us to this sole work.
Poetry.
Faustnh 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
Faustnh 2 years ago
Kind of like Temirkanov's emotional restraint, even though I wouldn't have done it myself. It's in a class by itself.
dga471 2 years ago
@thesilvershining listen he didnot die of sicknees he commited suiced by drinking poison because back then being gay(which he was and in poverty) was a sin he showed his whole life through that last symphony i 100% agree with u
weaponhand57 2 years ago
This piece sounds like a summer grey cloud...a touch of sadness...full of feelings.
minigarvi 2 years ago 2
My father told me once, about the Adagio Lamentoso... "A man who wrote such a masterpiece made it only inspired by God"....Now, i believe so.
I agree entirely with thesilvershining.
MrGunterguerrero 2 years ago 4
Black bassoon.. absolutely magnificent..