I swear to God this sounds like Thee Ministry of Lost Souls by Dream Theater. You know, that section right before the solo. DON'T TURN YOUR BACK ON PARADISE!!!
@meiaxx music is both emotion AND theory body and soul they were just asking and talking about direction to find the sound they find pleasing and expressive. do not bother and play what YOU feel they are just looking to find a good way to play what THEY feel.
Sunderlanding you need to go and read a music theory book. A natural minor doesn't have a G#, any theory book will confirm this for you. And A natural minor is the same as the key of A minor you moron. How would A be the relative minor of C if it had a different note?? Idiot. Oh and by the way, USING CAPITALS DOESN'T IMPROVE YOUR ARGUMENT IT JUST SHOWS YOU ARE A RETARD WHO CAN'T EXPLAIN HIMSELF WITHOUT BEING RUDE.
@HereWeGoSteelers You can say that all you want, but it doesn't make it correct. Look don't take my word for it just go to any school that does conservatory exam preperation and ask the theory (rudiments) teacher what is the difference between C major and A minor and you'll see that I'm correct. If all you do is learn ACDC songs from some burnt out dude in a guitar shop you won't learn this stuff, but technically A minor has a G#.
@Sunderlanding A harmonic minor has a G#, A natural minor doesn't. A harmonic minor = A B C D E F G# A (ie a major 7th) A natural minor = A B C D E F G A.
@GuitarLessonsGlasgow Please read closely and carefully this time. A harmonic minor is a SCALE. I'm NOT talking about SCALES. With me so far? A natural minor is a SCALE. Once again I'm NOT talking about SCALES. Understand? I'm talking about KEYS. In the KEY of A minor you have a G#. It's a common misconception that C major and A minor are the same KEY. They DO share a KEY SIGNATURE, but they are NOT the same. The KEY of A minor has a G# and the KEY of C major does not. Got it?
@Annulable Come on people go read a theory book. If you don't have a G# you're just in C major or A aeolian as the case would be, but if you have a G# you are in A minor. In order for it to be a minor key you must have a dominant V chord which means you have to raise the seventh. Thus A minor has a G# and C major does not.
@Sunderlanding there is a G# in this song you are right about that, but thats just because of a keychange, from Aminor to Amajor, back to minor, thats how the G# is used in this example, but in the regular key (scale, mode) of Aminor there is not a G#, just like the Cmajor, because Cmajor is the same as Aminor, so i wonder from what conservatory teacher you get your lessons from, but i suggest you get a new teacher
@alstartheman Like I told all the other people. Go read the "elementary rudiments of music" which is standard conservatory text, and go to the chapter on key signatures. It'll state that since C major and A minor have one note difference they share a key signature. That note....G#. The reason for this is simple. In classical theory the V chord must always be major (dominant), and in order to do that in a minor key you need a major seventh. In A minor this is G#.
@Sunderlanding No, it's F. G,B,D,F is the G dominant 7th chord, and G is the V chord of C major. A is the vi chord. There are no major seventh's in a dominant chord. What are you talking about???
Besides the fifth which I'll omit, a dominant seventh chord has a major third and a minor seventh, a major seventh has both a major third and a major seventh interval and a minor seventh has a minor third and a major seventh interval. C, D, E, F, -G- <- G7(G,B,D,F) is the V chord.
@Sunderlanding And there's no such thing as a KEY of a minor, only key of A. Full stop. C major and A minor(i.e. aeolian) share the same notes but not the same KEY. They are enharmonically equivalent when no root note is present which changes the tonality. The NOTES are the same. If I first punch you in the face and then the stomach, it would be the SAME as punching you in the stomach first and in the head second. Capisce?
@FranLesPaul Um. How do I say this. You're a musical idiot. A minor is it's own KEY. I'm telling you go read the conservatory grade two rudiments text and you'll find this to be true. Minor keys are different than major keys. Aeolian is not the same as minor. In A aeolian your I and V chords would be A minor and E minor. In the key of A minor they would be A minor and E. Go look at any score of a piece in any minor key and you'll see what I'm talking about.
You learn theory to play the guitar, not play the guitar to learn theory. I know only 3 scale formation, yet I have a happy life and I enjoy my improvisations. There shouldn't be an argument on every singe youtube backing track about philomodargianonianic modes and shit
Refer to your cycle of 4th's or 5th's you idiot. A minor is relative to C major. Last time i checked C major doesn't have a G#. An A minor scale with a G# is harmonic minor. Maybe you should read grade 2 rudiments, you obviously missed something. MORON
@flosendamager Back in the day, you would play some crazy stuff and you'd have girls around you like whoa. These days all the girls go home with their disrespectful "boyfriend" and you'll be surrounded by guys reliving the old days :/
@Shadowmov3r Agreed, but that doesn't mean there's still a few chicks out there that find true musician ship impressive, I know i've met a few at least
A minor and C major are not the same key. Obviously. "A" and "C" are not the same letter.
They do contain all the same notes however, but all music is relative to what sounds the most like the root note. I must admit most of this jam track sounded major, but thats completely okay, I A minored it up anyways.
Funny enough, with all this C major A minor talk, it's more of A aeolian than A minor. Technically A minor should have a dominant V chord. The resolution here is from a G to an A minor, bVII, which is way more aeolian than minor.
@TintedRedFilms You missed what I was saying. A minor as a key should technically have a dominant V chord. That means it must have a G# in it somewhere. A aeolian does not have a G# it has a G. Therefore A aeolian isn't a minor it's a aeolian. Understand yet?
@TintedRedFilms No that's a common misconception. C major is completely natural, but A minor is different. They share a key signature because they're close, and thus are relative major and minor, but technically the key of A minor has a G#. You can reference a grade two theory book, and it'll confirm what I'm saying.
@SimonKalla God Damnit there is no G# in A minor! The raised seventh makes is HARMONIC MINOR. Seriously... I swear on my life there is no G# in A minor. WHWWHWW. That is the fucking formula. Now stop driving me nuts with this retarded exchange and study some music theory children.
@Sunderlanding stop spreading ignorance fool! why don't you reference this theory book you condescendingly point us to? It's probably because you're WRONG! No natural minor scale on this earth has a RAISED seventh! That's reserved for the harmonic minor scale! Now go back to school, give back your college degree in music if you have one, and beg your teachers to show you the fundamentals once again!
@getupanddosomething Fuck you're dumb. Read carefully this time. The KEY of A minor has a G#. I didn't say anything about a natural minor scale I was talking about the KEY of A minor.
@Sunderlanding Please reference where the hell you learned that. The key of A minor doesn't have a dominant V because you're looking at the tonality of the harmonized MAJOR scale. To find out what the V is for the harmonized minor or aeolian scale is you simply start at the vi like so: i, iim7b5, III, iv, v, VI, VII dominant. In other words the harmonized minor scale is minor, diminished, major, minor, minor, major, dominant. With all due respect
@Sunderlanding I would also like to add that in this case the scale and the key are one and the same. In other cases, scales (also known as modes in this usage) actually serve to refine the key to reduce the number of "wrong" notes. For instance, a song can be in A minor, but that minor could be a Dorian or a phrygian minor instead of the natural minor. And for the record, relative major and minor are based off of the key signature, which would mean that the number of accidentals in A minor is 0
@getupanddosomething You're wrong. A dorian is not the same as the key of A minor. It is a minor scale, but it is not the key of A minor. You can ask any theory teacher this and they'll confirm it, or refer to the Grade 2 rudiments book.
@Sunderlanding Jesus Christ, I realize that. There is such a thing as a song being in the mode of dorian minor though, just listen to John Scofield or Kind of Blue. I guess what you're talking about is every possible variation of the minor scale being included into this minor key, which isn't practical for conversation in my opinion. I think I was confused with what you were saying because everything you've said to back up your argument is poorly explained and in some cases incorrect.
@getupanddosomething I know that asshole. I was talking about the key of A minor. That's all. You were the one who replied when clearly you didn't know what I was talking about. Next time read all the posts before you comment. A minor as a key has one sharp and it's G#. That's all I was ever saying.
@WhoIsRasmus The ignorance on YouTube is amazing. Once again, MORON, I was talking about the key of A minor not any scale. The KEY of A minor has a G#. Go read the grade 2 rudiments book and you'll see that I'm right.
@Obliaxe What the fuck is wrong with you? I just said I'm not talking scales I'm talking keys. There is no key of A harmonic minor. The key of A minor has a G#.
@Obliaxe Can't you read? That's what I've been saying. In the key of A minor there is a G#. The notes in the key of A minor are A B C D E F G#. If you don't belive me you can reference any grade two rudiments text, or check with the royal conservatory.
@Sunderlanding I'm sorry dude... but that is not true... and yeah, I'm pretty sure the royal conservatory agrees with me on this one, because the reason the harmonic and melodic minor were invented was to place a note in a minor key, a half step away from the route, thus creating more tension towards that note. So in a regular minor key there are no notes a half step away from the route... if you place a G# there, then is harmonic minor, if you place an F# and a G# then it's melodic minor...
@Obliaxe Go pick up a copy of "Elementary Rudiments of Music" (standard conservatory) then go to the chapter on Key Signatures. It'll state that since A minor and C major only have one note difference they share a key signature. The note that is different...G#! This has nothing to do with scales, but with keys. In the key of A minor you have a G#. That's why the V chord is a dominant and not a minor! Seriously you clowns spend so much time with scales that you don't even know how keys work.
@Sunderlanding Ok I'm done feeding you... you're such an obvious troll it's almost embarassing, now go back to playing your G# over A minor... I'm sure it sounds wonderful. -_-
@guitarlonextreme Your ignorance is amazing. Pay attention this time. I'm talking about KEYS not SCALES. The KEY of A minor has a G#. This has nothing to do with the Harmonic, Melodic, or Natural minor. Those are SCALES.
@guitarlonextreme Seriously dude. I do conservatory preperation at a music school. I know my grade two theory. It states in the theory book "because C major and A minor have one note difference (G#) they share a key signature". End of story.
@Sunderlanding REALLY! so that's why your having youtube arguments in your spare time?! I DONT UNDERSTAND WHERE THIS G# comes from if you wouldn't play it over an A MINOR CHORD?!?!
@Strikerx20 Thanks asshole. I'm not talking about japanese minor and hungarian minor. I'm talking western music system. That is after all where keys come from. So for the purposes of my discussion there are three minor scales. Minor in name, not function, so dorian and phrygian don't count.
Nice
fxcksalt1 15 hours ago
Love the progression of this tune, AWESOME song!!!
buddyhoot 3 days ago
Came up with a sweet vocal melody for this one wanna buy a hit for yourself? :D
Teemujus 4 days ago
i did my fking best impro to taht !
thx for upload pls do more indie stuff!
RisingEternity 1 week ago
amazing!
muninongthombam 1 week ago
radiohead creep?
aintnopity 2 weeks ago
Can you tell me where to find this for licensing? I'd like to use it in a commercial project...
noonco 2 weeks ago
Amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Thank you...
noonco 4 weeks ago
I swear to God this sounds like Thee Ministry of Lost Souls by Dream Theater. You know, that section right before the solo. DON'T TURN YOUR BACK ON PARADISE!!!
YngwieAteMe 1 month ago
Thanks man, had a great jam with this track. Didn´t know you could create those awesome solo stuff with some scales haha ^^
PunkRockCovers 1 month ago
@PunkRockCovers Scales are the basis of all solos man... Most fundamental tool for soloing, scales scales and more scales.
plastic191919 1 month ago 3
this make me play better
carlosactz 1 month ago
This is fucking awesome!
Euphoriacity 1 month ago
try the mixolydian over this, its heaven (sorry for any spelling mistakes).
koalaman9 2 months ago
Wow I think I almost had an orgasm jamming to this!
metanomhk 2 months ago 2
sounds like Creep by Raddiohead
josevivo 2 months ago
@josevivo more like searhoses blinded by the sun
electrotar 1 month ago
i love this
blackgoetia 2 months ago
Great job!
Pietras311 3 months ago
what is the progression?
jusenfeida 3 months ago
@jusenfeida A minor, C, F, G and then C, E, F, F minor I believe
OptoOcto 2 months ago 4
I can hear kenny G playing the smoothest sax over this
themacdaddy1245 3 months ago
Love the track. Im not much of a skilled guitarist, and barley know my scales, but I just felt my way through this track with easy.
Baku6000 3 months ago
my jam to this :-) /watch?v=FSidRYOu5Mw
12Crowl 4 months ago
This is a really smooth track. I didn't think I'd enjoy it as much as a jamming piece as I do
DigitaIGhost 4 months ago 2
This really is the best backing track I have ever jammed to. Ever.
goodygoody23 4 months ago
BIG LICKS!!!!!!
Kaiserwho3 4 months ago
i wantthis backing track, anywhere to download it?
BigFriendlyNinja 4 months ago
i think i just cried while improvising over this.. or my eye jizzed.
Amaury400 5 months ago
@Amaury400 Try to visit doctor
flamaker2009 4 months ago
This backing track is awesome! I'm farting out some tasty licks over here.
sammydems 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Plugfather . com
* Collection of song tutorial videos for beginners and intermediate players.
* Online Guitar Tuner
* Learn how to: Play chords, read tabs, tune a guitar
* Learn guitar theory
And no, this is not a scam and it's all totally FREE!
WhatTheFork 5 months ago
dudeee...... fuck you
whitebloodcell305 5 months ago
parece creep de radiohead
metalmania050 6 months ago
Best backing track ever.
ChillpointNews 6 months ago 21
You don't know what Indie means :/ still cool track.
allsport1313 6 months ago
sounds like radiohead - cool
Mr90Dave 6 months ago
GREAT,GREAT backing track!Check out my improvisation on it /watch?v=3OpeIduOl40
rsavov211 6 months ago
very smooth transitions
TangerineGroovin 6 months ago
why does it has to end? :(
Aperfull 7 months ago in playlist backtracks
hhhhaaaah
andykins118118 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
check my vid: RWgQ5eVUE9w
chrohm 7 months ago
klasse! realy perfect for jamming and practise ... test ... licks :)
MrLesPaula 7 months ago
creep radiohead
ESPMETALLICAFAN17 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Check out the version "guitar improvisation by a 10 year old" in the video responses box, or in my channel.
Thanks
:)
FABIANM1964 7 months ago 51
Comment removed
rsavov211 7 months ago
this is another song...i can't figure out which one-might be creep-radiohead but dunno. thumbs up if u think it sounds like another song...
nashie899 7 months ago
What chords are in this progression?
alejo2564 7 months ago
This is 90's indie music, huh?...hmmmmmmm
fotwunny 7 months ago
playing my 6 string bass over this, so awesome to have something to jam to :)
JoeyRocksTheBass 7 months ago
I have all the Jamtracks you want :-)
GuitarJamTrack 7 months ago
Sounds like happy mondays!
DyloK96 7 months ago 7
This one was a nicccce jam
fatnate28 7 months ago
aaah la cancion ta cool...sigue siendo 4 acordes
AntiEmoMetalhead92 8 months ago
@AntiEmoMetalhead92 sera que es solo una base y la idea es improvisar sobre esto?
wallytalivan 7 months ago
still learning how to improvise.
I first started trying to do it all over the scale... but learned a tip...
Start with only a couple strings first so u can learn the sound and the scale more. so u know what you wanna hit when it comes to improvising!!!!
Jmccorkle1333 8 months ago
A Minor is the only Key i can solo to
FinestFilipinoX 8 months ago 2
@FinestFilipinoX key of e im finding pretty easy, blues style, this is much harder...
curlymolly70 8 months ago
@FinestFilipinoX key of e im finding pretty easy, blues style, this is much harder...
curlymolly70 8 months ago
@FinestFilipinoX Yeah me too!!! LOL but it's because it's the only one I know! XD
mrFatalDemize 8 months ago
sex scene
mikee2150 8 months ago
CreamerMusic, Did you create this back track?
SpikeBizarre 8 months ago
didnt expect to find a good backing track on youtube. LOOK WHAT I JUsT FOUND
spike4379 9 months ago
Jesus Christ with these snobs whining about the correct keys. Music is about emotion and soul, not theory.
meiaxx 9 months ago 2
@meiaxx music is both emotion AND theory body and soul they were just asking and talking about direction to find the sound they find pleasing and expressive. do not bother and play what YOU feel they are just looking to find a good way to play what THEY feel.
arcainjust 8 months ago
this is awesome! when i get a camera this will be the first I make a response for.
65galaxie500man 9 months ago
what are the chords here?
ghosterdude 9 months ago
@ghosterdude The chords are Am/Cmaj/Fmaj/Gmaj
spagbog1q2w 7 months ago
@spagbog1q2w thanks!
ghosterdude 7 months ago
who cares what key is what? conservatories? HA. more 20+ yr old virgins headed off to argue over what makes a dominant 7th...
WHO CARES! SHUT UP AND SOLO OVER IT!
laxdude67 9 months ago
It's called a relative minor... duh
sepr8te1 9 months ago
Sunderlanding you need to go and read a music theory book. A natural minor doesn't have a G#, any theory book will confirm this for you. And A natural minor is the same as the key of A minor you moron. How would A be the relative minor of C if it had a different note?? Idiot. Oh and by the way, USING CAPITALS DOESN'T IMPROVE YOUR ARGUMENT IT JUST SHOWS YOU ARE A RETARD WHO CAN'T EXPLAIN HIMSELF WITHOUT BEING RUDE.
GuitarLessonsGlasgow 9 months ago
@HereWeGoSteelers You can say that all you want, but it doesn't make it correct. Look don't take my word for it just go to any school that does conservatory exam preperation and ask the theory (rudiments) teacher what is the difference between C major and A minor and you'll see that I'm correct. If all you do is learn ACDC songs from some burnt out dude in a guitar shop you won't learn this stuff, but technically A minor has a G#.
Sunderlanding 9 months ago
@Sunderlanding A harmonic minor has a G#, A natural minor doesn't. A harmonic minor = A B C D E F G# A (ie a major 7th) A natural minor = A B C D E F G A.
GuitarLessonsGlasgow 9 months ago
@GuitarLessonsGlasgow Please read closely and carefully this time. A harmonic minor is a SCALE. I'm NOT talking about SCALES. With me so far? A natural minor is a SCALE. Once again I'm NOT talking about SCALES. Understand? I'm talking about KEYS. In the KEY of A minor you have a G#. It's a common misconception that C major and A minor are the same KEY. They DO share a KEY SIGNATURE, but they are NOT the same. The KEY of A minor has a G# and the KEY of C major does not. Got it?
Sunderlanding 9 months ago
@Sunderlanding There is no G# in the key of A minor, however there is in A major.
Annulable 9 months ago
@Annulable Come on people go read a theory book. If you don't have a G# you're just in C major or A aeolian as the case would be, but if you have a G# you are in A minor. In order for it to be a minor key you must have a dominant V chord which means you have to raise the seventh. Thus A minor has a G# and C major does not.
Sunderlanding 9 months ago
@Sunderlanding there is a G# in this song you are right about that, but thats just because of a keychange, from Aminor to Amajor, back to minor, thats how the G# is used in this example, but in the regular key (scale, mode) of Aminor there is not a G#, just like the Cmajor, because Cmajor is the same as Aminor, so i wonder from what conservatory teacher you get your lessons from, but i suggest you get a new teacher
alstartheman 9 months ago
@alstartheman Like I told all the other people. Go read the "elementary rudiments of music" which is standard conservatory text, and go to the chapter on key signatures. It'll state that since C major and A minor have one note difference they share a key signature. That note....G#. The reason for this is simple. In classical theory the V chord must always be major (dominant), and in order to do that in a minor key you need a major seventh. In A minor this is G#.
Sunderlanding 9 months ago
@Sunderlanding No, it's F. G,B,D,F is the G dominant 7th chord, and G is the V chord of C major. A is the vi chord. There are no major seventh's in a dominant chord. What are you talking about???
Besides the fifth which I'll omit, a dominant seventh chord has a major third and a minor seventh, a major seventh has both a major third and a major seventh interval and a minor seventh has a minor third and a major seventh interval. C, D, E, F, -G- <- G7(G,B,D,F) is the V chord.
FranLesPaul 9 months ago
@Sunderlanding And there's no such thing as a KEY of a minor, only key of A. Full stop. C major and A minor(i.e. aeolian) share the same notes but not the same KEY. They are enharmonically equivalent when no root note is present which changes the tonality. The NOTES are the same. If I first punch you in the face and then the stomach, it would be the SAME as punching you in the stomach first and in the head second. Capisce?
FranLesPaul 9 months ago
@FranLesPaul Um. How do I say this. You're a musical idiot. A minor is it's own KEY. I'm telling you go read the conservatory grade two rudiments text and you'll find this to be true. Minor keys are different than major keys. Aeolian is not the same as minor. In A aeolian your I and V chords would be A minor and E minor. In the key of A minor they would be A minor and E. Go look at any score of a piece in any minor key and you'll see what I'm talking about.
Sunderlanding 9 months ago
Sounds like Pulp :)
Play G Dorian (G maj scale) over that with a phaser and it sounds great.
lukeward17 9 months ago
seems like nobody played a nice solo over it yet
gamingz 9 months ago
try using the third shape pentatonic at D if you get bored of a minor, it gives a more interesting sound
SeizeTheA7X 9 months ago
This was such a cool track! It really has that smooth peaceful sound and my freakin awesome effects box had a PERFECT preset for this!
SeanRamey 9 months ago
It almost sounds like the song what about now
youknowitsBrad 10 months ago
Great track this. Love the changes in mood and rhythm.
Jim47ww 10 months ago
You learn theory to play the guitar, not play the guitar to learn theory. I know only 3 scale formation, yet I have a happy life and I enjoy my improvisations. There shouldn't be an argument on every singe youtube backing track about philomodargianonianic modes and shit
TheresNoFreeUsername 10 months ago
All of you, shut up and play your fucking guitars!
Steelelives 10 months ago
@Steelelives Best advice on youtube, right here.
coine3 10 months ago
Comment removed
fardinator3000 11 months ago
Refer to your cycle of 4th's or 5th's you idiot. A minor is relative to C major. Last time i checked C major doesn't have a G#. An A minor scale with a G# is harmonic minor. Maybe you should read grade 2 rudiments, you obviously missed something. MORON
fardinator3000 11 months ago
sweet great bakup
n8healer 11 months ago
I like playing solos over backing tracks.
Joediamond16 11 months ago 151
@Joediamond16 ?????
skeeptar 7 months ago
this is a fun one to jam on:)
thanks guy who posted it:)
haytionette 11 months ago
Sounds better with C major played over it.
therealtony 11 months ago
@agua639 and 3 more were dyslexic
TheRustee1234 11 months ago
play a smooth solo on that and you get all the girls
flosendamager 1 year ago 63
@flosendamager Well, all the ones that count anyways =)
MatthiasMeys 1 year ago
@flosendamager first you gotta get some girls in your room though.
jamirosmajicrocks 9 months ago
@flosendamager true story.
Vic10689 8 months ago
@flosendamager Back in the day, you would play some crazy stuff and you'd have girls around you like whoa. These days all the girls go home with their disrespectful "boyfriend" and you'll be surrounded by guys reliving the old days :/
Shadowmov3r 8 months ago
@Shadowmov3r Agreed, but that doesn't mean there's still a few chicks out there that find true musician ship impressive, I know i've met a few at least
Volcanistry 8 months ago
@Volcanistry Girls these days are pretty shallow overall.
AirHendrix91 8 months ago
@AirHendrix91 Yeah man i hear ya, you don't have to tell me twice
Volcanistry 8 months ago
A minor and C major are not the same key. Obviously. "A" and "C" are not the same letter.
They do contain all the same notes however, but all music is relative to what sounds the most like the root note. I must admit most of this jam track sounded major, but thats completely okay, I A minored it up anyways.
TheToxicity13 1 year ago
what ibanez model is this?
karavasilis12345 1 year ago
@karavasilis12345 s series ftw
nietjob 1 year ago
Creep- Radiohead?
josevivo 1 year ago 3
I love this backing track!!!!
I especially love the chorus, though it's not really A minor, it still works very well with the scale, love the change from F to Fm...
sarelg21 1 year ago
Funny enough, with all this C major A minor talk, it's more of A aeolian than A minor. Technically A minor should have a dominant V chord. The resolution here is from a G to an A minor, bVII, which is way more aeolian than minor.
Sunderlanding 1 year ago
Comment removed
TintedRedFilms 11 months ago
@Sunderlanding A Minor and A Aeolian are the same thing... There can be a Dominant or a Major in either. It doesn't matter.
A Aeolian = the 6th mode. A = the 6th degree of C Major = A Minor = A Aeolian.
TintedRedFilms 11 months ago
@TintedRedFilms You missed what I was saying. A minor as a key should technically have a dominant V chord. That means it must have a G# in it somewhere. A aeolian does not have a G# it has a G. Therefore A aeolian isn't a minor it's a aeolian. Understand yet?
Sunderlanding 11 months ago
@Sunderlanding First of all, there's no G# in any G Dominant chord.
Second, you're thinking of Harmonic Minor, which raises the 7th and gives you the G#.
TintedRedFilms 11 months ago
@Sunderlanding Since A Minor is a completely natural key, there would be no G#.
TintedRedFilms 11 months ago
@TintedRedFilms If you're in the key of A minor there should be a G#. If you don't have a G# you're playing A aeolian not A minor.
Sunderlanding 11 months ago
@Sunderlanding There's no G# in A Minor. There's only a G# in A Harmonic Minor.
TintedRedFilms 11 months ago
@TintedRedFilms You're talking scales. I'm talking keys. The key of A minor has a G#.
Sunderlanding 11 months ago
@Sunderlanding The key of A Minor is completely natural. There's no G# in A Minor.
TintedRedFilms 11 months ago
@TintedRedFilms No that's a common misconception. C major is completely natural, but A minor is different. They share a key signature because they're close, and thus are relative major and minor, but technically the key of A minor has a G#. You can reference a grade two theory book, and it'll confirm what I'm saying.
Sunderlanding 11 months ago
@Sunderlanding There's no G# in A minor.
TintedRedFilms 11 months ago
@Sunderlanding I retract that last bit. I'll be damned, I'm wrong. I just learned something.
TintedRedFilms 11 months ago
@Sunderlanding I never considered the accidentals.
TintedRedFilms 11 months ago
@Sunderlanding in a scale of any minor key there is a raised seventh note. in the key of a minor G# happens to be that note. so you are right
SimonKalla 11 months ago
@SimonKalla God Damnit there is no G# in A minor! The raised seventh makes is HARMONIC MINOR. Seriously... I swear on my life there is no G# in A minor. WHWWHWW. That is the fucking formula. Now stop driving me nuts with this retarded exchange and study some music theory children.
getupanddosomething 11 months ago
@Sunderlanding stop spreading ignorance fool! why don't you reference this theory book you condescendingly point us to? It's probably because you're WRONG! No natural minor scale on this earth has a RAISED seventh! That's reserved for the harmonic minor scale! Now go back to school, give back your college degree in music if you have one, and beg your teachers to show you the fundamentals once again!
getupanddosomething 11 months ago
@getupanddosomething Fuck you're dumb. Read carefully this time. The KEY of A minor has a G#. I didn't say anything about a natural minor scale I was talking about the KEY of A minor.
Sunderlanding 11 months ago
@Sunderlanding Please reference where the hell you learned that. The key of A minor doesn't have a dominant V because you're looking at the tonality of the harmonized MAJOR scale. To find out what the V is for the harmonized minor or aeolian scale is you simply start at the vi like so: i, iim7b5, III, iv, v, VI, VII dominant. In other words the harmonized minor scale is minor, diminished, major, minor, minor, major, dominant. With all due respect
getupanddosomething 11 months ago
@Sunderlanding I would also like to add that in this case the scale and the key are one and the same. In other cases, scales (also known as modes in this usage) actually serve to refine the key to reduce the number of "wrong" notes. For instance, a song can be in A minor, but that minor could be a Dorian or a phrygian minor instead of the natural minor. And for the record, relative major and minor are based off of the key signature, which would mean that the number of accidentals in A minor is 0
getupanddosomething 11 months ago
@getupanddosomething You're wrong. A dorian is not the same as the key of A minor. It is a minor scale, but it is not the key of A minor. You can ask any theory teacher this and they'll confirm it, or refer to the Grade 2 rudiments book.
Sunderlanding 11 months ago
@Sunderlanding Jesus Christ, I realize that. There is such a thing as a song being in the mode of dorian minor though, just listen to John Scofield or Kind of Blue. I guess what you're talking about is every possible variation of the minor scale being included into this minor key, which isn't practical for conversation in my opinion. I think I was confused with what you were saying because everything you've said to back up your argument is poorly explained and in some cases incorrect.
getupanddosomething 11 months ago
@getupanddosomething I know that asshole. I was talking about the key of A minor. That's all. You were the one who replied when clearly you didn't know what I was talking about. Next time read all the posts before you comment. A minor as a key has one sharp and it's G#. That's all I was ever saying.
Sunderlanding 11 months ago
@Sunderlanding Lol, A minor doesn't have any sharps. A minor with a G# would be A minor with a sharp 7th, with would be A harmonic minor.
WhoIsRasmus 11 months ago
@WhoIsRasmus The ignorance on YouTube is amazing. Once again, MORON, I was talking about the key of A minor not any scale. The KEY of A minor has a G#. Go read the grade 2 rudiments book and you'll see that I'm right.
Sunderlanding 11 months ago
@Sunderlanding lol why would the key of A minor have different notes to the scale of A minor XD
billylikenoodles 10 months ago
@billylikenoodles Because there are three different minor scales. Don't be afraid to go read a theory book.
Sunderlanding 10 months ago
@Sunderlanding Well... it still means that it becomes A harmonic minor...
Obliaxe 10 months ago
@Obliaxe What the fuck is wrong with you? I just said I'm not talking scales I'm talking keys. There is no key of A harmonic minor. The key of A minor has a G#.
Sunderlanding 10 months ago
@Sunderlanding Hey... easy there budy... so tell me again the notes of an A minor key... A-B-C-D-E-F-G... Oh... where's the G sharp?...
Obliaxe 10 months ago
@Obliaxe Can't you read? That's what I've been saying. In the key of A minor there is a G#. The notes in the key of A minor are A B C D E F G#. If you don't belive me you can reference any grade two rudiments text, or check with the royal conservatory.
Sunderlanding 10 months ago
@Sunderlanding I'm sorry dude... but that is not true... and yeah, I'm pretty sure the royal conservatory agrees with me on this one, because the reason the harmonic and melodic minor were invented was to place a note in a minor key, a half step away from the route, thus creating more tension towards that note. So in a regular minor key there are no notes a half step away from the route... if you place a G# there, then is harmonic minor, if you place an F# and a G# then it's melodic minor...
Obliaxe 10 months ago
@Obliaxe Go pick up a copy of "Elementary Rudiments of Music" (standard conservatory) then go to the chapter on Key Signatures. It'll state that since A minor and C major only have one note difference they share a key signature. The note that is different...G#! This has nothing to do with scales, but with keys. In the key of A minor you have a G#. That's why the V chord is a dominant and not a minor! Seriously you clowns spend so much time with scales that you don't even know how keys work.
Sunderlanding 10 months ago
@Sunderlanding Ok I'm done feeding you... you're such an obvious troll it's almost embarassing, now go back to playing your G# over A minor... I'm sure it sounds wonderful. -_-
Obliaxe 10 months ago
@Sunderlanding its the A harmonic minor cuz the natural minor has a b7 but you are right **
Curtisplaysguitar 10 months ago
@Sunderlanding just shut up and play guitar everyone....struth
benjy091 10 months ago
@benjy091 Likewise. Hypocrite!
Sunderlanding 10 months ago
@Sunderlanding no there isn't! ITS A G! A G# makes it HARMONIC MINOR not natural. STop going on about this book that u obviously cant read
guitarlonextreme 9 months ago
@guitarlonextreme Your ignorance is amazing. Pay attention this time. I'm talking about KEYS not SCALES. The KEY of A minor has a G#. This has nothing to do with the Harmonic, Melodic, or Natural minor. Those are SCALES.
Sunderlanding 9 months ago
@Sunderlanding YOUR ATTITUDE IS PATHETIC. you're WRONG deal with it you loser
guitarlonextreme 9 months ago
@guitarlonextreme Seriously dude. I do conservatory preperation at a music school. I know my grade two theory. It states in the theory book "because C major and A minor have one note difference (G#) they share a key signature". End of story.
Sunderlanding 9 months ago
@Sunderlanding REALLY! so that's why your having youtube arguments in your spare time?! I DONT UNDERSTAND WHERE THIS G# comes from if you wouldn't play it over an A MINOR CHORD?!?!
guitarlonextreme 9 months ago
@guitarlonextreme Did I say chord? I'm not talking chords, or scales. I'm talking keys. They KEY of A minor has a G#.
Sunderlanding 9 months ago
@Sunderlanding 3? there are more than that
Strikerx20 10 months ago
@Strikerx20 Thanks asshole. I'm not talking about japanese minor and hungarian minor. I'm talking western music system. That is after all where keys come from. So for the purposes of my discussion there are three minor scales. Minor in name, not function, so dorian and phrygian don't count.
Sunderlanding 10 months ago
Thumbs up if this reminds you the Bloody Ice song from the MMO - Cabal !!
;)!!!
tolarasftw 1 year ago
@StDamasus dude A minor and c major are the same key..
NabeeltheThird 1 year ago
@NabeeltheThird no their not..... they contain the same notes but they give different flavours(of sound)
their totally different keys, Am has a as its tonal centre while Cmajor has c as its tonal centre
darrylportelli 1 year ago
me podrian decir los acordes que lleva la cancion porfavor?
musicaALTERADA 1 year ago
me podrian decir los acordes que lleva la cancion porfavor??
musicaALTERADA 1 year ago
Hey! thats my guitar ibanez s520ex :D
MrSharpenis 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Great track!!! Check out the tracks by Trihouse Montreal.
daveyb696 1 year ago
@StDamasus uh yea it is..
NabeeltheThird 1 year ago
gr8 backing track
hey guys heres my improvisation on this see it
babairocker 1 year ago
another nice instro from you iàm great
bestrat1 1 year ago
@StDamasus yeah it is, what key do you think it's in?
Quikfingers 1 year ago
good track, but a pic of an ibanez S doesn't really fit lol
MarcusFenixtheMan 1 year ago
it really sounds like" i hold on" of slash
falcont2t 1 year ago
201,844 views.... I was probably a few hundred of those! Great and fun jam! Thanks
kidwave1 1 year ago
Loved this backing track since th