Added: 1 year ago
From: IGNentertainment
Views: 776,242
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,120)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • nice trailer. bad game.

  • Pity the game did not actually look this good.

  • this looks epic but battle for middle earth 3 would be such a good game >.< too bad EA lost the license to make ord of the rings games :(

  • We need brand new Battle for Middle-earth 3, but with good graphic and better gameplay.

  • i think this game was great..not a amazing game but it was great a bit repetitive but other than that..it was really great

  • with frodo , peregrin, meriadoc, gandalf and so on its not the same for me :(

  • if the gameplay would be as awesome as the trailer...

  • This game sucks. But yet, I keep playing it, so it must have some redeeming factor.

  • a few Q's about the game...

    1:what system is it for?

    2:ive heard its an rpg...like third age rpg? (if so it better have good fuckin voice-acting)

    3:is it based on the movies or the books?

    4: wtf was with Minas Tirith and the inscription from the ring on that guys sword? if hes in the north it wouldnt make much sense if he was from Gondor

  • @nastrael It's on PC, Xbox 360 and PS3, it does have very good voice acting and the story isn't fully based on the movies and books but it happens at around the time of the first movie and onwards as you progress through the game and some of the events will be based on the books and movies such as the forming of the fellowship in rivendell and stuff like that :)

  • @Pud270 well as long as the voice acting is better than in the third age... the one-liners at helms deep made me wanna throw it out the window...yea it was that bad lol

  • o man i just jizzed all over my keyboard

  • Is this game worth getting?

  • @sgauden02 No. It will just piss you off. Get yourself Skyrim instead.

  • @IhasMetal lol skyrim has to be one of the most boring fucking games ever , all you do is run around searching for guys to talk to and kill a few dragons and fly with a fucking horse , makes sense ? no

  • @Jombaee You are a retard.

  • @sgauden02 Yes, it's pretty awesome in my opinion, its a pity to see such a great game get mediocre reviews but I suppose everybody is entitled to their own opinion and most 'reviews' are just one persons opinion.

  • Comment removed

  • i think everyone will agree. we seriously want a battle for middle earth 3 !!

  • @ezza0069 give this man ur thumbs!!!

  • @ezza0069 YES YES YES!

  • @ezza0069 YES! Thank you! Petition time? lol.

  • I wish I lived in this amazing land, I would do a quest to find its creator... J. R. R. Tolkien

  • The review for this game was terrible, but i got it anyways and spent 5 hours straight playing it o_O

    In other words this game is fucking awesome!!!! LOTR for life :D

  • A troll is a troll, you trolls!

  • To everyone... This game is sooooo fucking awesome!!! Like diablo.. but as LOTR!!! Addicted!!

  • Can't get that fucking orc chieftain dead in fucking fornost, this game sucks. LOTR rules tough...

  • @IhasMetal took me like 5 tries!!

  • Great game. Just look at it as a new game, not as Lord of the Rings. The battle style is immensly entertaining and the class skills are bad ass. If your reason for not playing this is because it doesn't follow tolkeins exact story line, then newsflash, niether did ANY of the games or ANY of the movies. Pull your head out of your ass and enjoy a great game.

  • Wow in 3rd person?

  • @piranhasportsteam WoW is in third person O_o ... and no

  • It would have been cool if you were the fellowship of the ring

  • fail.. Troll in the sun.. as if .. ^^

  • when is it coming out? or is it already out?

  • nothing of this trailer makes me want to buy it

  • is this game worth buying?

  • Why dislike this cool game? MW3 Players?? Just fuck off!!!!

  • Skyrim!!

  • I seldom see this now... :)

  • I HATE THE TROLLS IN THIS GAME

    CANT KILL THEM

  • Say what you want, I am enjoying playing this game. It may not be the best game made but it's fun and enjoyable.

  • @Funkyoh Finally someone i can agree with!

  • @Funkyoh i never played this game and im obsessed with skyrim but i agree 100% on what you said. if you find the game fun, play it. its as simple as that. a game that got bad reviews that i enjoyed was predator concrete jungle on the ps2. i had a blast with that game lol.

  • tHIS GANE IS JUST A REMODDELED WARHAMMER SPACE MARINE. iTS PRETTY MUCH THE SAME GAME.

  • And then Dovakiinh came and killed all this game characters

  • @MIchaelnj123 The problem is there would be complaints without that archetype.

    And also, most people don't know that the only magic in the Middle Earth are the Malar so they don't really care.

  • pretty quick trailer, but glad to finally see a woman fighter, the elf looked good enough. LotR was a total sausage fest before this game.

  • @BloodnSteel Fuck you

  • The only wizards in this game are the Istari. Then there are those who can shape-shift like Sauron. Then there are those who can control the weather like Galadriel, Arwen, and Elrond. Besides those people, there are no other wizards. To be able to play as a mage is fucking ridiculous and Tolkien himself would demand this game to be cancelled.

  • @mikerules999

    Demand?

    He'd do more than demand. His wrath would be terrible, his vengeance swift.

    The great lord Tolkien would send out his Nazgul to hunt down and kill the gameplay designers.

    Then he'd pour all his power forth into the blackened lands of Mordor and forge an army beneath his mighty fortress of Barad Dur, an army bred for a single purpose:

    The destruction of the world of Warner Bros.

    And maybe the world of men too, if he felt like it was worth the effort.

  • @Michaelnj123 you clearly didn't read anything about the characters before writing that then, no? Because the "mage" is an "Elven Loremaster, taught by Elrond" meaning they stay perfectly loyal to the lore as set by Tolkein

  • @Snowlock99 Perhaps, the lore as in literally, but not the whole idea behind LOTR. I wrote some comments to Carbonitexo, check em out, perhaps you'll understand my point :)

  • This game should present a different approach and gameplay than dark souls or skyrim. It's great to finally be able to have great rpg selections after some dry years on console. And by the way kingdom of Amalur looks promising also.

  • i have a wierd gut feeling this will be better than skyrim

  • el troll esta de día debería hacerse de piedra

  • i got hacked and lost 12k sub me thx

    supra exozion/dare exo

  • LOTR has one good feature over skyrim thats online capability and i cant wait for both of them to come out

  • RANDOM RUNNING SCENE! LOOK OUT A TROLL! EAGLE STRIKE!....wtf just happened?

  • i really wish these Lord of the Rings games would remain loyal to the lore and concept... Just the fact that you can be a "mage" as a class is sad. Magic is something entirely different in Tolkiens universe than to how it is presented in WoW or Dragon Age. Magic is something ancient and mystical and universal, something that you can only hope to understand if you're just as ancient and mystical and definitely not human, like the nazgûl, or Gandalf, or Tom Bombadil, or Galadriel or Sauron

  • @Michaelnj123 Here here!

  • @Michaelnj123 i couldnt aagree more. But, i personally will get the game. xP hehe. i think it looks entertaining

  • @lovaofMUSIK yeah gotta say, looks pretty cool anyways :p

  • @Michaelnj123 NERD

  • @9EricR rofl :D

  • @Michaelnj123 Yeah, that is true. But then it just defeats the point of having an RPG. A role playing game that you can only use magic if you are "not human, like the nazgûl, or Gandalf, or Tom Bombadil, or Galadriel or Sauron" is silly. Of course they are not going to follow Lord of the Rings lore if doing it their way adds to game play and adds a bigger role playing audience. I don't disagree with you because I am a huge Lotr fan, but what you said is just not the way to create a game.

  • @Carbonitexo 1. Hold on this is gonna be a long and tiresome one: Yeah well, can't say I agree ;) I mean, the thing I adore about Tolkien’s stories is his philosophy that even the smallest being, with the will, can change everything. If I were to play a LOTR game like this, I’d prefer to situate myself as a something of no greater 'significance' like Frodo, a tiny little Hobbit saving the world, even though he never understands any of these ancient and powerful forces ... (next comment)

  • @Carbonitexo 2. … that are presented to him as he progresses further. Not at all saying I’d prefer to be a hobbit, but just something less exceptional, if you follow me, discovering the world and challenging these great mystical forces, even though mission seems impossible :) I think that it’d add a much higher level of ‘adventure-feeling’ and intensity to the game than if you were to be a powerful elven mage nerfing some thousand orcs with ya fellow Gondorian elite guards or whatever :)

  • @Carbonitexo 3. I know I might be gettin a little korny, but just, since I’m such a huge LOTR fan I’ve always wished for a game that would live up to the whole idea behind this great fantasy. Try and notice something about LOTR, whenever characters encounter a danger, they’re fighting with brute force, and that as well adds the feeling of realism, in a weird sense, but that as well makes LOTR special, what separates it from stuff like Dragon Lance.

  • @Carbonitexo 4. …yeah alright Gandalf uses magic against the Balrog, The Witch King and those guys, but they’re demons and.. “witch kings” for god sake, give him a break  Whenever Gandalf encounters minor dangers, he keeps to the sword and staff. It shows that magic is something belongs in greater “situations” and with greater “beings”. It’s not like you got like a few mages in your elvish, or Gondorian or Mordorian army, like you we saw it in Lord of the Rings: Conquest, thats fucked ...

  • @Carbonitexo 5. …LOTR is like our Middle Ages, people act, live and fight like we would’ve, the only difference is this weird magic aspect that lures in every stone and every tree and creates both good and evil. I wish magic would be more mystical and ancient these games. I’d rather like to feel awe whenever I experience it, than just being able to throw a fuckin fireball whenever I feel like it :)

  • @Michaelnj123 It's completely fiction. This was all way too much to read. But you have your opinion and I have mine. But mine was more logical to be honest.

  • @Michaelnj123 You Sir have it all figured out.

  • @Michaelnj123 you said everything in the world of Tolkien magi were different species of human but a class in this game? okay you have the mage class in an rpg partidade table, but we're talking about Tolkien, he totally changed the rules and monsters for your fantasy world, the lord of the rings is meaningless in this game

  • @guiguicapuuu i'd really like to answer you, but i'm not sure i get what you're sayin, try and explain to me what you mean :)

  • @Michaelnj123 I meant that magic made​by the creators of the first stories of the genre has a magical way and today is totally different, this game had to be a magician in the world class when tollkien mages are not human .. And the last of them was gandalf hehe

  • @Michaelnj123

    Actually, certain elves had the ability to use magic.. So.

  • @Michaelnj123 The nazgul are human ;D

  • @mirror452 yeah they used to be ;)

  • @Michaelnj123 In the East there were magical cults that the Blue wizards worried they were responsible for, also the "mage" in this is an elf, not human. i dont agree with pissing on tolkiens lore like previous games have done, but an elf knowing magic isnt that far fetched

  • @TheDocGoblin yeah you're right she's not human, but doesn't really matter, it's besides my point. I've tried n explain a few times to people :) All I wish for is a game that would respect and understand Lord of the Rings for what it is, what makes it different from so many other fantasies. It would be awesome.

    now I've witnessed numerous attempts to put LOTR into a game, not a single one was successful, and this one wasn't anything near it either. Still a cool game i admit, just wrong title

  • @Michaelnj123 Nazgul are human... just corrupted by their rings. And magic in Tolkiens universe is to do with domination and machinery. What the Elves and Tom Bombadil use is Art. There's a big difference. Although I do agree with you that these games are doing little more than leaching off the fan base to make money.

  • @Metanator The point of the nazgul is that these kings had been twisted so much by evil power that they could not be identified as human beings, they are merely a shadow of their human soul. Their existence has left the natural plane. Didn't really get the thing with "art" of elves and bombadil please explain to me :)

  • @Michaelnj123 i havent even seen all of the films, but I totally agree on the mage thing, just seems forced and out of place in tolkiens universe,

  • @Michaelnj123 I undestand your point and I prefer the lore of Lord of the Rings aswell but it's still a game , and the developers do their best to stick with the lore but if you want to make an enjoyable game then you sometimes have to make some changes.

    And the mage class in this game isn't the mage class you see in most games I think , the magic is far more delicat.

  • @ElectTheDeadBelgium Hmm, no. There are tons of ways this game could've been improven to make it more authentic, and still wouldn't hurt the income. as so infinitely many other tellings, LOTR has become a victim of mindless moneymaking instead of actual creativity and commitment. It's not a "kill your darlings" necessity that creates these terrible games, it's just lack of creativity and commitment. but you're actually right in some way; might be product of low budget to begin with.

  • @Michaelnj123 You're right it is made to make money but I personally think you enjoy the story and lore much more by reading the books. Even if the game was accurate , books give the story its magic .

    So I personally ignore most of the flaws in games and just try to enjoy the attempt of recreating Tolkien's universe. Because if I started to pay too much attention on the mistakes in all the games based on books or movies , I'd go crazy :P.

    But I get your point

  • @Michaelnj123 Sorry but you don't know too much about Tolkien's work. Didn't you play or read about his Roleplaying game? You can be a mage, animistic, and some other magic-user classes, we could say every class can throw spells.

    I refer to the 80's rpg, not the last release based on the film.

    The Magic in Tolkien's world is everywhere.

  • @charlierayden Tolkien didn't make a roleplaying game..? and yes, the magic is everywhere, as i said: "it is universal", but it is much more foreign and complex in Tolkiens concepts. That's why it's inappropriate to add a mage class, it sort of spoils the mystical and ancient aspect of magic.

  • @Michaelnj123 Just want to point out the "Mage" you're referring to is an Elven Loremaster. That being said I've not come across any references to elven offensive magic in this sense. Closest I could think of was enchanted weapons. Healing magics sure but Magic bolts? [Citation Needed]

  • @Michaelnj123 Stop ruining good fun with lore goddamnit

  • @SpoonTheAmazing If i ruined anything to you, it's be because you agree somewhere deep down :i

  • @Michaelnj123 No, i KNOW, that mages arent like that in the books/films, but theres no good way to make mage lore in a GAME.

  • Yeah... I think that after having 20 people answering him, killerixi finally understands why all trolls doesn't turn to stone. And if he still doesn't get it, he's probably a lost cause... So can we please stop with all the troll comments.

    Because. Every. F*ckin'. Post...

    *SPOILERS*

    Is the same!!!

  • Reminds me a lot of Dragon Age

  • Skyrim is going to be equally as epic as this even though they are totally differnt games and this one is multiplayer 3rd persons rpg

    and skyrim is mainly first person single player rpg with more NPC's than any other game

  • @Insani4cc its a game itself

  • this game looks meh

  • Lord of the Rings never disappoints

  • @killerixi Its a cave troll

  • i want bethesdas attention to detail and lotr's storyline, i get the feeling this will disapoint

  • this game generally seems to be about surviving long enough for the eagles to come and mess up someone's day.

  • Will there be an evil campaign?

  • 0:20 Thats a very bad shield xD

  • Troll got fucked up by the Eagle

  • 0:29 FALCON CLUB!

  • Mediocre game at best. Why can't any of these studio's hear our plead of wanting a PROPER LOTR RPG. Is it really /that/ hard?

  • you call that a trailer?

  • gay

  • Eagles win......always

  • If this was a free roam game it would probably beat Skyrim.

  • Looks good.

  • LMAO he was like FUCK YO SHIELD *SMASH*

  • Gettin' pretty damn tired of seeing Skyrim in the top comments for some of these War In The North videos... But nothing's gonna change my mind. War In The North For The Win

  • not all trolls turn to stone in the sunlight

  • why the troll was on sunlight? werent those things supposed to turn stone in sun xD

  • @killerixi

    No, those were golems, not trolls :-)

  • @killobite ahaha my bad :D ty for correction :)

  • @killerixi

    No, no. You was right, I was wrong. Sorry for confusing you!

  • @killobite Trolls. Not fucking golems, Golems are made of stone.

  • @gardenguyvic

    Damn, you´re right. Sorry, my bad!

  • @killerixi and a crippling addiction to mutton?

  • @killerixi could be a special troll? idk maybe an internet troll!

  • @killerixi it was wearing a cloak

  • @asherty1012 rofl ty for awnsering to mah question :DD

  • @killerixi not if it's a mordor troll. sauron specially bred them so that wouldnt happen :P

  • @killerixi not if it's a mordor troll. sauron specially bred them so that wouldn't happen :P

  • @killerixi I agree even in the movies they are in sunlight sometimes, but they don't turn to stone. Maybe only some type of Trolls turn to stone.

  • @thegamingwarhero this might be true, i guess we never know the exact truth :D

  • @killerixi

    They are Olog-Hai, special trolls which can survive in the sunlight.

  • @killerixi its an olog hai, the only type of troll that can walk in the day but it was not invented by tolken its a jackson thing

  • @gunslingerspartan kewl ty man :D i guess you always learn new things when ask from youtube xD

  • @killerixi The trolls bred by Sauron were Olog Hai, and could live in the sun, being super evil or summat.

  • @killerixi The Olog-Hai don't

  • @killerixi that is only a certain troll called a stone troll i think. the troll on the vidio was a cave troll

  • @killerixi I IS TROLOLOLOL

  • @killerixi In fact its gandalf that made them turn into stone, bilbon beggins thought it was the sun cause he didn't saw gandalf casting the spell, which made some light like if the sunlight were piercing throught the trees leaves

  • @YohanGuitarist kewl, didint know that :D as i said be4 u always learn new things :D heh ty for replys guys <3

  • @killerixi Olog-Hai. Were like Uruk Hai; could walk in sunlight, meaner, smarter etc.

  • @killerixi It's written on the book that after Saruman started serving Sauron, evil creatures could be created, that didn't have the sun weakness anymore. ;)

  • @killerixi Yeah, but not if it's a Mordor troll, which I think that one was :P

    It has to be, or it would have turned to stone yeah lol

  • @killerixi Read the Hobbit? Only mountain trolls turn to stone in sunlight.

  • @killerixi i think thats an ogre, not a troll. In return of the king they use trolls all the time during the sun

  • @killerixi trolls of olog-hai can come in the sun. They are the trolls sauron uses

  • @killerixi

    Apparently some of them are immune to sunlight, like the ones used to push those mobile fortresses in RotK.

  • @killerixi dude? what about the trolls who attacked Minas Tirith... = there are a lot of different trolls in middle earth...

  • @XandoProductions Those trolls were Olog-Hai trools that were breed by Sauron to withstand sunlight and crush Minas Tirith. Secondly, Sauron also cast a shadow over the land when he sent his armies out to crush middle earth. These developers aren't being mindful of the lore.

  • @BBlueu2 dude i know! :D you're  absolutly right, i already knew that :p i was trying to make killerixi shut up :p

  • @XandoProductions i didint really pay that much thought to those trolls, and the fact is i dont really care bout the matter anymore since i got the awnser i wanted already :)

  • Comment removed

  • @killerixi Not all types E.G. Mountain trolls, Hill trolls, Olog-Hai etc.

  • DAMN

    thats one of the WORST trailers ive ever seen!

    theres nothing interesting on this!

  • @Kaokli the one for the game of thrones rts is pretty bad

  • This is why I am getting TOR. They have fancy gameplay to equalise the fancy trailers, where as in this they have fancy trailers but can't deliver good gameplay.

  • the old movie games like The Return of the King and The Two Towers MADE my childhood back on the gamecube... I hope this is them going back to those old roots

  • don't trolls turn to stone in sunlight?

  • @Jurjenjans83 there are snow trolls, mountain trolls, hill trolls, cave trolls and stone trolls. stone trolls are the ones that turn to stone in sunlight.

  • @AbolQasim6 Ahh I see. Shows how little I know about the Tolkien lore. Thanks. I guess internet trolls are also among those that don't stand sunlight very well :p

  • @Jurjenjans83 that's what I thought, only way they don't is if they are under some sort of spell I guess; the antagonist is supposedly a sorcerer, soooooo....

  • @Jurjenjans83 Also, not Olog-hai. This looks like an Olog-hai.

  • why the fuck did they make this trailer look awesome but have the crappst gameplay demo ever?

  • o nasıl bi fragman lan öyle :D sanki film fragmanı gbi olmuş :D

  • Please have multiplayer and BFME3 would be nice

  • the trailer looks gay

  • Don't know how the man survived the ogre hit. Guess Middle Earth people were stronger than they looked like.

  • Daaaayuuum! Hommie took a HIT! Talk about BABE RUTH...YEEEESH!

  • THIS AND SKYRIM WILL BE THE BEST GAMES EVER!!

  • @jaywolf313 gonna nerd all over the floor

  • @firstfreegame was it yourself?