If there was ever a song that could be Tarja's signature song this would be it. Powerful and inspiring. Very beautifully done by a very talented woman. Playback or not this is a very beautiful song, PERIOD.
@alexutzcel Maybe it's a live performance on a tv show? Some shows have areas of their studios made specifically for live performances, this may be a case of one.
This is playback. Tarja actually doesn't sing in jean on stage, here's no audience, I bet there's fake audience noise, plus she doesn't play with the camera.
It's not Tarja's fault, but just a fucking tv-show. Plus she moves a bit too much to sing like the album version; when she opens her mouth, just compare to some other vids, it's not the same note that is sung by her. Guys, I love Tarja, more than anything else, but be realist, this is a fucking tv-show...in playback.
I simply love tarja...but i got disappointed: she's very good at live singing, but here it looks like playback, and she can do so well without it.
I know in some tv shows playback is required, but in Italy Placebo as well as Muse did not accept that: at sanremo festival placebo broke all instruments , and muse's singer and drummer inverted their roles.
I always think nightwish were better with her...Annette's voice shrills in Nemo and all other songs made for Tarja, but playback is a low punch
@Jurie0 It's not playback... it's called effects, like echo and such... they do that so it will be as close as possible to the album version/studio. A shit load of bands does this...
@MrHaxwaffles sadly it cant be live though, at least not the singing if you listen 3:20 till 3:25 hmmm... cant be... you can't sing 2 things at the same time. it's just the album version.
@temari190 It is playback, but about the 2nd voice, tv show also thought about it, look closely, there's someone behind Tarja :) ...but just to make people believe it's live -.-, damn that tv show.
I think this video's music is directly from the cd, hence why it sounds way too flawless and exactly as the cd....... idk what's up with this one, but it isn't the original sound to the concert.
@666MetalMatt so you're admitting that she's lipsynching here but she's good live aswell ;) don't worry :P everybody knows this is lipsynch the "i walk alone" after "waiting up in heaven" isnt possible live but everybody knows she's wonderful live :) it's kind of a shame that she seems a bit more shy on stage now that she's out of nightwish though...
@temari190 /sigh like i said,shes not lipsynching.The real audio is replaced by a back track.If she actually ever did lipsynch she would lose all her credibility.
tarja es unica en el mundo y nightwish no sera nada sin ella ella lo era todo para ese grupo y esta demas mencionar que su voz es imprecionantemente hermosa cuando se presentara en venezuela seria lo mejor para mi poder asistir a uno de sus conciertos
+1 en todo, tarja era el alma de nightwish, con anette ha perdido demasiado, es un grupillo mas del genero, no como antes que eran unicos, tarja forever!
Tarja you are my idol, being a part of nightwish or just singing by yourself it's the same.. the magnificent voice of yours doesn't change, your songs become unique as soon as you sing them.. ! YOU ARE THE BEST!
@sorena19 :) is it just me or it is every time she sings i get either really relaxed, smile, pumped up or all those things at once? she's fantastic! <3
Yeah, I found her "My Winter Storm" to be a little disappointing. Don't get me wrong, I love Tarja but the album turned a little...Generic and dare I say it: watered down. However, she has some strengths like "The Reign" and "Ciaran's Well"
No biggie if it's playback. Nightwish did it too, haha. It's hard for artists to avoid it if they need televised promotion and the producers are demanding playback - which some of them do.
Who cares if the song is playback or not, just enjoy it, because it is a beautiful song, and it is sung by Tarja who has a wonderful voice. The offical video is great too.
la mayoria de las veces hacer playback no lo decide el artista... es culpa de los costos de produccion y comodidad de los programas q x 1 o 2 canciones no kieren armar y compaginar toda la calidad de sonido necesaria para una presentacion en vivo... :))
for those of you arguing about this whole playback thing, it's a tv studio performance. it HAS to be playback. other than that, at her own gigs she's most definitely singing live.
i think it`s playback... I was at a Tarja concert yesterday where she definitly sang live and it sounded a little different to this... but live or playback, she`s great!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Well well well...what do we have here...a playback? So many Tarjaholics criticized Nightwish for their Amaranth playback at the Echo Awards and said that Tarja ALWAYS sings live. Eat your words Tarjaholics...EAT YOUR WORDS! ~cheers~ :)
this isn't playback, this sounds alot different then the actual track, this version her voice is heavier and she used vibrato in places she didn't on the track.
Don't make me laugh. You put this video and her music video for I walk alone on at the same time and they're the EXACT same. Looks like Tarja DOES use playbacks. I'm saying this message to all of the tarjaholics who say that Tarja is perfect and NEVER uses playbacks. Don't let the door hit you on the way out ~cheers~
she isn't perfect, but when idiots like you say she is using playback i'm going to call you out, neither anette or tarja use playback, so cheers to you cunt.
If you honestly believe that no one uses playbacks you are clearly ignorant and deaf. Even Nightwish, MY FAVOURITE BAND used a playback at the Echo Awards for Amaranth and there's nothing wrong with doing so. I called out Tarja on this video because so many fantards criticized NW especially Anette for using a playback and said Tarja would NEVER use one. As for your uncouth dribble, stick it where the sun doesn't shine ~CHEERS~ :D:D:D:D:D
well when i heard this i was worried that she did use playback, but then i played the song with this and clearly it is not, and i never knew anette used playback.
Well here's the thing. There is a version on youtube of NW's echo performance without a playback. However, most of the NW echo awards performances on youtube has the playback and it's obvious. This started a whole other online war about how NW sucks and Tarja would never use playbacks because she can actually sing and she's a godess and blah blah blah. That is why when I heard her using a playback here i was like....well well well. I'm not criticizing her for using one I'm just saying...
that she's not as perfect as her religious followers make her out to be. It's your choice whether you believe Tarja is using a playback here or not but when i put this performance and her music video together at the same time they sound the same. Take care :)
Anette didn't actually use playback there, it's just that almost everyone who uploaded those videos thought it was a bad performance so they took the video and overlapped it with playback. But there is a video on youtube without playback. But I am pretty sure that this is playback. I'm a singer and I pay great attention to this kind of thing, and with her dictation, how she's not showing her accent at all like she normally does live, I can say this is a playback, unfortunately...
well, that's no a question of the band or not, mostly it's just the tv channels that want the bands to perform with playback and not live so nothing can go wrong. that's the shame with those sorts of shows... it's not up the artist to decide.
maybe it's not exactly the album/single version, but it's pre-recorded - her lip movements don't always match the sound, and check out 3:18. no matter how talented a singer she may be, I've never seen any performer pull THIS off live ;-)
Well ... the girl in the back doing the backgrounds alone with Tarja has kind of the same voice as Tarja .. I just spoke to her ... and she told me how that works ... hehehe sorry folks .. ! I am pretty sure you are not that lucky !
Um...the girl on keyboards can't be doing ALL those background vocals. Not to mention at the end, where Tarja is supposedly holding a note (and it's obviously her voice), but begins singing the chorus again, while still holding that same note (3:23). That's, um, impossible.
Her live versions are always a bit different. This is absolutely not. I think also it is playback, even if Tarja's my favorite singer...
olivermanton 3 weeks ago
TARJA :*:*:*:*:*:*:*:*:*:*:*:*:* greatest singer
zadigiarje 1 month ago
Fuck playback.....!! (pero no importa) es increíble! ^^
haditititah 1 month ago
Hey! She can sing with herself in duett. And this is Live xD
DavidbeeSuper 2 months ago
@DavidbeeSuper Look closely and you see someone doing back vocals...
spaansholland 1 month ago
If there was ever a song that could be Tarja's signature song this would be it. Powerful and inspiring. Very beautifully done by a very talented woman. Playback or not this is a very beautiful song, PERIOD.
AlabamaVid2 4 months ago in playlist Liked
This is Playback... :(
jefferson0666 4 months ago 2
@jefferson0666 how do you see it is playback?
spaansholland 1 month ago
its the album version
Blackwish92 4 months ago
great song
i wish she will find new band
YuvalZakOL 5 months ago
Comment removed
YuvalZakOL 5 months ago
at least she still sings
Lasadialarwen 5 months ago
This is for some small TV studio, be glad its playback (for the musically ignorant people) because it would've sounded crap otherwise.
lordabomity 7 months ago in playlist TARJA
@lordabomity Dont get carried away, this is still Tarja and it still would have sounded just as good.
z4nc0u00961 6 months ago
@z4nc0u00961 Ofc. But I was thinking more of the show as a whole. Shame though.
lordabomity 5 months ago
@maybekrazi you love the airguitar? me loves tarja's voice!
VayleGW 8 months ago
LOVE the air guitar!
maybekrazi 8 months ago
Too bad this is the lip sync >:(
TonyTwoToes6669 8 months ago in playlist Tarja Turunen, Nightwish
♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥.
z4nc0u00961 9 months ago
in a tv show there isn't proper equipment for playing live. Did anyone expected Tarja to bring 10 mil. meters of cable after her to a tv show? :))
alexutzcel 10 months ago
@alexutzcel Maybe it's a live performance on a tv show? Some shows have areas of their studios made specifically for live performances, this may be a case of one.
z4nc0u00961 9 months ago
Tarja eu te amo!!!
Deusa Eterna!!!
marccosc 10 months ago
This is playback. Tarja actually doesn't sing in jean on stage, here's no audience, I bet there's fake audience noise, plus she doesn't play with the camera.
It's not Tarja's fault, but just a fucking tv-show. Plus she moves a bit too much to sing like the album version; when she opens her mouth, just compare to some other vids, it's not the same note that is sung by her. Guys, I love Tarja, more than anything else, but be realist, this is a fucking tv-show...in playback.
PingouinBleu1 10 months ago
uhuhuh...dia 12/3 Tarja no Basil...e eu vou! uhuhuhuh
Cahgatti 11 months ago
I simply love tarja...but i got disappointed: she's very good at live singing, but here it looks like playback, and she can do so well without it.
I know in some tv shows playback is required, but in Italy Placebo as well as Muse did not accept that: at sanremo festival placebo broke all instruments , and muse's singer and drummer inverted their roles.
I always think nightwish were better with her...Annette's voice shrills in Nemo and all other songs made for Tarja, but playback is a low punch
AbsynthPoison 11 months ago
That's just beautiful! Absolutely beautiful!! Love her :D
Moka1022 11 months ago
tarja es tan sexy ufffffffffffffffffffffff teamo tarja
juankmarin 1 year ago
@Jurie0 It's not playback... it's called effects, like echo and such... they do that so it will be as close as possible to the album version/studio. A shit load of bands does this...
Digger843ASXM 1 year ago
I don't think i'm wrong if i say that Tarja has more fans than Nightwish in these days:D
pogy155 1 year ago
@pogy155
Think again...
NightDreamer88 1 year ago
EPICA it's better
burgos36 1 year ago
う~~ん。すばらしい!!!
彼女の高音ヴォイス・惚れ惚れする!
今のナイトウィッシュは、好きになれないし、興味ありません。
Tajaがいてこそだったのに!!!
royalhunt0603 1 year ago
@royalhunt0603 Che cazzo lo pubblichi a fare un commento se non usi caratteri umani?
agaliareth78 1 year ago
@agaliareth78 なにいってるのかわりましぇえええん!
日本語でおねがい!!
またみちゃったけどさ、やはり、Tarjaの深みのあるソプラノヴォイスはすばらしいよね!
royalhunt0603 1 year ago
Such a beautiful woman! What a fantabulous song! Soo emotional and wonderfully made! Such talent! Tarja you're awesome!! ;) *waves*
hallowgurl55 1 year ago
I can't stand so much beauty, what a woman
wdbm86 1 year ago
you the BEST!!!! Very beautiful song! thanks
friday13uk 1 year ago
WE LOVE YOU TARJA
GOD BLESS YOU
Baptkira 1 year ago
Pause at 01:02 and you see the bass is plugged in, also look up ''Wireless Guitar Cables''
MrHaxwaffles 1 year ago
@MrHaxwaffles sadly it cant be live though, at least not the singing if you listen 3:20 till 3:25 hmmm... cant be... you can't sing 2 things at the same time. it's just the album version.
temari190 1 year ago
Comment removed
Jemalacane 1 year ago
@temari190 It is playback, but about the 2nd voice, tv show also thought about it, look closely, there's someone behind Tarja :) ...but just to make people believe it's live -.-, damn that tv show.
PingouinBleu1 10 months ago
Why playback? We all know she can sing, so just do it!
1MaBreaux1 1 year ago
it soooo obvious that its playback, non of the instruments are plugged in, but i still love it :)
MissGothicLaura 1 year ago
nemůžu si pomoct ale tohle je playback......
Kritak5 1 year ago
You can see from her actions that her usual gothis metal stage actions are clashing with this syle.... that what i think anyways...
drzn3n3fan 1 year ago
por qué playback?
Symphox85 1 year ago
@Symphox85 tiene q cuidar de ves en cuando su voz... no puede estar acada rato hacinedo esto TALVEZ estaba enferma...
carlosxtinajlo 1 year ago
She's awesome ! Can't wait for her new album .
TippingWater 1 year ago
this woman is born to sing,nightwish sucks royal cock without her
GrowlingVocals 1 year ago 67
obvious playback is obvious...
alahad 1 year ago 22
@alahad ...yeah..to bad..
missdepp97 6 months ago
is playback --... =/
pblokito 1 year ago 5
This is playback but WHATEVER.
This is so cool.
Tarja is the best singer I ever know.
MrsLesleyOlivia 1 year ago 3
wow she did brilliant! I love her voice. Shes such a wonderful singer and is always a pleasure and treat to hear!
LoveofAphrodite 1 year ago
Tarja is the most beautiful woman of all time <3 so pretty... and a fantastic singer...
Obelix5150 1 year ago
Comment removed
Obelix5150 1 year ago
Woow, esa mujer es como los buenos vinos, nomás pasa el tiempo y se pone cada vez más bella.
Que talento !, Que voz !, Que belleza !...
DTPhoenix9 1 year ago
This is the only drug i need, what a high. Does she realize the power she holds when she sings
258diane 1 year ago 3
playback
kurabiyelikler 1 year ago
SHE IS MY FAVORITE PERSON EVER! And she has a voice like an angel. <3
XEvanescenceXLove 1 year ago
@XEvanescenceXLove me too! i would give my right ovary to see her live and then get to meet her! lol
xenassidekick1216 1 year ago 2
tarja is just incredible!
i love her to death!
and does anyone else notice how epically awesome her clothes are?
xoxo
xenassidekick1216 1 year ago 2
The best! Tarja!
JosephKrammer 1 year ago
she gotta stop playing air guitar during her singing its kinda dumb but she always be amazing no matter what cuz she is Tarja
rockpop1 1 year ago
AMAZING!!!
jwadiak 1 year ago
Playback! And she did it the same way in a German Tv-show I've seen!
She is amazing
GeileLory 1 year ago
she is so beautiful...omfg is that even possible to be someone like her...oh god I so love her <3<3<3<3
LoveTarja4Ever 1 year ago 3
sorena are you a girl?
LoveTarja4Ever 1 year ago
Briliant!!! I love this song!!! Strange rock but it is good!!!
himhimjohn 1 year ago
ohhh my god she is amaizing!!!!!!!!!!!!!
CERVANT100 1 year ago
i love her voice, she is great !!!!!!
whiteangel081 1 year ago 4
Bueno estaba doblando pero ewal estuvo genial la presentacion de mi Diosa
MithozDark 1 year ago
3:45 that guy is hot.
and Tarja is such a lovely singer.
Sonkirihami 1 year ago
she looked so pretty!
fig9ux 1 year ago 3
I love this new tarja :3 she always put on the same outfits in nightwish during concerts but I'm glad she improved her taste :3
NemoNameless0 1 year ago
I think this video's music is directly from the cd, hence why it sounds way too flawless and exactly as the cd....... idk what's up with this one, but it isn't the original sound to the concert.
SeraphimIllusion 1 year ago
she's not lipsynching, she's just really good.
runincircles70 1 year ago 4
no offense to tarja but she was a lot better in nightwish and it sounds like she's lipsynching
metalfan423 1 year ago
@metalfan423 shes not lipsynching,this videos audio is just from the cd but shes just as great live.
666MetalMatt 1 year ago 3
@666MetalMatt so you're admitting that she's lipsynching here but she's good live aswell ;) don't worry :P everybody knows this is lipsynch the "i walk alone" after "waiting up in heaven" isnt possible live but everybody knows she's wonderful live :) it's kind of a shame that she seems a bit more shy on stage now that she's out of nightwish though...
temari190 1 year ago
@temari190 /sigh like i said,shes not lipsynching.The real audio is replaced by a back track.If she actually ever did lipsynch she would lose all her credibility.
666MetalMatt 1 year ago
@666MetalMatt
I know Tarja does not lip sync.
Jemalacane 1 year ago
Comment removed
ger36 1 year ago
either she's lip syncing or they've put a different audio track to it.
UrMYM0nk1e 1 year ago
amo a tarja,su voz y su cuerpo de vikinga
andresnavalopez 1 year ago
pues claro que es playback!
osea el guitarrista y el bajista no se pueden ver mas falsos!!
pero deseguro no fue culpa de tarja lo del playback!
luego suelen ser los programas chafas esos!
Perono importa asi la amo con playback o sin el!
ajuuaaa ARRIBA TARJA
LA MEJOR
VAMPMEROT 1 year ago
@VAMPMEROT tienes razón!!! son los pinches programas q obligan a los grupos a hacer playback!!!!
Tarja canta como un Ángel, mmm pensandolo bien, no, POR QUE TARJA LE DA 1000 PATADAS EN EL TRASERO AL ÁNGEL =D
MusicaCool23 1 year ago
Esse não é o som original do vídeo, é?
gdpiu 1 year ago
it´s a beautiful song!
Kikilove95 1 year ago
Lamento decirlo, pero esto no está en vivo. Es un playback. Qué lamentable.
SlipknotRAE 1 year ago
lavate la boca para decir algo de tarja
EOLSLAYER 1 year ago
cada dia mas linda mi tarja
efraingotico25 2 years ago 2
this is not live ! this is just form the albul my wibnter storm the song i walk alone it`s not live
tarja7050 2 years ago
I don`t care it`s playback or not, album is good or not, Tarja is still the best singer I ever known. No one can change that.
Rasmusen777 2 years ago 2
i wanna play guitar for her
brucekirk89 2 years ago
the song is amazing but as its playback it shouldn't say live.but its not her fault
leiefilm 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
BryceIbanez17 2 years ago
ohh Si la mejor, sin duda
:D es geneal
karloz1793 2 years ago
Tarja is the best :-)
Kritak5 2 years ago 4
cool !
LAURENdatbenik 2 years ago
tarja es unica en el mundo y nightwish no sera nada sin ella ella lo era todo para ese grupo y esta demas mencionar que su voz es imprecionantemente hermosa cuando se presentara en venezuela seria lo mejor para mi poder asistir a uno de sus conciertos
LAMJ1000 2 years ago 5
+1 en todo, tarja era el alma de nightwish, con anette ha perdido demasiado, es un grupillo mas del genero, no como antes que eran unicos, tarja forever!
EOLSLAYER 2 years ago
Tarja you are my idol, being a part of nightwish or just singing by yourself it's the same.. the magnificent voice of yours doesn't change, your songs become unique as soon as you sing them.. ! YOU ARE THE BEST!
tarjaholopainen4ever 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
Nightwish reperesent nothing without Tarja and Tarja is nothing without Nightwish.
AlexOne82 2 years ago
Oh god, I'm in love
sorena19 2 years ago 51
@sorena19 :) is it just me or it is every time she sings i get either really relaxed, smile, pumped up or all those things at once? she's fantastic! <3
xenassidekick1216 1 year ago
@xenassidekick1216 When she sings, all of my frustrations melts away just by watching her and listening to her
sorena19 1 year ago
@sorena19 me too!!! she just this ability to calm me down even when my head is two seconds away from exploding! xoxo
xenassidekick1216 1 year ago
@xenassidekick1216 lol tarja suprised me when i first saw this. she hit every note perfectly
sorena19 1 year ago
@sorena19 of course she did! she's tarja turunen she's my idol!
xenassidekick1216 1 year ago
Marcos was the backbone of Nightwish. Tarja is a great singer, but without Marcos writing the music, she's just not the same. Disappointing.
PhoenixJasmine 2 years ago
Yeah, I found her "My Winter Storm" to be a little disappointing. Don't get me wrong, I love Tarja but the album turned a little...Generic and dare I say it: watered down. However, she has some strengths like "The Reign" and "Ciaran's Well"
ComaLies225 2 years ago
@PhoenixJasmine
it was Tuomas not Marco who wrote the music...although Marco does have an awesomely unique voice \m/
Sonata101209 2 years ago 2
Tarja es lo máximo!
vAmPiiRaKiiSs 2 years ago 2
No biggie if it's playback. Nightwish did it too, haha. It's hard for artists to avoid it if they need televised promotion and the producers are demanding playback - which some of them do.
Sapphirepearlz 2 years ago 2
Completely true, and most TV stations,
demand playback. They don't have
the right kind of equipment to get the music
recorded in high quality.
LovingLife411 2 years ago 2
she is fantastic , love you Tarja <3
DangerousKind333 2 years ago 5
Most of what you said is true- but not all
TV studios require playback.
But who cares she's still amazing, she's
just less amazing because she isn't live, but
she still has good energy and stage
presence. And either way- it's not her choice to
use playback or not. German TV for example-
makes you use playback.
LovingLife411 2 years ago 4
обожаю ее , настояший профи , нашим псевдо пзвездам до такого недорасти никогда
lexa45666 2 years ago 2
yeah WHO CARES IF IT IS PLAY BACK, she is amazing...
00jandj00 2 years ago 5
Who cares if the song is playback or not, just enjoy it, because it is a beautiful song, and it is sung by Tarja who has a wonderful voice. The offical video is great too.
julzierecson 2 years ago
playback? uhh....
I love Tarja ;d
TxAxRxJxA 2 years ago 2
claro que ella no tiene la culpa que la pongan hacer playback!!
ella puede cantar 100000 veces la cancion en vivo! y cantarla espectacular!!
por eso es unica!!
lo malo son los programas!! muy malos malos!!
arriba tarja!!
VAMPMEROT 2 years ago
I LOVE YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!<3
sagrathserbia96 2 years ago 19
igual, si hubiera cantado en vivo... hubiese sido espectaculaaaaar!!!! con esa puesta!!!!! wow ... lastima q no :S
colaborar09 2 years ago
la mayoria de las veces hacer playback no lo decide el artista... es culpa de los costos de produccion y comodidad de los programas q x 1 o 2 canciones no kieren armar y compaginar toda la calidad de sonido necesaria para una presentacion en vivo... :))
colaborar09 2 years ago
this is not playback.
TheandreHIMvillevalo 2 years ago
Hey dipshits around 3:21 to 3:28 no one is noticing the woman playing piano behind Tarja with the microphone.
toddthecat 2 years ago
Sorry but this is a playback because the intonations are the same that the album. And you see at 2:18, she mouth open even before the note is played.
I'm a vebig fan of Tarja but this video is a delusion. I'm really disappointed.
Ladythegreenpriest 2 years ago
esatto, e anche perchè lei nei live fa sempre qualche variatione!
metallara91 2 years ago
:s nunca pensé q ella pudiera hacer eso q mal :s
klausviridiana 2 years ago
for those of you arguing about this whole playback thing, it's a tv studio performance. it HAS to be playback. other than that, at her own gigs she's most definitely singing live.
komorli 2 years ago 4
Muitoo boom !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
RickPextii666 2 years ago
she is very cooooool
i wanna this mon :P
lisascott9494 2 years ago 3
shes lipsinging totally.
MusiicKim 2 years ago
i love tarja soo much this videos makes me very happy !!
imtolazytothinkofone 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ich liebe Sie
SubwaytoSallyBastard 2 years ago
yeah, playback
mustheart 2 years ago 4
playback xDDD
pentaculito 2 years ago 4
so what?? on TV, every band use playback...we know she can sing live perfectly too duh!
SoileHolopainen 2 years ago 2
not live lolz duhhhhhh
snowwhitequeenofice 2 years ago
shes lipsinging
WaterQueenIV 2 years ago
the person who probably made this video audio swiped it
christie54444 2 years ago
Heh, Spkurmind is right. I played both at the same time and they're the same. Same timing and everything!
She was so much better with Nightwish, shame she didn't care about the band by the end of it
RaveME102 2 years ago
... no shit.......
it is playback
i did it several times just to make sure...
hahahahaha
Akoro88 2 years ago
playback or not !!! Tarja is the best i love her sooo much !<3
666SCHNEIDERLEIN666 2 years ago
This is my favorite song by Tarja...and this video is awesomely dramatic for it :) Ty for sharing :)
SuperMetalAngel 2 years ago
Of course it's going to sound different...you don't have all the fucktards screaming at the top of their lungs....You can actually hear her now....
PNutButterWolf 2 years ago
i bet nightwish knows what their missing out on now! Tarja fucking kicks ass!
HappyAppleseed 2 years ago
This is the song that probably says that she has now gone solo (due to her husband's interference with the band) and directed at Nightwish
ValkyrieFreyaAngel 2 years ago
This is live fools
toddthecat 2 years ago
i think it`s playback... I was at a Tarja concert yesterday where she definitly sang live and it sounded a little different to this... but live or playback, she`s great!!
Antropomorphics4518 2 years ago
i think this is live... is it? oris she playbacking..? i dunno...
temari190 2 years ago
i dont care if is a playback...., I love this girl
manshadowed 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Well well well...what do we have here...a playback? So many Tarjaholics criticized Nightwish for their Amaranth playback at the Echo Awards and said that Tarja ALWAYS sings live. Eat your words Tarjaholics...EAT YOUR WORDS! ~cheers~ :)
spkurmind 2 years ago
this isn't playback, this sounds alot different then the actual track, this version her voice is heavier and she used vibrato in places she didn't on the track.
JrockFTW22 2 years ago
Don't make me laugh. You put this video and her music video for I walk alone on at the same time and they're the EXACT same. Looks like Tarja DOES use playbacks. I'm saying this message to all of the tarjaholics who say that Tarja is perfect and NEVER uses playbacks. Don't let the door hit you on the way out ~cheers~
spkurmind 2 years ago 2
she isn't perfect, but when idiots like you say she is using playback i'm going to call you out, neither anette or tarja use playback, so cheers to you cunt.
JrockFTW22 2 years ago
If you honestly believe that no one uses playbacks you are clearly ignorant and deaf. Even Nightwish, MY FAVOURITE BAND used a playback at the Echo Awards for Amaranth and there's nothing wrong with doing so. I called out Tarja on this video because so many fantards criticized NW especially Anette for using a playback and said Tarja would NEVER use one. As for your uncouth dribble, stick it where the sun doesn't shine ~CHEERS~ :D:D:D:D:D
spkurmind 2 years ago
well when i heard this i was worried that she did use playback, but then i played the song with this and clearly it is not, and i never knew anette used playback.
JrockFTW22 2 years ago
Well here's the thing. There is a version on youtube of NW's echo performance without a playback. However, most of the NW echo awards performances on youtube has the playback and it's obvious. This started a whole other online war about how NW sucks and Tarja would never use playbacks because she can actually sing and she's a godess and blah blah blah. That is why when I heard her using a playback here i was like....well well well. I'm not criticizing her for using one I'm just saying...
spkurmind 2 years ago 3
that she's not as perfect as her religious followers make her out to be. It's your choice whether you believe Tarja is using a playback here or not but when i put this performance and her music video together at the same time they sound the same. Take care :)
spkurmind 2 years ago 3
LovingLife411 2 years ago
well, that's no a question of the band or not, mostly it's just the tv channels that want the bands to perform with playback and not live so nothing can go wrong. that's the shame with those sorts of shows... it's not up the artist to decide.
tabidda 2 years ago
maybe it's not exactly the album/single version, but it's pre-recorded - her lip movements don't always match the sound, and check out 3:18. no matter how talented a singer she may be, I've never seen any performer pull THIS off live ;-)
jdnajes 2 years ago 2
It is Playback.Lisen to the normal versoin
alinsche583 2 years ago
KIITOS Tarja
GILLEStheBRAVE 2 years ago
Well ... the girl in the back doing the backgrounds alone with Tarja has kind of the same voice as Tarja .. I just spoke to her ... and she told me how that works ... hehehe sorry folks .. ! I am pretty sure you are not that lucky !
hectespinosa 2 years ago
She's AWESOME :X
hilflosmara 2 years ago
Medorien ... Wrong !
Devoratur ... so wrong !
Danielix11 ... terribly worng !
and son on ....
THIS is so LIVE ! and she is the BEST !
LOVE YOU TARJA !
hectespinosa 2 years ago
check 1:27 ... lol
hectespinosa 2 years ago
lol ... you should know the girl in the back with the keyboard does the chorus as well ... hehehe
hectespinosa 2 years ago
Um...the girl on keyboards can't be doing ALL those background vocals. Not to mention at the end, where Tarja is supposedly holding a note (and it's obviously her voice), but begins singing the chorus again, while still holding that same note (3:23). That's, um, impossible.
Definitely playback.
TwoFlightsDown 2 years ago
Actually, check it out from the point, 3:20. You'll see what I mean.
TwoFlightsDown 2 years ago
Yeah i know!!...I like the wtf??!!
PosionSkittle 2 years ago
I am sure it is playback. No one can sing double in the same time:/
Medorien 2 years ago 5
esa amgnifica voz que tiene ella (L)
TheKisstoxic 2 years ago
i dont know, why you care about playback...
johnprestoncz 2 years ago 5