He was crueler in the book than he was in the movie. And then,upon his return, he couldn't understand how she believed him so easily. He should have had to fight for her more to get her back. Just my opinion.
and this made me cry. I never read the book, but i watched the movie. Im looking forward to watching "New Moon". Edward.I.Hate.You.For.Leaving.Bella.
i like cried at that part i was so pissed wat a ass to do that to her why edward why . that was a pretty brutal way to say he wasn't in love with her anymore dont you think aw wat a jerk ya i skipped a lot of that part to its no good unles edwards there he is like the main charicter. midnight sun is the best but im pissed about her not finishing it but can ya blame her who ever leaked that out diseves to be punched out
Reading New Moon after Twilight with no spoilers was shocking. I loved the relationship they had in Twilight and when he said I'm leaving I was like OMG!! I nearly shattered my heart!! I truly thought he wouldn't come back, and then It was so unexpected that Alice turned up, after finishing New Moon I was like "Wow that was unexpected!" I love the Twilight Saga!!!
i was in school when i was reading this chapter and when he left her i threw the book on the ground and i almost started to cry and my teacher was like uhhh are you ok? haha it was pretty funny.
lol i was 2 and i was so mad i went ahead in the book 2 make sure he was comin back i missed edward so much i love that book so much i love the twilight saga so much omg i love this part because even though it was so sad i still liked it so much because i felt bellas feeling omg i love that book :)
Awwha, I cried my eyes out when read that. Mostly the part when she asked if he wanted her and her answered 'No'. I was team Jacob for a while. (Ahaha, Not anmymore.)
oh my gawd. soooooo sad. i cried reading it in the book and i almost cried again. =( even though i know he comes back its still sad to feel all of that again that she felt.
Yeah, thats a good idea! But, well, these arent important chapters. Its just how he felt w/Bella when he was near her (her smell), and then them becoming friends. It goes up till the part where he is asking her all these questions. Its sooo good! But if u dont wanna read it now, Im sure not gonna spoil it 4ya! lol! u'll love it! ; )
omg.. no.. ! I hope not! I cannot wait! Its an amazing book so far, anddd i cant wait that long. I cant occupy myselft for longer then a coupla months.. : (
ik i just found the video...hahaha omg i want that book soooo bad...i can't wait till november when new moon comes out they say they are gonna show us what edward does when he's gone!!!
I know me 2! I loved the few chapters she posted up, they're so addicting!! Wait, they said they were?! Thts soo cool! I cant wait till November 20th! : D
Yeah, but idk how long that will take, and my friend suggested it. Its not the WHOLE thing, just about a couple of chapters. Its AMAZING. u really should c it. I will re-read Midnight Sun once it comes out anyway. Heehee.
now why did you have to go make me cry!jk jk but I seroisuly am crying I was so sad at this part and this song made it so much worse lol. but great video:) now if you'll exuce me I gotta go get some tissues lol.
Yes he does towards the end...don't worry. Have you read it? Well I guess not...lol. Um...just keep reading. He'll be back. Never fear Edward is near. *sorry I got a little weird there* But yeah Edward is in all of Eclipse!!! YAY!!! In the meanwhile (after he leaves) you get to know Jacob better. He's a good guy...in my opinion anyways. Unlike my friend, Brenna, who thinks he should die! Anyways...just keep reading...trust me it gets less depressing!
omg thank you so much!! i Am reading it..but im only in page 134..so i read twilight and im reading new moon :) im going with eclipse after! THANKS FOR TEWLLING ME!!!!
im only on pg 102 nd it rlly sad i cant wait till edward comes back its so sad and jacob black does seem like a nice guy! (tlkn bout new moon) cant wait 4 the movie to come out 12-12-08
well, at least now its only 2 weeks away! And their's an exclusive clip on mbc on monday the 10th! Im pretty sure u know by now that its coming out 11/21, ryt? every Twilight-fan is all caught up on that! lol : D
I don't have the book with me right now *sigh* I think it's chapter 19 20 or 21 I do know that it's called Volterra. It's one of my favorites♥. Bella is my favorite charater.
i was soo mad when this happend! the rest of the book was like sooo boreing without edward!....and i dont like jacob! edward is soooo much better!but when he did come back or should i say bella made him come back i was like PHEW!yes! <3
He was crueler in the book than he was in the movie. And then,upon his return, he couldn't understand how she believed him so easily. He should have had to fight for her more to get her back. Just my opinion.
danimart1105 1 year ago
what song did u use for this?
teamjacobgirl2009 2 years ago
@teamjacobgirl2009
Please Remember by LeAnn Rimes
you see it at the end
Lieneltje 2 years ago
i bawl like a baby when i watch this!!!!! i cry way hard in the book thought!!! i read this part at night and i literally cried myself to sleep!!!!!
Alice6808 2 years ago
Jeez. This vid makes me bawl each time I see it..Lol.
NaruSakuROX 2 years ago
i made a video of this to but i put in the narration to
shortysha417 2 years ago
i love the books, and even though this one is super sad i love it. everytime i read this and where bella jumps i cry like a baby.
not to mention every time i watch this video i cry too.
twilightsagax3 2 years ago
:`< omg ive read the series 13 times,
and i bawl my eyes out every time i read this part
its so sad :<
LaurenClaudiaMovies 2 years ago
Ok!Edward Comes Bck I Done Read Both Of Da Twilight Books Im Bout2 Read Eclips!&&Charile Is Bella s Dad
TwilightRockz215 2 years ago
Who is charlie?
and this made me cry. I never read the book, but i watched the movie. Im looking forward to watching "New Moon". Edward.I.Hate.You.For.Leaving.Bella.
ZOMGishAbby 2 years ago
Charlie is Bella's dad.
edwardsonlybella 2 years ago
oh, thanks. hah, i forgot.
ZOMGishAbby 2 years ago
I've read the twilight Saga 6 times straight (on my 7th time now) and everytime I still cry when edward leaves!
TwilightDebaters 3 years ago
i cry ever time i read this1 i m crying right now! bu thank god i read all the books or i would have dead! they all live happily ever after!
joejonasislife122 3 years ago
i like cried at that part i was so pissed wat a ass to do that to her why edward why . that was a pretty brutal way to say he wasn't in love with her anymore dont you think aw wat a jerk ya i skipped a lot of that part to its no good unles edwards there he is like the main charicter. midnight sun is the best but im pissed about her not finishing it but can ya blame her who ever leaked that out diseves to be punched out
twilightscool17 3 years ago
Reading New Moon after Twilight with no spoilers was shocking. I loved the relationship they had in Twilight and when he said I'm leaving I was like OMG!! I nearly shattered my heart!! I truly thought he wouldn't come back, and then It was so unexpected that Alice turned up, after finishing New Moon I was like "Wow that was unexpected!" I love the Twilight Saga!!!
miracle21209 3 years ago
it sucked....in a good way haha
but yeah when alice came back i was so happy i was in the car with my aunt and she was like omg! haha
chelsluvsnickj 3 years ago
i was in school when i was reading this chapter and when he left her i threw the book on the ground and i almost started to cry and my teacher was like uhhh are you ok? haha it was pretty funny.
chelsluvsnickj 3 years ago
lol i was 2 and i was so mad i went ahead in the book 2 make sure he was comin back i missed edward so much i love that book so much i love the twilight saga so much omg i love this part because even though it was so sad i still liked it so much because i felt bellas feeling omg i love that book :)
90twilight09 3 years ago
Awwha, I cried my eyes out when read that. Mostly the part when she asked if he wanted her and her answered 'No'. I was team Jacob for a while. (Ahaha, Not anmymore.)
That was great.(:
xLetterBoxesx 3 years ago
Lol. Wat changed ur mind??
Shahdsayshi 3 years ago
I don't cry during this stuff, but it's so freaking sad ! I'm so glad that he came back :)
DiaryOfJane94 3 years ago
i read this part on a plane, and i was so upset.
guitarhero12197 3 years ago
this is so sad
pcambdel 3 years ago
plz tel meh this isnt true! if it isnt it is SO NOT FUNNY i luv edward nd bella. jus,,,,u jus dnt tease us like this.
XxClarissax 3 years ago
i don't tease when it comes to twilight
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
true, jus 2 sad 2 believe =[
XxClarissax 3 years ago
Omg that is sad.. D:
XoXo1Amber1XoXo 3 years ago
o my god, when i started reading this for the first time, i was in math class and i started crying so bad that my teacher sent me to the counsler
bunny1boo3 3 years ago
hahaha. that's comedy.
dancerinureyes 3 years ago
when i read this part i was busting out crying!! I was in reading class to so that kinda embarassing... but i cry just as much everytime!
lauragirl802 3 years ago
omg, 2 girls in my class started crying when they were reading new moon during class to :(( its soo sad
xxhsm4everxx 3 years ago
oh my gawd. soooooo sad. i cried reading it in the book and i almost cried again. =( even though i know he comes back its still sad to feel all of that again that she felt.
Bubbub95 3 years ago
ik it's like sure comes back but...he left her..and said he didn't want her...i am soooo glad he came back...so glad!!
i cried for three hours when iread it...and durn breaking dawn when everyone is saying bye to each other...so freaking sad!!
BlairBarbie12 3 years ago
I know! I'd b heart broken if someone just tells me they dont want me and im in love w/him! I cry every time I read tht part, it just, its SOO sad!!
Shahdsayshi 3 years ago
NOOOOOOOOO!!!! I haven't read the book... So... Was she even crying or sad at all??
alyaj9 3 years ago
ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooh yeah
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
KK, thanks!
alyaj9 3 years ago
duhh...u think she would be happy....lol jkjk
BlairBarbie12 3 years ago
whats POV jw...and he is rock lol
i felt bad for bella
BlairBarbie12 3 years ago
Point Of View.
Shahdsayshi 3 years ago
it was so sad...
he leaved her..
but MY heart was broken :(
.... to read, how she feel.. it was very bad..
aLeviBabyfaCe 3 years ago
The 21st is approaching so quickly!
babyseallover 3 years ago
Yeah, thats a good idea! But, well, these arent important chapters. Its just how he felt w/Bella when he was near her (her smell), and then them becoming friends. It goes up till the part where he is asking her all these questions. Its sooo good! But if u dont wanna read it now, Im sure not gonna spoil it 4ya! lol! u'll love it! ; )
Shahdsayshi 3 years ago
i read somewhere that stephenie's not goin to release it yet and it'll be on hold for a long time so she can work on another novel
=( i hope it's not true
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
omg.. no.. ! I hope not! I cannot wait! Its an amazing book so far, anddd i cant wait that long. I cant occupy myselft for longer then a coupla months.. : (
Shahdsayshi 3 years ago
agreed
=(
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
gr8 minds think alike. lol : D
Shahdsayshi 3 years ago
lol yep
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
heheee : D
Shahdsayshi 3 years ago
haha what were u talking about??
BlairBarbie12 3 years ago
hahaa, wow, that was a while ago. We were talking about Midnight Sun... and such. lol.
Shahdsayshi 3 years ago
ik i just found the video...hahaha omg i want that book soooo bad...i can't wait till november when new moon comes out they say they are gonna show us what edward does when he's gone!!!
BlairBarbie12 3 years ago
I know me 2! I loved the few chapters she posted up, they're so addicting!! Wait, they said they were?! Thts soo cool! I cant wait till November 20th! : D
Shahdsayshi 3 years ago
yeah they said they will show us what edward is doing while bella and jacobs relationship heat up...ew...haha lol!!!
BlairBarbie12 3 years ago
Lol! OHHHH! Tht sounds AWESUM. lol. But tht part abt jacob and bella.. "ew" is ryt. lol! where'd u find tht anyway?
Shahdsayshi 3 years ago
oh i found it in this magazine... ik that the bella and jake part is sooo ewwie....lol hahaha....yeah
BlairBarbie12 3 years ago
Hahaa. Yeah. But I like Jacob. He's funny and like.. I kind like his character. But not how he treats Edward! Lol. I cnt waiiiit!
Shahdsayshi 3 years ago
Yeah, but idk how long that will take, and my friend suggested it. Its not the WHOLE thing, just about a couple of chapters. Its AMAZING. u really should c it. I will re-read Midnight Sun once it comes out anyway. Heehee.
Shahdsayshi 3 years ago
lol
yeah i'm gonna keep it a surprise so when i read it, i wont know what will happen.
=)
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
that is saddd!
I wonder how he felt saying goodbye,
even though he showed no emotion..
he musta felt SOMETHING.. like in Twilight,
he loved her ever since he spoke to her
for the very 1st time, in biology,
but he hid his emotions soo well
that she didnt know and niether did i,
until i read Edward's POV Midnight Sun...
who agrees?
Shahdsayshi 3 years ago
i know it's sad... *cries*
i feel the same way, but i'm waiting for midnight sun to actually be released to read it
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
Ahh so so so sad!!! 3:01 that is horrible and 1:30 to 1:47 is ahhh so tragic!!! BUt the song was perfect!!
GinnyWeasley01 3 years ago
i thought that song was perfect
=)
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
you were definatley right!!
GinnyWeasley01 3 years ago
that hurts to watch. but i love it even know i always cry.
xxNicci1295 3 years ago
omg! i love it! its so perfect! i crying! im going to beat you up tomorrow at school! haha jk ily girl. (we go to the same school)
4beautifullybroken3 3 years ago
no no please don't
lol see ya
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
why does this have to be so flippin sad?!?!
random0423 3 years ago
idk
;'-(
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
awe, ive read that book & this part millions of times but i still makes me cry everytime. ='[
xxNicci1295 3 years ago
me too
*cries*
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
I cryed when edward left. good choice of music though goes in with the whole sistuation.
iluvEddieCulle 3 years ago
I'm sorry that I made you cry. Everyone says that they do when they watch it. Yeah I thought it was a good song choice for New Moon.
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
i watch this like every day and i always have to re-apply my makeup, its running down my cheeks by the end!
but thats a good thing lol awesome job i love it
redhot654 3 years ago
i don't even bother reapplying mine lol
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
great job<3
i'm OBSESSED with the twilight series and everytime i watch videos about them it makes me cry :[
xdiannababyyx 3 years ago
me2 lol
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
oh my, this is so beautiful
great song choice, and that makes me cry every time. :( thank you so much for putting this on youtube
baha i was in the computer lab at school when I first saw this too and my teacher thought there was something wrong with me :P
this is like the 6th time i have watched this :'( the only time i ever hated edward :(
redhot654 3 years ago
this is the only time i hated edward too :'-(
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
*crying* This song went perfect with that moment. It's so sad.
NaruSakuROX 3 years ago
I know!
:'(
I read this part during school and I started crying. Nobody noticed... I hope.
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
*cries*
RonandHermioneLOVER 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm right there with you.
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
i cry everytime i her those words (it will be as though i never excisted) im cryin now great vid
iloveedwardcullen133 3 years ago
Thanks ;)
I cry too. *tear* A lot of people have said that this makes them cry. I feel bad. lol♥
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
good job!
this part is soo sad!! ;(
i almost cried when i read the book and i was so happy when edward came back :)
they are so cute together! jacob can go die :D
great vid!
5/5
Rikku113 3 years ago
Thanks♥
I had to type this video 3 times before I got it on YouTube. *cries*
Why do a lot of people think Jacob should die? It's not fair...he can't say anything to defend himself.
lol♥
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
:D he is just so annoying :D lol
Rikku113 3 years ago
and your welcome ^^
Rikku113 3 years ago
now why did you have to go make me cry!jk jk but I seroisuly am crying I was so sad at this part and this song made it so much worse lol. but great video:) now if you'll exuce me I gotta go get some tissues lol.
TwilightFreak103 3 years ago
Now you're making me cry *amber gets a tissue* no I was totally kidding lol.♥
I am glad you liked it!!!♥
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
WAIT !! is he coming back?!?! in the book..?
ivanita007 3 years ago
Yes he does towards the end...don't worry. Have you read it? Well I guess not...lol. Um...just keep reading. He'll be back. Never fear Edward is near. *sorry I got a little weird there* But yeah Edward is in all of Eclipse!!! YAY!!! In the meanwhile (after he leaves) you get to know Jacob better. He's a good guy...in my opinion anyways. Unlike my friend, Brenna, who thinks he should die! Anyways...just keep reading...trust me it gets less depressing!
B.t.w. Go TEAM EDWARD!!!
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
omg thank you so much!! i Am reading it..but im only in page 134..so i read twilight and im reading new moon :) im going with eclipse after! THANKS FOR TEWLLING ME!!!!
ivanita007 3 years ago
no problem
:)
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
im only on pg 102 nd it rlly sad i cant wait till edward comes back its so sad and jacob black does seem like a nice guy! (tlkn bout new moon) cant wait 4 the movie to come out 12-12-08
animelover407 3 years ago
READ!!!!!!!! If you read the book you don't have to wait as long. LOL
So yeah, did you like the video?
I ♥ Edward
I can't wait for the movie either!!!
♥♥♥
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
well, at least now its only 2 weeks away! And their's an exclusive clip on mbc on monday the 10th! Im pretty sure u know by now that its coming out 11/21, ryt? every Twilight-fan is all caught up on that! lol : D
Shahdsayshi 3 years ago
k thats good ill do just that keep reading! how far towards the back cuz hes my fav charecter?
animelover407 3 years ago
I don't have the book with me right now *sigh* I think it's chapter 19 20 or 21 I do know that it's called Volterra. It's one of my favorites♥. Bella is my favorite charater.
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
k thanx nd i dont like bella that much but awsome vid! I <3 edward!
animelover407 3 years ago
thanks
Why don't you like Bella?
♥♥♥
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
he's gone from page 71-381. trust an obssessed
fan girl.
fireheart102667 3 years ago
*cries*
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
I loved how you wrote how this!! Its really kool
flutemelodytwister 3 years ago
thank you
:)
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
=[
this part is so sad
KeithUrbanLuver4Ever 3 years ago
I cry every single time.
:'-(
AmberPenguins 3 years ago
me 2 =[
*cries*
KeithUrbanLuver4Ever 3 years ago
I hate when Edward left but unlike most I see why he left her. For her safely.
flutemelodytwister 3 years ago
i was soo mad when this happend! the rest of the book was like sooo boreing without edward!....and i dont like jacob! edward is soooo much better!but when he did come back or should i say bella made him come back i was like PHEW!yes! <3
yuskoponygirl 3 years ago