Don't be naive, I have never heard such rubbish before, you can listen to Joey's singing on 羅文&梅艷芳's song and hear the heavy breathing. The class singer like 羅文&梅艷芳 don't have that issue!!!
Although 羅文&梅艷芳 are dead but they represent the elite standard for singers. Joey might be the Queen of Pop but she sings as if she is half dead because of heavy breathing.
You think that is the case? GEM sings all sorts of songs, you might think: Greatest love of all, Lady Mamalade, Fallen, Loving U are easy? Well I will like to hear Joey's version. GEM likes challenges while Joey just sticks to K songs. In fact, I would like them sing each other songs and you will see Joey is much over-rated K song pop queen.
Anita and Lo both are full of surprises, they have performed many style of music, in fact Anita has sung R&B in her last concert with 陶喆, she did very well。Joey hasn't given me too much surprises after the first few years, her live performance has got worse because she tries to select the more difficult songs, the problem of tone change and breathing comes out
Frankly, I dont know why I was replying your post or what I am arguing for now lol, as i should not challenge anyone's subjective preference. As I said, I respect your opinion but everyone has his/her own rubric when it comes to defining good singing, and I can see you value a lot on breathing and the ability to perform other styles of songs, which is fine.
GEM has sung other style before:聽海、李香蘭、Shall we talk 等等in concerts. When GEM sings Joey's song she doesn't need to prefrom in R&B style. I have heard many people sang Joey's song well: 汪明欣( 明日恩典@TVB)官恩娜(心花怒放@澳門漁人碼頭), you go and listen to 官恩娜 version, her change of notes and breathing is better than joey's but I have yet to come across someone who can sing Gem's song's well.
both songs have build ups when you sing to the last parts of GEM's songs, you will find it is hard as that takes a lot of power. Although GEM has only 15 songs, but she has sung some difficult ones, I am sure Joey can't perform Fallen, loving u, greatest love of all, (which are no K songs) as good as GEM, this girl is definately not affraid to sing difficult songs or partner with experienced singers. I definately can say GEM can cover a wider range of music than Joey
Oh c'mon u guys! She didnt mean it that way, she's only thanking the people that has helped her thru her career! Like she says in an interview, being a singer doesnt mean u know how to talk correctly!
如果冇同某些人發生過關係,你係樂譠條路邊有甘順..
shearer1973 1 week ago
講錯野0.0
祖祖你都系唱歌好過講野啦
shirleykohw 2 weeks ago
老實說G.E.M才是真正的天后(至少十年後是),王菲也还没这资格呢!
saltamsal2711 2 weeks ago
@saltamsal2711 55;我都覺得係(:
RouniLuvGem 3 days ago
妖你!!!!
sallyleung96 3 weeks ago
鬼拍後尾枕... 尼句好正好認同!!!
fannieng1979 1 month ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
香港這種人人營役的都市、追求感官刺激的樂壇,最需要的,也許就是更多像謝安琪這樣的清流
movebetween 1 month ago
Comment removed
Mrblue255 3 months ago
真心話
Zillionwintermac 6 months ago 6
鬼拍後尾枕?!
karina123hk 8 months ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
好的説話經過D人諗完就變成dirty的思想,無聊白癡gim低能;\
ying403jy 8 months ago
@ying403jy 是真的~
hefbc1 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
很無聊的影片
祖兒根本不是這果意思
刻意扭曲別人說話好好玩ma?
幼稚~~支持容祖兒!!!!!!!!!!!
babycaca13579 11 months ago
好好笑
hokakiu 11 months ago
she so dirty ~~
carltonlau2006 11 months ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
there you go
keyqui05 11 months ago
佢本身係想講*有關係*,
之後為左節目效果就改左做*發生關係*。
maggie0099 1 year ago
哈哈哈 好好笑XDD
iamaveryuglyboy 1 year ago
香港乐坛在王菲与郑秀文后就再也没有真正的天后了。
lmml09 1 year ago 11
@lmml09 你邊位呀=_=?天吾天后都吾由你定啦
iamaveryuglyboy 1 year ago
@lmml09 老实说只有王菲才是真正的天后,郑秀文也还没这资格呢!
Mrblue255 4 months ago 4
@Mrblue255 老實說Maria Callas才是真正的天后,王菲也还没这资格呢!
thomastmwc 3 months ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
@thomastmwc 但是maria没王菲那么有知名度。。。。。晒气
Mrblue255 3 months ago
@thomastmwc 老實說大家應該在討論最近兩個世紀的香港樂壇
JoEl628l 1 month ago
@JoEl628l 冇人講明,嘻 :P
thomastmwc 1 month ago
知佢多老細喇
wkchan27 1 year ago 14
This has been flagged as spam show
用「歌星仔」去形容佢其實已經好畀面佢。
我會用家禽去形容佢囉!
klsuperman 1 year ago 6
Comment removed
klsuperman 1 year ago
個腦諗乜個口米講乜囉
d dj都笑到hihi
bbcomqq 1 year ago
每個人ge力量.. 令佢更舒服..haha!!!!!
lovedung88 1 year ago
鬼拍後尾枕
magician226 1 year ago 8
祖儿最大的缺点就是不擅长表达....
mayxuan 1 year ago 11
@mayxuan
佢最大既優點就係夠坦白
Cylam 1 year ago 43
@Cylam 无论你们怎么说,他也是我最喜欢的香港女歌星了,香港歌星越来越差了,你们自己香港人也这样踩自家歌星,到时候没有人喜欢hong kong singer 咯
mayxuan 1 year ago
好舒服
ka619 1 year ago 2
oh come on dont pick on her , she doesnt have the talent to make good speeches .
sanndyzhou 1 year ago
其實佢本身係想講咩呢? =\
Mikeoldyo 1 year ago
多謝今年曾經同我有關...發生過關係既所有人 係 佢地每一每一個人既力量都令我既...路...行得更加...舒服
MolsonpEx 1 year ago 9
佢哋每一個人既力量都令我既路行得更加.......舒服
diyjj1 2 years ago 11
蜥蜴
leonleon1222 2 years ago 7
佢多謝緊蜥蝪仔!
liardwc 2 years ago 85
@liardwc 誰是蜥蜴仔-0-?
iamaveryuglyboy 9 months ago
@iamaveryuglyboy
hk.news.yahoo.com/article/100128/4/gcna.html
liardwc 9 months ago
@liardwc got it . 哈= =..
iamaveryuglyboy 9 months ago
边个系gem???
Mrblue255 2 years ago
Comment removed
Mrblue255 2 years ago
哈哈 习惯了 joey的人太直了 整天说错话
没关系 我最是喜欢她的认够真..
mayxuan 2 years ago 8
若然講野太直的話....她說的就是真話~
morristotti 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
太直是應該說真話.......而這句"發生關係"就是真話.....
morristotti 2 years ago
冇野呀嗎~講錯野姐
同埋有關係唔代表d咩
vickylubyou 2 years ago 4
Hahaha~~呢個圈大把呢啲野,見怪不怪…
lovenardo 2 years ago
哈哈哈哈幫襯過佢班「老細」真係一額汗
klsuperman 2 years ago 123
@klsuperman
080218197 1 year ago
佢初出道仲好過而家 起碼唱歌唔會唱到哮喘咁 一d真係專業ge唱歌老師 如果你考試果時有抖氣聲 已經唔會畀你pass
idiotbutsmart 2 years ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
thmay25 2 years ago
講錯野姐
洗吾洗甘大反應牙
chun0909 2 years ago 11
Essien betrayed her body for her career!!!
MikeAipe 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
發生關係發上腦了
MrKeane111 2 years ago 19
This has been flagged as spam show
執著於幾個講錯野既位就大肆抨擊
真係好無聊
fung1989108 2 years ago
Comment removed
nanablvd 2 years ago
Don't be naive, I have never heard such rubbish before, you can listen to Joey's singing on 羅文&梅艷芳's song and hear the heavy breathing. The class singer like 羅文&梅艷芳 don't have that issue!!!
tokyojoe1698 2 years ago
well those classics you mentioned are both dead
and i think joey could sing better than a corpse
DerekBucket 2 years ago
@DerekBucket
Although 羅文&梅艷芳 are dead but they represent the elite standard for singers. Joey might be the Queen of Pop but she sings as if she is half dead because of heavy breathing.
tokyojoe1698 2 years ago
@nanablvd
You think that is the case? GEM sings all sorts of songs, you might think: Greatest love of all, Lady Mamalade, Fallen, Loving U are easy? Well I will like to hear Joey's version. GEM likes challenges while Joey just sticks to K songs. In fact, I would like them sing each other songs and you will see Joey is much over-rated K song pop queen.
tokyojoe1698 2 years ago
Comment removed
nanablvd 2 years ago
Comment removed
nanablvd 2 years ago
Comment removed
nanablvd 2 years ago
Comment removed
nanablvd 2 years ago
@nanablvd
Anita and Lo both are full of surprises, they have performed many style of music, in fact Anita has sung R&B in her last concert with 陶喆, she did very well。Joey hasn't given me too much surprises after the first few years, her live performance has got worse because she tries to select the more difficult songs, the problem of tone change and breathing comes out
tokyojoe1698 2 years ago
@tokyojoe1698
Frankly, I dont know why I was replying your post or what I am arguing for now lol, as i should not challenge anyone's subjective preference. As I said, I respect your opinion but everyone has his/her own rubric when it comes to defining good singing, and I can see you value a lot on breathing and the ability to perform other styles of songs, which is fine.
nanablvd 2 years ago
@nanablvd
GEM has sung other style before:聽海、李香蘭、Shall we talk 等等in concerts. When GEM sings Joey's song she doesn't need to prefrom in R&B style. I have heard many people sang Joey's song well: 汪明欣( 明日恩典@TVB)官恩娜(心花怒放@澳門漁人碼頭), you go and listen to 官恩娜 version, her change of notes and breathing is better than joey's but I have yet to come across someone who can sing Gem's song's well.
tokyojoe1698 2 years ago
Joey sings all sorts of songs as well
So you are saying "where did you go" "睡公主" are not k songs?!!
well G.E.M. only have 15 songs at the moment~ so you can't actually compare the songs that joeys has with G.E.M.s
ECrazyMeC 2 years ago
both songs have build ups when you sing to the last parts of GEM's songs, you will find it is hard as that takes a lot of power. Although GEM has only 15 songs, but she has sung some difficult ones, I am sure Joey can't perform Fallen, loving u, greatest love of all, (which are no K songs) as good as GEM, this girl is definately not affraid to sing difficult songs or partner with experienced singers. I definately can say GEM can cover a wider range of music than Joey
tokyojoe1698 2 years ago
yes~
but have you notice that GEM cannot sing calm songs~~
is that what you mean by a "WIDER RANGE"??
ECrazyMeC 2 years ago
@ECrazyMeC
tell Joey and GEM to sing Lady Mamalade together, Joey will get KOed esaily.
RightFooted123 2 years ago
tell joey and GEM to sing 何苦 together..
GEM will just suddenly SCREAM in a calm song!!
ECrazyMeC 2 years ago
@ECrazyMeC
GEM can and has sang calm song, just because you haven't heard it. For example: "18" from her album.
BTW about K songs, that's like 2 K songs out of 15 songs. And other HK singers have like 90% K songs.
RightFooted123 2 years ago
i can count 4 k songs
90%係K歌係因為派台..
唔該你諗下..
如果一首歌唔派台點樣有得唱...
一個人係樂壇耐就會有好多K SONGS!! BTW 係囉! 就係一首歌係calm嘅..
唔聽首歌我都諗佢係一首咁calm嘅歌到大叫丫!
ECrazyMeC 2 years ago
@ECrazyMeC
得一首calm歌唔代表GEM唔到calm歌.
唔派台唔代表唔係K歌.
唔祗派台, 唔派台90%係都K歌.
連張學友新碟都唔出K歌.
K歌是指香港樂壇一些專門為卡拉OK而創作的歌曲。這些歌曲一般旋律慢,較為簡單易唱,音域亦遷就一般人的水平,不會太高或太低. Even if they aren't in Karaoke, they will produce MTV.
唔該你諗下.
RightFooted123 2 years ago
你講到好似90%嘅歌都係有mtv...全部歌手嘅歌都係K歌..得GEM唔係...
ECrazyMeC 2 years ago
@ECrazyMeC
No, in HK, there're also 方大同, Rubberband, Dear Jane and other bands that has a lot of non-K歌.
RightFooted123 2 years ago
就係得咁多囉...
點解要講呢..
我有我唔鐘意G.E.M.
你有你鐘意..
我唔想再講
coz you'r not worth it!!
ECrazyMeC 2 years ago
@ECrazyMeC
唔夠講就唔想再講la?
你對人唔對事.
RightFooted123 2 years ago
妖..
我都無再講野
仲要話我唔夠講!!
你係唔係好得閒想講姐...
ECrazyMeC 2 years ago
@RightFooted123
G.E.M.咬字咁唔正!!
唱歌幾好聽都無用!!
你唔洗同我講話咩21歲先可以做手術..因為我知!!
但你覺得做完手術咬字就正喇咩?
ECrazyMeC 2 years ago
@ECrazyMeC
Yes, 做完手術咬字就正ga la.
RightFooted123 2 years ago
你好confident喎!!
咁你放長雙耳聽喇下..
我就無你咁得閒!
ECrazyMeC 2 years ago
@ECrazyMeC
OK.
GEM 22歲, Joey都退休lu.
RightFooted123 2 years ago
你死joey都未退!!
ECrazyMeC 2 years ago
發生關係天后
MikeAipe 2 years ago 5
鬼唔知攪過咩....
samc66mi 2 years ago 6
又關係,又舒服,HAHA
如果你係佢細佬?你會點?
hydrablue888 2 years ago 4
都要睇樣嫁==
samc66mi 2 years ago
講錯野遮`
你吾比佢句野系咁`
但系個意思就完全吾同ah?___?
用個腦唸下拉`.
好m0?口?
bulem00near 2 years ago
講錯野姐
洗吾洗甘大反應牙
有關聯牙
selinatong 2 years ago 3
不予置評: )
mickeylove2da 2 years ago
全部同佢發生過關係- -
恐怖!!
sisisze2007 2 years ago
都吾明點解係香港做歌手就要比老闆搞.....
le個係香港樂壇致命ge原因
lfilnkg 2 years ago 12
哦~乜你認為其他國家冇咩?天真
fung174138 2 years ago
人地紅就得啦~算啦
arFarF6 2 years ago
Freudian slip! Hahaha! But if I was a rich old pervert, I would not bang that. She's ugly and has no body.
lwc888 3 years ago 4
楊生幫了她很多呢 換佐咁多獎返黎 又拎佐個天后虛名
idiotbutsmart 3 years ago 7
虛名? 你去唱好不好?
我睇你就算發生左關係都唱唔到@@
同老闆發生關係 同 唱歌功力 係兩回事
唔好拉埋黎講
Dennis8283 2 years ago 6
我又唔覺佢d"功力"有幾咁勁 連G.E.M.都好過佢lor
idiotbutsmart 2 years ago 4
我好記得教唱歌既miss話~唱歌係唔應該俾人聽到抖氣聲~聽到抖氣聲既同學仔唱歌o個part通常都會俾佢fail左~
唱live G.E.M.真係好過呢位人工天后好好多~無奈就係人地冇佢咁多同佢有關係既老細囉~
jlam10123 2 years ago
佢d抖氣聲好哮喘 聽死人 所以我唔聽lor 唔想死住
idiotbutsmart 2 years ago 3
你去唱好不好?
dud e, please stop asking this stupid question...
we are not singers so we do not neeeda sing well, ok?
However,she is a singer and she has the responsibility to sing well...
xbf006 2 years ago
可惜佢出道10年都唔及得上新出爐既妹妹仔呢~
唔好話佢跟咩人學唱歌喇~有辱師門呀~攪到人地千年道行一朝喪~
jlam10123 2 years ago
就放長雙眼睇下哥d [新出爐既妹妹仔] 可以紅幾耐?? 睇下有邊個會拎到 [天后]之稱?
Dennis8283 2 years ago 5
所有天后當年都係 [新出爐既妹妹仔]~ 祖兒o係第一間公司呆左幾年都只係得一隻歌啦. 個陣佢都係唔紅格~
sfmeow 2 years ago
Comment removed
sfmeow 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
joey係廢, 但gem仲廢
blackivyyy 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
GEM點都勁過JOEY囉
jchuoe 2 years ago
Comment removed
sfmeow 2 years ago
haha so funny
dinnohim 3 years ago
頂你地...雖然祖兒表達能力真係媽媽..但係人地都係想搞下gag姐....你地都知道祖兒既意思唔係咁嫁啦...都要比你地踩到咁盡..唉...
123chuk123 3 years ago
come on~好無聊lo~~
gavin13f4 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我真係覺得你好無聊囉
你分明係到捉佢字啦
唔好咁白痴啦-.-
tracycheuk 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
she speaks the truth!
msmandy1018 3 years ago 17
This has been flagged as spam show
永遠都要批判人家的說話用詞嗎,香港人?
何不能將重點放在歌手們的音樂嗎???
yellow1211 3 years ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
雞容,公廁容你唔使講大家都心照啦
咁舒服,咁蛋巷好不好玩呀???
bayelmunich 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Oh c'mon u guys! She didnt mean it that way, she's only thanking the people that has helped her thru her career! Like she says in an interview, being a singer doesnt mean u know how to talk correctly!
LittleJen 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
唉...
識唱歌..識跳舞...
係唔識講野...
搞到明明唱得好跳得好...
都要比人串...
tracy9357 3 years ago 18
This has been flagged as spam show
s0sad, 香港會有人無知成咁同埋咁無聊 囧
ivanmak7 3 years ago 4
我只可以講一句
sosad
lockfung 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
拜託你夜夜到此 一晚都不少
就這樣 到破曉 你引致我的床搖搖
dickylks 3 years ago
我都唔明點解有d fans會咁樣睇自己既偶象
人地容祖兒唔忘本
多謝番d幫過佢、俾過錢佢洗既老細
d fans又自己對號入座
真係奇怪
AveiroWong 3 years ago
@AveiroWong 俾過錢佢駛?點解?點俾?點解俾?俾完又點?俾之前做過D咩?容祖兒係一個咩人唔重要,最重要係...楊受成係咩人?成龍係咩人?佢公司D高層同大陸D客係咩人?楊受成係越南賭場o既拍擋係咩人?金三角D軍頭係咩人?英皇係一間咩公司?所有野,人在做,天在看。
honghey2002 1 year ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
容祖兒真正既意思係咪咁
我真係5信你地會5知囉
cmantong 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我諗唔知果個係你lo, 天真到以為入得英重會唔洗同人發生關係
cammycammy 3 years ago 45
哈 乜你估其他公司果d歌手 唔洗同老闆發生關係? 我諗你都幾天真wo 以為淨係英皇係咁?
fung174138 3 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
佢真係講真
之前有老細小過佢
CHOYJJJJJ 3 years ago 19
This has been flagged as spam show
呢d叫"鬼拍後尾怎", 自己講出真相
cammycammy 3 years ago 19
This has been flagged as spam show
都係講真心話
pikcheong 3 years ago 21
This has been flagged as spam show
白痴容祖兒fans
thinkingalone 3 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
哈哈 ~ 唔知有幾多個老細會同佢發生關係呢
shinglai 3 years ago 19
This has been flagged as spam show
too many!!! haha.....
paulamcnight 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
JACKIE CHAN, MR YEUNG.....WHO ELSE?
aj3247 3 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
中文太差了
royli2006 3 years ago
-_-! Joey geh表達方式真係有待改進~~~
storeunlimitied 3 years ago 7
佢d言語表達方式好鬼特別-.-"
windbell315 3 years ago 14
i knew it...how else can she get all those awards
petercollins09 3 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
28歲的做左淫野都唔使講到出面啊
royli2006 3 years ago 14
joey forever
cutiechae 3 years ago
呢句5值得討論.. = =
不過可以比個位人地話佢咁解姐
barrysxange 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
曲線!屌你老冇
hi1997 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我老冇話5比你屌,想屌就屌自已個老冇
同埋你知5知'曲線'點用
barrysxange 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
joey fans ? i fuck you!
hi1997 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我都同Joey發生過關係,haha!~
hi1997 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
好過某老姑婆無人要
慘到要貼仔
RafaelTsang 3 years ago
Respect other singers please!
asukaxP 3 years ago 7
could u translate what joey said
cutiechae 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
thank everyone who had sex with me this year
cammycammy 3 years ago
^ comment is for RafaelTsang's rude comment...
asukaxP 3 years ago
Comment removed
tracycheuk 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
做雞係咁做
cheunglim 3 years ago 11
This has been flagged as spam show
唉..某人D fans唔抵得..真系cheap...
JFkaki 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
千嬅fans始終係千嬅fans
最鐘意抹黑容祖兒!
phylogist 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我同你老母發生過關係呀@o@
lara5842 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
joey好明顯係講緊笑啦,小題大做
sukicy 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我都係咁話
ilovedogsncats 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
唔識講野就唔識講野啦...佢連講野都唔識講。。仲講咩笑啊...唱歌吧啦
cyrusbenny 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
你又點知佢幾時係講笑幾時係講錯野呀
你係佢本人咩
ting1511 3 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
我當然唔知佢幾時講笑幾時講錯野啦...但佢講親野我都覺得佢係講野1舊舊咁 ..連小學生背書都不如...哈哈。。。
cyrusbenny 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
不知所謂..
KIU06071979 3 years ago 4
年年都有金句爆出黎
果然係8連霸勁爆女歌手
實至名歸
dicky902 3 years ago 20
This has been flagged as spam show
我諗佢呢次失言都有排搞-,-!
ricolam4532 3 years ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
哇 咩佢咁坦白
不過唔駛講 個個都知架啦=]
yiukristy 3 years ago 13