Added: 3 years ago
From: minirausch
Views: 27,434
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (19)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • set theory is the prostitution of European XX music theory and history... don't blame Webern

  • @DaveSmey The development of serial music is not based on "fancy chords". This would make the whole issue a matter of taste. But when Schoenberg and his pupils left tonality behind, they were in the danger to become "musical outlaws". They felt the necessity of a "new order" to make composing in greater structures possible again. For every form of classical music until 1910 was based on tonality. Set theory was no idea "created at the desk" but the end of a struggle "in the middle of nowhere".

  • When you analyze the Bagatelles (which are as influenced by medieval techniques as those of Schoenberg), you learn they are probably the most concentrated music ever written. One of them is only *nine measures long* but manages to suggest an *entire sonata rondo form*.

  • I actually think it sounds so funny. It sounds like they're all screaming.

  • Some of the most beautiful, almost saintly, music ever written.

  • I was 10/11 when I first heard of Webern, Schoenberg, Berio, etc. Now I'm over 40, and I still like them very much. The first impression I received was of extreme freedom! "Expression" is the word I think of... Thanks for uploading. The "6 bagattelles" is exactly what I started with!

  • @RobertoTifi

    You're right, it does give the impression of freedom: but it's really extreme order, not extreme freedom, that Webern is getting across.

  • These were the first serial compositions I enjoyed listening to, and where I could say I finally got it. Thanks for posting!

  • @jmckaskle

    Strictly speaking, the bagatelles for string quartet are free atonality, not serial, but I'm glad you "got it"!

  • @WrestlingHeretic I agree its not serial but i would argue that this work can be applied to set theory. Not as free atonal as one might assume. However, I'm sure plenty of free atonality has been subject to set theory analysis and relationships found. The question is what was Webern thinking? Not about sets I presume.

  • @zebmcl - Ah, but sets are just fancy constellations of intervals - it's not as foreign to traditional musical thinking as you might assume. You can look at his mentor Schoenberg's search for interesting new chords as one source - it's just a small leap from constructing weird chords to spreading them around in a more abstract way (horizontally and vertically), and BOOM you've got the origins of set theory. I'd recommend the writings of George Perle as a more down-to-earth approach to sets.

  • what are these paintings?? I like them a lot.

  • ... circa 1911... wow...

  • Minatures of great beauty.

  • I saw the Emerson Quartet perform these. Great music.

  • magnifico

  • Krawutzi Kaputzi!!!

  • hurray!

  • Yes, I know the Lasalle's too, fine renderings. One instantly recognizes them. I'd be thinking to upload some of them.

    Nice work.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more