It's not even about being mean, and we're not even saying that she does not have the talent, she is just not vocally ready for the role. No one is gonna like it, it's not going to be good. Simple as that.
The sad part is probably most of Taylor's fans have never seen the musical or know whats its about. This story is emotional and depressing, and I wouldn't be surprised if her fans will come out of the movie saying "Y U HAVE TO DIE TAYLOR?"
@MusicMakesItBetter21 Her fans are happy for her! Just because you think that way doesn't mean everybody thinks that way. I'm really open about her portraying this role. Aren't you a little quick to judge? No, it doesn't suck to be her. She's beautiful, famous, classy, rich and people love her.
@variel2 Not really... read these comments... none are possitive about taylor.... yea shes talented and beautiful and and classy and rich and famous but she will be a HORRIBLE eponine...
hey i made a cover of this song. it's my first video and it'd be boss if you could check it out and tell me if i'm any good and if i should make any more covers. thanks! xx
Yeah, why the hell is Taylor Swift playing Eponine in the movie? I mean, I love Taylor. But, NOOOOOOOOOOO! Shes going to ruin Eponine :( She is a great singer, but not STRONG enough to be her. Besides, having a pop star in the movie might ruin it for everyone
@Vikstarararaahah I don't like Glee per say, but I don't think they killed it. Lea Michele has a very theatrical and broadway voice, and pulls it off pretty well.
@asskickerone Yeah you're right she has got a good voice, but in glee they do auto tune it so much and I think that's what ruins it! She sounds good without it, she doesn't need it!
SO PUMPED FOR THE MOVIE. I mean, c'mon... Russell Crowe, Hugh Jackman, Aaron Tveit, Amanda Seyfriend, and either Taylor Swift or Lea Michele. This movie will be PERFECTION.
weird in the origional cast version it began like "and now im all alone again no where to go no one to turn to. did not want your money sir i came out here cuz i was told to, and now the night is near..."
Really, cmon. Love Taylor Swift, but you GOTTA go for Lea Michelle (from Glee) for the movie... she's famous too, and is just absolutely amazing live! Check out her "On My Own" performance
I really didnt want to say this bc I LOVE Taylor Swift, But I also LOVE Scarlett Johansson, and Les Mis is one of three all time fav musicals and I mean this with absolute respect for the music. BUT TAYLOR AS EPONINE IN THE UPCOMING MOVIE-MUSICAL PRODUCTION! No, taylor, NO! You SHOULD NOT have tried out for that! U cant really sing! AHHH, I am sory I am saying this, but Scarlett or some others (LEA)WOULD have been much better! HOLLYWOOD OUGHT2 b SHAMFUL! DISSING SCARLETT FOR TAYLOR? NO! NO!!!
@esmurko1 OMG PLEASE NO TELL ME THIS IS NOT TRUE!!! TELL ME THIS IS NOT TRUE. why couldn't god wait till i was a famous singer/ actress='( now i wana die.
It's a musical for goodness sake. The musical American Idiot is sung through but it's not an opera. Furthermore operas employ pure operatic voices like Juan Diego Flores m
We need this hit song on the top 10! On the Radio. Someone please let's get beautiful music on the radio. And I know it's only in my mind. My idea is just a river....
Hello! I did a cover of this amazing song on my channel, and though nothing lives up to the original, it would be really great if anyone would check mine out! Thanks!
No offense to anyone, but Kaho Shimada's version of On My Own on the complete symphonic recording blows Lea Salonga's version out of the water. There's so much more emotion and she learned the entire song phonetically because she doesn't speak English.
I love the rythm, but what I really think makes the lyrics. "I love but when the night is over he is gone the river's just a river..." an actually love song about the happiness of someone else no matter if they love them or not! A wonderful song sang by a wonderful person! Lea Salonga <3 <3
I love this song to bits ♥ "On my own, pretending he's beside me, all alone I walk with him till morning, without him I feel his arms around me, and when I lose my way I close my eyes, and he has found me" That is how I feel about my secret crush ♥ "I love him but only on my own"
@Jakebrad4 Just as those who work on the stage differentiate between Musical Theatre; and the "Legitimate Stage" even though you will find both genres on Broadway and the West End in the UK.
@haute03 Thats not Lea she's more nasal and sounds more pop music like this is the broadway version this sounds more like Sutton Foster but I don't think it's her.
@MyCatSaraphina . You obviously don't know anything about Broadway. You sound like you've never seen the play,at all. I bet you've never seen any broadway plays, at all. Stop making comments on something you haven't got the slightest idea of. This IS the voice of Ms Salonga! I bet you don't even know what a nasal sound is, or maybe you are referring to leah michelle of Glee , instead of lea salonga.
@649999able Hell no don't tell me that I've seen 21 Broadway musicals and after I saw this vid I didn't know who i finally realized u were talking about Lea Salonga I thought u were talking about Lea Michelle. But I'v been in allot of musicals at community theaters.
Technically Les Mis is an Opera because the entire show is singing except two lines...
--I know I hate when people post this kinda stuff in their comments...but I desperately (obviously) want to know what people think of my video of me singing some of On My Own...if u care, they're my only vids posted so far...sooo yeah..please watch? (:
@AncientHistoryBuff Untrue. Les Mis is widely considered one of the best musicals of all time, say what you like but singing is one of the most emotive forms of communication that we have. To tell the tale of a man constantly hounded by the police for a crime that was insignificant singing is entirely necissary, The music tells the raw frustrations of a trapped man as he longs to keep his promise and protect his adopted daughter from all of the hells of a poverty stricken urban environment.
@williamswadling, that's your opinion. i like musicals like The Phantom Of The Opera (both the movie and stage show; I saw them in that order), but Les Miserables, in my opinion, simply DOES NOT lend itself out as a musical, in my opinion.
@AncientHistoryBuff As I said before. This isnt just my opinion, it is widely considered by many people. Both the Phantom and Les mis are right up there. And the concept of singing being the most emotive form of communication isnt opinion. Its been proven that the same message portrayed by song is far more effective than the same through normal speech and body language
@AncientHistoryBuff I respect your opinion, but I would like to point out one thing, its technically an opera, not a musical. A musical is where singing and speaking takes place, an opera only contains singing minus one or two spoken lines at most. I just wanted to point out a bit of terminology.
@BellumTabula an opera is normally full on singing and more of a simple story line; a musical is more acting with music and a more complex story line. so it is a tough call, because les mis is only singing, but is quite a complicated story and even if everything is sung, it's sung very clearly so that is is very comprehensible. so in this case, saying that les mis is not really an opera would even be a compliment, because the story line is so sophisticated :)
whoever came up with the idea to turn one of the greatest novels ever written into a stage musical should be horsewhipped. At over 1,000 pages long, the novel is much too epic for the confines of a 3 hour theatrical performance.
I love les mis (although I didn't understand half of it becasue I'm only 12) but I'm teaching myself this song and hope to sing it at a concert or something.
Love the vulnerability she manages to convey through her notes. Incredible. @MyZebraAteYourMom Lea is fillipino, and I perosnally didn't like Ruffelle's version. :/ Sorry. By the way, this recording was called the 'Dream Cast' for a reason.
I don't understand why people love this. I guess becuase American viewers like it, as she is american? But I've seen the west end UK version, and at the start its lovely and hushed- not like this where its loud and shaky. it needs to be from feeling, not belting it out! sorry, my opinion.
Love Taylor, but I really don't think she can pull off Eponine vocally. The role is just too different in vocal style for her.
CalisthenicsLuver 1 day ago
I don't understand the reason she over enunciates to that degree, it doesn't sound natural.
Symphonious7 3 days ago
It's not even about being mean, and we're not even saying that she does not have the talent, she is just not vocally ready for the role. No one is gonna like it, it's not going to be good. Simple as that.
dominicanmami02 3 days ago
isn't this lea salonga?
jamiepriscille 4 days ago
@jamiepriscille it is
saralbruno 4 days ago
Can't wait to see Taylor as Eponine! Don't dismiss her just like that and don't underestimate her. She might surprise. :)
variel2 5 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The sad part is probably most of Taylor's fans have never seen the musical or know whats its about. This story is emotional and depressing, and I wouldn't be surprised if her fans will come out of the movie saying "Y U HAVE TO DIE TAYLOR?"
yellowwinged 5 days ago
OMG I wanted lea michele so bad for this part. -___-
snlproductions1 5 days ago 2
i bet taylor feels really bad about herself... there is not one american whos happy for her.
HA. SUCKS TO BE YOU TAY TAYYY
MusicMakesItBetter21 5 days ago
@MusicMakesItBetter21 Her fans are happy for her! Just because you think that way doesn't mean everybody thinks that way. I'm really open about her portraying this role. Aren't you a little quick to judge? No, it doesn't suck to be her. She's beautiful, famous, classy, rich and people love her.
variel2 5 days ago
@variel2 Not really... read these comments... none are possitive about taylor.... yea shes talented and beautiful and and classy and rich and famous but she will be a HORRIBLE eponine...
MusicMakesItBetter21 3 days ago
@MusicMakesItBetter21 You can't say that just like that. How can you be so sure? It's not even out yet.
variel2 3 hours ago
hey i made a cover of this song. it's my first video and it'd be boss if you could check it out and tell me if i'm any good and if i should make any more covers. thanks! xx
dancinglilpolarbear 5 days ago
its official: taylor swift is defiantly playing Eponine :(
DatingExperiment 5 days ago
@DatingExperiment is it possible to die of disappointment and sadness? cause if so...i gata call 911
saralbruno 4 days ago
90 likes a i will make a cover :-) xox
AussieMusoxx 6 days ago 2
i dont like this version...too fast...
xxpoisonkiss92xx 6 days ago
......this song just describes me.....
omgitsnotime4goodbye 1 week ago
singing this in cores at school
zeldabeatle9 1 week ago
this is LEA SALONGA'S VOICE right?
asteeg1412 1 week ago 4
Why Taylor Swift? Why? They really couldn't find someone else?
matthewtyler92 1 week ago 2
I absolutely CANNOT believe Taylor Swift is going to be Eponine... if I was Lea Michele, I would be PISSED.
tuityfruity12aj 2 weeks ago 31
@tuityfruity12aj taylor swift can do it you know. don't underestimate her!
shanelovestaylor13 1 week ago in playlist 548 Heartbeats (songs)
@tuityfruity12aj if I was the whole world, I'd be pissed.
dominicanmami02 3 days ago
im strangely attracted to that girl on the front.
weirdStranger5 2 weeks ago
@weirdStranger5 she's like 12 dude...
SnareDrummer26 1 week ago
A place near me is doing Les Miserables. I'm thinking of auditioning, and Eponine is my dream role, but I suck sooo much at singing =(
dottiedots221 2 weeks ago
@dottiedots221 I'd say go for it! Break a leg :D
fluorescence94 2 weeks ago
@fluorescence94 You're so sweet! Thank you, but I'm REALLY bad. I'm trying to get voice lessons. haha Some better girl will get it :(
dottiedots221 2 weeks ago
Yeah, why the hell is Taylor Swift playing Eponine in the movie? I mean, I love Taylor. But, NOOOOOOOOOOO! Shes going to ruin Eponine :( She is a great singer, but not STRONG enough to be her. Besides, having a pop star in the movie might ruin it for everyone
dottiedots221 2 weeks ago 11
Comment removed
YoureNotLaura 2 weeks ago
can't wait for taylor swift to do this!
midgetgem3000 2 weeks ago
Glee killed this song :( beautiful though!
Vikstarararaahah 2 weeks ago
@Vikstarararaahah I don't like Glee per say, but I don't think they killed it. Lea Michele has a very theatrical and broadway voice, and pulls it off pretty well.
asskickerone 2 weeks ago 6
@asskickerone Yeah you're right she has got a good voice, but in glee they do auto tune it so much and I think that's what ruins it! She sounds good without it, she doesn't need it!
Vikstarararaahah 2 weeks ago
SO PUMPED FOR THE MOVIE. I mean, c'mon... Russell Crowe, Hugh Jackman, Aaron Tveit, Amanda Seyfriend, and either Taylor Swift or Lea Michele. This movie will be PERFECTION.
thenextbigthing100 3 weeks ago
weird in the origional cast version it began like "and now im all alone again no where to go no one to turn to. did not want your money sir i came out here cuz i was told to, and now the night is near..."
OneLifetoChange 3 weeks ago
guys stop complaining about taylor and enjoy this beautiful song
LalaGirl695 3 weeks ago
Really, cmon. Love Taylor Swift, but you GOTTA go for Lea Michelle (from Glee) for the movie... she's famous too, and is just absolutely amazing live! Check out her "On My Own" performance
Shicks0 3 weeks ago 3
<3 i refuse to even hear taylor sing this..
breakingdawnsthebest 3 weeks ago
taylor shit is gonna sing this??? ewwwww
RabbitSlayer5 3 weeks ago 3
Taylor swift singing this?? HA!!! Come on just cast someone else who can actually sing.
bolanomi132 3 weeks ago 3
i swear i watch Lea Salonga's On My Own every day.... i regret absolutely nothing.
coynie3 3 weeks ago
it is a such a good chance for Taylor Swift .if you think she can`t do it,do it by yourself .
yvonne13236 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I really didnt want to say this bc I LOVE Taylor Swift, But I also LOVE Scarlett Johansson, and Les Mis is one of three all time fav musicals and I mean this with absolute respect for the music. BUT TAYLOR AS EPONINE IN THE UPCOMING MOVIE-MUSICAL PRODUCTION! No, taylor, NO! You SHOULD NOT have tried out for that! U cant really sing! AHHH, I am sory I am saying this, but Scarlett or some others (LEA)WOULD have been much better! HOLLYWOOD OUGHT2 b SHAMFUL! DISSING SCARLETT FOR TAYLOR? NO! NO!!!
vocaltalent1 3 weeks ago
What were the directors thinking, casting Taylor Swift as Eponine?! Gag.
AwesomeSauce297 3 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos 8
this song makes me wanna cry........ its beautiful but sad. and taylor swift is playing her??? god help us.......
IrunwithWerewolves96 3 weeks ago 7
i really love taylor swift as a songwriter and artist, but there is NO WAY she can do this song justice.
jwall310 3 weeks ago
taylor swift got the role as eponine for the movie :(
ImUrFanGirl 3 weeks ago 4
lea salonga is the best eponine.... and now here comes taylor swift!
ovitatirac 3 weeks ago
@ovitatirac I. Know. I wanna throw up on her vocal chords. Taylor's, I mean. I agree, Lea Salonga is the best one! Taylor canNOT sing this song.
SamanthaAaron 3 weeks ago 6
Mmm... Taylor Swift playing this part in the upcoming film makes me want to cringe
esmurko1 3 weeks ago 99
@esmurko1 really?
shanelovestaylor13 1 week ago in playlist 548 Heartbeats (songs)
@esmurko1 OMG PLEASE NO TELL ME THIS IS NOT TRUE!!! TELL ME THIS IS NOT TRUE. why couldn't god wait till i was a famous singer/ actress='( now i wana die.
saralbruno 4 days ago
@esmurko1 With that news, I am now going to go kill something. Throw knives at a passing stranger or something.
tuggymonster1 3 days ago
LEA SALONGA <3 :DDDDDDDD
ltm8901 4 weeks ago
The 86 dislikes are heartless justin bieber fans who dont understand what real music is.
koalalover421 1 month ago 4
@koalalover421 yes compared to the 2030 people who know what real music is, they dont matter
OneLifetoChange 3 weeks ago
beautiful song
81jenster 1 month ago
@Jakebrad4 @SeptemberAngle1 @Music101775 YAH! ITS ALMOST AS ANNOYING AS WHEN PEOPLE CALL AN OPERA A MUSICAL!
NikkerFilms 1 month ago
@NikkerFilms Well, it's technically not an 'opera'. It's a 'sung-through musical'.
AwesomeActress101 1 month ago
@AwesomeActress101 touche
NikkerFilms 1 month ago
This pic reminds me of Saint Ursula school
tavish11 1 month ago
Continuation, or voices like Jussi bjorling. Operas don't have voices that are classically trained only.
s9747324b 1 month ago
It's a musical for goodness sake. The musical American Idiot is sung through but it's not an opera. Furthermore operas employ pure operatic voices like Juan Diego Flores m
s9747324b 1 month ago
Um, I'm pretty sure that Les Mis is an opera....
wickedlesmisfan 1 month ago
@wickedlesmisfan it is a sung-through musical.
AwesomeActress101 1 month ago
Wow! Les Miserables has to be my favorite PLAY!
IncredibleGoliath 1 month ago
@IncredibleGoliath sung-through musical.
AwesomeActress101 1 month ago
@Jakebrad4 I HATE when people call musicals a play! It makes me mad!
Music101775 1 month ago
I sung this song for a competition and got 1st place and im singing it again in my schools musical i figured this lady should b better at this!
DancerOnTheLow 1 month ago
this is beautiful by lea salonga I love her!!!
This is what i call music!!
arielbottom 1 month ago
We need this hit song on the top 10! On the Radio. Someone please let's get beautiful music on the radio. And I know it's only in my mind. My idea is just a river....
mrscardinal1 1 month ago
Comment removed
Aradessa12 1 month ago
Comment removed
Aradessa12 1 month ago
Comment removed
Aradessa12 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hello! I did a cover of this amazing song on my channel, and though nothing lives up to the original, it would be really great if anyone would check mine out! Thanks!
elenicakes 1 month ago
Like this if your heart breaks for her whenever you hear this song.
koalalover421 1 month ago 87
No offense to anyone, but Kaho Shimada's version of On My Own on the complete symphonic recording blows Lea Salonga's version out of the water. There's so much more emotion and she learned the entire song phonetically because she doesn't speak English.
EmilyRHarris93 1 month ago
my teacher wants me to use this song for home work
TheDramaqueen143 2 months ago
@TheDramaqueen143 mine too :)
Mlssmusic 1 month ago
@TheDramaqueen143 Hahaha. Your teacher's got a keen sense of humor then. Don't copy!!
SamanthaGirafa 1 month ago
i'm doing this in my school concert, love this song but absolutely terrified!
fionaasaurus 2 months ago
I love the rythm, but what I really think makes the lyrics. "I love but when the night is over he is gone the river's just a river..." an actually love song about the happiness of someone else no matter if they love them or not! A wonderful song sang by a wonderful person! Lea Salonga <3 <3
varsitydanceJFK 2 months ago
@Jakebrad4 YES!!!!!!
hopgrand 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
please check out my video!!!
rubygrail1 2 months ago
I love this song to bits ♥ "On my own, pretending he's beside me, all alone I walk with him till morning, without him I feel his arms around me, and when I lose my way I close my eyes, and he has found me" That is how I feel about my secret crush ♥ "I love him but only on my own"
IlariaCeline 2 months ago 2
This is random but.... Does it bug anyone else when people call a MUSICAL a PLAY?!?!?!?!?
Jakebrad4 2 months ago 104
@Jakebrad4 no because a musical is what we got from fusing opera + play
wogus86 1 month ago
@Jakebrad4 It bugs my brother, he's an actor. And my mother (she is too).
noname4422 1 month ago
Comment removed
NikkerFilms 1 month ago
@Jakebrad4 you hav no idea.
navyluvr08 1 month ago
Comment removed
NikkerFilms 1 month ago
@Jakebrad4 absolutely! and then they ask whats the difference?!?!?!?
SeptemberAngel1 1 month ago
@Jakebrad4 Sometimes but I du it too sometimes so I can't say anything lol
fortheluvofme 1 month ago
@Jakebrad4 Just as those who work on the stage differentiate between Musical Theatre; and the "Legitimate Stage" even though you will find both genres on Broadway and the West End in the UK.
cidspimms 1 month ago
@Jakebrad4 I do professional Musical Theater and my mom constantly calls the shows I'm in plays. Makes me crazy. -.-"
OfficialKatieAlexis 3 weeks ago 3
@Jakebrad4 No.
theghostisjack 3 weeks ago
@Jakebrad4 omg, yes!
AwesomeSauce297 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
Otset 2 weeks ago
@andrei112594 Lea Salonga is the voice of Mulan but not Jasmine. A quick trip to IMDB could have prevented your misinformation.
trevormichaelbs 2 months ago
@trevormichaelbs she did do the SINGING voice of jasmine just not the speaking voice, quick trip to imdb ...
missmcpirate 2 months ago
@trevormichaelbs She sang the A Whole New World (Aladdin 1)
try to search it on youtube.
alphalava 2 months ago
@trevormichaelbs she sang a whole new world ^^, try to search it...
andrei112594 1 month ago
@trevormichaelbs No, she's also the singing voice of Jasmine.
dottiedots221 2 weeks ago
this is Lea Salonga, ...watch On My Own of Les Miserables 10th anniv
andrei112594 2 months ago
Great music, Great lyrics from the Great composer. Great Casts; Great Lea Salonga.
rawguan 2 months ago
Is it bad that I sing this song in Chilies and start fake crying...then everyone starts starring at me? :)
Jakebrad4 2 months ago
@Jakebrad4 nope. Not at all.
BrittanyMarie793 2 months ago
@Jakebrad4 rofl hmmm.... i guess it's not a great thing.... but hey -shrugs- you can't win 'em all ;]
ItzzRach 2 months ago
1,852 people have good taste of music
25823666 2 months ago
@25823666
Thx very much
inusword 2 months ago
This song used to be just another great song from Les Mis to me, but it became so much more to me when I was rejected by the girl I loved.
Now this is my favorite song in Les Mis.
I learned the feeling of Eponine's pain of unrequited love.
videosearcherwhenbor 2 months ago
this isint glee pople
azsv100 2 months ago
This isn't Lea
MsCittycat19 2 months ago
Everytime I listen to this I cry, and I am not ashamed of that. TuT
troggdorthesecond 2 months ago
this song is so heartfelt it put me to tears, i feel so bad for her... its a beautiful song thats for sure...
dreamdancer1823 2 months ago
I prefer frances Ruffelle's, but i think it's because i heard that version first and got used to it. This version is still amazing though!
xAxeI 2 months ago
Omg, Lea's voice is very beautiful.
CaliShandie 2 months ago
Im going to see les mis on wednesday in London. Ive wanted to ever since I did a singing workshop with the bbc a few years ago.. Wow im excited xD
73musicmusic 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@73musicmusic I just saw it this summer, it will blow your mind!!! Eponine is fantastic!
OperaWish 3 months ago
Les Mis is to theater what Citizen Kane is to film.
MasterCheifn343 3 months ago 23
This iz AMAZING!!!!!!! :D
kateandjaz1 3 months ago
is this Lea Salonga? I know that she did play Fantine or Eponine (maybe both) on Broadway at one point.
alyssheartsanime 3 months ago 2
@alyssheartsanime I'm not sure, but I think it's Lea... and if it's not her, there's a singer that sounds JUST like her :P
ethalinia 3 months ago
@alyssheartsanime
Yeah, I believe this is Lea singing.
haute03 3 months ago
@haute03 Thats not Lea she's more nasal and sounds more pop music like this is the broadway version this sounds more like Sutton Foster but I don't think it's her.
MyCatSaraphina 3 months ago
@MyCatSaraphina . You obviously don't know anything about Broadway. You sound like you've never seen the play,at all. I bet you've never seen any broadway plays, at all. Stop making comments on something you haven't got the slightest idea of. This IS the voice of Ms Salonga! I bet you don't even know what a nasal sound is, or maybe you are referring to leah michelle of Glee , instead of lea salonga.
649999able 2 months ago
@649999able Hell no don't tell me that I've seen 21 Broadway musicals and after I saw this vid I didn't know who i finally realized u were talking about Lea Salonga I thought u were talking about Lea Michelle. But I'v been in allot of musicals at community theaters.
MyCatSaraphina 2 months ago
@MyCatSaraphina ok we're good.
649999able 2 months ago
@alyssheartsanime This si Lea Salonga and she did indeed play both characters at the same time,in the same play.
SnitchSeeker 3 months ago
It seems like "pop-opera" would be a perfect term to describe Les Mis.
Drezin86 3 months ago
this song starts for me 1.42 <3
katieeeeeeeb 3 months ago 2
i cryed when i saw this... im an 18 year old starting qb at my highschool
SlimmyTalls 3 months ago 2
I love this song and les mis <3
hamiheart2 3 months ago
I adore this song, it actually made me cry when I saw Les Miserables.
BellumTabula 3 months ago
We did plies in ballet to this song today. And then it got stuck in my head. Not that that's ever a bad thing XD
KazeTeisei 3 months ago in playlist KazeTeisei's favorites
ONE OF MY FAV SONG EVER!!!!
Ramx26x 3 months ago
I love this song, she Sing it so beautifully!
Missiertjuuhh 3 months ago
Technically Les Mis is an Opera because the entire show is singing except two lines...
--I know I hate when people post this kinda stuff in their comments...but I desperately (obviously) want to know what people think of my video of me singing some of On My Own...if u care, they're my only vids posted so far...sooo yeah..please watch? (:
ChristinaElizabethR 3 months ago
as either a 4 hour movie or a 15-20 hour miniseries, Les Miserables would definitely work best as a visual medium, but NOT as a musical.
AncientHistoryBuff 4 months ago
@AncientHistoryBuff Untrue. Les Mis is widely considered one of the best musicals of all time, say what you like but singing is one of the most emotive forms of communication that we have. To tell the tale of a man constantly hounded by the police for a crime that was insignificant singing is entirely necissary, The music tells the raw frustrations of a trapped man as he longs to keep his promise and protect his adopted daughter from all of the hells of a poverty stricken urban environment.
williamswadling 4 months ago 3
@williamswadling, that's your opinion. i like musicals like The Phantom Of The Opera (both the movie and stage show; I saw them in that order), but Les Miserables, in my opinion, simply DOES NOT lend itself out as a musical, in my opinion.
AncientHistoryBuff 4 months ago
@AncientHistoryBuff As I said before. This isnt just my opinion, it is widely considered by many people. Both the Phantom and Les mis are right up there. And the concept of singing being the most emotive form of communication isnt opinion. Its been proven that the same message portrayed by song is far more effective than the same through normal speech and body language
williamswadling 4 months ago
@williamswadling, like i said, i like musicals, but I simply think that Les Miserables does NOT work as a musical. but whatever. to each his own.
AncientHistoryBuff 4 months ago
@AncientHistoryBuff I respect your opinion, but I would like to point out one thing, its technically an opera, not a musical. A musical is where singing and speaking takes place, an opera only contains singing minus one or two spoken lines at most. I just wanted to point out a bit of terminology.
BellumTabula 3 months ago
@BellumTabula, thanks.
AncientHistoryBuff 3 months ago
@BellumTabula, thanks. it still, in my opinion, doesn't work as an opera, though.
AncientHistoryBuff 3 months ago
@BellumTabula an opera is normally full on singing and more of a simple story line; a musical is more acting with music and a more complex story line. so it is a tough call, because les mis is only singing, but is quite a complicated story and even if everything is sung, it's sung very clearly so that is is very comprehensible. so in this case, saying that les mis is not really an opera would even be a compliment, because the story line is so sophisticated :)
acmulhern 3 months ago 3
whoever came up with the idea to turn one of the greatest novels ever written into a stage musical should be horsewhipped. At over 1,000 pages long, the novel is much too epic for the confines of a 3 hour theatrical performance.
AncientHistoryBuff 4 months ago
*tears* this is beautiful.... My friend is singing this for an audition!
ForsakenNobody 4 months ago
She's amazing. Eponine is by far the best character in this show. Well...female character anyway.
dreamerchick22 4 months ago 4
I have been asking to sing Les Mes in my school's glee club, and we are now doing On My Own. I am so happy. :)
paygeee 4 months ago 23
@paygeee am really happy to read this :)
best of luck singing On my own in glee club
ShandoCenarius 2 months ago in playlist Liked videos
@ShandoCenarius thanks ! :)
paygeee 2 months ago
love this song
brynncullingsmusic 4 months ago
The 78 dislikes are obviously from Cosette....
dramakid95 4 months ago 227
@dramakid95 You mean, Javert, do you not?
2bdefacto 2 months ago
@dramakid95 you just made my day
sweeneyskeligirl 2 months ago
poor rendition.
NKrader 4 months ago
Lea salonga is the best
emceemc21 4 months ago
is that samantha barks
MsOctoberstorm 4 months ago
@MsOctoberstorm no that is not samantha barks singing. Lea Salonga is singing this version.
JBmedia123 4 months ago
I love les mis (although I didn't understand half of it becasue I'm only 12) but I'm teaching myself this song and hope to sing it at a concert or something.
crazycatz4356 5 months ago 3
Les Miserables is an amazing show. Always put on with such passion and talent. I just wish it would come back to Toronto.
leedantom1980 5 months ago
The scene right after this song made me cry so much...best musical i've ever seen. Period.
JazzOfTheAncients 5 months ago
This is the song that fits me like no other song ever
SophisticatedLunatic 5 months ago 3
WHY ARE THEY STILL MAKING MUSCIALS, THEY KNOW THEY CAN'T TOP LES MIS, I'VE HEARD 3 SONGS AND I KNOW ITS EEEEEPIC!!! LIKE IF YOU HAVE EARS
computorboy77 7 months ago
JAVIER FONTANA sings this song just AMAZING.
marx2870 8 months ago
This is Lea Salonga and She's the best Eponine , ever!!
vampire26knight 8 months ago
the emotion and the spirit is in :) work of love
27serenity 9 months ago
had a go myself,please click on my name+take a look;) xxx
niamyhill2 10 months ago
Really makes a connection when you know how it feels..
LaCherryPanda 10 months ago 5
esta canción la cante en comedia musical!!
Laiila199 11 months ago
Love the vulnerability she manages to convey through her notes. Incredible. @MyZebraAteYourMom Lea is fillipino, and I perosnally didn't like Ruffelle's version. :/ Sorry. By the way, this recording was called the 'Dream Cast' for a reason.
melischang 11 months ago
This gives me goosebumps AMAZING GO GIRL:)
specialiris1 11 months ago
for god sake shut up people..........
sugerpea1 11 months ago 14
Lea is so AMAZING! <3
GeeWayIzMine 1 year ago
I don't understand why people love this. I guess becuase American viewers like it, as she is american? But I've seen the west end UK version, and at the start its lovely and hushed- not like this where its loud and shaky. it needs to be from feeling, not belting it out! sorry, my opinion.
MyZebraAteYourMom 1 year ago