Nine Inch Nails: Gave Up (1992)

[caco364]

I was feeling kind of bummed out before I started listening to this, but as soon as it was over I began to feel like a better person :)

[caco364]

Very dark, very bleak, but I can't help it loving this motherfucker. Trent Reznor Is GOD!

[aLadyGrey]

Wow, has Manson changed!

[hayzeydays]

awesome tune

[chrgi]

20 years ago and still better harder and more truthfull than anything around today

[TheMessianicManic]

This was made 20 years ago. I'm fucking old.

[caco364]

@TheMessianicManic I know what you mean dude I was 7 when this video was made, Now I'm 26 and on my way to hell. That's how old I think Trent was when he released this album LOL

[Calun3]

ღ♫(((¯`♥♪(♥♫(♥♪(♥♫d)))­`­♥‿♥­´­­(((b♫♥)♪♥)♫♥)♪♥´¯)))♫ღ

[harshlight7]

Reznor looks like he just blew his load at the end of this. Epic.

[FokkerTISM2]

This should have been the album version.

[PeaceWalk100]

omg manson...

[clubmanrob]

Whoah! Fantastic...Love it! Love the NIN..Legends...The Man is a total Legend!

[MegaNiggajoe]

Anyone else catch the "Fuck you steve" on the sequencer screen at 0:37? lol

[ALIENDNA14]

@MegaNiggajoe Good eye...!

[TheFilth89]

Marilyn Manson was always a wannabe-NIN...But nobody could reach Trent Reznor!

[AngelsOfAcid]

Hey, I know these kinda comments are generally annoying, but we're a hard rock band. And we'd love it if you could check out or channel. We just posted a new Vlog. Thank you so much :)

[RandomInOcity]

man i havn't watched this in forever and it still leaves me in AUHHHHHH

and marilyn's and trents beautifullnesss, well they still do that for me today

[wihyena69]

oh, wow. this CANNOT be 20 years ago!! :P i'm getting old!! lol

[matugman]

how old was manson there like 18???

[PhoenixValentine]

Being such a huge NIN and Manson fan, I'm having a hard time getting rid of this erection right now.

tehe, "hard.."

[lazyjain]

sometimes when i watch nin videos and i dont see robin in them i get a little sad

[falling325]

apart from Manson who is the guy with long hair?

[hippa2dahoppa2]

either vrenna or lohner i forget what the 2 looked like

[falling325]

@hippa2dahoppa2 Hmm so it makes him Lohner, 'cause Vrenna is playing drums ;)

[ollieroks]

@hippa2dahoppa2 Lohner wasn't in the band yet, he was still in Skrew.

[hazza5600]

before Marilyn Manson turned into the antichrist...haha

[SpiritCrisis]

God I miss rock

[naboba]

I remember hearing this song in some skatevideo back in the early ninetys.. thank god amazon allows you to search albums and listen to tracks! pure classic!

[WENCHY101]

Manson wearing a Genitorturers T-Shirt in a NIN video in the Tate house... LOVE IT!! :)

[kathrynj60]

shiney happy people holding hands lol

[kathrynj60]

these guys beat the hell outta this shit

[maynardfangirl]

I didn't know MM was in this song.

[Sion6]

@maynardfangirl He wasn't. This isn't the album version.

[GeorgeVreelandHill]

I live near where this house was.

It was torn down not long after this video was made.

George Vreeland Hill

[Moneyisnotanissue]

@GeorgeVreelandHill Why was it torn down?

[StickyInADarkBlueCut]

@GeorgeVreelandHill lol why did you say your username in your comment or is it that you based your user name on your comment?? Either way wtf? O.o

[MartyrLoserKing]

such a beautiful friendship they once had :')

[LEVELGAMINGNET]

PROFESSOR SNAPE :D

LOL

[santosh3260]

3 of the biggest icons of industrial metal..now if only NIN, Marilyn Manson, Filter, Ministry & Rammstein were to tour together like the "big 4" tour. We can name the tour "Industrial Toxic Waste" tour. Freaking Awesome tour that will be eh?

[THEMANOUTOFTHECAVE]

@santosh3260 They would probably kill each other before the tour would even start. Though yeah it would be awesome :D

By the way Skinny Puppy is missing!

[santosh3260]

@THEMANOUTOFTHECAVE ..LOL at the thought of them kicking each other's asses although i think Rammstein would win hands down. Till Lindemann alone could kick all their collective butts..Skinny Puppy, listening to them for the first time. pretty awesome..kind of like Godflesh.

[THEMANOUTOFTHECAVE]

@santosh3260 Skinny Puppy were the fore runners of Industrial Metal and helped creating NIN (Trent started his industrial career by performing with SP). Thing is all these bands have some rivalries somehow: Nivek (frontman of SP) called Trent a sellout and a feud ensued (though I think it's over now). MM and Trent presumably had one (it may still be going on); Ministry had one with NIN too. So yeah everybody would try to murder Reznor. It would be the Cluedo of Industrial Metal XD

[santosh3260]

@THEMANOUTOFTHECAVE .Thanks for the info, buddy. i have been listening to a couple more of their tracks.

[chrgi]

@santosh3260 keep lookin as there is a lot of produced stuff which is ok but like this was u need unproduced for them so much better peace

[cainmartel]

Wasn't this recorded in Le Pig?

[RyDawg084]

I just danced and head banged my head fucked...happy new year!!!...Thanks trent

[Kapricorn1]

fucking love this, happy new year people x

[LetsLeaveTown]

richard patrick

[DollyDoppel]

Marilyn when he used to be pretty ;)

[maynardfangirl]

@DollyDoppel God, he was beautiful. As was Reznor. :D

[IzabellaRitaSzendi]

I think, Sharon Tate's ghost was so f***ing glad about them.

[imlistening2it]

For anyone who doesnt know, the guitar player is the one that formed his band Filter. Check out there first album if you get a chance. not a fan of Filters later albums. we know what happens after your songs start showing up on the "top 5 at 9".

[romansoldierdude]

Dude, what's with the hair shift Trent has from 0:53 to 0:54? It's like "FWOOSH HAIR ON FOREHEAD". Editing FTW.

That said, this is the best version of Gave Up. Hands down (or Head Down).

[JermaineEvent]

@romansoldierdude Agreed. The absolute best version.

[hippa2dahoppa2]

he was getting jiggy with it and lost control

[thefirdblu]

@romansoldierdude There were two takes done

And they put em together

[mariojr4487]

love this video. my favorite version of "gave up".

[wrenchbender320]

Fuckin cornball music

[DocHolliday182]

nearly 20 years ago....my how things have changed

[naboba]

@DocHolliday182

crazy isn't it...

[DELlirous14]

Omfg!! Trent and Manson look sooo FUCKABLE!!!! XD

[SmelMyFinger]

Fucking Richard Patrick on guitar too... oh mey gaud.

[deadlifepuppetry]

O shit didn't they record this at the Sharon Tate house??

[videogeek27]

@deadlifepuppetry Yes, which was Trent's former home that he lived in. The house apparently still had the door with "PIG" written in blood on it, which he kept after moving out.

[coste111]

@deadlifepuppetry

Yes they did!!!

[TheMagicSpaceGhost]

i almost cant take the awesomeness.

[ThePorstar]

manson and trent

[axa269]

Marilyn Manson posing since '92

but still like him

[theebadnun]

manson and reznor-fucking sexy

[sunsweetsuitable]

im fingering myself right now

[residue102]

@sunsweetsuitable me too?!! In the butt!

[malonemuert]

That video is not that old. Reznor met Manson around 1994, maybe late 1993. It was specially recorded for Closure video compilation, around 1996/97 (last years of friendship with Manson). Patrick and the rest were just guests, as they played with Reznor round time it was recorded.

[loganalexa]

@malonemuert It says on the NIN channel that it was from 1992

[CliffRomer]

damn damn good damn damn good good good damn damn good damn....good.

[MotyaJasha]

Trent Reznor looks like crazy motherfucker in this clip. In a good way xD

[iamthecorsetgirl]

love the song

[ItsMESyL88]

Richard Patrick who played with NIN and later founded Filter is in this vid too...

[naboba]

@ItsMESyL88

what are some good songs from filter?

[willbtill]

which one is manson i can;t even tell

[rskityaev]

@willbtill Guitarist with errr...Black guitar :)

[chessinfantry]

@willbtill wow....kids today are mindnumbingly....lame

[xXMissPoodlePantsXx]

LOVES IT!

[SuperZombiechic]

hey, theres a midget playing the keyboard

[Eraser1994]

i didnt realize how good this song is until i saw the video... now and i think that 49 people dont gave up but i do i give up to this song

[h748syb]

Stunning

[lone0029]

Good times, when trent reznor creates Music and Manson looks human

[AshliiSays]

Jizzyastic guys thanks for inviting me

[cinemavirtualis]

Richard Patrick fuckin ROCKS in this video!

[therichards2000]

@cinemavirtualis

imo he doesn't get nearly enough credit for his role in the early nin

[pleasureavalanche]

The 'broken' version of this song is so much better.

[AcmeNewsLLC]

One of my all time favorite songs on one of my all time favorite albums.

[Metal4evar13]

This is actually better than the eps version.

[jonDDA]

Haha at 0:35 the sequence is called "FUck you steve"

[gmacpurifier]

Still think this is one of their better videos...

[SHINTANYA]

tsss <3 . <3

[bonniebloodworth]

smashed up my sanity.....

[lilly669]

Still in love with this after all these years. Hot!

[JermaineEvent]

I wish NIN still sounded like this....

[gombie]

wasn't there another music video of this? From the Broken Movie?

[justmeleslie]

cant get enough of those drums... like a freight train :)

[bonniebloodworth]

smashed up my sanity,smashed up integrity.....love NIN!!!

[leucomaofthecornea]

does Jared Leto really never fucking age?

[NayveeMan]

@leucomaofthecornea - hahaha its brian leisgang from Filter.

[azurell666]

Oh, Trent looks so hot in this vid.... ._.

[riquelmestheshit]

barefoot bass drumming? make yourself at home.

[AlcmenaChan]

This is the song that made me love NIN about 4-5 years ago. I ll never get bored of this.

[D3lud3d]

just danced around my room like fuck

[enlightenedwarrior16]

marilyn manson looks so.... young and innocent

[sidewaysfcs0718]

@enlightenedwarrior16 funny how a teenager with a piercing in his lip, long black hair and a shitload of rings on his arms plus tatoos looks innocent

next to the manson we all know that is.

[bennyboy4ever]

cant decide which was the better song of the decade for NIN, Gave Up, or Were in this together?

[DoubleIvan]

Okay. Reznor, Warner, Patrick, Vrenna, Liesegang...it's like a who's who of 90's industrial. Am I missing anyone?

[coldstaind91]

@DoubleIvan Maynard from Tool....but the whole fucking video would fucking explode in epicness.

[edub77]

@DoubleIvan

Nivek Ogre and Cevin Key from Skinny Puppy

[loganalexa]

@DoubleIvan Ogre there would have been cool too.

[jordansthiary]

Yeah MR MANSON Rockzzz THE guitar!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[harassed09]

@jordansthiary He's pretending! Manson is only pretending to play the guitar, says so in his autobiography... He's not a guitar person.

[Flales001]

marilyn manson talked about this in his book

[OctopusCarcass80]

@ryanjofre u are retarded, do you really think he didnt know what house that was? it must suck to be a complete idiot. that was the whole point of setting up a studio there, to make music in the tate house. please die

[marivani1]

Who gives a shit about ugly ass Marilyn Manson? It's all about Richard Patrick.

[brnmre]

Brian Warner (a Mr. no-one) before became Marilyn Manson

[saveuslayer]

@brnmre and now everybody know who he is

[czechman1234]

Its very interesting . MM cant play guitar in this video. ( sry for my english)

[ryanjofre]

Marilyn Manson is one Ugly Mother Fucker.

That's such a Trip that Trent Didn't know that that was the Tate House and took the *Pig* door and put it on his Studio in New Orleans!

The Live Version of this Song on the Beside you in Time DVD(2006 Concert Era) is fuking perfect. This one is Ok!

[Vodevil110287]

Damn it! I still remember when I first saw this video. I hadn't heard about NIN and it caught my eye only 'cuz I saw Manson on it. Then I became a NIN fan.... I wish I was 14 again...

[zombieMM7]

MARILYN MANSON!!!

[slipknotaregods123]

@zombieMM7 hell ya

[TheNewMusicNetwork]

uh martin atkins drummed on this, not that other guy. this vid was recorded later.

[mdhookey]

God, this almost 20 years old...I am getting old :(

[darkdragonred19]

This is a true thrash song mosh baby mosh

[TheDudeWithPants420]

WOW they all look so young... I miss those days

[frozenbloodbullets]

hahaha I love how manson looks normal in this video...

[fruckles]

@frozenbloodbullets its my favorite look for him, aside from 'the man that you fear'

[phagtacular]

@frozenbloodbullets LOL that's Manson? That's hilarious, it looks like Michael Wincott from The Crow!

[ToxicityGuitar]

@frozenbloodbullets what is "normal"? without make up and contact lenses?

[buuski]

@ToxicityGuitar

duh

[sidewaysfcs0718]

most people dont realise why manson and trent had that huge fight ...it was something that had to happen for antichrist superstar to happen

during the recording of antichrist superstar the entire band plus trent where experimenting with drugs, sleep depravation, pain rituals, and also a home-made isolation chamber , basicly they wanted to get so fucked up that everything deep down in their sub-concious would make it on the album raw

and what a fucking beast of an album that was ...

[csurowka]

@sidewaysfcs0718 - Surrealist artists did a lot of the same thing to dig out their subconscious and paint it on the canvas. However, I do agree with you, Antichrist Superstar was/is MM's most compelling album.

[adolfoMK1]

They had the greatest gay orgies

[KwiteGiphted]

I love this

[OctopusCarcass80]

i cant get enough of this. wish i had a time machine to go back to the 90s

[frostr1]

@OctopusCarcass80 me to, music is just not like the good old days.

[rainethesage]

I heard that there's supposed to be ANOTHER music video for Gave Up, a rare one that almost no-one has ever seen.

Apparently, it was so disturbing, it was universally banned. I also heard it was included as part of the disturbing Broken Movie.

[oswalddeath]

I want to dress exactly like Rich in this everyday of my life. Tucking in shirts is so boss.

[Mafila]

Holy crap this is back when Manson looked somewhat normal. Trent definitely is a way better musician than Marilyn Manson. In my opinion Manson does too many covers, focuses too much on making a fashion statement, and doesn't have even half as many quality original tracks as Nine Inch Nails.

[sidewaysfcs0718]

@Mafila he only has like 5 covers...

[KateyG17]

And marilyn for that matter, while we are wishing for impossible things...

[KateyG17]

I wish I was one of the millions of lucky women that had trent in this year! ;-)

[8BitJay]

Does anyone know if Trent actually likes using 57s for vox, or were they just for show in the videos?

[tulanderio]

thumbs up for Richard Patrick!

[TyJamesTT]

[]\[] [] []/[] F T W

[chloemcc89]

damn it, he's sexy

[Chrisgodoflard]

Probably the rarest scene with Marilyn Manson with a guitar. 

[MacCrackCan]

Filter ,Marilyn Manson ==> NIN

[WildChild80Style]

Perfect little dream, the kind that hurts the most....

[ThePorstar]

omg ..trent +manson .. PURE SEX !!!

[ScreamingPat]

Trent+Manson=fucking end of 'suicide,die,grow, burnthisworld,hate,love,fuckyo­u,andme,music'

[thecompleteofficial]

20 years later and this STILL TOTALLY ROCKS.

[Colombchaos]

WHO'S THE DRUMMER???

[poshi12]

@Colombchaos

Pretty sure its Chris Vrenna

[gangurobitch]

@Colombchaos Trent's then hetero life-mate.

[greenriver]

richard patrick still plays here.. nice

[Stowx111]

Marilyn Manson ;)

[iamnotagroupie]

I'm actually crying at the sight of a young Trent Reznor and Marilyn Manson together. It's just too much beauty for one video.

[rOcKeRzAdDiCk]

F Record Labels. Go Trent!!!

[Biggie3057]

Broken version will make you shit bricks.

Truth.

[gothrose1986]

Marilyn Manson is so hot on this vid! What happened? lol

[gangurobitch]

@gothrose1986 Too many drugs and Twinkies.

[Invadertoden]

nin = filter + manson

[DeafMuteZombie]

Greatest Ever.

[ThePorstar]

marilyn + trent <3

[Fehkia]

two of my favorite artists in this video...

[darcass69]

Trent and Manson with a guitar.. that was Epic

[yothisisgdog]

Hey, back when Manson was actually respectable and cool. Don't get me wrong, huge fan of MM's music, but damn, look what he's become...

[romansoldierdude]

@yothisisgdog Even though Trent is the one singing "After everything I've done I hate myself for what I've become!" xD

[recentlyIhave]

@yothisisgdog I follow Trent, but what became of MM? He was never much a song writer, more like a performer (and virtual intellectual!) - to me.

[Sianaz]

Manson looks incredibly cute in this vid..

[tm2jetfire]

I think recording and filming in the Tate house was a symptom of what Trent was going through at the time. He's probably not especially proud of it anymore.