lol is Keikenchi Joushouchuu really such a great song that even somebody who dislikes anime sims would be compelled to do it? I mean, it is a good song, but...
In any case, not bad, but you got a bit lazy towards the middle and just started using a bunch of 8th notes. It sorta hurts the consistency of the file and doesn't really take advantage of the rich rhythms of this song.
Overall, for this file, the steps fit well but you could have probably done more with them.
Actually, Heavy steps are supposed to be like that for reasons unknown to you but known to me. The sim was updated shortly after I uploaded it with Challenge steps, but I sort of refuse to update the Heavy steps, as they offer Standard players a gate into Heavy mode.
lol no, there's absolutely no good reason to break the consistency of a simfile - all that does is confuse the player. This isn't a question about difficulty - making a file better absolutely does not imply making it more difficult. All I'm saying is that your use of only vocals for part of the file and only 8th notes for the rest is off-putting and doesn't do the song justice. There's a lot more you could have done WITHOUT making the file any more difficult.
It's sort of like listening to an orchestral piece and watching the musicians switch for no good reason from major to minor key and back again 10 times during the song. Mass chaos ensues, and the song becomes rough and begins to give you a headache.
But if you're really that convinced that the file is in no need of even minor edits, then I salute your confidence. Just keep in mind that I had no malicious intent in my criticism -- just trying to help out a fellow simfile author.
lol is Keikenchi Joushouchuu really such a great song that even somebody who dislikes anime sims would be compelled to do it? I mean, it is a good song, but...
In any case, not bad, but you got a bit lazy towards the middle and just started using a bunch of 8th notes. It sorta hurts the consistency of the file and doesn't really take advantage of the rich rhythms of this song.
Overall, for this file, the steps fit well but you could have probably done more with them.
-PBI
ProofByInspection 3 years ago
Actually, Heavy steps are supposed to be like that for reasons unknown to you but known to me. The sim was updated shortly after I uploaded it with Challenge steps, but I sort of refuse to update the Heavy steps, as they offer Standard players a gate into Heavy mode.
-2BB (Call me that if you will :))
blazerboy8920 3 years ago
lol no, there's absolutely no good reason to break the consistency of a simfile - all that does is confuse the player. This isn't a question about difficulty - making a file better absolutely does not imply making it more difficult. All I'm saying is that your use of only vocals for part of the file and only 8th notes for the rest is off-putting and doesn't do the song justice. There's a lot more you could have done WITHOUT making the file any more difficult.
ProofByInspection 3 years ago
It's sort of like listening to an orchestral piece and watching the musicians switch for no good reason from major to minor key and back again 10 times during the song. Mass chaos ensues, and the song becomes rough and begins to give you a headache.
But if you're really that convinced that the file is in no need of even minor edits, then I salute your confidence. Just keep in mind that I had no malicious intent in my criticism -- just trying to help out a fellow simfile author.
-PBI
ProofByInspection 3 years ago
Wow... You SURE do like to talk (or type... idk, idc :P) a lot, right?
I understand where your coming from. Thing is... I kinda like to confuse the player xD
However, download the sim, and play the Challenge steps for me. I beleive they have consistency now.
-2BB (<-- Joke)
blazerboy8920 3 years ago
lol ok but I'll send it to you as a message... continuing to do this on a youtube comment board is a bit pointless
ProofByInspection 3 years ago