11. La donna è mobile, Bella figlia dell' amore

[carbukoski]

what is this dirty?

[pautalux]

la mia panna, la mia panna conneolar...

[qraqut]

a to co?

[Tslater316]

This is a hot mess.

[clubamicidellamusica]

eccezionale

5*****

[louvet66]

La famille Pondman doit aller apprendre à chanter, surtout le pauvre Duc qui est lamentable et risible. En l'écoutant, j'ai mal à la gorge.

[ShawDAMAN]

The tenor sounds like he's weakly choking through the whole thing. Horrible diction/pronunciation. Sorry. The rest sound weak, sloppy and/or inaudible. Please take this in a kind way if you are serious about singing opera. I don't mean to be mean.

On a positive note, it's great to see young people interested in opera and I think you could all be so much better. Best wishes

[steakopera]

ShawDAMAN

I told you before don't be so modest with your talent. Do you realize it, now?

[ShawDAMAN]

@steakopera: no, lol ;P

[bigus]

the tenor is...............wow..........­.......faking everything? sounds like a horrible immitation of correlli without any volume. i agree entirely with aroncooker they should in no way be singing this. learn the technique first on easy music then do the harder pieces so you dont build bad vocal habits on these pieces and never be able to sing them properly with beauty and ease.

[carloh011]

creepy ^^ but very high ^^

[MUSICOSO58]

definitivamente no me gusta esta interpretación

[aroncooker]

I have to comment again. Why were they singing this? If they all have the same teacher, then he is an idiot. This is such a crazy mess on sooooooo many levels.

[aroncooker]

is this serious or an opera parody? If its a parody, its halirious. If not, well wow.... This tenor is, i dont even know how to describe what he is doing. Its just gross and funny at the same time. But its killing me. What are you doing? I cant understand a single word either.

[svjatazarov]

The voice is good! Now..it`s the matter of technique ..in question....He is young...i think he`ll manage to find his own way....don`t judge him severely...he sings as he can...

[bigus]

@svjatazarov his voice may be good but its too hard to tell because of the lack of technique, and the poor diction and everything else. i guess if its just for fun then thats fine but why sing this? why not sing something easy so you can sound good on it? thats my philosophy anyway but its okay that not everyone has my opinion =).

[svjatazarov]

i appreciate your opinion...just post sth of your own...

[sillyboydeux]

It is to opera what Starbucks is to a cafe in Trastevere.

[vocede]

Der Sänger zeigt Talent, so dass man aus der Stimme was machen kann. Auf der Kehl- und Ansatzrohrebene sind die Einstellungen soweit richtig. Es fehlt einfach der Atemantrieb, um noch wesentliche Obertöne zu verstärken. So klingt die Stimme noch nicht, was sehr schade ist. Lehrer suchen, der das noch vermitteln kann, ohne alles komplett ins Falsche umzubiegen!!!!

[giampiero1939]

Occorre migliorare la dizione in italiano.

Discreta voce.

Deve sapere cosa dice!

[tenordramaticitm2]

I prefer VICTOR BORGE !

[gvdfans]

what is this ????? can someone explain us...

[steakopera]

gvdfans

My immediate impression was "This got a be a comedian or an actor displaying imitation of a famous singer" but it wasn't. I don't want to degrade his effort although I must say, it takes a lot of courage to post this on a youtube. I hope his singing will be better in the future.

[AfroPoli]

I have read that the tenor "has no voice left". Quite the contrary. The tenor has a lot of voice, and the technique provided by his teacher protects his voice. Those who critisize cannot sing one single aria from Rigoletto without choking, not to mention the quartet that follows.

The tenor has great talent. His voice has a good color and high notes with no problem.

[familypondman]

nice to know, thank you

[nessundorma111]

If this is a parody then it's great, very funny!

[familypondman]

especially for you

[Aspide1979ge]

@familypondman

The WORST "Donna è mobile" i've ever heard.

[familypondman]

AfroPoli,

most people with nasty comments are nasty. don't bother but thanks anyway for your support, you have guts!

[reeferisme]

AfroPoli...your a fool

[AfroPoli]

I have been made aware of the constant badmouthing of your work on the Grandi Tenori website. Be sure, these people are hobby singers and "experts" with no voice at all, and they are negative because they are envious.