I think Eden is really good. I'm a die hard Idina fan, that's for sure but the more I listen to Eden (as Elphie or as Maureen in Rent), the more I like her. They both had their talent and their flaws and I don't get why everyone lose their time comparing them and arguing. They're both great. BTW, Eden rocked that song!
Yes, that was Stephen Schwartz playing, when the announcer guys turns to say something else, that is what he was going to say but people were already clapping...
after eden says "did that really just happen" u can hear a girl say "ye it did" in the background. in another video u ere the girl say it much more clearly
Eden is amazing!! Her voice gives me goosebumps just watching this video. Although I kinda prefer to see the song being sung by a green skinned girl XD
But she is amazing~ Especially her renditions of the other songs like No Good Deed.
she's amazing. she does the best version of this song i think. even defying gravity. cuz she doesnt do the usual riffs like all the others do. yay eden!!
It IS agreed that Idina is amazing, but thats not really what we came to watch. This is an Eden video. WHich means that were supposed to be here to watch EDEN. Its not wrong to have an opinion on who is the best, but I just think that if its about someone you shouldnt post about someone else. Thanks. Dont take this offensively. =] (btw this is totally coming from one of the big huge Idina fans, so this is no slam against her)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I'm sorry but Eden Espinosa is not going to go down as the greatest Elphaba ever Idina will because she's the original and the one on all the recordings
and also incase you haven't realised Eden's just trying to copy Idina
i mean first Wicked as the same character and now RENT as the same character
but it's never going to happen because she is nowhere near as talented or as beautiful as Idina
Are you kidding? Nobody even comes close to Eden. Caissie was the most inconsistent Elphaba to ever take the stage. Eden will go down as the greatest Elphaba ever!
I'm looking for constructive criticsm, so if you're in the mood to give any please check my videos. I'm going to sound terrible compared to eden tho! But thanks I appreciate it.
I miss her SO much in this role. Not only is she an amazing actress with a phenomenal voice, but she's also one of the most down-to-earth, humble, sweet people you'll ever meet. I saw the show again last week and the magic just isn't there any more. *sighs* Wicked misses you, Eden. But bring on Flora -- I can't wait to hear that gorgeous singing voice again!
Cassie is an awesome Elphaba but Eden is good too. Seriously when Cassie sang Defying Gravity everyone in the audience seriously got the biggest chills.
This is the first time I've heard Eden. My personal preference is Caissie Levy. Caissie has such a power yet sweet touch to her voice. Not taking anything away from Eden, I just fell in love with Caissie voice. It's amazing.
i love eden she is i think the best elphaba then idina comes next (dont get me wrong idina is amazingbut i liked her better in rent) but eden shows more of the character to me
few i jsut watched anouther elphaba (no names mentioned) and didnt like her and i was like omg i need edens wizard and i or i will actually cry! so thanx som much 4 savin me jst then wid this vid lol
This is the best version of this song sung by her. There were a lot of riffs in there that she doesn't normally do, and they were absolutely amazing. I miss Eden. She should come back and do Wicked LA until it's run is over. Same with Megan. Once Megan leaves, the LA production is going to suffer. Huge.
I love this! Eden does some little things that bother me, but she is most definitely onw of my favorite Elphie's. Her rendition of "No Good Deed" is the best I've ever heard.
Remember Elphaba is just a girl... Idena Menzel sounds the same... is a SUPER HIGH BELT song.... in order for a female to "belt" that high and safely without damaging the voice... it has to sound like a little girl. Listen to any high belter--- she's fantastic and can sing the sh__ out of it!!!
i love her voice, but for some reason when she sings out of character like this, her voice takes an unpleasant tone till she starts to really belt, especially at the beginning. other than that, she's phenomenal.
I just saw WICKED for the second time with Ms. Espinoza in the lead and her rendition just gives me chills. She is into it 110% every minute and tears the house down with the song "Defying Gravity," the thunderous end of the first act. People absolutely shout and cheer! It's fun to see her sing in this video without her green makeup :) and I think she sounds great as ever. A true actress/singer but also a very musical singer...and that combination doesn't happen very often!
I'm sorry for anyone that doesn't agree with me, but I really don't like Eden. There's just something about her voice i don't like. She sang this well, but..idk.. i just feel "eh" when i hear her perform it.
You can feel free to disagree with me, i dont care, but just don't leave me a long essay on why she's the best, cuz personally it's my opinon.
thats intersting that you dont get all excited when she sings. cause i find that the way she sings a song, its never really the same. she changes the notes up quite a bit. usually when i hear her sing my heart just beats like crazy. it took me a little while to really get into her as much as i have. for a while, i thought she was a bit nasally, but eventually i really really started to like her.
its wierd i think eden is a bit nasally sometimes. but i like some of the little things she does with the song! "things ive never felt" is definitely the best bit!
Quote from wikipedia (which is not always correct but I'm pretty sure about this): "She is currently reprising this role alongside former co-star, Megan Hilty in the open-ended Los Angeles production of Wicked. She recently extended her contract till December 2007." So she's staying till december! Yay!
I'm so mad i didn't go to any of the Wicked Wednsdays!!! I only live an hour and a half away (without traffic) from LA!!!!! I love Eden and Megan so much!!!!
she seems a little....too serious. i dont know what it is, but she seems a little bothered or something. her pronounciation is really really really really good.
Mmmm.. She´s very good.. but I think that It´s not about who can reach the most high note.. She´s very good, I think that all elphabas (Dee, Sho and espinosa) were wonderful.. BUT Idinas voice, in my opinion, was the best for the role.. It´s strong and powerful in the same time.. I think espinosa´s voice a little thin for this role.. Someone with a strong voice will do it better.. I think that she could do glinda´s part, ´cause she has such a amazing voice..
to iheartwicked91: YES! I saw her in LA and that's the one thing I took from the show and can't forget. I love how she took her own freedom and chose not to do what Idina Menzel did. oh! it gave me chills when I heard that! thanks teletooby for this post. It made me feel good inside.
You're welcome, justify56! Thanks for commenting. I think Eden's take on Elphaba is perfect. She puts so much emotion into her singing. Her voice is so powerful and moving! I can't wait to see her again...and Megan, too!
yeah i saw her lat night and i swear to god i didnt know that a sound like that could come out of a person. people were screaming after almost every song that she performed.
I totally agree with you, cocotheslug! I love Idina, especially in Rent, but I think this role was made for Eden...I'm so glad she's signed an extended contract! BTW, LOVE your username!!!
First off, Eden has a good voice. It's not bad. But Idina, on the other hand, has a way more powerful voice than Eden. Also, she sounds sooooooooo nasaly. It actually distracts me from the song. Sometimes Idina is flat, but she changes up the song a lot and it's not easy. Eden in this song also is flat. But I've always been and will always be an Idina fan. She's amazing!
ooo um eden is way more powerful than idina. dont get me wrong, i love idina a lot shes one of my heroes, but eden is way more powerful. and eden sounds wayyyy better live. trust me it makes all the difference.
The best thing about this song is that Eden makes Elphaba little. You know? Young. Like her voice isn't fully matured yet. Then as the play goes on, Eden gets more and more mature w/ her voice. Wonderful acting skills there! But I don't like how sometimes she tends to sound extremely low. Like a man. That's a little annoying. And so is the way she holds her mouth at the end. I can't help it, it just bothers me. Although her voice control is wonderful.
OH STEPHEN'S PLAYING!?!?!? now that's awesome... cause he like, has it memorized, so he can alter is and make it as amazing as he wants, because he'll never get lost, cause again, he wrote it! lol, wow...
I just saw Eden at the Pantages. She was fabulous!! Her voice is so beautiful and so powerful. I love her as Elphaba! She and Megan are a great pair!!!
I think you're referring to "As we work hand in hand." Those aren't the wrong words. Those were the original words. How it was written. But I think Idina changed it. Or something like that. But those are the original lyrics.
i prefer her in defying gravity even though i think idinas way better, i like the riffs in gravity. but i feel like the beginning of this is just like boring
have you heard idina sing this song??? talk about boring im sorry but eden is so unbelieveably powerful and strong she brings so much passion to the role. The beginning of this song no matter who sings it is boring :)
I get goosebumps every time I've seen her sing in Wicked too! She's so moving to hear!!! I've seen it 3 times now in LA and will probably go back just for Eden!
I saw her and Megan in NY 1 year ago(it dones't seem like that long!) and they were both amazing. Eden had me crying at the end of Defying Gravity and took me the whole intermission to calm down. I LOVE her voice. Though my favorite video of her singing this song(from Megans last night on Broadway) is gone. =(
she is such a good singer. i saw the show in london last week, i was amzed i had goosebumps the whole way through lol and i also liked the guys hat in front of the camera lol.
Gotta love Eden she has SUCH great voice!!!!!
FutureGreenGirl 8 months ago 2
3:02 ... YES.
imsillyareyou 1 year ago
I was THERE!!!! :D
Kaianna89 1 year ago 2
I think Eden is really good. I'm a die hard Idina fan, that's for sure but the more I listen to Eden (as Elphie or as Maureen in Rent), the more I like her. They both had their talent and their flaws and I don't get why everyone lose their time comparing them and arguing. They're both great. BTW, Eden rocked that song!
nellielovett026 1 year ago 5
Idina and Eden are spectacular, amazing... Any other great word there is, that's what they are! I have to be one of their biggest fans. ; u ;
VocaloidNekoChan 1 year ago
Eden is better eye candy then Idina..thats why im watching this video..lol
UncleCoolJay 1 year ago
eden's amazingg :)
d0ggylover21 1 year ago
Hahahahaha
Eden: Did that really just happen?
Person: YEAH it did!
Classic.
RasberryBop 1 year ago
wow - love it!!!
GeaAy 1 year ago
uh...WOW.
havemofun 1 year ago
awesomeness!!!!
kilay2000 2 years ago
I love her soo much!
brightsunshine 2 years ago
saw her perform in LA...fab... super fab...the end.
b0bbi3pin 2 years ago
:O I think that was Stephen playing the piano in the background... :D Saweeet! At times Eden reminds me of Idina... :D
wickedx716 2 years ago 2
Yes, that was Stephen Schwartz playing, when the announcer guys turns to say something else, that is what he was going to say but people were already clapping...
megalissa21 2 years ago
who plats elphie now? and glinda?
rivkasings93 2 years ago
when she sed the first wizard and i she went really deep made me laugh a bit
asswhole239 3 years ago
she's fantastic. the end
NickJonasGirl4ever15 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This shit should be banned
spazquestt 3 years ago
eden!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
liuxgrace 3 years ago
I love the man's cap in the forefront (sp?) :D
FlyingFishie 3 years ago 5
sining it with just piano must be a bit harder. hahah but she was amazing!
iheartwicked91 3 years ago 2
after eden says "did that really just happen" u can hear a girl say "ye it did" in the background. in another video u ere the girl say it much more clearly
Ready4Broadway 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she sounds a lot like idina here!!!
Evilina4evaxo95 3 years ago
i love eden! imagine the pressure of stephen shwartz playing the piano and u have to sing
iloveelphaba17 3 years ago 3
I wish I could of gone to one of the Wicked Days, that would be so awesome!
sopranosinger123 3 years ago
Eden is amazing!! Her voice gives me goosebumps just watching this video. Although I kinda prefer to see the song being sung by a green skinned girl XD
But she is amazing~ Especially her renditions of the other songs like No Good Deed.
moujinboo 3 years ago 8
Amazing!
xEternalxx 3 years ago 3
One Word : WOW
bestfriendwebshow 3 years ago 2
she's amazing. she does the best version of this song i think. even defying gravity. cuz she doesnt do the usual riffs like all the others do. yay eden!!
caseywun 3 years ago
It IS agreed that Idina is amazing, but thats not really what we came to watch. This is an Eden video. WHich means that were supposed to be here to watch EDEN. Its not wrong to have an opinion on who is the best, but I just think that if its about someone you shouldnt post about someone else. Thanks. Dont take this offensively. =] (btw this is totally coming from one of the big huge Idina fans, so this is no slam against her)
GOOOO Eden!!!!!! She rocks!!!!
slytherinhearts 3 years ago 30
Well said! Idina has her own videos, this is Eden's...
TeleTooby 3 years ago 3
i think idina is the best no one ever came close to idina! =D
sbzr35 3 years ago
I saw them both live and I thought Eden's voice is much better. Idina's is a little more nasal.
ivoonhersido 2 years ago 11
i totally agree, and to be honest... Idina's eyes freak me out in the green makeup, she is less sympathetic of a character to me than Eden was...
megalissa21 2 years ago 5
@sbzr35
Go and say that on an Idina video that Idina is the best if you have nothing to do than bitch about Eden.
You're sad.
boffinme80 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm sorry but Eden Espinosa is not going to go down as the greatest Elphaba ever Idina will because she's the original and the one on all the recordings
and also incase you haven't realised Eden's just trying to copy Idina
i mean first Wicked as the same character and now RENT as the same character
but it's never going to happen because she is nowhere near as talented or as beautiful as Idina
And she overacts way too much
blink182011 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I have to agree with you I like Eden kinda but damn Idina is a goddess in the musical theater community and in my heart =)
she's lovely and talented and IS elphaba...
she's the only woman on earth who could pull off that makeup and still look perfect.
and her voice!!?!?!?!?!? are you KIDDING????
LunaCullen6 3 years ago
Eden Espinosa Rules!
wicked0004 3 years ago 3
i think i like Caissie better...
ya i like her(Caissie) better.
dorksRUS54 3 years ago
Are you kidding? Nobody even comes close to Eden. Caissie was the most inconsistent Elphaba to ever take the stage. Eden will go down as the greatest Elphaba ever!
wicked0004 3 years ago
Sorry, but i have to disagree, that would have to be Idina Menzel. She ruled on broadway, and everywhere else she performed
prettyponybaby2007 3 years ago
I have to disagree =] She is fabulous but not the best.
I think every performer brings something different to the role...
But I guess its all about personal preference...
lwg1607 3 years ago
She is soooooooooo friggin awesome! She was great in Flora, and she is sooooo gonna rock in RENT! Yay Eden!
karakatso 3 years ago
I'm looking for constructive criticsm, so if you're in the mood to give any please check my videos. I'm going to sound terrible compared to eden tho! But thanks I appreciate it.
OceanSunRise4 3 years ago
eden is a powerhouse. end of story.
:D
ajp22689 3 years ago 4
shes amaaaazing
ohskits 3 years ago
i still have no clue how all that amazingness comes out of someone so teeny : )
sbort 4 years ago 6
Hi! LOVED your video response! You have an awesome voice,too...Thanks for that!!! :)
TeleTooby 4 years ago
Eden you have to come back!!! you see how much everybody loves you!! you see how much my family loves you!! you're on our christmas card!!
COME BACK TO Wicked!!
ForGood26 4 years ago
Ha ha ....ilove the nice view of the Defy Gravity cap. i also love eden singing this song.
witchOFtheWESTend 4 years ago
I miss her SO much in this role. Not only is she an amazing actress with a phenomenal voice, but she's also one of the most down-to-earth, humble, sweet people you'll ever meet. I saw the show again last week and the magic just isn't there any more. *sighs* Wicked misses you, Eden. But bring on Flora -- I can't wait to hear that gorgeous singing voice again!
missgalinda88 4 years ago 2
Cassie is an awesome Elphaba but Eden is good too. Seriously when Cassie sang Defying Gravity everyone in the audience seriously got the biggest chills.
baby29303 4 years ago
you mean caissie and yes she is amazing!!!!
MidgetLoving420 3 years ago
Man, being able to scream and sound good, that's quite a talent
sushiboi53 4 years ago
This is the first time I've heard Eden. My personal preference is Caissie Levy. Caissie has such a power yet sweet touch to her voice. Not taking anything away from Eden, I just fell in love with Caissie voice. It's amazing.
source60 4 years ago
i love thisssss omg
54spiritedwill54 4 years ago
I like Eden alot, but Kerry is my favourite Elphie. With Eden in second and Idina 3rd. Eden has a pretty amazing voice!
charmedalltheway 4 years ago
what about Caissie? she's awesome.
source60 4 years ago
I dont know her. I've never heard her, but I'll check her out. But no-one will replace Kerry!
charmedalltheway 4 years ago
i love eden she is i think the best elphaba then idina comes next (dont get me wrong idina is amazingbut i liked her better in rent) but eden shows more of the character to me
skimble101 4 years ago 3
few i jsut watched anouther elphaba (no names mentioned) and didnt like her and i was like omg i need edens wizard and i or i will actually cry! so thanx som much 4 savin me jst then wid this vid lol
i sounds crazy
im not
x
babyfairywings 4 years ago 2
i love the way she says "i'd be so happy i could melt"
973420 4 years ago
I love her dress and her voice!!! and that guy's hat! xxx
HazelCharlesworth 4 years ago 3
This is the best version of this song sung by her. There were a lot of riffs in there that she doesn't normally do, and they were absolutely amazing. I miss Eden. She should come back and do Wicked LA until it's run is over. Same with Megan. Once Megan leaves, the LA production is going to suffer. Huge.
GALiNDAFi3D 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wow - yes - physically bothersome.
I also saw her video on u tube singing Eva Cassidy's version of Over the Rainbow.
Wow - such a pale version. Embarrassing actually.
Blinglover 4 years ago
I love this! Eden does some little things that bother me, but she is most definitely onw of my favorite Elphie's. Her rendition of "No Good Deed" is the best I've ever heard.
renthead1123 4 years ago 2
she is an amazing singer and one of my favourite Elphaba's
Xoph012 4 years ago 4
LMAO
"did that really just happen?" she sings
some dude in the crowd "yes!"
If i was her at that moment i would have broke down and laughed even though i was performing, hahahaha
alfredgoovermon 4 years ago 3
She is good but I prefer Idina and Shoshana.
methebookworm 4 years ago
I met her! She is so nice just like megan.
Nookway56 4 years ago
I miss her...
thegreengirl1 4 years ago 2
Am I the only one who thinks she would make a great Lucy in Jekyll and Hyde?
tjvids7 4 years ago
She's cool. I like her.
ko7461 4 years ago 2
No one belts like eden. She is kind of amazing........ i wish i had those pipes. She rocks the socks off of once upon a time from brooklyn as well.
joeknis 4 years ago 6
She's amaaaaaaazing, but she gets the bad side of the vowels...<_< but she's still quite good!! love Eden!!!
TheGGFBW 4 years ago
I saw Eden yesterday! She's so amazing in Wicked!
serafimospretense 4 years ago
Eden ROCKS!
costamesaguy69 4 years ago 3
'feeling things i vever felt' its amazin :)
andyborthwick2k7 4 years ago 2
OOOOOOoooooo! WickedFan2008 from a month ago..oooo TeleTooby treated you....
Broadwayboy101 4 years ago
i was there and i was crying through this song cuz it was so amazing!!!
my friend Alan (hes a strighty) was like R U SERIOUS, UR CRYING? ahahhaha... i ADORE eden!
jessegyllenhaal 4 years ago
i love thisssss omg
her "ill stand there with the wizzAARAARRd"
wickedlover4 4 years ago
She is so freakin amazing! Though, that piano player needs some practice.
WickedFan2008 4 years ago
That piano player goes by the name of Stephen Schwartz. He wrote the music for Wicked!!! Be nice!
TeleTooby 4 years ago
I know, he was just a little off. However, I will always be so grateful to him writing this wonderful music.
WickedFan2008 4 years ago
Me, too!!! :)
TeleTooby 4 years ago
haha sam, u put ur foot in it there didn't ya
xxtinkerbell91xx 4 years ago
Remember Elphaba is just a girl... Idena Menzel sounds the same... is a SUPER HIGH BELT song.... in order for a female to "belt" that high and safely without damaging the voice... it has to sound like a little girl. Listen to any high belter--- she's fantastic and can sing the sh__ out of it!!!
rodolson 4 years ago
i love her voice, but for some reason when she sings out of character like this, her voice takes an unpleasant tone till she starts to really belt, especially at the beginning. other than that, she's phenomenal.
soundstrulycrazy 4 years ago
I just saw WICKED for the second time with Ms. Espinoza in the lead and her rendition just gives me chills. She is into it 110% every minute and tears the house down with the song "Defying Gravity," the thunderous end of the first act. People absolutely shout and cheer! It's fun to see her sing in this video without her green makeup :) and I think she sounds great as ever. A true actress/singer but also a very musical singer...and that combination doesn't happen very often!
venturacenter 4 years ago 4
She's so good! Check out her recent performances...she's awesome!
kingstevesmith 4 years ago
Thats so weird. No her, she's really good! I mean, its a awesome some, and its all happy, then in the back, its like 'Texas Chainsaw Masacre"
strikern57 4 years ago
She's very good, no question. I persoanlly have a problem with heavy throat pressure... she gets kinda froggy at times.
Jmillzx 4 years ago
She's An Amazing Singer.
EndOfStory.
HelloNando 4 years ago
She's Ok I Liked It
jldubeu 4 years ago
I'm sorry for anyone that doesn't agree with me, but I really don't like Eden. There's just something about her voice i don't like. She sang this well, but..idk.. i just feel "eh" when i hear her perform it.
You can feel free to disagree with me, i dont care, but just don't leave me a long essay on why she's the best, cuz personally it's my opinon.
xBiggMistakeex33 4 years ago
thats intersting that you dont get all excited when she sings. cause i find that the way she sings a song, its never really the same. she changes the notes up quite a bit. usually when i hear her sing my heart just beats like crazy. it took me a little while to really get into her as much as i have. for a while, i thought she was a bit nasally, but eventually i really really started to like her.
thegreengirl1 4 years ago
Same. I think Eden just takes a bit of getting used to before one becomes a groveling fan (not that I grovel).
TheChosenOne613 4 years ago
There you go! But I do grovel lol. Just not in public.
thegreengirl1 4 years ago
Haha, I don't like her, either.
KSab02 4 years ago
Well, I LOVE her! What I said before wasn't meant to say I hate her, I meant that she is staying in a good way. I LOVE her! And the show!
wickedelphabafreeek 4 years ago
I like the dude with the defy gravity hat in the front
bobewell9 4 years ago
Where did you read that? YAY!
ariannaschardt 4 years ago
its wierd i think eden is a bit nasally sometimes. but i like some of the little things she does with the song! "things ive never felt" is definitely the best bit!
aoife92 4 years ago
Does anyone know for sure that eden is leaving in sep.? cause i want to go see her again and try to meet her!!!! please tell me asap!!!!!
camilliebean34567 4 years ago
I'll ask someone who might know whether or not Eden is leaving in Sept. I'll let you know what I find out!
TeleTooby 4 years ago
eden just extended her contract to december! no date yet for sure but we have her for 3 more months!
thegreengirl1 4 years ago
Quote from wikipedia (which is not always correct but I'm pretty sure about this): "She is currently reprising this role alongside former co-star, Megan Hilty in the open-ended Los Angeles production of Wicked. She recently extended her contract till December 2007." So she's staying till december! Yay!
wickedelphabafreeek 4 years ago
yep its true!
thegreengirl1 4 years ago
I'm so mad i didn't go to any of the Wicked Wednsdays!!! I only live an hour and a half away (without traffic) from LA!!!!! I love Eden and Megan so much!!!!
camilliebean34567 4 years ago
shes the greatest :]
twilightXXloves 4 years ago
I do love her version of this song!
I love the way she interpritates the songs into her own!
Northern1Lass 4 years ago
Wait she isn't in Wicked anymore right? I would give anything to see her perform.
OceanSunRise4 4 years ago
yeah shes in LA! she may be leaving the first week of september though.... **tear**
thegreengirl1 4 years ago
i saw her on july 19 and she was awsome
elaine501 4 years ago
i saw her in LA and she's amazing.. i just don't like it when she sings like what she did in 3:18.. it's a bit annoying..
but i still looove her =)
a1francisco 4 years ago
yeah.. like when she goes into the back of her throat and sings that weird low note. i don't really like that either
xBiggMistakeex33 4 years ago
Yea, she sounds alot better preforming:D i saw her in L.A!
ElphieForever 4 years ago
shes really gd but she does sing through her nose alot...
animecatgurl 4 years ago
no i think its just the video sound. she really doesnt sound like that live.
thegreengirl1 4 years ago
she seems a little....too serious. i dont know what it is, but she seems a little bothered or something. her pronounciation is really really really really good.
so0shi04 4 years ago
I think it's called enthusiasm
justl1keraven 4 years ago
Woooooooah. How awesome is she?!
SnowSpider18 4 years ago
ooo so did you get to talk to her? i assume you met her somewhere other than the stage door if she knows ur friends. thats awesome!
thegreengirl1 4 years ago
it would of been funny if after she sung did that really happen some one in the audiance could yell yes it did!...lol
lsutigergirl5 4 years ago
Mmmm.. She´s very good.. but I think that It´s not about who can reach the most high note.. She´s very good, I think that all elphabas (Dee, Sho and espinosa) were wonderful.. BUT Idinas voice, in my opinion, was the best for the role.. It´s strong and powerful in the same time.. I think espinosa´s voice a little thin for this role.. Someone with a strong voice will do it better.. I think that she could do glinda´s part, ´cause she has such a amazing voice..
Thx for sharing
sexylove1477 4 years ago
Gosh; eden is so amazing; she is perfect for the role of elphie! elphaba isnt just a good voice its and attitude and eden has got it.
DanceLikeEvry1sBlind 4 years ago
I met Eden and took a picture with her
Filmkids 4 years ago
to iheartwicked91: YES! I saw her in LA and that's the one thing I took from the show and can't forget. I love how she took her own freedom and chose not to do what Idina Menzel did. oh! it gave me chills when I heard that! thanks teletooby for this post. It made me feel good inside.
justify56 4 years ago
You're welcome, justify56! Thanks for commenting. I think Eden's take on Elphaba is perfect. She puts so much emotion into her singing. Her voice is so powerful and moving! I can't wait to see her again...and Megan, too!
TeleTooby 4 years ago
love her "feeling things I never felt"!!
iheartwicked91 4 years ago
I love Indina too but Eden just simply out did her in this role.
This video isn't a very representation of how great she really is.
cocotheslug 4 years ago
yeah i saw her lat night and i swear to god i didnt know that a sound like that could come out of a person. people were screaming after almost every song that she performed.
thegreengirl1 4 years ago
I totally agree with you, cocotheslug! I love Idina, especially in Rent, but I think this role was made for Eden...I'm so glad she's signed an extended contract! BTW, LOVE your username!!!
TeleTooby 4 years ago
Really? She signed an extended contract? For how long? How did you find that out? I'm so excited now!!!
minimemama 4 years ago
First off, Eden has a good voice. It's not bad. But Idina, on the other hand, has a way more powerful voice than Eden. Also, she sounds sooooooooo nasaly. It actually distracts me from the song. Sometimes Idina is flat, but she changes up the song a lot and it's not easy. Eden in this song also is flat. But I've always been and will always be an Idina fan. She's amazing!
BlueMagick06 4 years ago
ooo um eden is way more powerful than idina. dont get me wrong, i love idina a lot shes one of my heroes, but eden is way more powerful. and eden sounds wayyyy better live. trust me it makes all the difference.
thegreengirl1 4 years ago
i like eden better than any other elphaba
thegreengirl1 4 years ago
i like Kerry better than any other elphaba
loyanini 4 years ago
Me too, seen Kerry twice, she is just amazing!!!
Northern1Lass 4 years ago
The best thing about this song is that Eden makes Elphaba little. You know? Young. Like her voice isn't fully matured yet. Then as the play goes on, Eden gets more and more mature w/ her voice. Wonderful acting skills there! But I don't like how sometimes she tends to sound extremely low. Like a man. That's a little annoying. And so is the way she holds her mouth at the end. I can't help it, it just bothers me. Although her voice control is wonderful.
LiveAndLoveLife 4 years ago
Eh ok, Idina does it soo much better tho :D
BlueMagick06 4 years ago
no, idina sucks, eden is waayyy better. Idina is all breathy and is constantly FLAT
CTDoyle123094 4 years ago
OH STEPHEN'S PLAYING!?!?!? now that's awesome... cause he like, has it memorized, so he can alter is and make it as amazing as he wants, because he'll never get lost, cause again, he wrote it! lol, wow...
MrHuggy05 4 years ago
Eden and Idina do actually look pretty similiar! Lol random
Amazing job though! Love her!!!
tjvids7 4 years ago
She's really good! :o
I saw her on broadway. It was pretty nice.
ChinamiMiyanagi 4 years ago
I just saw Eden at the Pantages. She was fabulous!! Her voice is so beautiful and so powerful. I love her as Elphaba! She and Megan are a great pair!!!
TeleTooby 4 years ago
when she sang the wrong words u could c it in her face... but she did better than ever after that!
NessaroseRules 4 years ago
I think you're referring to "As we work hand in hand." Those aren't the wrong words. Those were the original words. How it was written. But I think Idina changed it. Or something like that. But those are the original lyrics.
LiveAndLoveLife 4 years ago
no no i think she meant when she goes, "O wat a pair a pair well b" @ the worng part
noahcyrus 4 years ago
ooooooooooooooo. Yeah, Eden changed the lyrics.
LiveAndLoveLife 4 years ago
i prefer her in defying gravity even though i think idinas way better, i like the riffs in gravity. but i feel like the beginning of this is just like boring
CanIDeGreenifyYou 4 years ago
have you heard idina sing this song??? talk about boring im sorry but eden is so unbelieveably powerful and strong she brings so much passion to the role. The beginning of this song no matter who sings it is boring :)
amarinaballerina 4 years ago 2
She was amazing when I saw her last week!!!
Medic246 4 years ago
I get goosebumps every time I've seen her sing in Wicked too! She's so moving to hear!!! I've seen it 3 times now in LA and will probably go back just for Eden!
minimemama 4 years ago
me too! ive seen it 3 times in la now and as much as love wicked, i'm mostly going back cause i love eden and megan.
thegreengirl1 4 years ago
LOLOL i love stephen rockin the shades in the background like ray charles, haha!
Melimo 4 years ago
eden does a great job, i saw her last saturday
vhbeazel 4 years ago
I saw her in WICKED. I thought she rocked!
CloakedSchemerVI 4 years ago
She totally ROCKS! I'm seeing her this month...I can't wait! I saw her in Wicked on Broadway. She really is amazing!!!
TeleTooby 4 years ago
This Girl ROCKS!
Maxkustrap 4 years ago
i live in chicago but i came all the way to LA just to see her and megan and i didn't regret it!!
angelsassygirl 4 years ago
shes my fave elphaba! just her voice, her personality and everything stands out! her dg is fantastic love the riffs!
jackhurst85 4 years ago
I saw her and Megan in NY 1 year ago(it dones't seem like that long!) and they were both amazing. Eden had me crying at the end of Defying Gravity and took me the whole intermission to calm down. I LOVE her voice. Though my favorite video of her singing this song(from Megans last night on Broadway) is gone. =(
AliciaFS 5 years ago
i saw her and megan in wicked. she was amazing. she kind of sounds like idina so she makes a great elfaba
blondey0201 5 years ago
WOW she's great and she has a diffrent voice of her own GO EDEN
tube2boy 5 years ago
I LOVE Eden...she's so pretty and has a pretty voice! I saw her and Megan in February.
MissElphieThropp 5 years ago
she has an amazing voice...i stil love idina and kristen..i love the guys hat that says defy gravity
polishpride131 5 years ago
Loooove this song, especially how Eden acts while singing it. She's soo awesome.
ritabook42 5 years ago
she is such a good singer. i saw the show in london last week, i was amzed i had goosebumps the whole way through lol and i also liked the guys hat in front of the camera lol.
dunbar1234 5 years ago
omg i love how close this is to her face.
ginohhh 5 years ago
I MET HER! it was awesome. we had camp for choir and she was a special guest. she's sooo nice =D
iamaquamannn 5 years ago
That is so COOL that you got to meet her! Did you get to hear her sing? Have you seen her in WICKED???