Winx Club-Rai and Nick-Magica Winx-Are you for which version?

[TheJBfan2002]

bloom-old /reason: Heart shape at the end won

Flora-New /reason:Her petal blowing won

Stella-old /reason:Love how her hair ties automatic

Musa-old /reason:Her dancefloor stuff and CD spin

Tecna-old /reason:Her kungfu at the front is nice

[ccans1998]

original



[JasminesHolidays]

orignal one

[thenewageriseth]

I like the animation of both shows from what I've seen but I like the NICK theme MUCH better than the 4Kids THEME...the 4kids theme is a little redudant lol O.o

[xrrgr]

nice i like it it goes so good with the nick transformation and you know what's funny i was gonna make my own video like this.

[BelievixHeart4TV]

Both. They all looked great! Don't worry Winx Club fans, they're still the one-and-only Winx Club we love,right?

[MaiNanami95]

Original Version..... :D

[Wings1535]

Старый лучше.

[WinxCollector]

I like both. But a little bit more the original one. :D

[Bloom107StellaTV]

мне нравится все обе варианта

[AWESOME112799]

Bloom- New

Reason: love the background and the dragon at the end

Flora- New

Reason: I love the flower effects

Musa-Tie

Reason: in the old I like her little dance and CD and in the new I like her clothes better

Stella- New

Reason: her body shape is weird while transforming in the old one

Tecna-New

Reason: her back flips give her more personality

[extraman79]

sera con mejores graficos pero el de nick no sobrepasa al normal

[iOmeOlovei]

the original is better and the best

[AnimaMandala]

I don't like any of the new ones...i mean on whole the music isn't as exciting and not as much detail goes into them, plus all the special effects seem like overkill and completely outclass the later transformations. I respect the artistic vision behind them, but the originals just have a certain spark that nick's doesn't.

[364189071]

a da nick e melhor

[jasmindiva9]

wolę charmix na nicku

[kokisimpson]

bloom old transforimation i like the heart in the end so old win for bloom

stella old transformation i like it when they say stella stella Stella so old win for stella

flora new transformation i like the flower effect so new wins for flora

musa old transformation i like the cd effect so old win for musa

techa new transformation i like the backflips so new win for techna so old wins

[kokisimpson]

i love new

[yoamoelclubwinx]

The new transformations are cute and magic, but... the originals are so powerfull and... *o* So the old wins of course!!!!!!

[angelgirl2400]

the original for sure!

[NabelVEVO]

Bloom : old. Flora :new Stella new musa old tend a new

[NabelVEVO]

Ehh igino straffi did that not nickelodeon and I like new one

[Enchantix00Sasori]

Thx new version is so much better^^.

[978eli]

exellent¡¡



[AlexisLovesWinx]

I like both, okay maybe a little bit the old version. But what I want to say is that this transformation is only a SPECIAL!!! It's not a new Season or something like that. It's only a SPECIAL!!

But the Original wins of course!!!!!

[AlexisLovesWinx]

I meant: I like both, okay maybe a little bit MORE the old version. Sorry. (:

[blanka856]

NEW !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[TheOriginalKasanruh]

I personally liked the 4kids version the best, regardless of the fact that they changed a bunch of stuff

[petshoplover04]

old old old old old old old old old old old

[MegaCandyCaneGurl]

ORIGINAL WINX!!!!!!

[1lricardo]

OLD WINX OLD WINX OLD WINX OLD WINX OLD WINX OLDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD­DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD WINXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX­XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX­XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX­XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Eszra]

Undesided on Old and New Bloom. Seeing as I just don't get a feeling from anything for either transformation scene.

New Flora wins.

New Stella wins.

New and Old Musa are a tie cause I like bits of each.

I want to say Old Techna, but the New one gives her more personality. I should give this a tie but I'm gonna say New Techna wins.

[petshoplover04]

@Eszra its tecna !

[nohabody]

Bloom: New

Flora: New

Stella: Original

Musa: Original

Tecna: New

[PrincessSierra102]

I like the nick version of everyone but Bloom, Stella, and Musa. The original has it for the others

[bloomlaviace]

Nick made the new be so stupid. They even changed the voices. The old outfits and transformations and voices all win. Igiono Straffi and Rai win. Thank you 4kids.

[Xmrosli26]

Bloom:New (eyes to narrow in old)

Stella:Old

Flora:New

Musa:old

Tecna:new

[1budgies]

Bloom:old

Flora:new

Stella:old

Musa:old

Tecna:new

old wins

[mewmewpowerbrasil1]

Rai.Totally

[Xmrosli26]

Nick never made these transformation Igiono Straffi did so dont blame nick

[WinxMusaitsumademo]

@Xmrosli26 thank you somebody finally gets it. Every change in the specials were made by the original creators, Nick is just giving the show a channel to broadcast on.

[sDreamSpirit]

the original <3

[werwolfloverever]

nick

\

wins



[MegaClawd]

elle ont les couleurs believix

[t2nunu88]

The faces for the original one is kind of not right a bit too narrow. That bugs me a lot for some reason. The Nick one is too fast but it looks more magical and detailed. I don't see any changes in the outfits. They all are only "made" differently. All in all, I think Nick's transformation is better.

[xPandaBearRawrx]

@t2nunu88 I will say what someone else commented before at one video similar to this, comparing the transformations. The problem is that the new transformation is too good and too detailed, there is no place for improvements that would make Enchantix and Believix more magical. Because the old ones were simple, they really showed that Enchantix was a higher fairy level.

[t2nunu88]

@xPandaBearRawrx In season 3, they switch it so they use the magic winx transformation. Like the same as the one on the left.

[t2nunu88]

@therealwinxclubbloom Nickelodeon isn't the only show with the name Aisha. Other places use it, too.

[iDrawAnime101]

Original! It's always better!

[princessvulpix100]

Rai English (the old one) I HATE the new one they changd the voices,the music, and some of the outfits.

Final answer: Rai english

[HowrseGirl2012]

original cuz nick messing with winx (especially Tecna) makes me so mad!

[15Emogirly]

The Original :)

[Floranature1999]

Definitely original

[JPERALTE]

nick i watch it cuz i dont get the other ones

[purplefire210]

the rai

[ceciliapotter1]

Las Winx Originales, obvio! xD

[MCR4EVER14]

original wins my vote

[cakecrumb095]

I wonder why they did completely new transformations for Nick. Was that really necessary? Either way, I'm indifferent to this cause I grew up with 4kids.

[89990000]

R.A.I. always wins! Nick's transformation is like....Believix. Too magical for a Winx outfit! I like the original version. Spongebob Channel had ruined their transformation! WTF? But I like Layla's original name!

Mariana Erwin

P.S. 4KIDS < RAI

[WinxClubSeason5Fan]

i like original it is awesome

[Aneczka0210]

They ruined Stella's transformation :( I'm totally for the old ones. The Nickelodeon ones are, I don't know, too fast...

[JAPgally4340]

Im picking the old version bc Musa and flora's transformation was fantastic! Those 2 r my favs!

[JAPgally4340]

Well it's a bit unfair to compare them to each other because the RAI version was created b4 the nick one and Nickelodeon just decided to make it look more like it pops with glitter and stuff. obviously, people wud pick the Nick version over the old one

[kawaiikiwi777]

THE ORGINAL WINS

[knon2000]

ok i cose the new vurson becuse in the old vrson tecna sounded british!

[JAPgally4340]

@knon2000 Tecna wasn't suppose to b british in the first place. This show was ITALIAN so none of the characters were suppose to b british. Ppl just got used to the fact that tecna is british in the 4kids version. No offense but I just can't believe ppl r complaining about tecna's voice in the nick version! They shud just b happy that the Winx r back! Back better then ever! It's better than them being gone.

[LiliaLuciaFun]

rechts...!!!

[89990000]

A fairy show has been damaged by Nickelodeon. Their cartoons are more better rather than the borrowed ones.

Mariana Erwin

P.S. - Magic Charmix S.U.C.K.S!

[89990000]

Nickelodeon's Magic Charmix looks like they transformed into Believix. F**K them! Even their voices which make good acting in TV! RAINBOW S.R.L. FTW!

Mariana Erwin

[89990000]

Magic Winx wins! F**K NICK! Magic Charmix loses! Go RAI! Go ORIGINAL! The Old version always wins and never those new stuff.

Mariana Erwin

[Xmrosli26]

Bloom: new

Flora:New

Stella:both

Musa:old

Tecna:new

[saharabdulwali]

original version

[saasy12345a1]

i like the old one

[Luvyourself16]

BLOOM: OLD

FLORA: NEW

STELLA: BOTH

MUSA: NEW

TECNA: BOTH

[cosmotails12]

RAI

[nancyzhang7]

I like both versions

[Najlagirl123]

i like the nick version better!!

[TheMagicPeople100]

nick



[chemutu]

why the nick version call the transformation charmix? isn't charmix supposed to be the additional purse and brooch thingies??

[NanaXTabs]

Rai :3

[chomper83]

the 4kids is still better they should make a season 4 on 4kids

[saharabdulwali]

@chomper83 yes

[Plutonima]

Bloom : I like her beginning spin effect with that fire so the old win

Flora : I like the necklace , pendant and glove shot so the old win

Stella : I like her spin when the twintail comes and the circle effects so the old win

Musa : I like her disco dance and the CD spinning pose so the old win

Tecna : I like her "hand-cross" pose and the flying at the end so the old win

DAMN NOTHING CAN BEAT THE ORIGINAL!!!

[BlossomPPGD17]

Bloom: Nick

Flora: Old

Stella: Both

Musa: Old

Tecna: Nick

[purplefire210]

nick started to use the version with that song.

[CindiLeeJM]

My only complaint with the Nick version of the series is the voice acting. Forgettable voices and voice acting that I don't find very convincing. Having heard the original dub and the 4kids dub, I prefer the older adaptations of Bloom and Sky's voices, along with some of the other girls.

[MewIchigo10982]

@CindiLeeJM Omg I SO agree with you. I just don't like this new Winx in general. These kids don't even know about the whole switcharoo thing Sky did with Brandon. The Trix's voice have no power behind it. They just sound like bratty teenage girls now compared to sounding like WOMEN. I wish they would have kept the voices, but I do like their modern transformations.

[darknessslayer]

Both old and new are made by the same company so its a hard toss up.

[jaslene105]

i like both

[McDanilushk]

Original

[987saphire]

new version

[ShAyY214]

nothing can beat the original!!!

[HowrseGirl2012]

@ShAyY214 I so agree

[soyoyotokyo]

bloom: nick

flora: nick

tecna:nick

musa:rai

stella: rai

aisha/layla: rai

the old ones show more detail in the fact you see EVERYTHING come onto them and the nick one they are already in costume and just add pieces the background is cooler though in the new ones :D

[magicasandra]

The Rainbow is much better, Nickelodeon is very much like Believix, besides the fire dragon does not appear if not to the Enchantix.

Top Rainbow is better!

[zuziiite1]

Well, the new version of NICK is more modern, better quality,and colours, it just looks better.

But nothing can beat the original, so the old version wins!

[HowrseGirl2012]

@zuziiite1 I so agree, cuz I watched this cartoon since I was 4. And I still love it!

[sailormoonrevenge]

@zuziiite1 in u guys opinion!

[987saphire]

new

[Plutonima]

The Nickelodeon one is for the FIRST TRANSFORMATION ???? It's too much :D

[DragonMisstres2008]

i think nick might have a problem, but who knows maybe they will be able to make something original while keeping to the original. we don't know yet. no one can judge from just one remake. I think i will remain neutral until they do the ones.

[KaYlAhT08]

Old one is better, it wasn't all about Bloom in the first 3 Episodes. -.-

[mrwombatwombat]

i think the 4kids the nick ones makes girls look girlier

[blossick4evs]

all of u shut the fuck up!!!

it doesn't matter!!!

if the new transformation was the old version u go for it sooo IT DOESNT MATTER!!!! UR ALL IDIOTS except for those who like both...

[waterstars10]

GRRRRRRR I HATE NICK FOR MAKING A COMPLETE WEIRD VERSION OF WINX!!! *CRIES*

[TearDropQween]

Old transformation is good! I like it! Of course,

but the new one is cool too.

So I pick both of them

[MewKiyoko]

I appreciate the originality Nick has with its transformations.

[Tigerfangs13]

how do you put 2 videos into 1??i have always wanted to split 2 videos into 1 but i cant figure it out..can u PM me or just reply to my comment?

[cesarelchido1]

me gustan las dos transfrmaciones

[TheBespectacled]

@loveminne424

I think so to

[LoveMinne424]

Old version waaaay better. Nick's version is garbage and I prefer to watch ever season in italian than nick's piece of crap! They RUINED winx club!!!!!!!

[glemsy10]

im for the right version

[cutiepop405]

old the new tried to make the old one look bad

[Weldora13]

Old transformations is better.

[IcyTrixSite]

old transformations!

I still don't understand why they made a new version of the first season. They really ruined my fav season...

[sparkles0205]

you all relize that in the old transformation, each girl crosses her hands?

[CrystalKabuto]

I like how Nick starts the transformation but I like Rai actual transformations.

[shelbypink1]

the new ones are soooooo much better without a doubt

[dogs869dansjet]

i like the nick version better



[wickedodd12345]

old one

[FallenRaeLi21]

lol Wow the new ones are kinda gay. The Old ones were not so girly -_-

[catokeeffe]

@FallenRaeLi21 They're girls. What are they supposed to look like? If anything, by your reasoning, the old transformations were more gay (lesbian to be specific), because they were less girly.

[FallenRaeLi21]

@catokeeffe ...I don't like them as much as the old ones is that better? -_- just a opinion. I like how the old ones were not so idk flashy.

[catokeeffe]

@FallenRaeLi21 The word gay doesn't mean "something I dislike." It also doesn't mean "flashy", "girly", etc. Learn how to speak English.

[FallenRaeLi21]

@catokeeffe Sorry...

[sparkles0205]

@catokeeffe no..that's the new one. the only thing now is that their wings glitter as well as the clothing

[wonzo9090]

Also who hates the new clothing

[wonzo9090]

The thing with nick is that it is changing the winx style. I love the old ones because they followed the original from Italy and originals are always the best. Including the animations. I mean of people of today who like new stuff and the cool animations will choose the nick or the people who are 1st watching the show. Originals always are the best because without those, there would be no new versions, so to say.

[catokeeffe]

@wonzo9090 Congratulations. You have succeeded in making absolutely no sense.

[FallenRaeLi21]

@wonzo9090 Agreed

[CrestCharger32]

Both

[moxieteenz731]

Nick Nick Nick nn nick nick

[marceliin4]

love transformation of nick the stella love transformation of the cartoon network fo the nick is beutiful transformation and dont have spanish of mexico?

[LockedFilms]

New transformations are better...

[Melissiehartje]

colors*

[Melissiehartje]

the old version becaus i hate that cors they have in the transformation in the new!

[gina1998m]

Bloom: old Flora: both Stella: both Musa: old Tecna: new.

[lilboiiswaqqs13]

Bloom- New

Flora- both

Stella-Old

Musa-Old

Techna-Old

The new version makes them look like they 16..the old version actully makes them look like collage gurls

[wonzo9090]

@lilboiiswaqqs13 they said many times that Alfea was a college for fairies.

[lilboiiswaqqs13]

@wonzo9090 i kno butt like they just look like teenagers half the time

[PinkOwlsRule]

i dont really care i am just happy their producing it in the United States again!

though i do perfer the old tiles and musas nick transformation is kinda lame compared to the other girls'

[mh12cav]

musa:new

flora:new

bloom:new

tecna:new

so i'm for the new one :) ;)



[Toshisan]

i dont like how stella's winx was made skimpier, original stella's outfit covered more which nick stella's was skankyer (the shorts are the most noticeable, originally thier normal girl shorts, nick made them into practically panties)

[borielikesdropjes]

right side is best

[StellaStarinWinx]

I prefare the new version but nick has set a high standart to aim at to make a new transform as well nick has used the season 3 clothes they will have to make some new up :)

[SinistraFangirl13]

I hope that Nick doesn't gloss over Stella's parents being divorced. Well then again they did dub her the "Fairy of the Shining Sun" I like her title from the old version "Fairy of the Sun and Moon". and I loved Musa's old transformation with the giant CD.

[desiwim10]

i like the old version more

[jaspergeXD]

New version!

THUNBS UP IF YOU AGREE!

[Secretallheart13]

Definitely the old version but . . . i do also realize that everyone has their own version so . . we will see what happens.

also . . i do like the new one also :)

[Secretallheart13]

Definitely the old version but . . . i do also realize that everyone has their own version so . . we will see what happens.

[Solitemel]

I like the old version, but I say the new one is better. It's more magical and I'm in love with that song.

[winxfloralove]

the problem with the new one is that it's too good. with the simpler old version, they were able to make the transformations look better and better as the winx got more powerful. nick is going 2 hav a problem maybe as early as believix when they can't improve the transformation anymore. for this reason, i choose the old version.

[kitten349]

@winxfloralove yea but some people what the new version too look like the old one.

[winxfloralove]

@kitten349 well, that's the version ppl r used to, so it's only natural that they prefer the old one and want to change nick's version.

[AelitasWings]

@winxfloralove You're kidding, right? As they get more powerful they get flashier outfits and larger wings; if you're creative enough, you can come up with new transformations that go with the new looks in awesomeness!

[winxfloralove]

@AelitasWings no, i am not joking, and i would appreciate it if u respected and considered my opinion just as i am respecting and considering yours.

[AelitasWings]

@winxfloralove No offense intended. By the way, when was this "new version"? I only started watching around Nick's "help, Stella's been cursed and now her own daddy's trying to kill her" episode, and the transformation sequences just looked like better-quality renditions of the old versions.

[Lucillerose24]

I Choose New Version Cause I've Never Seen The Old One Before.

[HeartPearlVoice]

Old, but thats just because of the voices. They actually fit, and they were very good actors. The new ones either can`t act or don`t sound like the characters.

The new one has very nice drawings and animation. I like it, actually.

The old will have a special place in my heart for ever, but I`ll give the new a chance.

[ChibiCatinc]

Although you may think the old version is "Better" The new version is not a "rip-off". It's from the same creator and animators. It's just had adjustments. It's not even that important. It's just to warm us all up for the new season, and showing us how it will be animated. So either way, I love both versions and I'm freaking excited that Winx Club is PROPERLY in America. <3

[jflys423]

I think it should look like this you know two camera view

[ThewinxT]

i like the old one better. its more original and not so girly. the nick one is too posy and i hate the fact that they named the first transformation charmix. i think the only transformations that should have a name are the ones that are a higher achieved level. and i'm kinda disappointed in mr. straffi. it only shows how very unproud he is of his early work. i am 100% loyal to the original italian version.

[MANMEE55]

Musa has short hairstyle i don't like the hairstylist

[monsterhighwinxlove1]

New version, it is more I don't know, Sparkly. Isn't that what Winx is about?

Bloom- New

Flora- New

Stella- Old

Musa- Old

Tecna- NEW!!!! I hated the old one xD