how did beyonce even get mentioned on this video? this is about Barbara Streisand and this song makes me cry...I am not a fan perse but this movie is amazing and her singing in this movie was truly amazing
¡¡¡¡¡¡DIOS QUIEN HAYA SUBIDO ESTAS MELODIAS MICHISSSSIIIMMMAAASSS GRACIAS ...NO TENE IDEA DE TODO LO BELLO QUE VIVI ESCUCHANDOLAS ....CAY NO TENGO PALABRAS. AUN GUARDO LA FUNDA ORIGINAL DE DISCO DE ESTA BELLA PELICULA....DE VERAD GRACIAS¡¡¡¡¡¡¡
Still the best. People like to be able to enjoy singing along with the song. Today's music doesn't let you do that......It's too all over the place.. One of my absolute favorite movies.
@vanfane1069 well to bad so sad that I don't care what they do with this movie! and like i already said i know that it was a remake i've seen them all!
@billyboylb well its not like iher of them can do there own movie again and i knoe mrs. streisand with mr eastwood chose BEYONCE SO THE NEGATIVE COMMENTS MEAN DUST..
Now I'm a complete Beyonce Stan and watched this movie for the first time, and honestly she will NEVER COMPARE to Barbra and I think they're gonna make new songs for her so I wouldn't be concerned about this song being "messed up"
@MelviNichols THEN U ARE NOT A STAN BECAUSE IF YOU WERE U WOULD KNOW BEE GIVES 1000% SHE WOULDNT DO IT IF WAS WHACK AND YES SHE IS WRITEING NEW SONGS FOR THE MOVE MR EASTWWOD JUST ANNOUNCE. MRS BARBARA AND EASTWWOD BOTH RECENTLY SAID FROM WHAT THEY DID UNTIL THEY HAD TO STOP BEFORE SHE BECAME A MOTHER THAT SHE WAS CLEARLY THE CHOICE..
@gspott699 Oh no trust me I'm a stan, no disrespect! at all all I'm saying is that these women are all good at what they do in their own way but all the movies are going to be AMAZING
Y'all criticizing Beyonce before she start working on it. Y'all won't know how good or bad it is until you see it. And the singing? Have y'all not seen Dreamgirls and Cadillac Records? Yes no one will top an original record, but Beyonce does each and every song from both films justice. I'm sure she will do the same with this song from the film. She has complete control over her voice unlike most singers.
@HOMIEiGoHard THANK YOU.. YOU ARE SO WRITE AND IF THEY TOUGHT SHE COULD NOT THEN IT WOULD BEEN SOMEONE ELSE. MR EASTWOOD JUST SAID BEE IS ACTUALLY WRITEING NEW MUSIC WHICH HE WANTED HER TO DO.
No one.... absolutely no one can even come close to Barbra Streisand when it comes to singing..... the tone, the inflection, the passion, the emotion...... not Celine. not Mariah. Not Beyonce...... all good singers, even great singers..... but Barbra is the ultimate!....... she pulls you in and never lets you go.
@Vanasse1 - I totally agree with you Vanasse1. I have always said there has never been nor will there ever be a greater singer than Barbra. The others you mention are great in their own right (though I wouldn't include Beyonce on the same tier as the other two) but Barbra is the benchmark all great singers should aspire to.
@Vanasse1 I`ve been saying that for years, when people said celine was better I didn`t get it....just listen to babs sing Somewhere, from west side story.....ultimate...can`t be copied
@ecanem1964 There's just that 'it' factor in Barbra... she makes you feel every single note that she sings... while other singers might have great range, and great power, Barbra doesn't try to impress you with fancy runs and octaves... she just makes you feel it!.. I can't imagine anyone ever, ever topping her.
@mscatherinelewis because they wanted beyonce some with talent weather u like it are not and a name people still know and will bring hem to the big screen.. celine is mummy and well leona is a one album wonder..
Jonnie Mathis and Barbra are like fine wine.. .... and both has earned everyones respect and well should just how long have they been popular? go figure????????????? love you both thanks for all the tunes and memories..
I don't think Beyonce would do a good job at this song...and before all you Beyonce fans get angry I'm not saying she can't sing I'm saying this isn't her style...I think Mariah Carey could pull this song off though she could hit Barbra's high notes.
There is only one Barbara....this was a great movie when I first saw it some 20+ years ago...even used the song, Evergreen, in my wedding....its still a classic and always will be...the marriage is over now, and I still feel this songs impact on me...I will carry on..
Response to Remaking with Beyonce. The Barbera version was already the 3rd or 4th version of this movie. EVery generation deserves a shot. The movie will be based on it's own merits.
@WilliamsKarl I AGREE WITH YOU AND TO ME BEYONCE IS THE FEMALE OF THIS GENRATION. I'M NOT TALKING NEW COMERS GAGA,KATIE,RIHANA,ADELE THEY GOOD IN TIER RIGHT BUT BEYONCE IS QUEEN.
@kissthis4x - The Streisand version was a remake of "A Star is Born" (1954) starring Judy Garland, which was a remake of "A Star is Born" (1937) starring Janet Gaynor.
@tracyblogger well i knew that lol! what i was really saying is i don't want them to re-make this again, not with Beyonce' at least!!! not trying to be mean or anything!!
@kissthis4x I bet folks back in 1976 said the same thing about Babs .... "What??? Barbra Streisand doing Judy Garland???? Noooo!!!" By the way, have you seen the Judy Garland version? Its fantastic.
@Jany1954 yeah but i'm pretty sure their gonna make it so Beyonce can make her mark on it like Barbra did so all us good Barbra fans is going to have to try our best to stop looking at it as a Barbra movie when we go see it, and let Beyonce have her monment so her fans can be proud of her!!!! You know!!??
@wambui37 Yeah, I gotta agree, I've been following Barbara since I was young, nobody comes close, as much as I love Beyonce, Barbara has such a special presentation, voice & tonal quality that is unmatched.
@kissthis4x .... but this is like the second remake of this film..... it was originally brought to screen in the 30s, then again in the 50s with judy garland as star, and then this time in the 70s with streisand. I say a remake is long over due!! Plus, it would be nice to see how it is reinvented.
@kissthis4x .... but this is like the second remake of this film..... it was originally brought to screen in the 30s, then again in the 50s with judy garland as star, and then this time in the 70s with streisand. I say a remake is long over due!! Plus, it would be nice to see how it is reinvented.
@kissthis4x .... but this is like the second remake of this film..... it was originally brought to screen in the 30s, then again in the 50s with judy garland as star, and then this time in the 70s with Streisand. I say a remake is long over due!! Plus, it would be nice to see how it is reinvented.
Why not this has been remade twice before Barbra, 1937 with Janet Gaynor, then judy garland and barbra, was third , so I must say that Beyonce is the next diva of our time to actually pull it through . Dont expect the same songs , each movie is totally different. Barbra made it a musical movie. I dont think the others were musicals.
Absolute Perfection BRAVO Sweet Barbra!!!
romanticspirit 1 week ago
how can u beat this? awesome voice, awesome film!
purplejan88 2 weeks ago
like'a meatloaf band!
arkadert 2 weeks ago
This is from the good old days when singers sustained their notes without whirling around like dervishes.
vinniemcgee 1 month ago
how did beyonce even get mentioned on this video? this is about Barbara Streisand and this song makes me cry...I am not a fan perse but this movie is amazing and her singing in this movie was truly amazing
davisfontanes 1 month ago
the perfect voice
stevesg92 1 month ago
such a complex vocal performance a true demonstration of an actor singing
swnotley 1 month ago
¡¡¡¡¡¡DIOS QUIEN HAYA SUBIDO ESTAS MELODIAS MICHISSSSIIIMMMAAASSS GRACIAS ...NO TENE IDEA DE TODO LO BELLO QUE VIVI ESCUCHANDOLAS ....CAY NO TENGO PALABRAS. AUN GUARDO LA FUNDA ORIGINAL DE DISCO DE ESTA BELLA PELICULA....DE VERAD GRACIAS¡¡¡¡¡¡¡
MrCarolinaandrade 1 month ago
One of the most underrated movies out there. Love Barbra's character's renditions of Kris' character's songs. Her spin was superb!
amethystlady 1 month ago
It is BARBRA !!!!!!!
Still the best. People like to be able to enjoy singing along with the song. Today's music doesn't let you do that......It's too all over the place.. One of my absolute favorite movies.
jilla1123 1 month ago
Love this movie, and what an ending song!! She's the best IMHO!
Jany1954 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
@vanfane1069 well to bad so sad that I don't care what they do with this movie! and like i already said i know that it was a remake i've seen them all!
kissthis4x 2 months ago
hollywood thinks these kids today can match/duplicate a talant like Babbs LMAO no way!!! Get a grip STUPIDWOOD
fischparov 3 months ago
Hmmm... well obviously these are just weak remakes of the Judy Garland film
davidreeves101 3 months ago
Beyonce is good at what she does but i wouldn't put her next to Garland or Streisand.
billyboylb 3 months ago 8
@billyboylb well its not like iher of them can do there own movie again and i knoe mrs. streisand with mr eastwood chose BEYONCE SO THE NEGATIVE COMMENTS MEAN DUST..
gspott699 1 month ago
Star is born with babs was a remake
RandeClark 3 months ago
as truly enthralled as I am by this entire scene, " your eyes are like fingers touching my body" still really weirds me out.
alexis97871 3 months ago
Okay I cried. D: I admit it
Streisand101Lover 3 months ago
DO U WANT TO KNOW ME ?
DOGGODCRAIG 4 months ago
One of the best movies that Barbara Streisand made...still awesome as it was from the first time I saw it.
KajunKels 4 months ago
look at her eyes, so emotional :)
maxxieassies 4 months ago
one of my favorite song I love it !!
soly0424 4 months ago
When she held him after he died so so sad.. and when she was on the Staris--- Award Winning Performance!!!
romanticspirit 5 months ago
Screaaaaammmmm!!!! Tremendous Barbra .. And what an ending to a great film.
824koumari 5 months ago
She is one of the best, and will always be, You cant improve on the best
mikeybugguns 6 months ago
f'in shivers!!!
ohioname 6 months ago
I like Tom Servo's version better. ;-)
sleepyhollow783 6 months ago
get over it brillo dweller . . .jeez.
realtallshorty 6 months ago
Now I'm a complete Beyonce Stan and watched this movie for the first time, and honestly she will NEVER COMPARE to Barbra and I think they're gonna make new songs for her so I wouldn't be concerned about this song being "messed up"
MelviNichols 7 months ago
@MelviNichols THEN U ARE NOT A STAN BECAUSE IF YOU WERE U WOULD KNOW BEE GIVES 1000% SHE WOULDNT DO IT IF WAS WHACK AND YES SHE IS WRITEING NEW SONGS FOR THE MOVE MR EASTWWOD JUST ANNOUNCE. MRS BARBARA AND EASTWWOD BOTH RECENTLY SAID FROM WHAT THEY DID UNTIL THEY HAD TO STOP BEFORE SHE BECAME A MOTHER THAT SHE WAS CLEARLY THE CHOICE..
gspott699 1 month ago
@gspott699 Oh no trust me I'm a stan, no disrespect! at all all I'm saying is that these women are all good at what they do in their own way but all the movies are going to be AMAZING
MelviNichols 1 month ago
Y'all criticizing Beyonce before she start working on it. Y'all won't know how good or bad it is until you see it. And the singing? Have y'all not seen Dreamgirls and Cadillac Records? Yes no one will top an original record, but Beyonce does each and every song from both films justice. I'm sure she will do the same with this song from the film. She has complete control over her voice unlike most singers.
HOMIEiGoHard 7 months ago
@HOMIEiGoHard THANK YOU.. YOU ARE SO WRITE AND IF THEY TOUGHT SHE COULD NOT THEN IT WOULD BEEN SOMEONE ELSE. MR EASTWOOD JUST SAID BEE IS ACTUALLY WRITEING NEW MUSIC WHICH HE WANTED HER TO DO.
gspott699 1 month ago
sorry. Beyonce is no Barbra. Talented as she is, but still....
15bluethings 7 months ago
@15bluethings So true!! She's no Barbra!
Jany1954 6 months ago
@15bluethings even tough mrs. barbra supports bee she want a judy garland ither.. but beyounce will do great.. she has control over her voice
gspott699 1 month ago
This song is maiking me tremble !!!! NO ONE WILL EVER SING IT LIKE SHE DID !!!
dimitu3 7 months ago
No one.... absolutely no one can even come close to Barbra Streisand when it comes to singing..... the tone, the inflection, the passion, the emotion...... not Celine. not Mariah. Not Beyonce...... all good singers, even great singers..... but Barbra is the ultimate!....... she pulls you in and never lets you go.
Vanasse1 8 months ago
@Vanasse1 - I totally agree with you Vanasse1. I have always said there has never been nor will there ever be a greater singer than Barbra. The others you mention are great in their own right (though I wouldn't include Beyonce on the same tier as the other two) but Barbra is the benchmark all great singers should aspire to.
Jimmy110459 8 months ago
@Vanasse1 I`ve been saying that for years, when people said celine was better I didn`t get it....just listen to babs sing Somewhere, from west side story.....ultimate...can`t be copied
ecanem1964 7 months ago
@ecanem1964 There's just that 'it' factor in Barbra... she makes you feel every single note that she sings... while other singers might have great range, and great power, Barbra doesn't try to impress you with fancy runs and octaves... she just makes you feel it!.. I can't imagine anyone ever, ever topping her.
Vanasse1 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is a great soundtrack even now. Why not Celine or Leona Lewis for the re-make?
mscatherinelewis 8 months ago
This is a great soundtrack even now. Why not Celine or Leona Lewis for the re-make?
mscatherinelewis 8 months ago
@mscatherinelewis because they wanted beyonce some with talent weather u like it are not and a name people still know and will bring hem to the big screen.. celine is mummy and well leona is a one album wonder..
gspott699 1 month ago
I love many of the songs from this soundtrack. Maybe Celine or Leona Lewis for the re-make. ?
mscatherinelewis 8 months ago
For my my son's father who died at 46 1/11
cmrutter1 9 months ago
Jonnie Mathis and Barbra are like fine wine.. .... and both has earned everyones respect and well should just how long have they been popular? go figure????????????? love you both thanks for all the tunes and memories..
rufngo 9 months ago
Comment removed
Enticingmami0813 9 months ago
I don't think Beyonce would do a good job at this song...and before all you Beyonce fans get angry I'm not saying she can't sing I'm saying this isn't her style...I think Mariah Carey could pull this song off though she could hit Barbra's high notes.
Enticingmami0813 9 months ago
The woman is perfection; always was, always will be.
cidspimms 9 months ago
great voice, though her hair looks like a brillo pad..:o
sweetucky 1 year ago 2
@sweetucky It was the rage in those days!
zinzan999 10 months ago
@sweetucky It was all the rage in those days!
zinzan999 10 months ago
@sweetucky Barbra looked great in this movie. The style is relevant to the time this movie was made.
Jimmy110459 8 months ago
Amazinggggggg
mymarty23 1 year ago
There is only one Barbara....this was a great movie when I first saw it some 20+ years ago...even used the song, Evergreen, in my wedding....its still a classic and always will be...the marriage is over now, and I still feel this songs impact on me...I will carry on..
bernitamchaput 1 year ago
Response to Remaking with Beyonce. The Barbera version was already the 3rd or 4th version of this movie. EVery generation deserves a shot. The movie will be based on it's own merits.
WilliamsKarl 1 year ago
@WilliamsKarl I AGREE WITH YOU AND TO ME BEYONCE IS THE FEMALE OF THIS GENRATION. I'M NOT TALKING NEW COMERS GAGA,KATIE,RIHANA,ADELE THEY GOOD IN TIER RIGHT BUT BEYONCE IS QUEEN.
gspott699 1 month ago
unique!!!!!
sambatrela 1 year ago
i can't believe they are going to re-make this!! with BEYONCE' AS LEAD??? they can't re-make every thing!!!
kissthis4x 1 year ago 21
@kissthis4x - The Streisand version was a remake of "A Star is Born" (1954) starring Judy Garland, which was a remake of "A Star is Born" (1937) starring Janet Gaynor.
tracyblogger 8 months ago
@tracyblogger well i knew that lol! what i was really saying is i don't want them to re-make this again, not with Beyonce' at least!!! not trying to be mean or anything!!
kissthis4x 8 months ago
@kissthis4x They don't seem to realize that.
austwin1 8 months ago
@kissthis4x should I point out that this was a re-make?
...of a re-make!
wezthewezwez 7 months ago
@kissthis4x should I point out that this was a re-make?
...of a re-make!
wezthewezwez 7 months ago
@wezthewezwez and I know that!!!!!!!!! 3 times! But I think Barbra's should be the last one!!!!
kissthis4x 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kissthis4x should I point out that this was a re-make?
...of a re-make!
wezthewezwez 7 months ago
@kissthis4x I bet folks back in 1976 said the same thing about Babs .... "What??? Barbra Streisand doing Judy Garland???? Noooo!!!" By the way, have you seen the Judy Garland version? Its fantastic.
Aussiemarco 6 months ago
@Aussiemarco Barbara did a much better job IMHO!
Jany1954 6 months ago
@Aussiemarco yeah i'm pretty sure they did!!! But hey she might do a good job!! and yes I have it's wonderful!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
kissthis4x 6 months ago
@kissthis4x really, Beyonce? Oh my goodness - it won't be the same - no way!!
Jany1954 6 months ago
@Jany1954 yeah but i'm pretty sure their gonna make it so Beyonce can make her mark on it like Barbra did so all us good Barbra fans is going to have to try our best to stop looking at it as a Barbra movie when we go see it, and let Beyonce have her monment so her fans can be proud of her!!!! You know!!??
kissthis4x 6 months ago
@Jany1954 HATTER ITS NOT MENT TO BE IF EASTWWOD AND MRS BARBARA TOUGHT SHE WASNT THE CHOICE THEY WOULDT HAVE CHOSE HER DONT BE A HATTER..
gspott699 1 month ago
@kissthis4x if I were beyonce, I would reject the role. She can only lose!
no one plays and sings this Esther Hoffman as fantastic as Barbra Streisand.
Another story and other music ... ok then.
wambui37 5 months ago
@wambui37 Yeah, I gotta agree, I've been following Barbara since I was young, nobody comes close, as much as I love Beyonce, Barbara has such a special presentation, voice & tonal quality that is unmatched.
juzzlookin 3 months ago 3
@kissthis4x .... but this is like the second remake of this film..... it was originally brought to screen in the 30s, then again in the 50s with judy garland as star, and then this time in the 70s with streisand. I say a remake is long over due!! Plus, it would be nice to see how it is reinvented.
danielletheadorkable 5 months ago
@kissthis4x .... but this is like the second remake of this film..... it was originally brought to screen in the 30s, then again in the 50s with judy garland as star, and then this time in the 70s with streisand. I say a remake is long over due!! Plus, it would be nice to see how it is reinvented.
danielletheadorkable 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kissthis4x .... but this is like the second remake of this film..... it was originally brought to screen in the 30s, then again in the 50s with judy garland as star, and then this time in the 70s with Streisand. I say a remake is long over due!! Plus, it would be nice to see how it is reinvented.
danielletheadorkable 5 months ago
@kissthis4x : I so agree with you! When will Hollywood writers start writing their own stuff instead of re doing classics!!
irishtaz44017 5 months ago
@kissthis4x
Why not this has been remade twice before Barbra, 1937 with Janet Gaynor, then judy garland and barbra, was third , so I must say that Beyonce is the next diva of our time to actually pull it through . Dont expect the same songs , each movie is totally different. Barbra made it a musical movie. I dont think the others were musicals.
rgsobe 4 months ago
@kissthis4x You do realize this was a remake of a remake right?
bpnsirdiealot 3 months ago
@kissthis4x this version of the film is the 2 remake of the film, so, yes, they can remake this another time
vanfanel069 2 months ago
@kissthis4x That is sad.
Lainer1 2 months ago
@kissthis4x dont be hatter all your life
gspott699 1 month ago
@kissthis4x YEP I'M EXCITED YOU SHOULD BE TOO
gspott699 1 month ago
@gspott699 yep! I'm glad you are!!!!
kissthis4x 1 month ago
EXCELENTEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
BIGOTEPOBLANO 1 year ago
visto e rivisto....un film stupendo:)
esterester1968 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i loved this movie.... i even got that hair cut after i saw it...
radiodiva777 1 year ago
i loved this movie.... i even got that hair cut after i saw it...
radiodiva777 1 year ago
Great Woman, Great Actress, Great Singer, Great Voice
MrBeautifulstranger1 1 year ago
sin palabras!
xavisert 1 year ago
BRAVO Barbara !
1BGrazyna 1 year ago