Greensleeves existed in 1580. Refer to Shakespeare. Then a christian overrode the original lyrics of a love lament, about 300 years later. Same crap as with the blasphemy of slathering christian lyrics over "Freude, schöner Götterfunken" / Beethoven's Ninth as "joyful joyful we adore thee". Why must people override human experience and love for humanity w/ dogmatic mythology in a terrible attempt at improving the original?
@johnwhite79 look at hollywood....they do it all the time to books. (and as of late, previously released motion pictures). i think its because people cant think for themselves anymore.
@RubyLeo2006 I don't have time to go into it now, but please go to Amazon and looking at the CD listing of these songs. :) This is Mr. Guaraldi's "Greensleeves", the CBS Recording of this album. Take care.
@RubyLeo2006 Greensleeves was written in 1580, while What Child Is This was written in 1865 and was put to the tune of Greensleeves. Therefore, there is no way to differentiate them other than duration.
@RubyLeo2006 Actually, they are both takes on the same song. Greensleeves is sometimes alternatively referred to as "What Child is This." Guaraldi decided to record two versions of it. "What Child is this," however, has a somewhat different feel to it. Trust me, I have the album. This is "Greensleeves."
@RubyLeo2006 No, this is "Greensleeves". But I can see why you'd be confused, because "Greensleeves" came first, & "What Child Is This" had the melody. But I know this is "Greensleeves", because you can note small differences between the two during the beginning.
I have the album from 1964 . It is my favorite Christmas album
airkooled05 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
• ★Merry★* 。 • ˚ ˚ ˛ ˚ ˛ •
•。★Christmas★ 。* 。
° 。 ° ˛˚˛ * _Π_____*。*˚
˚ ˛ •˛•˚ */______/~\。˚ ˚ ˛
˚ ˛ •˛• ˚ | 田田 |門| ˚And a happy new year !!
...♥*•♪♫•*¨* ℒℴvℯ ॐ Light *¨*•♪Joy to all! ♫•*¨*Peace on Earth♪♫•*¨*
DreamChemistryMusic 2 months ago in playlist charlie brown christmas
I cant listen to this music without seeing snow falling and swirling and blowing in drifts in my mind. Beautiful!
tdavis25 3 months ago
Good God, Guaraldi was a genius. This is mesmerizing
bregowine 3 months ago
Beautiful and Timeless <3
Tadoow11 7 months ago
There is another version on youtube.
marvy1118 1 year ago
This is love made music
lmk10000 1 year ago
oes anybody here realize that Greensleeves goes back to fifteenth century England? "What Child..." is a direct melody lift.
MultiBudboy 1 year ago 3
the piano is simply an extension of this man's fingers. uncanny.
anetys 1 year ago
Greensleeves existed in 1580. Refer to Shakespeare. Then a christian overrode the original lyrics of a love lament, about 300 years later. Same crap as with the blasphemy of slathering christian lyrics over "Freude, schöner Götterfunken" / Beethoven's Ninth as "joyful joyful we adore thee". Why must people override human experience and love for humanity w/ dogmatic mythology in a terrible attempt at improving the original?
johnwhite79 1 year ago
@johnwhite79 look at hollywood....they do it all the time to books. (and as of late, previously released motion pictures). i think its because people cant think for themselves anymore.
upstatenyphann 1 year ago
Greensleeves = What Child Is This. They are one and the same. Love.
MeredithWeaver2 1 year ago 6
@MeredithWeaver2 :)
ladybret 1 year ago
ok :) i dunno just sound like what child is this my mistake
RubyLeo2006 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is what child is this not greensleeves
RubyLeo2006 1 year ago
@RubyLeo2006 I don't have time to go into it now, but please go to Amazon and looking at the CD listing of these songs. :) This is Mr. Guaraldi's "Greensleeves", the CBS Recording of this album. Take care.
:Ladybrett
ladybret 1 year ago 4
@RubyLeo2006
Greensleeves came first; the song "What Child is This" was set to the Greensleeves melody.
ruthampton 1 year ago 8
@RubyLeo2006 Greensleeves was written in 1580, while What Child Is This was written in 1865 and was put to the tune of Greensleeves. Therefore, there is no way to differentiate them other than duration.
1nijigirl2 1 year ago
@1nijigirl2 ok my apologizes
RubyLeo2006 1 year ago
@RubyLeo2006 Actually, they are both takes on the same song. Greensleeves is sometimes alternatively referred to as "What Child is This." Guaraldi decided to record two versions of it. "What Child is this," however, has a somewhat different feel to it. Trust me, I have the album. This is "Greensleeves."
TheNewMightyChalaza 1 year ago
@RubyLeo2006 Greensleeves and What Child is This share the same music.
jgfunk 1 year ago
@RubyLeo2006 No, this is "Greensleeves". But I can see why you'd be confused, because "Greensleeves" came first, & "What Child Is This" had the melody. But I know this is "Greensleeves", because you can note small differences between the two during the beginning.
minamu8 1 year ago
Thank you!
cacacarmen11111 1 year ago 3