Added: 1 year ago
From: TheManThatGetAway
Views: 16,008
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (51)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Comment removed

  • Dear Judy what a wonderful rendition of true talent & emotions without the hype of today's distractions that try to hide dishonest performances with no talent and character of the artist and his/her skill.

  • Her final movie. She was taken away far, far too soon. RIP beautiful lady.

  • My GOD...Judy Garland...what you do to my SOUL...I adore you. I love you. Thank you for making me so happy. No one compares to this,

  • I love this woman! thank you for posting

  • love judy love the song but red on red what were they thinking?

  • @ajgroelant I actually LOVE the red on red, especially in the middle of the song when she turns her back and walks back toward the curtain, as if her character were immersed in the stage -- they did this in several other scenes in the movie (matched her dress with the stage background), and I think the effect is wonderful!

  • Her best version of this ... Wonderful production values ... move from inner monologue to theatre, etc. What power! ... and what seeming conviction. Odd, but I do not even think of this as "Fred's song anymore ... but more Judy's own. And yes, the walk ... love the walk. (And despite the comments of others ... I think the red on red works well in the context of the film!)

  • I love how she just walks off stage; no bow, just walks off.

  • @themanthatgetaway you are my hero..

  • @DebsTasha45 Hahaha! Thanks! ;)

  • Great singing but my god what were they thinking letting her wear that monstrosity of a dress.

  • this was on netflix. so beautiful. im 16 and ive been in love with judy since i was 11. during these 5 years i come to her, she knows my pain, she comforts me. she puts a smile on my face. thank goodness for judy.

  • I literally cannot describe Judy Garland, but I will mention that I have never ever loved anyone else's voice as much as Judy's , right from the start when I was 2, starting with the wizard of oz, my favourite film of all time!

  • I think she is finally letting herself "unravel", in this performance and showing the pain she is in emotionally. A FANTASTIC performance, and she deserved an Oscar for it.

  • heres a question, can someone explain why judy has a different hairstyle and clothes style in the first half of the movie? was there a big gap or something? Look at her in hello bluebird, nice clothes and they really suit her, i think her clothes from after hello bluebird are not complimetary at all to her....and her hair is a bit mad after it as well....

  • Judy is just phenomenal. I just wish I could have seen her live. Just one time.

  • I know this is gonna sound wierd but notice at the end how her throat and lips quiver while she's holding that last note from 4:04 to 4:10. For some reason that's always the only thing that I can focus on for this number. It's amazing, where the hell does that voice come from? Seriously.

  • When she sings the last note and walks off it RIPS ME UP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Every time I see it. I have the movie and it is truly her story come to the screen. I hope when GOD reruns this earth that we all get the chance to see her and do better ourselves.Because even tho she was sick people left her standing there all alone by herself.And that is not the kind of world I would want to live in.R.I.P. Judy

  • I just saw this movie. Had never heard of it before seeing the clips on YouTube. Wasn't expecting a great film, but it was. It is an excellent film. Garland's acting is so ahead of its time, and she should have won an Oscar. Edith Head's costumes were terrible, but that said, this is a film that every Garland fan should see.

  • Love this song by Judy but I like the version on her TV show a bit more. That was live and pure electric. On both versions I love it when she turns and walks around. That knocks me out every time. However, my overall favorite of this tune has to go to Fred Astaire as he sings it in The Bandwagon, walking along the train platform. Beautifully sung. Gorgeous shot. Just pure elegance! Judy and Fred, love 'em both.

  • One of the greatest entertainors and singers ever.

  • You see here little kids who likes untalented pop stars who only got into show business because of there good looks and shows alot of skin in music videos...

    This is real talent!

    Judy Garland was sooooo much more then a pretty face!

  • love this song!

  • Great vocal. Hideous dress. That is the one dress Edith Head did not design. Who would wear red in front of a red curtain?

    She looked great in red in Meet Me in St. Louis and In the Good Old Summertime, but not here.

    But the talent is awesome. That's why she is still so popular.

  • Certainly a career-capping performance. Too bad the wardrobe department couldn't find her a better fitting brassiere for this number!

  • PERFECTO MUNDO! YESSSSS! Judy, Judy, Judy, you are still alive in our hearts!

  • Judy was in peak voice here. I wish she had sung this at Carnegie Hall... The song "It Never was you" she sang in this film was done live and not prerecorded.. She is TRULY " MISS SHOW BUSINESS" NO one then or now could ever touch her style and singing technique, MGM she once said on The Tonight Show with Johnny Carson that they had the biggest influence on her career. She lived her songs and she could wrench tears out of Soild Rock..

  • Here we see the difference between a singer and a true performer. Everything she does contributes to the effect, especially those eyes that can look so lost one moment and defiant the next. The most thrilling number I can think of.

  • no one like her. ever.

  • @joeyjosephs Thanks for the insights (-.-)

  • The end goes right through my bonemarrow !!

  • I just adore Judy and all her beauty and talent. But I haven't seen this film- it seems to me that she doesn't quite look well, a bit pale?

  • @1940smusicals Judy wasn't well here, is was on too many medications again to loose weight and meet the demands of her agents to work, at this point she was becoming temperamental again, holding up the picture, fighting with the director fighting with Sid, and fled from the US to the UK with Joe and Lorna against Sids wishes, and he was having an affair with one of her agents. i don't know the full story on that,

  • @joeyjosephs You're right on all counts. Re: her agent affair, yes, she was having an affair with David Begelman while married to Sid; Begelman was married as well. This was an unfortunate habit of Judy's- mixing business with what she convinced herself was romance. Begelman did rip her off; not millions as often said, but still, many thousands of much-needed money. Years later, he took over Columbia Studios and was busted for various frauds, including forging Cliff Robertson's name.

  • Simply The Best Ever !!!!!

  • i want to see eveything thats judy garland

  • i want to see eveything thats judy

  • A star is born was redone with babs. I love babs but Judy owns that picture. They should not remake again.

  • In the words of Oliver, then ... PLEASE may we have some more? With the greatest thanks and appreciation, mind you!

  • Masterfully arranged, directed, and performed.

  • If anyone remakes this movie I will have a lot of stuff to say, some things need to be left alone. There was talks to remake A Star Is Born and rumored for Beyonce to be in it, that is the day I would lose all self control and have a melt down. Judy remade it and it shouldn't be touched.

  • FLAWLESS! I have this film on DVD. I love watching it this time of year. It's a cozy up under the blanket kind of movie. I mean that in a good way.....cheerful, funny, yet sad at times.

  • judy was wonderful in thie movie she should of received a oscar nom. for this.

  • Thanks SOOOO much for posting!!! This is my favorite performance of any song by anyone. The power and emotion are incredible, and I've been waiting for someone to post this for ages. The power of Judy's performance here is almost superhuman, and your channel is so well organized and helpful. Cheers.

  • simply perfect. This is how's it done people, raw, emotional and perfect

  • Thank you so much for this. Judy thought this was her best song and performance in this film.

  • you have the best vids how do you do it lol :D

  • @judygarlandxoxo I'm glad you like them ;-). There are still some more...

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more