Besides, BSG and the tribal colonials would join the Federation. The Cylons would not ally with anyone, and the Klingons would keep raiding the BSG until driven off.
I think the scale involved is a bit overlooked. A battlestar is about 10 times the size of a constitution class starship and a bird of prey is even smaller. Vipers might as well be firing BBs as the ships from star trek carry high powered shielding.
This is crazy--the Colonial fighters and Galactica, the Klingons, the Cylons, and the Enterprise are all fighting each other! At the very least, you should have had the Galactica and the Enterprise join forces, and then the Klingons and the Cylons join forces.
you guys realize, its just a video, right? Quit arguing, shut the heck up, and just watch the damn thing. It's not a bad splice, better than all those morons who film video games. words from a man older than Star trek
@aradioactivedonut: the reference was to Galactica:1980 which was the 2nd version of the show. The 3rd version was 2003 BSG on Sci-fi. & from what I've heard from some fans of the show they weren't to thrilled about the last few seasons. As for Universal I'm sure they were very happy about the 3rd version as they profited from it and made the spinoff series Caprica.
"they have shields, and phasers, and even photon torpedos. And all galactica has is bullets"
All that plates on Glactical is Armor (which is why "deathsqads" of Cylone fighters had to fly into the hanger bay and basically shoot up everything from the inside before the Kamakazi explosion hopefully taking out the battlestar's main reactor)
They have (bad cgi) Phasers and those Missles (6:11) can pack a Nuclear or high explosive warhead for taking out large space stations
@alienwaretechguy 'Bullets'? their Viper's and Turrets use rounds much larger than what 'bullet's are made out to be. And some of the turrets use shells that either explode at a range to destroy fighters or penetrate hulls, which is where a Star Trek ship would be in trouble. I'd put it up to about three BSG battlestars to one ST cruiser. yeah, photon torpedos and phasers would destroy a battlestar, but that doesn't mean a Cruiser's sheilds wouldn't fall to enough 'bullets'.
Trek shields are both gravitic (deflectors) and electromagnetic (force-fields), meaning that they basically make the beams MISS, while very little if any energy is absorbed by the shield.
In The Motion Picture, we saw the Enteprise-refit's new shields stand up to a weapon that completely wiped out three K'ting-class battle-cruisers; lasers won't even penetrate nav-shields.
@postalmeter "lasers won't even penetrate nav-shields." Then explain why Picard was afraid to take the Enteprise into a warzone with ships that were armed with Laser weapons, also could you explain how the Borg managed to cut a chunk out of the Enterprise-D using a laser. Federation ships are not 100% immune to lasers, thinking otherwise is idiotic. A Laser is nothing but a beam of photons, aka light which is basicly energy. Hell Picard even ordered full power to sheilds to block a laser weapon.
Dear scifi friends: it's amazing how much fans don't pay attention to any particular shows chronology or " universal rules" / details of that particular show. The 2 biggest things I've noticed is fans confusing old BSG with new BSG. (old BSG had turbo lasers & missles- new BSG bullets & missles)- Old Trek was set 78 years BEFORE TNG Trek , so it's kind of pointless to continually referencing Picard, Borg when referring to Kirk's 23rd Century Trek tech.
@NANOFORGE Science in some ways is catching up Phaser could likely be an inphase laser or a laser of all or close to all the same frequency, a pulsar could possibly be a pulse laser which use microsec build up of energy to release nano second burst of energy repeated every microsecond althought a beam 1/1,000,000,000 of a second repeated every one 1/1,000,000 of a second couldn't really be shown visually so they showed much slower burst. Energy burst that far in the future likely faster yet.
Liked it. These fan film/mash ups are creative and entertaining. Just an observation about the negative comments. It's a fan film! If ILM were in the credits I would expect more but not in a nine minute short posted on YT. So keep up the good work because these videos get me through the commercials on tv.
While I like the video, it bothers me that you insult the re-imagined Bsg series as it also had its merits, granted the two shows were radically different but the whole point was that it was supposed to be radically different. Im a fan of both incarnations and wont contest the fact that the old versions weapons were a little more potent but don't belittle a good series just because its not what u grew up with
Regardless of the technology arguments, the story is disjointed. With all the Star Trek and BSG a better cut together story could have been made just by merely sticking to a simple story and leaving the cylons out. Good attempt though.
If this has been brought up before, my apologies, but in your description, you said "The Viper pilots shoot the Galactica because a) they're in a war and a big white ship shows up, whom they don't know and kinda looks like a Klingon ship, maybe it's re-enforcements? "" - No matter how hopped up they are, why wouldn't they recognize the Galactica as their own home ship? Did you mean the Enterprise?
disclaimer: have only seen the new BSG, hell of a show!
Star trek is like. So much stronger than anything on galactica XD.
Galatica is very realistic, armor is just metal not some magic kind of "multi phasic shielding" no kinetic barriers, no external shields, no travelling at Faster than light (only jumping to another place).
Putting them in a fight is just rediculous. (note: photon torpedo's beat nukes)
Star Trek technology is vastly superior to all other sci fi shows. Except maybe Stargate. The Ancients are pretty unstoppable. I would love to see an all out battle between the Q and the Ancients!!!
@ghostgate82 Stargate tech is without a doubt superior to Trek tech (or at least the Federation's). An example of this would be the fact that Voyager got stuck in an area that is still in the Milky Way, where as Stargate ships, with ample power supplies, can travel between galaxies, going distances that vastly exceed 70,000 lightyears. (Granted, the technology was "loaned" to Earth).
Didn't Daniel Jackson say that being ascended doesn't make one all knowing or powerful? The Q are omnipotent.
@Nesseight Most absolutley. A 304 Earth starship has taken more punishment than the entire Enterprise-D's weapons could dish out combined. The Deadalus was stated to carry 1.02 Gigaton Nukes as standard whcih would one shot any Trek ship and they you have Asgard beam weapons that cna slice up a Wraith Hive ship that would normally take little damage from a 1.02 Gigaton nuke. Trek has really no chance against StarGate. The Asgard Hyperdrive on a 304 can cover a galaxy in minutes.
@Nesseight The Q are not omnipotent nor have they displayed any form of it. If I remember Sisko punches Q and knocked him down, there is no possible way to knock down an omnipotent entity with a punch, that is impossible, DO you really think you can punch and knock something that has unlimited power about. Something omnipotent would be infinite in everyway. Saying the Q are omnipotent goes against all logic and canon and what we have seen in the show. The Q are not omnipotent.
@NANOFORGE You recall correctly... however, you didn't didn't see it correctly. Q only let Sisko hit him because he was toying with him... I think it was to teach Sisko something, as he always does with humans.
I'm curious. 1.Is the officer at 2:57 the Galactica helm? 2.Which kind of explosives do the Colonial missles carry? Are the colonial cannons automatic?
Oh Boy! Just viewed your vid (LOL!) and enjoyed the hell out of it!! I first started to view it with a bit of skepticism, but as it progressed, MAN! This thing is absolutely hilarious!! I especially liked the closing video snatches and the Pizza was just too funny!
This movie is too amazing to be hidden: bobbydiablo must BROADCAST IT ON TV ASAP! But why there's another battlestar called Pegasus? I've never watched BSG, but I thought the Galactica was the only warship in the fleet.
This movie is too amazing to be hidden: bobbydiablo must BROADCAST IT ON TV ASAP! The only strange thing is maybe that the Viper squadron apparently takes care of the danger which CAN come from the Enterprise and nearly ignore the REAL one represented by the Cylon starships. But why there's another battlestar called Pegasus? I've never watched BSG, but I thought the Galactica was the only warship in the fleet.
THIS FILM IS PERFECT! IT MUST BE SHOWN IN CINEMAS! The only single strange thing is that the Viper squadron shoot to the Enterprise thinking they are other Klingons while the Galactica is under attack by the Cylons, who can surely be more dangerous.
Umm not really. Where to even start. First off the world of BSG doesn't have EM shields. Period. Right there you have an advantage for Start Trek. BSG has more maneuverable fighters. However it has been demonstrated in ST:TNG that the phaser arrays and canons can make short work of small fighters. And why did the Galactica jump from fighting Klingons to the Enterprise? Makes no sense. They are trying to find allies not enemies. I think this was a fight looking for a reason. :xP
i love this mash because it would be theoretically possible for this exact scenario to happen in either show's 'world' without seeming too impossible or unrealistic ... in BSG this could have very well been what they ran into when they did finally reach earth space ... same goes for the star trek side - suspension-of-belief isn't necessary for this movie/plot ... bravo, i'd like to see a full length movie of this for real
@pynipple fore real that is an awesome idea. I mean they already did all the mashups of the horror movies in a comical setting. why not a scify oneor 7 of em so many to flip together and easy to cg most of the action so no modles to be built. I mean shoot ea could even throw in stargate with star wars and star treck battle star galactica, basically all the star any thing movies
when you think about all they went through and the luck they always seem to have running from bad guys, something like this happening to the BSG crew was just murphy's law to them ... it's funny how they don't even seemed shocked at it, like being attacked by bizarre, unknown ships from every angle while they are fighting each other happens to them every day
i wish you would reconsider putting the 90min version on here in chunks ... youtube is the only way for some people to see online videos with some mobile devices - i'm sure they would be popular, watching this made me think it was funny at first, but then it makes you think about what would happen if this exact scenario did take place, which wouldnt be impossible from the point of view of either show - now i want to see the whole movie!
Nice try, but you obviously don't watch Star Trek. The Enterprise has something called a FORCE FIELD. Lasers can not penetrate shields! Starships were built for much heavier battles then that. The Enterprise held out against one of Vger's weapons which dwarfs puny lasers. A phaser is MUCH more powerful than a laser.
I kno this dude's post is 3 months old, but no-one's said it yet, so I feel I should.
A nuke only generates an EMP if it is detonated in Earth's ionosphere. This being the case, an EMP would only be generated if detonated sufficiently close to a planet Earth-like enough to have an Earth-like ionosphere and probably an Earth-like magnetic field as well.
@arckangel38 Read teh description: in bobbydiablo's (the author) vision of the respective technologies, BSG gunrays can easily penetrate the kind of energy deflectors shields used by the federal Starfleet.
very nice compilation but i remember one episode in TNG when picard say about 2 ships with lasers that they dont pass the navigation shield i assume will be the same for the original series.But i wonder what will happen if cylons and borg have a first contact what will happen haha
@knighttemplar6 Then then again we saw Picard order full power too shields in order to block an X-ray laser and the ship still shook. Not all Laser weapons can be blocked by a ships Navigational deflector.
@NANOFORGE You are right. As a matter of fact, I bet the most of (if not ALL) the weapons called "laser" we see in ST, SW, BSG etc. aren't actually based on the real L.A.S.E.R., but on a very different and more powerful technology. I'd like to know who introduced in the science fiction terminology a so unappropiated use of that word: he/she has been the creator of a terrible confusion >:-(
Perhaps by sheer weight of numbers which the Federation never had. BG being humans also will have the same level of intelligence, craftiness etc on their side too. Who knows what a nuke laced with Tribbles can do!
just nuke the federation lol a nuke would kill a fed ship the heat would burn out the shields or the emp would and the shockwave would cause it to to implode and BOOOOOOOOM!
You know nothing of Star Trek. Humanity's fear of nuclear holocaust was nonetheless realized beginning in circa 2026 with WW III. By the mid 23rd century, advances in deflector shield technology led to nuclear weapons losing their tactical significance. Romulan Birds-of-Prey employed them solely as self-destruct devices, and such a warhead detonated point blank in front of a starship caused relatively light casualties as well as temporary electrical disruption.
@captainpicard1701 ah ha! a proper trekkie, and as a fellow diehard fan (even if i am now a gater) everything you say here is accurate, though i think i do remember them being used as weapons in TOS by the a romulan (need to dig out my collectors tin dvds lol) the Enterprise's shields withstood multiple hits and yes they were also used for self destruct
The episode you are referring to is TOS "Balance of Terror." The Romulan Commander orders more debris into the disposal tubes, including a nuclear warhead to destroy the Enterprise. Spock picks up the 'metal cased object' on his sensors and the Enterprise fires upon it (probably thinking it would cause a low grade detonation). The massive explosion causes damage to the Enterprise but despite now having the upper hand, the Romulan Commander decides to head for home.
@stargateoracle The episode you are referring to is TOS "Balance of Terror." The Romulan Commander orders more debris into the disposal tubes, including a nuclear warhead to destroy the Enterprise. Spock picks up the 'metal cased object' on his sensors and the Enterprise fires upon it (probably thinking it would cause a low grade detonation). The massive explosion causes damage to the Enterprise but despite now having the upper hand, the Romulan Commander decides to head for home.
Lol. Everyone knows a Federation starship can't go five minutes in ANY battle without overloading its warp core, having its weapons system malfunction or sheilds collapse....."My God captain its the flux capacitor!" Whereas battlestars are built TO take a beating and have excellent damage control. BSG sends the panty waist Federation starship into the next life.
@Montebest Negative. Those were a pair of Klingon Bird of Prey scout ships. (Called B'rels in TNG, and Birds of Prey in Star Trek III, V, and VI) and a K'Tinga class battlecruiser (Which looks quite similiar to a D7)
Actually.. There could have been 3 Birds in there... There were scenes from three different brdges cut into there after all.
Um, dumb!!! We have Galactica fighting Klingons- I'm ok with that. Then the Fighters which were fighting/fleeing the Klingons, then decide to shoot at the ship which is fighting the Cylons?, Not so good.
There's no way a viper laser cannon would get through the Enterprise's shields. Plus the viper shoots a machine gun burst but the Enterprise clearly takes a hit from a solid laser and vipers can't make a long sustained shot like that
@WorldPeace21 Actually Galactica has the edge with fire power. Vispers also would own Suttlecraft. The advantages Trek has against Galactica is Shields and Warp.
I think this was very well done. A bit confusing from time to time but still pretty good. I liked how you mixed all the movie clips together. Yes i think this was very well done.
They are not consistent in this. If a Klingon ship can take out the Galactica with phasers and the viper weapons have little effect, you can't turn around and have those same weapons on the Cylon base ships take out the Enterprise. Consistency is everything.
LOL! Pretty funny. Who would have thunk they would meet. I would have liked to have seen Star Wars vs Battlestar Galactica. Ships are more comparable for bulk and firepower.
actually Sw ships outclass battlestars by many orders of magnitude. Besides alsmmost being the same size battlestars are weaker slower and less durable than their sw counterparts.
I liked it, It would of been cool if the two shows really did meet up in a big budget movie. But one was Paramont and one was Universal Studios. I guess in this day and age, more than one studio are involved in big epic movies. Look at Titanic has an example.LOL. Nice work anyway
I liked it, It would of been cool if the two shows really did meet up in a big budget movie. But one was Paramont and one was Universal Studios. I guess in this day and age, more than one studio are involved in big epic movies. Look at Titanic has an example.LOL. Nice work anyway
WOW the Birds of Prey were holding up better than the Enterprise.
Must of been one of those episodes where nothing on the Enterprise worked until the last second. Reminds me of the line in Spaceballs "even in the future nothing works"
SW vs BSG would be very close. I think the united federation of planets would win. If BSG has focused nuclear warheads, excellent point defences (against torpedoes) and electronic countermeasures, then they win. Maybe. I don't know if they have enough ships or enough territory and raw resources to pull it off.
Considering how strong ST shields are, i think BSG is better without them. In most ST episodes i have seen, the shields always goes down in the first shot, every single time i have seen a ST episode. What's the point of having a shield that does not do anything good? Seems better to put on some more armor instead which the Galactica seems to have done. Much better choice.
@onlypeaceindeath actually no, watch more than two episodes. about 50 times they time like 5 hits and the shields hold. it all depends on the arms on the other ship. so fuck BSG. it sucks
@onlypeaceindeath i dont know what st you have been watching but since next gen and up shields last quite a while, rarely going below 40%, under a heavy beating tho the shields will fail if aimed in patterns of the hidden shield generators, like in the movie st nemesis, but even after shield and weapon failure they still rammed the ship, also dont forget the awesome ablative armor from st voyager ;)
@onlypeaceindeath technalogicaly speaking, armour is far superior to powered defenses purely due to the power required to resist a force acting from outside ie, if you have a nuke, you need a nuke's worth of burst energy production inside your vessel to resist it, however...
the advantage to a shield system would be overall mass, and thus the ability to out accelerate the enemy ( assuming you can apply the ubserd energy systems you have aboard to power the ship's drive unit )
The Battlestar's do have shields. In the first film/episode Adama orders the shields to be raised and in Mission Galactica: The Cylon attack Commander Cain does the same when attacking the basestars at the end.
@bobbydiablo I read at one time that was a possible plan the Galactica would find earth in the 25th century with the Buck Rodgers cast as both were Glen A Larson Productions
@racefan32 : I think one of the inspirations for us back then was this ripped off storyline in the 2nd season of Buck Rogers where they go looking for the survivors of Earth. A total resetting of the Galactica storyline. Which led us to thinking instead of the Galactica showing up in Buck's 25th Century wouldn't it be cooler if they showed up in Trek's 23rd Century.
I like the original battlestar galactica , The new one was too much like LOST , everyone was think and not doing . they turned it into a day dreaming soap opera
"Target Engine Only"
*Blows up ship*
cjdaweasel 3 weeks ago 3
Besides, BSG and the tribal colonials would join the Federation. The Cylons would not ally with anyone, and the Klingons would keep raiding the BSG until driven off.
Darty105 1 month ago
4:43 AAAAAAGHHHHHH
danyeo 1 month ago
I think the scale involved is a bit overlooked. A battlestar is about 10 times the size of a constitution class starship and a bird of prey is even smaller. Vipers might as well be firing BBs as the ships from star trek carry high powered shielding.
dewfall56 2 months ago
This is crazy--the Colonial fighters and Galactica, the Klingons, the Cylons, and the Enterprise are all fighting each other! At the very least, you should have had the Galactica and the Enterprise join forces, and then the Klingons and the Cylons join forces.
PCCphoenix 3 months ago
@PCCphoenix unless the borg show up
mdtwiztid 1 week ago
You're missing a full second. At 9:13 seconds, it goes right to 9:15 seconds, where's that missing second??? I want it!!!
rizz917 3 months ago
you guys realize, its just a video, right? Quit arguing, shut the heck up, and just watch the damn thing. It's not a bad splice, better than all those morons who film video games. words from a man older than Star trek
coindude54902 3 months ago
The Klingons ship amar is a ktinga battlecruiser not a bird of prey
USSVoyager5 3 months ago
i like it.
MadMax74656 4 months ago
I personally, would love to see the 90 minute version of this. As I am a huge sci-fi fan.
Is there any way you could send me a copy of it?
dreamwarrior2008 4 months ago
"a 2nd version of the show Universal Studios is trying to forget about and so are we." Are you saying you disliked the re-imagined series?
aradioactivedonut 5 months ago
@aradioactivedonut: the reference was to Galactica:1980 which was the 2nd version of the show. The 3rd version was 2003 BSG on Sci-fi. & from what I've heard from some fans of the show they weren't to thrilled about the last few seasons. As for Universal I'm sure they were very happy about the 3rd version as they profited from it and made the spinoff series Caprica.
bobbydiablo 5 months ago
good cut
SimsonSchwalbenPilot 5 months ago
That was confusing. Although I liked the end credits, those were fun.
kzoodata 5 months ago
"they have shields, and phasers, and even photon torpedos. And all galactica has is bullets"
All that plates on Glactical is Armor (which is why "deathsqads" of Cylone fighters had to fly into the hanger bay and basically shoot up everything from the inside before the Kamakazi explosion hopefully taking out the battlestar's main reactor)
They have (bad cgi) Phasers and those Missles (6:11) can pack a Nuclear or high explosive warhead for taking out large space stations
TheRealArchAngel 7 months ago
nice:0
Yzon63 7 months ago
@alienwaretechguy 'Bullets'? their Viper's and Turrets use rounds much larger than what 'bullet's are made out to be. And some of the turrets use shells that either explode at a range to destroy fighters or penetrate hulls, which is where a Star Trek ship would be in trouble. I'd put it up to about three BSG battlestars to one ST cruiser. yeah, photon torpedos and phasers would destroy a battlestar, but that doesn't mean a Cruiser's sheilds wouldn't fall to enough 'bullets'.
Willsr14 8 months ago
@Willsr14 Trek shields are notoriously vulnerable to kinetic impacts, like all the random ramming that goes on.
Perion 7 months ago
@Perion
Trek shields are both gravitic (deflectors) and electromagnetic (force-fields), meaning that they basically make the beams MISS, while very little if any energy is absorbed by the shield.
In The Motion Picture, we saw the Enteprise-refit's new shields stand up to a weapon that completely wiped out three K'ting-class battle-cruisers; lasers won't even penetrate nav-shields.
postalmeter 6 months ago
@postalmeter "lasers won't even penetrate nav-shields." Then explain why Picard was afraid to take the Enteprise into a warzone with ships that were armed with Laser weapons, also could you explain how the Borg managed to cut a chunk out of the Enterprise-D using a laser. Federation ships are not 100% immune to lasers, thinking otherwise is idiotic. A Laser is nothing but a beam of photons, aka light which is basicly energy. Hell Picard even ordered full power to sheilds to block a laser weapon.
NANOFORGE 5 months ago
Dear scifi friends: it's amazing how much fans don't pay attention to any particular shows chronology or " universal rules" / details of that particular show. The 2 biggest things I've noticed is fans confusing old BSG with new BSG. (old BSG had turbo lasers & missles- new BSG bullets & missles)- Old Trek was set 78 years BEFORE TNG Trek , so it's kind of pointless to continually referencing Picard, Borg when referring to Kirk's 23rd Century Trek tech.
bobbydiablo 5 months ago
@NANOFORGE Science in some ways is catching up Phaser could likely be an inphase laser or a laser of all or close to all the same frequency, a pulsar could possibly be a pulse laser which use microsec build up of energy to release nano second burst of energy repeated every microsecond althought a beam 1/1,000,000,000 of a second repeated every one 1/1,000,000 of a second couldn't really be shown visually so they showed much slower burst. Energy burst that far in the future likely faster yet.
hydrolito 3 months ago
Oh you nerds. Golly that's adorable. :D
This1sS0Stup1d 8 months ago
That was good.
Apsu72 8 months ago
I want to see new BSG vs. new (Nemesis era) Star Trek. :P
CatsRuleDogsAreTards 8 months ago
@alienwaretechguy Bullets help. I want to see a Starfleet ship withstand a nuke.
CatsRuleDogsAreTards 8 months ago
@CatsRuleDogsAreTards In The Balance of Terror, the Enterprise withstands a nuke.
Idazmi7 4 months ago
Borg VS Daleks anyone?
or how about...
Cylons VS Cybermen?
Science Fiction, the cross over options are endless (litterally ; )
TSR1989LW 8 months ago 2
I would like to see the Borg run into the Cylons, that would be an awkward assimilation.
EaglesStrike910 8 months ago
@EaglesStrike910 Indeed ; )
or maybe the Cybermen, that would make for an amusing crossover.
TSR1989LW 8 months ago
@EaglesStrike910 Cylon's wouldn't show mercy though!
likestallwomen 8 months ago
would be fun whe nthe meet the BORG then we cna have a laugh
revolver2750 9 months ago
No fighters in StarTrek..shame
RealityDefenseLeague 9 months ago
Star Trek is too boring. That doesn't mean it's not good, I personally just couldn't get into it
TafTabTah 9 months ago
i dont think enterprise-a could take galactica. Batttlestars are massive and have a lotta firepower
Kingrex16 9 months ago
Thats enterprise a maybe defiant fire power and manoeuvrability
doctorwhodidapoo 8 months ago
Wow, that was great!! Very well done, especially when Sheba finds out the Enterprise is full humans. Ah, the memories.
Nikia2165 9 months ago
lol
jhitching 10 months ago
Poor Christopher Lloyd, all he wanted was prisoners.
AeronPeryton 10 months ago
Cylons created by a reptilans (os bsg) so why not V vs BSG
BSG came to earth when earth was invaded by the Vs and diana has a plsn for earth
whitemanstand72 10 months ago
Liked it. These fan film/mash ups are creative and entertaining. Just an observation about the negative comments. It's a fan film! If ILM were in the credits I would expect more but not in a nine minute short posted on YT. So keep up the good work because these videos get me through the commercials on tv.
satanicmechanic86 11 months ago
@satanicmechanic86 Cylons created by a reptilans (os bsg) so why not V vs BSG
BSG came to earth when earth was invaded by the Vs and diana has a plsn for earth
whitemanstand72 10 months ago
While I like the video, it bothers me that you insult the re-imagined Bsg series as it also had its merits, granted the two shows were radically different but the whole point was that it was supposed to be radically different. Im a fan of both incarnations and wont contest the fact that the old versions weapons were a little more potent but don't belittle a good series just because its not what u grew up with
100ThomasFletcher 11 months ago
The Cylons wouldn't stand a chance against THE ENTERPRISE . THE ENTERPRISE has far superior weapons and targetting computers.
trayguy 11 months ago
Regardless of the technology arguments, the story is disjointed. With all the Star Trek and BSG a better cut together story could have been made just by merely sticking to a simple story and leaving the cylons out. Good attempt though.
MistressSerafina 11 months ago
If this has been brought up before, my apologies, but in your description, you said "The Viper pilots shoot the Galactica because a) they're in a war and a big white ship shows up, whom they don't know and kinda looks like a Klingon ship, maybe it's re-enforcements? "" - No matter how hopped up they are, why wouldn't they recognize the Galactica as their own home ship? Did you mean the Enterprise?
yuriilev 1 year ago
@yuriilev : Good catch I totally missed that typo.
bobbydiablo 1 year ago
Sorry. Didn't like it. I think my expectations were too high.
680milo 1 year ago
wow this is epic !!
trickykid73 1 year ago
Melrose in Space-lol- the last new bsg seria- damn right
larswillen 1 year ago
disclaimer: have only seen the new BSG, hell of a show!
Star trek is like. So much stronger than anything on galactica XD.
Galatica is very realistic, armor is just metal not some magic kind of "multi phasic shielding" no kinetic barriers, no external shields, no travelling at Faster than light (only jumping to another place).
Putting them in a fight is just rediculous. (note: photon torpedo's beat nukes)
loederwijk 1 year ago
Star Trek technology is vastly superior to all other sci fi shows. Except maybe Stargate. The Ancients are pretty unstoppable. I would love to see an all out battle between the Q and the Ancients!!!
ghostgate82 1 year ago
@ghostgate82 Stargate tech is without a doubt superior to Trek tech (or at least the Federation's). An example of this would be the fact that Voyager got stuck in an area that is still in the Milky Way, where as Stargate ships, with ample power supplies, can travel between galaxies, going distances that vastly exceed 70,000 lightyears. (Granted, the technology was "loaned" to Earth).
Didn't Daniel Jackson say that being ascended doesn't make one all knowing or powerful? The Q are omnipotent.
Nesseight 1 year ago
@Nesseight Most absolutley. A 304 Earth starship has taken more punishment than the entire Enterprise-D's weapons could dish out combined. The Deadalus was stated to carry 1.02 Gigaton Nukes as standard whcih would one shot any Trek ship and they you have Asgard beam weapons that cna slice up a Wraith Hive ship that would normally take little damage from a 1.02 Gigaton nuke. Trek has really no chance against StarGate. The Asgard Hyperdrive on a 304 can cover a galaxy in minutes.
NANOFORGE 11 months ago
@Nesseight The Q are not omnipotent nor have they displayed any form of it. If I remember Sisko punches Q and knocked him down, there is no possible way to knock down an omnipotent entity with a punch, that is impossible, DO you really think you can punch and knock something that has unlimited power about. Something omnipotent would be infinite in everyway. Saying the Q are omnipotent goes against all logic and canon and what we have seen in the show. The Q are not omnipotent.
NANOFORGE 11 months ago
@NANOFORGE You recall correctly... however, you didn't didn't see it correctly. Q only let Sisko hit him because he was toying with him... I think it was to teach Sisko something, as he always does with humans.
terrywest111 8 months ago
Bloody Marvelous....Well Done. Would LOVE to see a full length movie of this. Capt, Merlyn A Hoff , Starship WARSPITE, NCC-1771
myrddyndewyn 1 year ago
STAR TREK >>>> Battlestar Galactica.
larkenos 1 year ago
I LOVE THE STAR FIGHTERS FROM BATTLE STAR GALACTICA AND 2ND BEST WOULD BE THE BUCK ROGERS STAR FIGHTERS.
RICK93IR 1 year ago
I'm curious. 1.Is the officer at 2:57 the Galactica helm? 2.Which kind of explosives do the Colonial missles carry? Are the colonial cannons automatic?
ilania95 1 year ago
Oh Boy! Just viewed your vid (LOL!) and enjoyed the hell out of it!! I first started to view it with a bit of skepticism, but as it progressed, MAN! This thing is absolutely hilarious!! I especially liked the closing video snatches and the Pizza was just too funny!
airwolfflies 1 year ago
This movie is too amazing to be hidden: bobbydiablo must BROADCAST IT ON TV ASAP! But why there's another battlestar called Pegasus? I've never watched BSG, but I thought the Galactica was the only warship in the fleet.
ilania95 1 year ago
This movie is too amazing to be hidden: bobbydiablo must BROADCAST IT ON TV ASAP! The only strange thing is maybe that the Viper squadron apparently takes care of the danger which CAN come from the Enterprise and nearly ignore the REAL one represented by the Cylon starships. But why there's another battlestar called Pegasus? I've never watched BSG, but I thought the Galactica was the only warship in the fleet.
ilania95 1 year ago
Im suprise no one tried pitting the Galactica against the Macross.
And can you imagine Vipers battling it out to death against Veritech Fighters?
EvilFingers 1 year ago
THIS FILM IS PERFECT! IT MUST BE SHOWN IN CINEMAS! The only single strange thing is that the Viper squadron shoot to the Enterprise thinking they are other Klingons while the Galactica is under attack by the Cylons, who can surely be more dangerous.
ilania95 1 year ago
Umm not really. Where to even start. First off the world of BSG doesn't have EM shields. Period. Right there you have an advantage for Start Trek. BSG has more maneuverable fighters. However it has been demonstrated in ST:TNG that the phaser arrays and canons can make short work of small fighters. And why did the Galactica jump from fighting Klingons to the Enterprise? Makes no sense. They are trying to find allies not enemies. I think this was a fight looking for a reason. :xP
KellicTiger 1 year ago
Shields weakening!!!!
Larrsify 1 year ago
8:18 Randolph Mantooth?
Sismiques 1 year ago
8:18 Randolph Mantooth?
Sismiques 1 year ago
i love this mash because it would be theoretically possible for this exact scenario to happen in either show's 'world' without seeming too impossible or unrealistic ... in BSG this could have very well been what they ran into when they did finally reach earth space ... same goes for the star trek side - suspension-of-belief isn't necessary for this movie/plot ... bravo, i'd like to see a full length movie of this for real
pynipple 1 year ago 14
@pynipple So they would both be in the same cannon world? XD
Austindude3954 9 months ago
@pynipple fore real that is an awesome idea. I mean they already did all the mashups of the horror movies in a comical setting. why not a scify oneor 7 of em so many to flip together and easy to cg most of the action so no modles to be built. I mean shoot ea could even throw in stargate with star wars and star treck battle star galactica, basically all the star any thing movies
demnlordd666 6 months ago
Captain - she's packing quite a whallop!
nighthawk0077 1 year ago
when you think about all they went through and the luck they always seem to have running from bad guys, something like this happening to the BSG crew was just murphy's law to them ... it's funny how they don't even seemed shocked at it, like being attacked by bizarre, unknown ships from every angle while they are fighting each other happens to them every day
pynipple 1 year ago
i wish you would reconsider putting the 90min version on here in chunks ... youtube is the only way for some people to see online videos with some mobile devices - i'm sure they would be popular, watching this made me think it was funny at first, but then it makes you think about what would happen if this exact scenario did take place, which wouldnt be impossible from the point of view of either show - now i want to see the whole movie!
pynipple 1 year ago
batlestar is better
AHE97 1 year ago
battlestar is better
AHE97 1 year ago
@AHE97 no it's not it sucks
buggyboo81 1 year ago
I would like to see a dogfight between the vipers and X wings from Star Wars.
Zurround100 1 year ago
Talk about clever. I really enjoyed your video very much. Thanks for posting it.
TheJohnlennongirl 1 year ago
Talk about clever. Nice job. I really enjoyed your video. Thanks for posting it. I really laughed my butt off.
TheJohnlennongirl 1 year ago
Nice try, but you obviously don't watch Star Trek. The Enterprise has something called a FORCE FIELD. Lasers can not penetrate shields! Starships were built for much heavier battles then that. The Enterprise held out against one of Vger's weapons which dwarfs puny lasers. A phaser is MUCH more powerful than a laser.
thefinalfrontier1701 1 year ago
nice job,,,
silverpizza100 1 year ago
@halorecon32
I kno this dude's post is 3 months old, but no-one's said it yet, so I feel I should.
A nuke only generates an EMP if it is detonated in Earth's ionosphere. This being the case, an EMP would only be generated if detonated sufficiently close to a planet Earth-like enough to have an Earth-like ionosphere and probably an Earth-like magnetic field as well.
But don't quote me on that.
macgeek2004 1 year ago
good try
kludge000 1 year ago
very weel. great. a tribute a series of tv.
gandasom 1 year ago
Damn that's a lot of bridge crews for one bird-of-prey.
OrthodoxParadoxBox 1 year ago
@OrthodoxParadoxBox As a matter of fact, I tink they were some different ships. Maybe, I'mwrong, but...
ilania95 1 year ago
That was awesome!!!!!!!! T'ich tor ang techmur. : D
dragongirl1409 1 year ago
Oh, come on ... a colonial viper can not inflict such damage to the enterprise ...
arckangel38 1 year ago
@arckangel38 Read teh description: in bobbydiablo's (the author) vision of the respective technologies, BSG gunrays can easily penetrate the kind of energy deflectors shields used by the federal Starfleet.
ilania95 1 year ago
Do we report this sir?
ARE YOU KIDDING?
StelarCF 1 year ago
very nice compilation but i remember one episode in TNG when picard say about 2 ships with lasers that they dont pass the navigation shield i assume will be the same for the original series.But i wonder what will happen if cylons and borg have a first contact what will happen haha
knighttemplar6 1 year ago
@knighttemplar6 Then then again we saw Picard order full power too shields in order to block an X-ray laser and the ship still shook. Not all Laser weapons can be blocked by a ships Navigational deflector.
NANOFORGE 1 year ago
@NANOFORGE You are right. As a matter of fact, I bet the most of (if not ALL) the weapons called "laser" we see in ST, SW, BSG etc. aren't actually based on the real L.A.S.E.R., but on a very different and more powerful technology. I'd like to know who introduced in the science fiction terminology a so unappropiated use of that word: he/she has been the creator of a terrible confusion >:-(
ilania95 1 year ago
@knighttemplar6 I don't even wanna know... lol. They would probably become an even greater menace than either two alone.
terrywest111 8 months ago
Dang it, why don't they just make a real star wars, battle star, star trek mash up movie.
armortron 1 year ago 16
@armortron because Q would mess everything up
ZuKahta 10 months ago
@armortron It would be so motherfucking epic, they need to create a series that can never end.
jaggedspikerespawn 9 months ago
Awesome ! Nice editing !
PristinSkyheart 1 year ago
The Enterprise kinda comes outta no where.
saquist 1 year ago
this is one messed up video
dwatt1964 1 year ago
Battlestar Galactica would win. They would bore the crew of the enterprise to death.
LandOfSteam 1 year ago
Perhaps by sheer weight of numbers which the Federation never had. BG being humans also will have the same level of intelligence, craftiness etc on their side too. Who knows what a nuke laced with Tribbles can do!
oneinsixcom 1 year ago
Something I want to know is 1) Star Wars Vs. Star Trek (Same number so ships, who wins). and Star Trek Vs. Macross, who would win?
dave19941000 1 year ago
Could have been fun, but was too random and unstructured. I'm sure it too a lot ot time to edit.
TeraRam 1 year ago
One of those Old Sci-Fi, mags did a speculation on this years ago.
Galactica meets the Enterprise, the Enterprise won.
racefan32 1 year ago
nice video
Dumbrarere 1 year ago
Was that Commander Kor with the Cylons? ;)
jptrekker 1 year ago
federation ships have one embarrassing design flaw: the lack of seat belts :-D
jednoucelovy 1 year ago
just nuke the federation lol a nuke would kill a fed ship the heat would burn out the shields or the emp would and the shockwave would cause it to to implode and BOOOOOOOOM!
halorecon32 1 year ago
You know nothing of Star Trek. Humanity's fear of nuclear holocaust was nonetheless realized beginning in circa 2026 with WW III. By the mid 23rd century, advances in deflector shield technology led to nuclear weapons losing their tactical significance. Romulan Birds-of-Prey employed them solely as self-destruct devices, and such a warhead detonated point blank in front of a starship caused relatively light casualties as well as temporary electrical disruption.
captainpicard1701 1 year ago
@captainpicard1701 ah ha! a proper trekkie, and as a fellow diehard fan (even if i am now a gater) everything you say here is accurate, though i think i do remember them being used as weapons in TOS by the a romulan (need to dig out my collectors tin dvds lol) the Enterprise's shields withstood multiple hits and yes they were also used for self destruct
stargateoracle 1 year ago
The episode you are referring to is TOS "Balance of Terror." The Romulan Commander orders more debris into the disposal tubes, including a nuclear warhead to destroy the Enterprise. Spock picks up the 'metal cased object' on his sensors and the Enterprise fires upon it (probably thinking it would cause a low grade detonation). The massive explosion causes damage to the Enterprise but despite now having the upper hand, the Romulan Commander decides to head for home.
captainpicard1701 1 year ago
@stargateoracle The episode you are referring to is TOS "Balance of Terror." The Romulan Commander orders more debris into the disposal tubes, including a nuclear warhead to destroy the Enterprise. Spock picks up the 'metal cased object' on his sensors and the Enterprise fires upon it (probably thinking it would cause a low grade detonation). The massive explosion causes damage to the Enterprise but despite now having the upper hand, the Romulan Commander decides to head for home.
captainpicard1701 1 year ago
Post 90min or GTFO :)
beefmalone 1 year ago
Lol. Everyone knows a Federation starship can't go five minutes in ANY battle without overloading its warp core, having its weapons system malfunction or sheilds collapse....."My God captain its the flux capacitor!" Whereas battlestars are built TO take a beating and have excellent damage control. BSG sends the panty waist Federation starship into the next life.
mcseeker1453 1 year ago
thats not a klingon battlecruser its romulan bird of prey!
Montebest 1 year ago
@Montebest Negative. Those were a pair of Klingon Bird of Prey scout ships. (Called B'rels in TNG, and Birds of Prey in Star Trek III, V, and VI) and a K'Tinga class battlecruiser (Which looks quite similiar to a D7)
Actually.. There could have been 3 Birds in there... There were scenes from three different brdges cut into there after all.
Fizwalker 1 year ago
That was fun! Thanks!!
zathras9now 1 year ago
Surprisingly... It'd actually be a pretty fair match, Two weak ass space fleets against each other in a battle for last place
spiritofthewolf15x 1 year ago
Damn this is the old one
I like the newer battlestar galactica
reesemekkes 1 year ago
Actually Galactica has the edge with fire power. Vispers also would own Suttlecraft. The advantages Trek has against Galactica is Shields and Warp.
NANOFORGE 1 year ago
dommage l'idée de depart est bonne mais c'est confus au milieu
Cassalier 1 year ago
nice thing.
builder396 1 year ago
Um, dumb!!! We have Galactica fighting Klingons- I'm ok with that. Then the Fighters which were fighting/fleeing the Klingons, then decide to shoot at the ship which is fighting the Cylons?, Not so good.
stitch656 1 year ago
Dude. you got to get the romulans, borg, and others in another video:D other then that, its really good, also with the other teams
TitanLover8011 1 year ago
I disagree around 4:35
There's no way a viper laser cannon would get through the Enterprise's shields. Plus the viper shoots a machine gun burst but the Enterprise clearly takes a hit from a solid laser and vipers can't make a long sustained shot like that
WorldPeace21 1 year ago
@WorldPeace21 Actually Galactica has the edge with fire power. Vispers also would own Suttlecraft. The advantages Trek has against Galactica is Shields and Warp.
NANOFORGE 1 year ago
Well done,and it has a vintage look and feel to it also.Cylons attacked everyone-the Galactica,the Federation,and the Klingons.lol
barzoolroolz 1 year ago
star trek vs bsg vs star wars vs star lost vs buck
floatingcompassmedia 1 year ago
I think this was very well done. A bit confusing from time to time but still pretty good. I liked how you mixed all the movie clips together. Yes i think this was very well done.
DarkGroudon8 1 year ago
Funny how John Colicos was in Trek and Galactica...
ddeniatpac 1 year ago
They are not consistent in this. If a Klingon ship can take out the Galactica with phasers and the viper weapons have little effect, you can't turn around and have those same weapons on the Cylon base ships take out the Enterprise. Consistency is everything.
LorynToo 1 year ago
What happened to the shields?
67irishfire 1 year ago
Canadian bacon, damn right!
ScottZirpolo 1 year ago
First half was ok. The editing in the second half is WTF.
grevensher 1 year ago
"Target engines only!"
*fires*
*ship explodes*
*captains like wtf dude listen*
jaywalkersunite 1 year ago
Cool.
nxdefiant1 1 year ago
LOL! Pretty funny. Who would have thunk they would meet. I would have liked to have seen Star Wars vs Battlestar Galactica. Ships are more comparable for bulk and firepower.
Timothy2035 1 year ago
actually Sw ships outclass battlestars by many orders of magnitude. Besides alsmmost being the same size battlestars are weaker slower and less durable than their sw counterparts.
blacksun2175 1 year ago
I liked it, It would of been cool if the two shows really did meet up in a big budget movie. But one was Paramont and one was Universal Studios. I guess in this day and age, more than one studio are involved in big epic movies. Look at Titanic has an example.LOL. Nice work anyway
hulkster46a 1 year ago
I liked it, It would of been cool if the two shows really did meet up in a big budget movie. But one was Paramont and one was Universal Studios. I guess in this day and age, more than one studio are involved in big epic movies. Look at Titanic has an example.LOL. Nice work anyway
hulkster46a 1 year ago
WOW the Birds of Prey were holding up better than the Enterprise.
Must of been one of those episodes where nothing on the Enterprise worked until the last second. Reminds me of the line in Spaceballs "even in the future nothing works"
Dmann4Christ 1 year ago
Comment removed
Dmann4Christ 1 year ago
Comment removed
Dmann4Christ 1 year ago
kick ass...
ReveretheHood 1 year ago
Im confused by it all
RafaleC77th 1 year ago
very cool! THANKS
tierneyufoshow 1 year ago
No! don't fire at will! what did he ever do? lol seriously though, cool vid.
dreamwarrior2008 1 year ago
Nice video, very well blended together.
SW vs BSG would be very close. I think the united federation of planets would win. If BSG has focused nuclear warheads, excellent point defences (against torpedoes) and electronic countermeasures, then they win. Maybe. I don't know if they have enough ships or enough territory and raw resources to pull it off.
TheJamesrocket 1 year ago
I actually enjoyed watching that. Nice work!
rogerwilco2 1 year ago
Great!!! I enjoyed watching that.
GreysAreHere 1 year ago
This was a first class montage of the great Sci Fi Classic Cheese movies. Fantastic work and with great sense of humor.
ObeeLektro 1 year ago
Thats not fair BSG doesnt have shields and ST does.
Foreegly 1 year ago
Considering how strong ST shields are, i think BSG is better without them. In most ST episodes i have seen, the shields always goes down in the first shot, every single time i have seen a ST episode. What's the point of having a shield that does not do anything good? Seems better to put on some more armor instead which the Galactica seems to have done. Much better choice.
onlypeaceindeath 1 year ago 7
@onlypeaceindeath actually no, watch more than two episodes. about 50 times they time like 5 hits and the shields hold. it all depends on the arms on the other ship. so fuck BSG. it sucks
buggyboo81 1 year ago
@onlypeaceindeath Becaaaaaaaaaauseeeeeee...
A) It's not real
and B) It makes for good TV
carwashh 1 year ago
@onlypeaceindeath when i designed my ship i made it have shields that GOD DAMN WORKED
tk5800 1 year ago
@onlypeaceindeath i dont know what st you have been watching but since next gen and up shields last quite a while, rarely going below 40%, under a heavy beating tho the shields will fail if aimed in patterns of the hidden shield generators, like in the movie st nemesis, but even after shield and weapon failure they still rammed the ship, also dont forget the awesome ablative armor from st voyager ;)
nxmoparmatt84 1 year ago
@onlypeaceindeath well that was for the show.
if you actually had that kind of shielding against projectile weapons of BSG it would be like a beetle trying to invade a nuclear bunker
ZuKahta 11 months ago
@onlypeaceindeath technalogicaly speaking, armour is far superior to powered defenses purely due to the power required to resist a force acting from outside ie, if you have a nuke, you need a nuke's worth of burst energy production inside your vessel to resist it, however...
the advantage to a shield system would be overall mass, and thus the ability to out accelerate the enemy ( assuming you can apply the ubserd energy systems you have aboard to power the ship's drive unit )
FirewallAndFlush 11 months ago
The Battlestar's do have shields. In the first film/episode Adama orders the shields to be raised and in Mission Galactica: The Cylon attack Commander Cain does the same when attacking the basestars at the end.
TRUMPER007 1 year ago
Always thought it would be more interesting if Battlestar met Buck.
rathraven1313 1 year ago
@rathraven1313 : We made a fun little trailer that goes with the full version where Buck Rogers fights the Cylons.
bobbydiablo 1 year ago
@bobbydiablo I read at one time that was a possible plan the Galactica would find earth in the 25th century with the Buck Rodgers cast as both were Glen A Larson Productions
racefan32 1 year ago
@racefan32 : I think one of the inspirations for us back then was this ripped off storyline in the 2nd season of Buck Rogers where they go looking for the survivors of Earth. A total resetting of the Galactica storyline. Which led us to thinking instead of the Galactica showing up in Buck's 25th Century wouldn't it be cooler if they showed up in Trek's 23rd Century.
bobbydiablo 1 year ago
Battlestar Galactica is more sensible. no wired eared people
heywatchme101 1 year ago
Like how all the ships from the ST and BG films were all spliced together for the battlescenes. Great work
BuddyFantastic 1 year ago
Nicely done
nausinora 1 year ago
hahaha dude u have WAY too much time on your hands! i liked it tho!
megans1016 1 year ago
Hahahahahahahahaha makes me laugh so much
wanderersrock268 1 year ago
star wars wins againest BSG
Killeruk454 1 year ago 2
@Killeruk454 by far
Jiveturkey68 1 year ago
I like the original battlestar galactica , The new one was too much like LOST , everyone was think and not doing . they turned it into a day dreaming soap opera
erwintipton 1 year ago
who would win depends on which battlestar galactica we're talking about. The newer one would totally kick Star Trek ass!
FunFlirtyFlute 1 year ago
intense but star trek wud totally win in three seconds with photon torpeados!
RingoReguard 2 years ago