Bach - Preludium BWV846

[manjukefernando]

Nice.. Keep up the good work... :)

[arfurlife]

Well done very nice.I ve always had trouble with that piece and given up. I ve thought about moving it into D major to get it to flow better. Great to hear it played on guitar. . i like it on piano too....I can actually play t easy on keyboard.

[prisoncop1860]

You are as lovely as you are talented. Thank you for sharing your gift in a world so bereft of beauty. I really enjoyed both watching you play and hearing your work. Do you by chance have any recordings?

[csybu]

@prisoncop1860 yes with my guitar duet! Check my website! You can order it from there!

[23JLOPZ]

I need to marry this woman can anyone help me?!

[23JLOPZ]

is it possible to marry you?!

[Javammad]

She is gorgeous, i want her to be me guitar teacher. Her smile is enough to inspire me to learn everything

[yumeybaconcutout]

you need to smile more.

[danoacel]

Please!! don't steal my heart you are so great and has develop huge....Keep up the good work.......

[raymondrayban]

NOT BAD i think you missed a twang at 1.06 BUT ILL LET YOU OFF ! keep on trying you will get there in the END!

[beelzebub686]

You are so graceful at playing... I like yor gestures and everything. Definitely the best guitar player i've seen on youtube.

[box1467]

Nice job pulling this off mostly in the 1st position.... and the transitions between fingering was very good, too.... I think the bass was a little muted and stymied, yet overall the skill is fantastic... I tried to learn this piece, and was stumped after about 12 bars...

[TheMax161]

@box1467 Oh...you stopped working on this piece after twelve bars...but you have no problem with being critical of someone who learned the entire piece? I'll bet you feel real good about yourself, don't you?

[zeppelin5289]

@TheMax161 I think it was just constructive criticism. Chill.

[stefanomom]

que cancion tan mas hermosa

[freemantemani]

good keep up with the classic its help for guitar thcnic end yue geting betar

[daffydoug]

I love the way you smile when you play! Just like sunshine!

[MrLiquid7]

me like you much very <3

[gfsdf123]

Lovely :-)) very sensitive ...

[osmargds]

So beautiful!!!!!!!!!!!!

[BOGZASV8MA]

this is good ..

[Raooligan]

honestly that is beautiful.... one can tell that you really love music... you smile while you touch the strings... you play very well ;)

nice guitar, great playing and a very pretty smile =D

keep on rocking (classicaly i mean lol)

[Busyhun]

Love the way you play!! I am so proud of being a women when I hear you playing!! XD

[marco1081]

i can watch you play alllll day long

[Helena81000]

gostei!!!!!!!!!

[atzitzikas]

Good performance, but if you study classical guitar, I suggest to take a foot stool.

In tirando, fingers go back to palm, the whole finger, not only the first section.

It's shame not to produce beautiful and powerful sound, all others are in a good manner. Try the arpegio BWV 999

[Diaboludus]

you make what are you playin' more beauty than it's with your smile is a very good point!

[senolgokmen]

I am in love with you :) Awesome

[k66shogun]

I like bach. I sometimes practice this song too. Not chord.

[xxbrownxxboyxx]

hey do can i u ad me on facebook i wanna talk with u al rosasi barook this my name on facebook

[norberth71]

Hello .....

We use as the basis for sounding the Ave Maria with violin.

Thanks and congratulations!

[csybu]

@norberth71 Really? Please record it I wanna hear it!!!

[LouisC9999]

I LOVED THIS!!!

[KlodeB92]

Very pleasant rendition .I have noticed that people who like /play flamenco also love playing Bach .This is obviosly your case .All the best .Claude

[spindlegrinder]

Very good keep up the good work

[KABRIS1]

Very nice.

[photoip]

fantasties!

[jmauriciosousa]

Parabens, Bravo!!!!!!!!

[danielsch13011984]

you are a great and beautiful looking musician :)

[SuperSeaCucumber]

I've always loved this song... it was one of the first I learned on piano. this version does it much justice :) thanks for posting

[birdwing98]

Beautiful song and nice playing.

[KENYUROYAHARA]

buena tecnica.........sonido limpio.......y sobre todo una sonrisa magnifica  (buena vibra)

[knorbi1986]

Szia Edina! Régóta nézem a videóidat és jó látni, hogy milyen gyorsan fejlődsz. Nagyon szeretem ezt a Bach Preludiumot (is), nagyon szépen játszod.

Érdekelne, hogy a darabokat hagyományos kottából tanulod meg, vagy tabulatúrás lejegyzéshez vagy szokva?

Üdv, Norbi

[csybu]

@knorbi1986 ezt kottából játszom, de inkább tabróljátszom, meg hallás után sokszor

[beni767]

@csybu gratulálok, de ha egy bach-ot nekem lejátszol hallás után, akkor önként elmegyek a ZAKra és beutallak

[csybu]

@beni767 Bachot nem játszom hallás után:-)

[nmclay]

btw, I love your smile as you play! You look like you are really enjoying it; as you should! You are very good.

[nmclay]

1st, very nicely done! You know how classical guitarists hold their guitar on the left leg? If you transferred the guitar to your left leg you could raise the neck fo the guitar. This would allow both your right and left hands to make more precise "attack" on the strings. That piece requires you to be very relaxed and precise. This would do it for you. Aside from that, really great post! Show us when you have practiced it some more!

[xtronic11]

Bad Technique.Hold the right hand wrist more high and fingers work like hammers.I will post a video with me playng with right technique.Also Good Job!Good luck trought!

[onetwoBias]

u have the sweetest little innocent smile when u play haha that looks so great XD haha

[verdnew]

muito bom parabens!!!

[mmmiska]

sorry, but I thing, that´s shit

[josehijar]

precioso ¡

[csybu]

I am not a classical guitarist mate at first and I got a music sheet from a great guitarist guy and thats what I learnt. There are a lot of versions of this song, it depends on who wrote the transcription for me it is all right.

[zohritube]

u are great even in classical. waw !!!

[wtdty4z]

very nice and nice smile

come to visit

[brianvai]

la tecnica de la mano derecha esta erronea!! saludos!!!

4/5*****

[kooldan76]

I LIKE YOUR SMILE

[cienanosdesoledad]

Nice

[JGULLIF]

I am astonished you played it as well as you did with that right hand ... the peice was lovely! That right hand, though, looks contorted ... you definitely "get it" musically.

[Robinom]

very beautiful thankyou..music is not about technical ability but feeling,sound and exspression and you have it..In my opinion you are a far better musician than the shit sound produced by john williams and julian bream..

[rockin982]

Clearly, the great number of listeners who consider Julian Bream to be one of the finest classical guitarists ever to play the instrument, have NO idea what they are talking about. but YOU on the other hand are an expert on the subject ....

[AegisAnother]

Don't dis John Williams.

This is an easy song and anyone can smile for a camera :P

[eddyvanbuiten]

very nice & very cute :)

[wassuppaska]

i was gonna post a comment full of critique but seeing that i'll get flamed, i'll refrain from that :)

instead, i'll just give this advice: change the fingering, that looks so much harder than the "correct" versions plus Bach wrote the notes of the chords to be played in a certain order to maintain melodic movement.

[Tutinita13]

mui lindo el tema =)

[nicpag9]

Wonderful right hand technique. What's so wrong with it? If that is what is comfortable for her then it's fine. What a dumbass.

[Tutinita13]

hermosoo (L)(Y)

[JFACR]

hi csybu, you re very pretty, dont listen to the critiques, anyone can do what they do, its so easy to criticize. Keep playing. i salute you for having the courage to post a video playing a bach prelude, it takes guts knowing how critical people are. well done!. but i would ban those rude and harsh people for posting those comments.

[federicothegreat]

you have talent but need to work more in the sound, maybe pratice more hours a day, maybe play it slower until it sounds better, or maybe buy a better guitar or all this together. Nice work, and you´re also cute :D

[miisu]

I like this... not perfect but this makes me feel good.

[urbanbalazs96]

you are a very talented guitarist, only like this longer

[tropicalfoxxxes]

if you play like that with your right hand you're gonna hurt it and you wouldn't be able to play again

[teoshaker]

She keeps smiling. That's lovely. :)

[ninetysevenford]

the sound of this performance reminds me of the time i cut off my own leg with a hack saw

[MayRy4n]

i wish you had a penish. or did you that off too???

[ralfiona]

do you happen to have the sheet music for this although it was written for piano

[vinnothelizard]

this is rubbish.. kids stuff,,, she shud be in a beastility porn movie as a dog!!

[tomashek2]

haha ...really funny can some comments be :D .You guys have nothing better to do than thinking them out at nights ...anyway keep doing it because this is what makes YouTube laughable place of entertainment XD

[martintoque]

Marvelous!

[DaDoCCiNoBaD61]

I like lancashire hot pots, so did BACH by the way. He also liked dairy milk with his cappuccino's, while he played the guitar and had a shower. If you are aspiring to be like Bach, then you must have a cappuccino....... I'm a really bad guitarist by the way, but i can make a smashing cappuccino.

[DaDoCCiNoBaD61]

This woman has such a wonderful momentum with the guitar, really knows how to handle one. She pulls a face a like a chicken when she plays the guitar, which shows her commitment to it. I need a cappuccino now :)

[davidclassg1]

very nice playing, you seem to really enyoy Bach wich is great

[benboy1971]

Lovely. Your smile shows how much you love playing the guitar. :)

[mosidosi]

Great job!! Thank you !

[mjrami]

Muy bien gracias.

Marcelo Jose Ramirez

[padrigleamhnach]

Very nice!

[Klaudiusz1983]

meadure 5 is HELL;)Good work

[EA0223429]

great work keep it going 5*

[JuBblanco]

Nice try, good sprite.

[laqhi]

csybu, you are doing a good job! Keep on practicing hard and you will eventually attain your goals. Do not pay attention to mean spirited comments like those coming from people like laureanobruno. Their negativism is the result of their own frustrations.

[laureanobruno]

Pooooooooooor Bach, one of the most importants books of the whole time "The well temepered clavier", ruin by this fat girl

[laqhi]

Can't your criticism be a little constructive? I would like to see you playing; I am sure this girl is much better than you. No wonder why many in Latin America have a negative opinion about Argentinians like you.

[keto6789]

and you're very beautiful!!!!

[MJMilanek]

You are amazing, as a musician, as a girl. Czech republic

[loekstroem]

Well done!

Greetings from Sweden.

[keto6789]

you're beautiful!!! and your guitar playing is beautiful too.

[claudesv]

Edina,

You are good guitar player, you have a beautiful smile, you are so beautiful!

[ROGERDILIA]

Alguien sabe quien es ella, como se llama y de que pais es?

[stanleytherockstar]

so soothing.......i could literally feel my shoulders coming down and becoming less tense and more relaxed.

[chicotrim]

I m from Brazil and you are really a beautiful girl,  I play piano and like

music since I was baby

kiss in your heart

Chico

[yarods]

exellent ; thks for your smiling and playing ; a piece that i love ....patrick

[almugabala]

yeah!!! beatiful

[koralekster]

Amazing!

[Luchito316]

Bravo,pero que no muerda,/.

[markofzb]

sweet and cute !

[JeremieHMR]

Excellent! I play this prelude on piano, i think it's much easier than on guitar.

[mohflamenco]

good play i love the music of j.s.bach

[delboy1978uk]

beautiful!

the song is excellent too ;-)

love 2 u!

[4c00h]

great job :)

[superkorg]

no pasa nada

[Tyrciusz]

suprer czy mogła byś na prv lub tutaj napisać jakie sado tego chwyty gitarowe bardz oproszę :) pozddrawiam

[xxxAsiuniAxxx]

Pięknie.... Ma ktoś może do tego nuty....??

[patman2112]

I'm learning this one thought I see how you play it. Great playing.  Pat :o)

[bobmax59]

grâce a votre interpretation de cette etude,

par la vue ,detaillée des accords.

j'ai pu apprendre petit à petit cette oeuvre et en faire profiter mon entourage .

je vous en remercie .Bob , Belgique

[naturanaturans]

Dear csybu

favorated for ur flamenco and now in classical. that is hard for left hand only I know is american guitarist(name forgot. kindly comment would sound more classical if you let your right hand against gravity^^

[zneella]

beautiful......5*****

[ryjcio]

It's great :)

[MAAS2007]

You are kindfull, but not your guitar which sounds too metalic. If I were you I'd try to be more kindfull in your touch. The music asks for it and will sound better. Good luck!

[Botthen]

You are GREAT !!!!

[pianolover94]

I like your playing!!!

Keep it up!!!!

I'm 13 y/o

[acoustic2rock]

I have this tab onlu that's in drop D

[corinneiscool]

Cool, i love it, could u send me tabs for this and/or music? or atleast tell me where you got it from, very nice:)

[csybu]

I have a sheet music from it, sorry but I cant send you I dont have a scanner. I got this from a friend. But this must be somewhere on the net. check: w w w. 911tabs .c o m

[corinneiscool]

Cool, thanx:) sorry for even asking, i know how it is for people to always ask for tabs and music:) thanx again, keep in touch friend:)

[csybu]

no problem my friend:-)

[amin031]

so nice thanks for all your videos

[romford25]

Beautiful ! I want play this too.

[GuitarSlingerPK]

If you were to rate your performance from a classical aspect than i suppose there would be some critique rerquired, but that would be only if you are trying to strive for perfection. Theres no need to say it a 1 star performance it was wonderful i think. As far as your sitting position goes, it would improve some of the reaches and hand formations required to play classically, but if you research , you'll find many amazing players who sit in the "folk" position not the classical one.

[acoustic2rock]

It gonna be in my favorits it is a drop D that im hearing?

[csybu]

NO it is normal tuning.

[Washburnklaus]

I think its great !

Such a courage to play on guitar one of the greatest musicpieces ever done shouldt be honoured.

Thank You, I love it !

Klaus from Germany

[csybu]

Thanks so much! I know it is very hard piece and it is written for the piano. Studying this was a challange.

[kunukn]

Now I wanna play bach too :)

your inspiring!

[annaclaramatos]

You are great! You play the guitar beautifully and I really enjoy your work. And you're beautiful too! I'm your fan. AND TO ALL THIS PEOPLE WHO COME HERE TO CRITICIZE, "GET A LIFE"! THIS IS RIDICULOUS...

[ricardolacerda1978]

good job. Bach is my hero!!

[shehsuvar]

i can't watch how you play , because you have a nice smile

[marvl]

Jitpring is entirely correct. To be perfectly blunt, it sucks. An accurate rating would be maybe 1 star.

This is not a good piece for the instrument, even Christopher Parkening has to hack at it a bit. Find something else to play.

[Jitpring]

I've just read all the comments. Please don't let them fool you. The performance is hardly "awesome." It doesn't inspire awe, at least not in an actual player. I don't say this to be mean, but to give you at least one honest assessment. Keep working on it, and you have much work to do indeed. Tonally, for example. Not to mention all the flubs. You might consider sitting properly to begin with.

[AlexanderMBlade]

Why cant y'all pretencious guitar players just leave people alone when it comes to the instrument? Bad enough they have their own stress to deal with but with y'all adding on to it kind of kills the experience. Let people have fun with what they do.

[Jitpring]

They're voting for your pretty face. As you know, you have much work to do on this piece before you do it justice.

[MelleStar]

It's everytime nice to see you smile! :) Great, Edina!!!

[Dmanlamius76]

Lovely playing!

[KrisShred]

Wow, you're a monster ;)) 5 *s

Kris

[csybu]

If this was a compliment thanks than!:-)

[KrisShred]

a monster (a giant) at your guitar ;o)

kris

[SlowStrider]

She's wearing a nice mask then :-). But seriously I really like your playing and this piece! (It's true there are some small mistakes you could work on, but I don't get why some people have to be so blunt about it.)

[Ottawarocket]

Beautiful guitar playing.

Rocket

[ElectricSpirit]

truely beautiful, i hope to hear more from ya, ill send my album on april 20th

[csybu]

I cant wait for it!

[aliogitarro]

5 stars for playing and nice smiling :D

[stilleman]

Nice work. Enjoyed your playing.

[glaoud]

It is a piéce or the choice of the accords is difficult and which(who) are hard to enchainer ,for étre faithful at the modéle of the harpsichord. Your guitar has a beautiful sound.Sorry for my englisch.

(I am french.)

[Krisboul]

Je suis sur que le message est passe! ;)

[csybu]

in English?

[blebon]

Krisboul said: ' I am sure that your message has been understood! :) '

[csybu]

thanks my friend!

[AndanteLargo]

WOW! Can a 50 year old man say: YOU ROCK MAN!!!

LOL

Really great played! Can I have the TAB? No! Kidding!

Thanks

Peo

[csybu]

LOL!:-)

[fabjan2006]

Btw look to my favourites ;-)

[csybu]

;-)

[jnclassicalguitarist]

Lovely!

[lipstick206]

BEAUTIFUL.

5 stars.

[adilzahrani]

yes edina thes is the rial music .thanks 5 stars

adil

[csybu]

Thanks Jeff! You are a star I'm your fan!

[NESaddict]

awesome playing, i wish i had a classical guitar

[anadrolking]

Your fingers on your left hand look like they could do anything on the guitar. Thet're long and totally limber. Keep up the good work.

[csybu]

yes actually I learnt this piece because it is a good warm-up exercise for my left hand before playing something more difficult, like flamenco.

[alwaysdreams]

very nice.thanks

[troubleclef]

Nice job! and posted on Bach's birthday.

[csybu]

I did not know that! wow Happy birthday to Bach!