I would like to find this movie. Could you pls let me know its English name? Thank you!
oldsonglovers 1 year ago
問我劉家昌唱的有否比江蕾好? 就歌論歌 煙雨斜陽 確實沒有人比江蕾好 這首歌是劉家昌特意為江蕾量身打造的歌 其實很難去比較歌者的好" 純純的愛"這首歌也是江蕾的招牌 如果你問劉家昌 劉老師一定會說江蕾唱的比鳳飛飛好 但鳳飛飛當年卻比江蕾紅! 在歌壇有很多個人因素之外 也有很多商業考量 對眾多江蕾的歌迷來說 無疑的江蕾是過於低調了
linhsien 2 years ago
是呀, 這首當時也很流行, 不過好像很多人唱過, 奇怪, 我好像沒聽過江蕾這個名字, 或者我是香港人, 江蕾好像沒來過香港吧!
lcsthomas 2 years ago
這首歌 當然是江蕾唱的 江蕾是位行事過於低調的歌者 與世無爭 許多非常紅極一時的歌 隨著她結婚退出歌壇 一再的被翻唱 翻唱者何其多 但相信江蕾的歌迷們 都知道 真的沒有人能唱的比她好聽 這也就是為甚麼劉家昌老師人前人後 極度的讚賞江蕾的原因 也是為甚麼費玉清最近特別翻唱江蕾多首懷念金曲的原因 在歌壇很多70 ,80年代的著名歌星 心目中的偶像 就是江蕾
我後來知道是江蕾唱的,我只是還沒更改相關資料而已。
不過我很好奇,劉家昌自己也翻唱這首歌,
難道您認為劉家昌唱得也沒有江蕾好?(他似乎只唱自己寫的歌!?)
如果你問我這個問題,我會說,那當然!!
他的歌藝確實比不上他的學生江蕾、甄妮、尤雅,
上天是很公平的!!
wuchinren 2 years ago
這曲當年也很紅, 如不是youtube, 想會遺失腦海裡.
這鏡頭太珍貴了,昔日的西門町夜景,現在已完全不一樣了。
This version is indeed sung by 湯蘭花. This definitely is not 江蕾's voice. 湯蘭花 has very good singing voice.
Thanks for sharing! =)
melodydamor 3 years ago
But I have heard 華萱萱's version, it's no difference with this clip's.
The singer should be 華萱萱, I guess.
How do you know it is 西門町?
wuchinren 3 years ago
Tang Lan Hua, the woman singing in this clip, is so beautiful. Wonderful song and memories too.
kindface 3 years ago
湯蘭花 may not be the singer of this clip, although she is also a good singer in fact.
The singer may be 江蕾 or 華萱萱, I am not sure.
You may well be right that the actual singer was not Tang Lan Hua. In fact, most likely, it wasn't. I remember that TLH sang a few songs in her days, but she was in no way a widely-popular singer.
這個是誰唱的,是江蕾嗎
as219 3 years ago
WOW! Very nice song. I have heard this song...sung in other languages but didn't know it was in Chinese too. Thank you for the upload.
nkaujnyab 3 years ago
謝謝 您的影音一用
littlewbot 3 years ago
I would like to find this movie. Could you pls let me know its English name? Thank you!
oldsonglovers 1 year ago
問我劉家昌唱的有否比江蕾好? 就歌論歌 煙雨斜陽 確實沒有人比江蕾好 這首歌是劉家昌特意為江蕾量身打造的歌 其實很難去比較歌者的好" 純純的愛"這首歌也是江蕾的招牌 如果你問劉家昌 劉老師一定會說江蕾唱的比鳳飛飛好 但鳳飛飛當年卻比江蕾紅! 在歌壇有很多個人因素之外 也有很多商業考量 對眾多江蕾的歌迷來說 無疑的江蕾是過於低調了
linhsien 2 years ago
是呀, 這首當時也很流行, 不過好像很多人唱過, 奇怪, 我好像沒聽過江蕾這個名字, 或者我是香港人, 江蕾好像沒來過香港吧!
lcsthomas 2 years ago
這首歌 當然是江蕾唱的 江蕾是位行事過於低調的歌者 與世無爭 許多非常紅極一時的歌 隨著她結婚退出歌壇 一再的被翻唱 翻唱者何其多 但相信江蕾的歌迷們 都知道 真的沒有人能唱的比她好聽 這也就是為甚麼劉家昌老師人前人後 極度的讚賞江蕾的原因 也是為甚麼費玉清最近特別翻唱江蕾多首懷念金曲的原因 在歌壇很多70 ,80年代的著名歌星 心目中的偶像 就是江蕾
linhsien 2 years ago
我後來知道是江蕾唱的,我只是還沒更改相關資料而已。
不過我很好奇,劉家昌自己也翻唱這首歌,
難道您認為劉家昌唱得也沒有江蕾好?(他似乎只唱自己寫的歌!?)
如果你問我這個問題,我會說,那當然!!
他的歌藝確實比不上他的學生江蕾、甄妮、尤雅,
上天是很公平的!!
wuchinren 2 years ago
這曲當年也很紅, 如不是youtube, 想會遺失腦海裡.
lcsthomas 2 years ago
這鏡頭太珍貴了,昔日的西門町夜景,現在已完全不一樣了。
This version is indeed sung by 湯蘭花. This definitely is not 江蕾's voice. 湯蘭花 has very good singing voice.
Thanks for sharing! =)
melodydamor 3 years ago
But I have heard 華萱萱's version, it's no difference with this clip's.
The singer should be 華萱萱, I guess.
How do you know it is 西門町?
wuchinren 3 years ago
Tang Lan Hua, the woman singing in this clip, is so beautiful. Wonderful song and memories too.
kindface 3 years ago
湯蘭花 may not be the singer of this clip, although she is also a good singer in fact.
The singer may be 江蕾 or 華萱萱, I am not sure.
wuchinren 3 years ago
You may well be right that the actual singer was not Tang Lan Hua. In fact, most likely, it wasn't. I remember that TLH sang a few songs in her days, but she was in no way a widely-popular singer.
kindface 3 years ago
這個是誰唱的,是江蕾嗎
as219 3 years ago
WOW! Very nice song. I have heard this song...sung in other languages but didn't know it was in Chinese too. Thank you for the upload.
nkaujnyab 3 years ago
謝謝 您的影音一用
littlewbot 3 years ago