Are Anasheed Haram?

[IslamstarMo]

So was this

[IslamstarMo]

Bosniansunni

[aminaormuminah]

Yes, but what did the Prophet Muhammed (sallalahu alayhi wa salaam) say about it? I find so many Muslims are so quick to run to a fatwaa without finding out what the Qu'ran or Prophet (saws) has said about it!

[youtue321]

Salam O Alikum can you please upload this nasheed ?

[hytata]

So why are the salafi scholars not giving any fatwas against the king for dancing with american flag and enemy of muslims instead of licking the feet of the king for money.

Only giving fatwa's to pull out the love of the Prophet (peace be upon him) out of the hearts of the Muslims. According to you wahabis, the whole muslim Ummah is in error except you tiny sect who emerged from Najd.

Allah has hands, feet, eyes, shin, face, Allah will run, Allah sits, Allah smiles.

Astagfirullah!

[Nixupiz3]

subhanallah you can easily differentiate between if it is a qari or a nasheed

[ripper2nite]

People said they follow the Islamic Scholar ( ulama'). Does the Ulama' listen to music?

If not, then why are they still listening to it?

Music is a form of Batil.

Where is the place for the Batil? Hell :D

Music is music. No exception!

[aminaormuminah]

@ripper2nite provide da'leel (proofs) please. No fatwaas.

[hason31]

Its best people listen to the Quran and learn Arabic.

Often a lot of nasheeds are full of incorrect lyrics. People think that just because Nasheed do not have "music" or are so called "islamic" that they are good.

However, a lot of nasheeds contain things that are not correct Islamically.

[Fight040Allah]

sorry brother but I cant support music, unsub.

[Fight040Allah]

you have some nice videos, but I am under the impression that it is haram,

[ScopedOUT2]

It doesn't please me how Islamic Emirate of Youtube is very selective with the fatwas they show. They take the "shopping cart" method when it comes to these fatawas and what they want to show. This is a serious error and will misguide the public.

Everyone should read a book by Ibn Uthaymeen called "Differences of Opinion Amongst the Scholars"

if I'm not mistaken, that is the correct title of the book.

[easyonetwothree]

And this Song in this video is harâm because it's not according to the conditions ibn 'uthaymîn mentioned:

/watch?v=ZKHdbWwdrdA

[SFAvfx]

@easyonetwothree

Akhi, claiming something is haram is a serious matter and should not be taken lightly, especially when you are basing your evidence on something subjective such as the way a person sounds. Ibn al-Uthaymeen didn't listen to this particular anasheed, so what you have just done is use his conditions and issue your own fatwa against this anasheed.

Akhi I suggest you go to an Islamic university and study, so that you can post the type of comments you normally make on videos.

[ysherbini]

@SFAvfx

I am really sick of some people who just call something Halal and Haram and they don't really what a big difference between both. in every Nasheed you will find someone raise his voice and said "Nasheed is haram , haram " and as you said it's a serious matter and they should know what Quran and prophet Mohammed Peace be upon him said about it.

[Nuha38317]

@SFAvfx Salam alaikum, I love your channel so much, but I have to agree with easyonetwothree, because one can also make music with the own voice, as explained in a video on YT of Sheikh Munajjid and also Sheikh Uthaymeen, may Allah have mercy with him, speaks about sung with forbidden melodic tones. No offence - keep it up :)

[12345678channelviews]

can you please verify that?

if i read a fatwa, and follow it, if the fatwa is wrong, and i am in fact sinning, without knowing either way, the sheikh gets the sin and not me?

[twylightsky2007]

Forgive but I am not someone fammilar with your words. I do not know what anasheed is. Do you refer to a music group? And haram? Is that in term of forbidden or sacred? Using these old tounge words can be confusing for us western types. Most of us have no problem with song or debate of anytype. However the cries or absolution in call for death often spoken by those that call themself islamic rather angers the majority of us off.

[strivinmuslimah18]

I love this! Insha Allah since you said its ok to re-upload your vids. I plan on re-uploading this on my account!! Jazak Allah Khair.

[zelem92]

salam alaykoum jazakallahu khayr.

[AmatullahTheTraveler]

Jazakaallah Khayren!

[afghan2be]

Who are these people to decide what is right and what is wrong?

[Pua8]

Allah and Muhammad s.a.w. with the knowledge given by Allah, and the scholars fit it into our times.

[crawleykakes]

EAT BACON !

[SIKM4N]

Subhanallah beautifully explained, now people telling me nasheeds are haram, i shall tell them to view this Inshallah b4 saying that statement to me again.

Jazakallah!

[mohimuddin]

sorry i meant to say who is singing it, can you please tell me the name if you kno

[SFAvfx]

Sorry, I don't know who sings it brother.

[chilli094]

salam,

its a group called Labbayk who are frm London,

this nasheed is off their album RHYMES OF PRAISE

[myfavnasheeds]

@SFAvfx the artist is named Labbayk, if u still wanted to know

[lindimantigjili]

@mohimuddin

nasheed is by

Labbayk - Tala al badru alayna

[Hadeeths]

@mohimuddin It's a group of 3 men called Labbayk.

The nasheed is called Tala Al Badru Alayna.

[mohimuddin]

Assalamu Alaikum brother SFAvfx, what the name of this nasheed can you tell me please?

[SamiSo12]

ya akhi, can you please give reference to the quotation which you wrote ?

BarakAllah fikom

[isa786]

salaam alaykum my brothers and sisters.. would anyone tell me what is the name of this nasheed! jazak allah

[TheMuslimahSouljette]

Mash'Allah. Gr8 vid once again.

Assalamu 'alaikum, thanks for uploading.

[muslimz0wnz]

Barakhallah feek

brother, could you make a video showing us how to use sony vegas? your videos are amazing Mashallah

[SFAvfx]

I will insha'Allah.

[aliggali]

man i love sfa may allah grant u and jannah and may one day WALLAHI i meet u on the battlefield

[jaanu006]

inshallah i will also join with u guys on battlefield

[ibnarab]

May you die in your anger and frustration, you ignorant individual where do we backbite them you expose their faults which they try to spread thats it but not insults like you and other foolish people say about the rulers and not only that you make takfeer.

[ThinkAbout5]

JazzakAllahkair for the video. Good to give proofs from scholars!

[izzatiizzatiizzati]

nice video

[mamatwiladhaa]

I am soooo glad you brought this up! Barakallah feekum. Oh and easy in the commentsection, very controversial...

[ShadowRainX]

Who's the singer of this nasheed?

[majesstic786]

talib al habib

[ILuvIslam1]

Jazak'Allahu Khair brother..

[ilive4allah]

AsSalamu Alaykum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatu...JazakaAllah Khair! May Allah swt reward you!

[viper62382]

Excellent

[DawahandJihad]

Assalama Alaykum wa Rahmat Allahi wa Barakatu.

Jazakum Allahu Khair. Amazing background.

[IslamResponses]

Beautiful video masha' Allah as usual.

The prophet peace and blessing be upon him said:

( 'This Deen or way of life is easy'; 'Make it easy, don't make it difficult; 'Let people rejoice in being Muslims and not run away from it' and 'Cheerfulness towards other people, even a smile is a sadaqah or charity to be rewarded by Allah'.)

[IslamResponses]

The prophet pbuh gave his companions the following advice:

'Facilitate [religious matters to people] and do not make [things] difficult. Obey each other and do not differ [amongst yourselves].'

(Bukhari & Muslim).

I do not like people who make everything haram kufer etc , our religion is easy alhamdu leeAllah.

[fuzy04]

@IslamResponses Subhanallah well said. Can't add or take anything away from that. May Allah bless us all, ameen

[SFAvfx]

YT is acting strange again. If you commented on this video and you no longer see your comment, then I want you to know that I didn't delete your comments.

JazakumAllahu khayr

[JihadOfTheSoul]

I love your videos akhi, may Allah reward you

[GeneralA3]

جزاكم الله خيرا

[ShadowRainX]

Mashallah, thanks for this video akhi. I always love to listen to nasheed AND music but i lack nasheed infos. But the nasheed you used here is better than any music i've heard!

[Lone1Wolf9]

jazakAllah khair

[TheEndGameBoY]

As for Tala'al Badru nasheed, i heard it is not authentic. Wallahu a'lam.

[SFAvfx]

I also heard it was weak by some scholars, but not very weak or fabricated. It may have been classified as weak because of a missing or unknown link in the chain of narrators..Allahu a3lam.

The fact is there were many cases during the lifetime of the Prophet (S) were anasheed was sung, especially during jihad or on celebrations.

[dammee]

I heard that is wasnt sung for the prophet saw when he came to madina, rather when the Muslims came back from a military expedition .

Allahu Aleem

[DawahandJihad]

Ibnul Qayyim Rahimahullah says that it was sung when he came back from Tabuk, not on the Hijra. His proof is that Thaniyyatul Wada' is to the north of Mecca, in the direction of Tabuk, not the south, in the direction of Mecca. Wallahu Ta'ala A'lam.

[TheEndGameBoY]

I heard similar thing from shaykh Abu-is7aq Al-Huwayni:

watch?v=rFniLe2jIRE

[TheEndGameBoY]

Baraka'Allahu feek akhi,

beautiful video too :)

[easyonetwothree]

Ibn 'Uthaymeen:

"Islaamic Anasheed is an Innovated Song, it reminds me of what the Sufies have innovated. Therefor, one should turn his back to this and turn himself to what the Qur'aan and sunnah contains..."

( Madjoo´ Fataawaa Muhammad bin Saalih bin ´Uthaymîn, p. 124)

[SFAvfx]

Half quoting will get you nowhere, now I will appreciate it if you do not cause fitnah on my videos.

[easyonetwothree]

Nobody is agasinst Poetry, your videos contain Sufi-stylish Anashid where men sing like backstreet boys!

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@ easyonetwothree

akhi can you provide a link of what you think is anacceptable example of a nasheed?

[DawahandJihad]

Because the backstreet boys are Sufis, right? And I wonder how you know how they sing....

[easyonetwothree]

No, but some Anasheed singers imitate the kuffaar in their songs, and yes I know how they sing because I was not a practicing Muslim my entire life..

[DawahandJihad]

If a Munshid is singing about victory for the Ummah and Nasr for the Muslims from Allah, without the use of musical instruments, then where is the imitation of Kuffar? These are the types of Anasheed that brother SFA uses. Where is this Sufism which you claim is prevalent in their audio? The fact that they are Jihadi nasheeds to begin with rules out Sufism for obvious reasons, so...errmm...yea....I don't see where you're going with this.

[easyonetwothree]

The imitation comes when they start to 1. sing in choirs 2. they are making their voice seem like Instruments while it is only voices, and the Bid'ah comes when they claim it is "Islâmic" while Islâm never came with this, Poetry is reciting verses yes, but it should not be like this:

/watch?v=eeeb1MuPWD4&feature=c­hannel_page

Very sufi-like!

[SFAvfx]

easyonetwothree

I kindly asked you before to take your fitnah somewhere else, but you still continue to issue fatwas based on your desires.

Th nasheed in the video is not sufi-like and you don't even know what bidah means, now go and make videos about how smiley faces are haram.

Follow Al-Albani's advice to people you like:

watch?v=Nwm1PsdxqPA

Sorry it is in Arabic, so you are going to have to wait until it is translated.

[12345678channelviews]

@SFAvfx

are smiley faces haram, or not? because since i read a hadith i am wary of using smiley faces

[12345678channelviews]

@easyonetwothree

brother, as far as i know, bida is only when it is something of ibada

[easyonetwothree]

@12345678channelviews Bid'ah is everything in the deen, not only 'ibaadah.

[easyonetwothree]

What Ibn 'Uthaymeen said is Halâl is to recite some verses and thats it, no recordings, no selling it, no choirs, no tones, no drums/duff, no dancing, no voices in background, etc, Only reciting some verses of poetry, which todays Anasheed singers absolutely fail to do! (And Al-Albanî gave the exact same fatwâ, and there are Fatâwâ where they completly forbid it, both of them, except in Jihâd)

[ibnarab]

Akhi what is the point of talking with these people they take bin baz and ibn untaymeen when it comes to things that suit (which the brother has misunderstood) them but when they say haram to back bit the rulers and protest they dont listen what is this ignorance ???

[TheEndGameBoY]

ibnarab

islam is not only about "Rulers", its about defending innocent Muslims as well. We don't like tyrant rulers. that is the fact which annoys the "......." group.

Does anyone in the"....." group dares to say what shaykh Al-Albani said about Rulers:

watch?v=ux8Nk0KMRUk

[ibnarab]

To: TheEndGameBoY,

Akhi i am very disappointed with you i have spoken to you on many occasions and have sent you daleel for many things but yet you still come with the same points which we have clarified before.

[TheEndGameBoY]

ibnarab

isma3 akhi, Da3wah to Tawheed includes everyone, that is the point i was trying to make. We need Du'aat and Shuyookh to speak the haqq like shaykh Al-Albani (ra7imahullah).

[c00lrasheed]

jazakAllah khayr

[IslamicRevolutionTV]

Masha'Allah jazakAllahuKhair for this.

[spiritlite]

AsalaamuAlaikum, MASHALLAH thanks brother,

May ALLAH bless you, Ameen.

JAZAKALLAH KHAIR.