Aaj Islam - Karen Armstrong critique by Javed Ahmed Ghamidi Part 1

[peacemaker571]

o man . . .if i had watched this 9 minutes video 4 years ago i didnt have to spend 3 years of my life wandering. . . . i was soo frustrated that i abanded my studies and spent 3 years on studying islam and its sects and other religions and i finaly find the truth in Quran . . . .now i m a university student and wanna bring a revolution in my country named . . . .pakistan

[hawk08ht]

@peacemaker571 First establish Prayers, Fasting do the basic stuff and above all take care of ur parents and close relatives. Charity begins at home :). Im with you newyas

[VJZ82]

I agree, how can you critic publicly someone without being present to defend herself. That is very unethical.

[zafarqos]

@VJZ82 Karen Armstrong ideas are well established, documented and well known. So there is no need for her to be present in every session which analysis her thesis. Should we stop criticizing the ideas of philosophers like Carl Marx, Frued or Socretus becuase they are not available to defend their thesis?

[zafarqos]

@VJZ82 In academia issues are debated or analyzed (like this). Both formats have pros and cons but both are practiced. Anti-religion thesis existed before her but Karen has presented it in reasonably & qualifies analysis. Any misrepresentation of her opinions or bad analysis must be objected. But to Que all TV shows until she is able to participate till her death does not sound very reasonable to me. Should we wait for Ghamidi's death to analyse his views in his absence?

[mercede75]

They should have invited her to explain the point of view about god rather than having this gamdi man explain what she meant