Added: 3 years ago
From: whatsda411
Views: 68,690
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (128)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I LOVED THE GUYS HARMONY, SOMEONE SHOOT THAT SCREAMING BITCH LOL...

  • Mariah is incredible here. Her control, espeically in the first 2 verses, is remarkable. & that is NOT Mariah singing those out of tune whistles. She doesnt even show it in her face..& we all know how mariah sometimes reacts after she hits a note that she's uncomfortable with.

  • Comment removed

  • That background singer gets on my nerve tryn to sing higher than my gurl nxt time mariah kick her ass off stage and let her sit dere for ah few mins haha !

  • sexy sexy sexy  pant pant pant love it

  • Well that squeaky whistle sound was mariah it happens at times because of her nodules, it pushes more air when she belts causing that sound making her voice split almost.

  • chike

  • WHAT'S WRONG WITH THE BACK SINGER???

  • she is the best.... studio singer. there is something wired when she sings live when she decides not to lip sing.lol she is not a good live performer. she doesn't practice enough. i dont care who you are and how long you've been singing you need to practice a lot before you sing live. because she sounded really bad at Michael Jackson's funeral

  • @Eliasnewmusic She have lipped 5-7 Performances in her live o_O This is live and fantastic

  • @Eliasnewmusic you can't say she is not a good live performer because she doesn't practice much and because she sounded really bad at michael jackson's funeral.

    It's not only about practicing anymore when a woman is mariah's age. she has vocal modules, and in recent years it has gotten worse. I think people should show respect to her as she still trying to do as much live as possible instead of jugging her. she own the title of best female artist long time ago.

  • @davidchubo she is a studio singer. dont get me wrong i love her music.

  • @Eliasnewmusic I understand what you saying, which i m not agree.

  • @davidchubo Ummm... She sounded bad at Michael Jackson's funeral because she was crying the whole time... I probably wouldn't be great at anything if I had to do it in front of a coffin.....

  • @sacampbell719 Hi friend, I think you replied the wrong person.

  • Apresentação meio tosca! Faltou ensaio!

  • whats wrong wid backup singas dese daiis tryna out sing MARIAH

  • yeah the background singer trying to whitsle && it doesn't sound good at all.

  • @amber31408 i dont think that was the back up singer i think that was mariah..yes she was belting and whistling at the same time.

    how? idk, but that was mariah.

    listen to other performances and u will hear it.

  • @oo0o0opss It's not Mariah screaming at 3:29 if you play it back you can hear Mariah trying to over power the screaming back up dancer.

  • @sacampbell719 i wasnt talking about 3:29 i was talking about the 'whistle' notes that amber31408 thought a backup singer was doing, but it wasnt a back up singes it was mariah and it happens because of her nodules like musicguy713 commented.

  • @oo0o0opss I really think it's the back up singers' scream. Mariah's nodules couldnt make those sound... usually nodules affect the high notes and control of the voice and sometimes split the notes, but it doesn't produce "whistle"notes. Especially all that noise sounded like "AH" when mariah was clearly singing with actually lyrics, and her belting actually sounded pretty clear and strong.

  • Man, Mariah Is A Bad Bitch!!....... u rule Mimi......... that actually used to be my nickname as a baby ..well it was screamin' Mimi cause as a baby i always cried loudly.. and mariah sings loudlyu get dah point rite

  • i love thee back singerss

  • Te amo Mariah Carey,a melhor cantora.

  • "Mrsamy1995 : não falo ingles e xinguem em portugês"

    hsudhasdusahduashdsuadh Ri Alto agora!!! kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk­kkkkkkkkkk

  • kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk q figura viu !

  • how can she be so pretty and toned in dat age

  • bla bla bla tem algo em portugues aqui por acaso mas que merda eu não entendo os comentarios que vcs colocam mas ela ta muito inda e amo muito ela!!

    BYE BYE BYE

    E AKON NANANANA

    FOREVER

    amOOooooo

  • WTF?

  • aff oque WTF eu nun falo ingles alguém me excplica oque esse doido posto

  • speak english fucking aff oque eu nun whatever shit

  • não falo inglês me xinguem em português

  • i loved this performance. it was very pure

  • Mariah Perfect !

  • amazing. best singer who ever lived. she looks incredible

  • uhuw concordo plenamente!!!

    quem for do brasil ai da um up!!!

    ok??

    beijos amores de minhas vidas

    amoOoo todos os fãs de mariah carey

    amo-te

  • She is singing this because her grandma died and YOU LOT is being mean to her. Anyway.why are you watching if you dont like her? To Mariah good luck!

  • it's hard watching Mariah sing this one, it's like she's forcing the words out and being too careful to make it sound right..that back up singer at the end released the tension. good work!

  • Legal :D gamei ;)

  • r u frieken retarted or just tone deaf. that was amazing

  • vagabundo idiota vai para o inferno vc que odeia a mariah carey ela é uma deusa vc nunca vai sder igual ela!!!

    sua baranguete falsificada

    invete sangalo do paraguai te odeio

    MARIAH CAREY THE BESTH FOREVER

    AMOOOOOOO

    *`___*

  • now shes singing "bye bye to that backup singer"

    no im almost positive its her voice

  • love this song

  • Mariah is one of the BEST female singers !!!! But the big Hen in the backround is too loud for the song.

  • Wonderfull

  • i hate the backing track, the voice dont match

  • i love this song! :D mariah sonds amazing live! :) <3 luv her voice! XD (sooo wish i cud sing like her!)

  • I Love this song very much. I'm dedicating this to my sister, MicheLLe.. -MichaeL ManiLag

  • Mariah sing the right note while the back up is wrong so who do you prefer?

  • the whistle background thing happens when she hits the higher belted notes... its coz of her nodules n stuff her vocal chords are kinda wierd so the airflow when she sings in normal voice causes sort of a whistke thingy to it i guess :S

  • they already replaced that back-up singer i guess... i dont see her on her other live videos...

  • Yes she was replaced due to the amount of complaints received.

  • HA HA theyre like "get your ass on up and out" lmao

  • no, actually its because of tuning problems with the microphone and speakers.

  • nah. its mariah. its her "whistle register" whats happening is that when she sings she putting air through her throat and it gets thinner and thinner as she hitting harder notes and its like shes whistling. it happened to another peformance.

    im almost certain its her

  • thats what i thought, but the x factor performance when she sang i stay in love, she had the same problem and ssimon cowell said that the high pitch thing was tuning problems

  • yeah. deff her voice. we know two things. one shes singing live and two her voice is hurting. but if it is tuining its her mic cause she carrys it around everywhere. but i highly doubt that although that would be a good excuse

  • Mariah's whisle doesn't sound like that. Its her back up singer. Well, she's gone now..^_^ The last part was a total mess.. though i think unintensionally..

  • It's her diamond mic,at the inaguration it did that and she had to switch mic's out.

    If you pay attention U will notice that she sings hero with that mic but then changes to a regular one during sign sealed delivered.

    so it's not the whistle and besides don't ya think it would be kinda of hard for 2 registers to come out at the same time???

    how can you do whistle and chest voice???

  • i never said that it was her mic. i said; "but if it is tuning its her mic cause she carry's it around. but i highly doubt that although that would be a good excuse" and it is possible to activate two sets of vocal cords at once. look it up.

    anyway its possible cause all a whistle register is is that air is passed through a thin opening in the vocal cords. so if shes reaching for a note and its strong enough to squeeze the cord than its possible if you say its not either or then what is it

  • Dont blame the backup singers or any body...guess like this performance didnt go any rehearsal...but then very good...i think the backup up singers try to sing Mariah's belted part with whistle...but though...those backup singers are good...remember they are just backup not a solo artist...and duh i saw Rachelle ann go in the philippines who try to sing the belted parts but then she never stop herself to screamed

  • whats that annoying whistle i can hear, its not hers she is belting out notes when it is happening, its probly the back up singers or the person who uploaded this trying to make us say it sounded good... NOT

  • she was mining from 3:21 to 4:09...

  • i luv this song it

    make me sad though but i always listen to it it reminds me of my dad and grandpa and i havent seen them since i was 7 and now im 14

    but i also think this song should have been #1

    and she looks sexy in dis

  • i luv this song it

    make me sad though but i always listen to it it reminds me of my dad and grandpa and i havent seen them since i was 7 and now im 14

    but i also think this song should have been #1

  • I love that Trey Lorenz is still one of her back up singers he has ben with her since the beginning of her carrer. I remember when she was on MTV unplugged and her and Trey sang I'll be there together. It was one of her best performances

  • pqp,,,canta muito^^ adoro vc suas tecnicas..tudoooooooooooooooo

  • i soo love this song....tho it reminds me of someone i knew....hell,it still hurts...

  • backup singer = SHUT UP!!

    mariah = SLAP THE BACK UP SINGER NEXT TIME!

  • @MimiNirvlarva i rckn.. fck the stupid back up ruins the song when she tries to outsing mariah haha

  • @MimiNirvlarva so stupid to say... 21 thumbs up?? LOL pathetic

  • In terms of Mariahs vocal performances this year this is possibly her best. The top three (now keep in mind this is judging on Mariahs vocals only) are this, fly like a bird (idol gives back), and Im that chick (fashion rocks)-> that intro was amazing

  • Wow, what a fantastic live performance of this great Song! Mariah you've stll got it on..girl! xxx

  • You Really Get the Message, Such an Amazing LIVE Singer!!!!

  • amo essa musika !!!

    parabéns Mariah Carey !!!

  • Mariah doesn't need to show to anyone anything. She just enjoys live. She will always be the best. Love you Mimi...I'll be loving you 4-ever!

  • the high notes are... wow.. she is great!

  • AMAZINNNGG. ;]

  • mann, she's good live.

  • i bet u inside Mariah's head she saying "shut da fuk up back up stop squeaking!!" while she did the note on bye byeeeeeeeeeeeeee. on 3:47

  • I KNow Right!

    The Back Up Singer Ruins Mariah's Performances Too Much!

    She Needs To Seriously Shut The Fuck Up!

  • omg... what was that background singer doing?!?! shes not what ppl are paying to see. i hope she got fired after that. id be so mad cuz she made it sound stupid UGH

  • Luv it!

  • ugh that bk up singer drowned our mariah at the best part of the song, n that singer kept drowning our mariah at the high notes

  • I love the back vocals here

  • You're Mad

  • does she mime from 1.12-1.26 ??

  • the back up singers sound fine until the last part of the song (the best bit), where they sound like flat sheep 'baa baa baa baa...' then the fat one to the right tries to outsing her! wtf happened when she went up high and the only one u could hear was the fat one?!?! mariah is a worldwide legend, don't the backup singers realise she's a billion times better than them?? ARRRRRGGGGGGGHHHHH sorry that's my daily moan out of the way.

  • I think she's still an amazing singer. She did show off her voice alot, maybe that's why it's not like it used to be. Either way, I still love her.

  • Aye!those back singers suck!

  • Hmm.. not cool.... Fuck that back up singer

  • lol i love how that even the backing singer drowns her out at 3:30

  • why people hate mariah just because she is perfect or cause she did what no other singer did??she is having a great time she does not need to expose her voice like she did in the past this is the second part of the emancipacin hello??you know what that means this album has great composicions and very charmous mariah you know who you are and don´t need to show to anyone we LOVE you!!

  • the backup singers totally screwed this performance up!!!

  • dear,Got2BeDowne69

    so ur sayin that u got that i-can-hit-high-notes-more-than­-anyone-else huh?

    puh-liz.

    mariah is timeless..whatever she does peeps still accept her. go mimi!!

  • plz..her live performances are trashy! she's only good on whistles!

  • so trashy!!! whistles??? inconsistent!!

  • mariah can't hit hight notes..she can only whistles and it's like it's too hard for her to hit high notes without using whistles! she sucks on live performances..she's the queen of lip sync! mariah has no chest voice power!

  • mariah obviously had chest power

    check any time you need a friend, she Hit a G5 there, and she ever do it Live

    and mariah Hit D6 with chest register in "subtle Invitation"

  • HAD being the operative word. She was an EXTREMELY POWERFUL singer in the beginning. What happened? She used to sing with live bands and not backup tracks. I think back to her performance on Arsenio Hall of Emotions in 1991 or 1992....wow........THAT was what was up!

  • yeh, i have to agree the back up singer was quite terrible lol!!!

  • hmmm....the most annoying part of this is in the first verse, one of the back up singers is singing a very high harmony through the whole verse. they are out of tune, and it makes mariah sound awful, whereas in the second verse, it is just mariah, and it sounds far better. same in the oprah version. they "bye"s by trey at 1.33 and 2.33 sound ridiculous. 3.20 - 3.31 is lip synched. 3.32-3.36 is live, 3.36-4.09 is lip synched, then the rest is live. if u cant see that ur thick.

  • Yeah thats my girl

  • OMG there is only one Mariah no one can do it like she can. This is a beautiful song and the performance was amazing. I couldn't stop my self from crying through the whole thing cause it's such an emotional song and MC was so emotional while singing it. I'm heading straight over to Itunes to Download this song & I will be buying her Album today.

  • It was a great performance but I'm wondering the same thing about the high note that u hear in the background, it sounds creepy, that's weird because I didn't hear it on TV when it was live. But then again who cares..lol..it was hot and she looked flawless in that dress.

  • Non-fans would think that this isnt a live performance but i guess she's out to prove them wrong. She has amazing vocals that it seems youre listening to a recording...but hey that's MARIAH...this live performance rocks!!! Way to go MIMI!!! Sherwyn and Karol you have to see this!!!

  • Loved it!

  • background vocalists do highnotes sometimes. See "My saving grace" performances

  • Omg i truly loved this performance and yes mariah is numba 1 but wat was up at 3:41 to 3:59, why did it sound lik someone tryna hit a whistle note while she sing and i jus hated how her background singers meanin the two woman tried to sing so high n drown out her voice, other than that i loved it, sum1 please explain to me from 3:41 to 59

  • I was wondering the same thing...the back up singers (the two girls) was killing the song. But i guess its hard to back up Mariah

  • yea...obviously on the record, Mariah does do a whistle towards the ending of the song, but for some reason she allowed one of those background singers to hit a whistle note as well...she shouldve just left that out all together if shes not going to do it, because OMG..that just threw me and it kinda messed up the perfomance...because its like who is screeching in the background..because they weren't doing a good job..at all..lol. But Mariah sounded awesome..and those two girls can't over do her

  • Great performance ...I watch this on tv...it sounded 2x better on TV...Mariah your the best!

  • good performance

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more