@bikemanezc Sapphire, I think. This song is set after the events of the Stay Positive album where Sapphire foresaw murder in "Both Crosses" (she's also the psychic girlfriend that appeared in "Chips Ahoy") and I think that freaked out the narrator and he's trying to stay away from her for a bit. Holly, Charlemagne, and Gideon are all involved with this somehow but it's kind of confusing and I'm not sure exactly what their connection is.
The Hold Steady are my favorite band in the world. (I even have a stay positive tat) But I have never heard them play this song live! Anyway great video!!!
@Stephanobentos Wow, one of the best fan made music videos I've seen in a while, well done! It's so great how their lyrics are so plainly narrative, creating a story in your head, with visuals often not unlike this, you've captured a little part of that. One of my other favourite things about them is not just the music and lyrics but how dedicated the fans are... you've demonstrated that - keep up the good work
I've removed all the annoying annotations. I used CoralDraw 9 for the graphics and iMovie 3 for the edit. I know there's way better software out there. But I'm cheap.
My only criticism, and it's a small one, is that it's sort of hard to read the letters on the "Charlemagne don't seem the same" line. Otherwise, great work! Awesome video for an awesome song.
awsome
LittleShroomChild 1 month ago
Anyone know where you can get this song? Album? Download? All I can find is the crappy Positive Rage version. TIA
Birdsnest101 4 months ago
LFTR PLLR
northkato 4 months ago
I cannot get over how much i love this song
bobthepurpleostrich 4 months ago in playlist amazing musicy goodness
What album is this off??
WideOpenTuna 4 months ago
@bikemanezc Sapphire, I think. This song is set after the events of the Stay Positive album where Sapphire foresaw murder in "Both Crosses" (she's also the psychic girlfriend that appeared in "Chips Ahoy") and I think that freaked out the narrator and he's trying to stay away from her for a bit. Holly, Charlemagne, and Gideon are all involved with this somehow but it's kind of confusing and I'm not sure exactly what their connection is.
StudioScarecrow 6 months ago
Is he singing about Holly or Sapphire?
bikemanezc 6 months ago
Comment removed
StudioScarecrow 6 months ago
The Hold Steady are my favorite band in the world. (I even have a stay positive tat) But I have never heard them play this song live! Anyway great video!!!
jwashing100 8 months ago
Impressive! I love the colors, the energy and the aggressiveness You obviously have a talent for this. :)
pettige88 10 months ago
@Stephanobentos Wow, one of the best fan made music videos I've seen in a while, well done! It's so great how their lyrics are so plainly narrative, creating a story in your head, with visuals often not unlike this, you've captured a little part of that. One of my other favourite things about them is not just the music and lyrics but how dedicated the fans are... you've demonstrated that - keep up the good work
thematfactor 10 months ago
Gaaaaaaaaay
snowghost24 11 months ago
I've removed all the annoying annotations. I used CoralDraw 9 for the graphics and iMovie 3 for the edit. I know there's way better software out there. But I'm cheap.
stephanobentos 1 year ago
@stephanobentos Mang!! I liked those annotations!! They were informative, not annoying!!
TheFlite29 10 months ago
@stephanobentos I liked the annotations. They were informative!!
TheFlite29 10 months ago
Wow!
One of my favourite music videos! And its a fan vid amazing.. What program did you make it with?
Fentoman 1 year ago
@Fentoman
I used CoralDraw 9 for the graphics and iMovie 3 for the edit. I know there's way better software out there. But I'm cheap.
stephanobentos 1 year ago
This looks really great, what did you use to make it?
morskihr 1 year ago
@morskihr
I used CoralDraw 9 for the graphics and iMovie 3 for the edit. I know there's way better software out there. But I'm cheap.
stephanobentos 1 year ago
St.Paul. LOL. :)
shingaki777 1 year ago
This is so much better with annotations off. That being said, wonderful vid!
Ryyy4n 1 year ago
great video the litte comments in the vid piss me off though
18skatevalo 1 year ago
My only criticism, and it's a small one, is that it's sort of hard to read the letters on the "Charlemagne don't seem the same" line. Otherwise, great work! Awesome video for an awesome song.
balthazord 1 year ago
This has gotta be one of my favorite music videos. I love the style, I love the song, and I love The Hold Steady.
AlmostKilledUs 1 year ago
This is possibly the best Hold Steady video I've seen, official or otherwise =]
moloch5642 1 year ago
Way to excellent video. And awesome song I haven't ever heard this one
Joekickass3000 1 year ago
this song is so cool
djh0267 1 year ago
love it!
lcdxhavok 1 year ago
This is really well done. Nice work!
bsf95 1 year ago
Great video - thanks for sharing :)
takedownroddy 1 year ago
I love this band and this song. Fantastic vid, very creative!
pistonpackinmonique 1 year ago
if you spelt adderall correctly (it has two ds) you'd get the hits you deserve for this video.
jonnyr00 1 year ago
@jonnyr00
You're totally right. Thanks Jonny.
stephanobentos 1 year ago
@jonnyr00 *spelled.
ladicius 1 year ago
@jonnyr00 spelled
bosco1109 1 year ago
@jonnyr00 spelled
bosco1109 1 year ago
Great stuff - love your little pop-up comments.
Like the fact your vid is as 'busy' as the song, hundred different things going on.
5 Stars.
Floorwarm 2 years ago
This is rad.
Great song.
Amazing band!
Melicoptersradical 2 years ago 2
Pretty damned good chappy.
Niiauyr 3 years ago 3
Comment removed
inputmodule 3 years ago
Excellent!
kmoneyham 3 years ago 2
this is excellent. thumbs up!
xMrVincentVegax 3 years ago 3
thanks for this, this is so great!
dodatani 3 years ago 3
Hey glad you like it.
stephanobentos 3 years ago
Absolutely fantastic film. A big thank you from a British fan of the band. My fave track from 'Stay Positive'.
alexhere2005 3 years ago 3
From one Brit to another, thanks Mate. THS are over here in a month. I'll be at the Roundhouse to see 'em on the 17th.
stephanobentos 3 years ago
Awesome!!!
The only bad thing about it is the text-singing choreographing.
Bands should be paying you to make these!
Frozensquirrel 3 years ago
Yeah half of that is the encoding and half of it was out in the original edit.
stephanobentos 3 years ago
Don't get me wrong, though.
This is f**king incredible.
Frozensquirrel 3 years ago 2
Thanks. I kinda let the mismatches ride as the thought of editing this again was just too much. Glad you like it.
stephanobentos 3 years ago
Petteroes' You're the first one to spot that.
stephanobentos 3 years ago
Love it when the Separation Sunday-image appears.
petteroesbikkja 3 years ago
You rock, SteveDave
MykeFahrenheit 3 years ago
Cheers Myke
stephanobentos 3 years ago