Manic Street Preachers- Train In Vain

[IEATGIANTGEESE]

@bluedog15 Jones wrote this after he broke up with the bird from the slits, wouldnt have been appropriate for Strummer to sing it and i think Jones's patchy singing makes it gid

[NucularTheArtist]

@IEATGIANTGEESE @bluedog15 Also, "Stay Free" was about one of his school friends getting released from prison, so Strummer couldn't have sang that one either

[timcoe82]

Not doing it for me. Clash version RULES OK!

[2bsom1]

not a patch on the clash version

[2010welshy]

love this cover,they always cover songs well tho.

[BlondeRocknRoll]

oh, great cover, takes a lot to take on The Clash, but JDB, vocals, and the manics, do a pretty good job.., aint Mick though is it !!!! , but i like the manics..

[JoesRamone]

This is epic! Epic in every sense! God I love the MSP and the Clash >:3

[Partoftheratpack]

James vocal is better than the original, before anyone says anything - i love the clash, just think this is really good.

[liamjwolves]

i prefer mick's vocals just by a bit, but this is a brilliant cover.

[billsmuztube]

@Partoftheratpack not a bad cover but sorry you are wrong never heard better than strummer singing this

[dewey1122]

@billsmuztube joe strummer didn't sing on train in vain

[billsmuztube]

@dewey1122 i stand corrected beer made me lie : )

[bluedog15]

@dewey1122 Mick Jones sang it and i never liked his voice unfortunately, "stay free" was ok, but I used to always be thinking "should have let Strummer sing it" whenever clash tacks were sung by Jones

[ASININIUS55]

cool