American Idol - Top 7 - One Sweet Day - Season 7

[yellowtents]

back when they didn't lip sync the group song.

[TheHellyeah14]

Carly was the best of this season...by far. Why does the best singer never win?

[Livlovs2laf]

Can someone tell me who is singing in order? I know Jason is first and a little bit more but I dont remember everything else.

[MultiOdom]

All of their voices together arent as big as MARIAH

[IcedLipGloss]

they need to have another mariah week!!!

[Esthersita11]

Nick Pitera sings this song better than they do!!!! check him out here on youtube

[parkerdude2003]

All the soul of the song sucked right out.

[hollydaytimetv]

This was a nice idea and they did their best, but no one is going to ever do it better than Mariah and Boys II Men.

[simple1for1]

horrible.

[Dkellz]

this sounds like shit!

[o0ber]

Carly needed to more songs like this than the rock stuff.

[hillmcdaniel]

i am just so pissed off listening to them kill a good song like this. i cant explain it. it just sounds so damn white. this is not american karaoke this is american idol

[7Skilletfan]

@hillmcdaniel Some live performances aren't going to sounds as good as they do in the studio

[raff23]

why were they singing this song anyway? entirely inappropriate for the occasion, its a sad song, a funeral song. Disgraced the whole meaning of the song by putting it on idol.

[kali902000]

i thought syesha and david cook sounded good together. funny cause i never thought their voices would blend that well

[lauranna75]

archuleta's voice sucks really bad here

[Redman5175]

David sounds great. The first two sucked.

[csolumaz]

yes it yes yes

this is one sweet day

[X3moCrushX]

mmmm that hottie with the dread locks is DOIN IT lol

[ohmyjoni]

JASON DAVID A AND DAVID C I LOVE YOU

[epirenta]

This is awful. They don't sing well together. They are ALL trying to out-sing each other. Archuleta is the only one who carries the note and tone comparable to that of the song. AWFUL

[filsk8ter]

Okay it wasnt that bad....

If someone can do a better cover to this song then go ahead, talk, but fer those who arent the best singers to this song and is saying these pple sukk aat singing this song, then just shut yer mouth for one minute and think.

[petergriffin9901]

@SHendo36 lol I know!the end is just a bunch of screaming!

[mrtbarrett]

both singers at the beginning SUCK. GET OFF THE STAGE! They ruined a great song. That's rude, disrespectful and tacky to destroy a song this good.

[zealousstatic]

Agreed

[honeyzr]

archie carly and syeshia really did a great job. jason screwed up, but hes cute though

[nedobnz]

They murdered this song.

[SOL1237]

David A.

Carly

David C.

Syesha

I love them!!! =D

[Will9323]

BOOOOO!!! To the guy in the beginning.Horrible

[craazyonuu]

Carly pwned.

[rearea718]

david syeshia and carly they should have been the only ones singing this song! while the others sway and smile in the background.was 2:16-2:19 syeshia?

[87bamboo]

All awesome, miss AI 7, esp Archie.

[iheartcb19]

i wish david archuleta opened the song it would hav been way better then jason castro

[michaellover10]

carley was great but the rest were pritty awful :(

[CrazySexyCool34]

why did they sing this song?! They sooo didnt do this song any justice. Mariah n Boyz II Men r way way above all of them vocally. omg such a shame.....

[abpfing04]

david cook is freakin hot

[petergriffin9901]

the song is too big for all of them,especially brooke and cook girl and corn hair

[mimi10115]

carly is the only one that knocked it out of the park. she was amazing!

[Jvilleman31]

he looks high, look at his eeyez

[iheartcb19]

yeah jason does look high lol

[gotchahooked]

they suck on this song no feeling

[iheartcb19]

its cuz they opened the song wit the 2 worst people in the comptetion that year

[idoltyler06]

Well I think it would've worked with Archuleta or Cook, and I think Kristy made the best she could with her part, so I can't take away from her.

[iheartcb19]

archie should hav opend for the song not jason he suks lol

[abpfing04]

no way. haha sorry just my opinion

[jazzyxfr3sh]

gaaaaay.

original was like 47932748932x's better maan.

[mundiman889]

This was an ok performance, wayy too difficult for them, except david A and Carly knocked it outta the park....but with 7 finalists, they still couldnt match the power and enthusiasm of B2M and MC....glad we appreciate and love talent!

[Malakai39]

they did the song NO justice

[EddyFleischmann]

him much closer to mariah

[spencerruefus]

kirsty, carly david cook excellent

david a booo

[mulattobabi10789]

jason,kristy sucked.

brooke, syesha,david cook ok

Archie and carly OWNED

[rubennovais]

brook sucked too!!

[alanlee119]

yeah, brook should have sung an octave higher.

[Hosspowaah]

he sings so beatiful :D

[dyaa1810]

i love this perfomance so muchh , :D

[fedexthebest]

jason castro sings really well in this...!

[aburleigh93]

Syesha really messed up that run at 2:16. It just didn't fit very cohesively.

[Jamaicanchocolate34]

It was different...i like it.

[fedexthebest]

totally agree.....it sounds weird.....

[lovetakescourage1127]

Wow, They were amazing.

I had no idea Jason Castro could sing so beautiful...

[HarryPotterTrio91]

i luv this song so much!!

[shikainaburningice]

David Archuleta and Syesha are the best!!!

[Sternenprinzesschen]

Awesome :)

[Hedleytrue]

Carly definitely brought it more than the rest of the crew. Awesome job as a group though!

[iqkid1212]

david cook, syesha and carly rocked this song!

[lovemusicand24]

aww. I missed this one. glad I got to see it here.

One of my fav songs!! hmm they sang pretty good...

[anakellyaclarkson]

carly's the best :]]]]]]]

[shaka055]

Carly was amazing..this girl can blow!

her vocals are just wow..incredible!

she should have won!

[17dra]

cooll syesha carly n david cook also brooke... coollllll

[kali902000]

i think syesha and david cook sound amazing together. they should have gotten bigger parts

[beatingxheartbaby]

the best in the competition.

[jstardude]

This was my favorite performance! I can not believe the season is officially over today I;m crying right now=(

Im going to miss all of them so much!!

[tomfy315468]

love this song! david a is awesome

[hottyMcl]

They should have let Carly sing this on her own the rest of them cant match her vocals she is unbelievable

[5jacques5]

Carly sings amazingly...she was the one with the strongest vocals from this season in my opinion.. the only one of the girls who could have made justice to that "as I praayyyy" high note I think...Wish she would have gone to the final...she rocks

[TheWendyWendy]

wow Carly's part was outstanding, really liked it!

[shellman02]

damn they dun fuked it up

[StevieHobbit]

Wow, Kristy Lee Cook sounds so much better without that thick country accent.

[TheJabHattEnt]

That's when I figured out I can sing better than David A. He's the best out of them though still.

[mulattobabi10789]

i love the collaboration of Carly and David A's voices at the end. her high pitch with his deep smokey voice is amazing. they were the best in this song

[raray143]

carly gets to sing the best line of the song...and she does it so well.

[FriendsFan91]

Carly and Archie killed this song (in a good way)

[Mil3yfr3ak212]

lol

[revolienn]

(ll)

[nicholos96]

the most related contestant between this 7 is carly,im my opinion.

[Ccindyy24]

I love Jason. He's so different and true to himself.

[xLuVaRcHiEx]

i love archie! he is sooo amazing

[nivraznerol]

jason sux!

[HotPinkKitties]

Kristy messed Syesha part up! lol

[jetkou]

jason is horriable

[juniorguillen]

Excelente canción! una buena interpretación de las voces

[littlekid97]

if only ramiel malubay stayed shed do awsome

any mariah song would be perfect for ramiel

[devinharper2222]

i can't here David Cook, Syesha lower the voice a little! Poor David, I couldn't here him! GO ARCHIE AND COOKIE!!

[anmc00]

i actually think this seasons group performances are good/great/wonderful...they are all different and all blend in nicely....i think there was one season the group performances was not very good... im not sure which season, i think its season five and season four....im not bashing that seasons....that 2 season has few of the best singer in this whole competition(elliott, carrie).....

[BasicallyMagnificent]

Carly and David A. were great at the end...GO ARCHIE!

[devinharper2222]

I'm not a Kristy fan, but she really didn't need to go! She is really good, she was getting better! If she was still around i might have voted for her a few times. But my all time favorite is Archie and will be forever!

[tshughes123]

Jason - Awful

Brooke - Weak

Carly - Yells

Syesha - Trying Too Hard

Kristy - Not Bad

David A. - Good

David C. - Great!

[TheJabHattEnt]

Omg, tshughes123 is just speaking the truth. Except Archuleta ruined the most climactic part of the song, and sang it flat.

[damsel2007]

Carly was actually the best in this. Jason was bad.

[Collapsed07]

yea hes awful..he really needs to leave.

[Collapsed07]

yea hes awful..he really needs to leave.

[ianhagg23]

this seasons group performances are just awful

[kennisings]

Actually, I thought the idols did an impressive job on this.

[1hardcore]

i think season group performance (Daughtry, hicks, yamin, and mcphee) were the bestest :P

[mrmngrl19]

Thanks for posting!

[tunenas]

What is w/Carly's outfit, she looks like she just stepped out of the office cubicle. It's not a corporate office interview.

[PinkFrostyDonut]

Jason-not too good

Kristy-great job, probably the best

Brooke-bad! poor!

David A. - Out of range.

Carly-Actually great

Syesha-she is shouting

David C-subdued by Syesha's loud mouth. Syesha is having as to have the biggest mouth and the loudest shout between her and David C.

Whoever sang hooo-hooo at 2:17 was bad.

[tunenas]

This song absolutely did not fit Jason Castro, he messed it up.

[kaosgurl]

best group performance this season!!!

[FalconsDouble07]

They should have given David Cook and David Archuleta more singing time in this one!