Maid Of Ace & Keith Foster - Eleanor Rigby

[battlebauble]

Both versions are great! You can't argue with the appeal of young rock-n-rool chicks with guitars or the simple pleasure of a single vocalist with guitar who performs a great song passionately!

[andymooseman]

@battlebauble I agree entirely :)

[kenrg]

I wasn't thrilled with the vocal on the first version, but each arrangement brought out something interesting and different in the song.

[andymooseman]

@kenrg I can see what you mean about the first version. I'll admit that when i heard it "live", i wasn't that sure either. But, i enjoyed it when i listened back during the editing.

[phekwig]

I think the test of a truly great song is if it works in different styles... This is one of those great sings

[andymooseman]

@phekwig I can't disagree with that Andy.

[penguinspetpumpkin]

Very cool representation of the diverse styles displayed at Beatles Day. Almost seems like this could be an advert for the event. Well done Andy!

[andymooseman]

@penguinspetpumpkin Thanks Lily. As it happens these two versions followed each other on my tape & just had to be included together.. Plus, i didn't capture the full version of either performance!

[MrRandomWritings]

well contrasted Sir

[andymooseman]

@MrRandomWritings Thank you sir. I thought they fitted well together.

[PaintedRavensong]

Sounds like you had a GREAT time!!! Love the Beatles music...the lyrics speak of so many truths today just like they did when it first came out!

[andymooseman]

@PaintedRavensong I sure did Mic. Their music has a timeless quality about it & as you say, is still very relevant today :)