Jodelle Ferland v.s. Dakota Fanning for the part of Jane Volturi of New Moon

[titanx9]

Dakota has this innocent and "good girl" look about her that you wouldn't expect her to be evil. It makes her even scarier than Jodelle who always plays the creepy kid; it makes it more subtle. But i'm still curious what it would have been like had they reversed roles, hmmm....

[lala32290]

I like jodelle better she has that unique rare beauty she would like she's from the voulturie..dakota is good but joelle woulda been better..just my opinion

[lysspetplay19]

Jodelle would be perfect!! she would have a perfect role for her, but i love Dakota to DEATH!! so i cant pick!

[xLifeIsBeautifulx3]

Jodelle should have been Jane. Dakota is good, but she just never came across as creepy in the movie. Jodelle is pro at the creepy part.

[lexilu935211]

who cares if jodelle didnt get the part??!! she played Bree!! and now she is going to get her own movie 4 The Short Second Life of Bree Tanner.and Dakota was great.

[wiccantutor]

jodelle defo. wheni watch new moon and eclipseat the movies, in pretended that is was jodelle so yeah

[SissalDH]

Definantly Dakota! I mean, yes Jodelle does look more scary.. But Dakota is an great actress... She nailed the role as Jane!

[SissalDH]

Definantly Dakota! I mean, yes Jodelle does look scaries.. But Dakota is an great actress... She nailed the role as Jane!

[twilightluvers123100]

Jodelle She can do the part better

[Jojogirl641]

Jodelle Ferland All the way, she was amazing as Bree though! TEAM BREE!!!

[GirlVersionOfCauis]

i kno its already over and jodelle just ended up being bree in ecilpse. but i think jodelle makes a better jane. jodelles past roles are more like jane, then dakotas past roles. dakota is a good acteress. but jodelle would have been a better jane

[rachsmithers]

Dakota Fanning rules as Jane!!!!!!!!! And I doubt that Jodelle could even compare to Dakota's skills as far as acting. The only thing they messed up on with her character is her hair color. It's suppost to be brown not blond with brown highlights.

[TheBestYouWillFind]

@rachsmithers What the fuck did you just say? Jodelle couldn't compare to Dakota!?!?! FUCK YOU! Jodelle is one million times better than Dakota! You should judge on ACTING, not who you like best, fuck face.

[SandyHermione1]

I love them, Dakota & Jodelle are realy good actresses. Dakota as Jane and Jodelle as Bree, make eclipse a good movie

[nicole101nicole]

JODELLE ALL THE WAY !

[laicilou77]

i think Jodelle would hav been better but Dakota did pretty well in my opinion. at least Jodelle is gonna play Bree in Eclipse

[GreenDevil1899]

im a big jodelle fan, but i hate twilight...thats a little difficult, but she is better than Dakota...

she can play an evil character^^

I love her ;)

[lilswtangel92]

some who jodelle reminds me of kristin kruek from smallville

[JenJen4690]

I think Jodelle would have been better suited for the part, she not only has more of the look as described in the book for Jane, but she has alot more experience with playing an evil, creepy character than Dakota. I don't think Dakota pulled it off well at all.

[Rosaliiiaaa]

HANNAH DAKOTA FANNING!!!!!!

[latuacantelvr]

ive always though of jane as jodelle

my jaw dropped whe i saw a picture of her i was like

omg jane 0_0

[kristenm911]

well Jodelle is going to play Bree for Eclipse. and i totally feel the same way.

[Syntax3rr]

YEA i want jodelle :((

[KandyCorn3000]

I think Jodelle can fit the Jane part greatly. Although, I'm really excited that she is going to be Bree in Eclipse!

[zickylicious]

I perfer Dakota for Jane because jodelle can fit the innocent girl that she now plays: Bree. While Dakota, can fit the torchurful additude of Jane

[DraculaDevours]

Always Jodelle! I have not liked Dakota's acting in any of the movies that she has been in...most recently I thought that she was very bad in Push. I loved Jodelle in everything that I have seen her in so far.

[seemegzllusion]

I dont know how This "JodeLLe FERLAND"..

But Somehow, Her pretty Face reminds me to "SUMMER GLAU" in a bit Sweeter Version :)

My Vote Goes to.... JODELLE FERLAND :)

DAKOTA is a great actress but I think we better give chance to JoDeLLE.

I have watched about 15 of Dakota's Movies

& 2 movies of Jodelle

But Jodelle is Much Harder to Forget.. dont know why.. She's so a Great Unique Talented Person!!

So.. in my opinion JODELLE AS JANE is Smarter Choice!!

[TheatreFanatic4eva]

Jodelle she's amazing!! Dakota is good, but I don't think she does very well in scary movies :P

[eyjeyheaven]

JODELLE!! XD \M/

[SkandyyKandyy]

I think Jodelle looks the part but dakota has the acting tEAM dAKOta

[SnowflakeTube]

Jodelle all the way :D

[MenaaaLOLZZZ]

When I first read new moon, i always pictured Jane as Jodelle! i think she would be perfect! Dakota Fanning is a great actor, but i think jodelle is more talented and she seems more like jane...in a good way :)

[BoRiCuAFoREvaA]

jodelle

[heavygirl1996]

Dakota Fanning  is the best!!!

[SundaysCybele]

Dakota is definitely talented enough to play any kind of part so I'm sure she will do just fine. Jodelle, on the other hand, has lots of experience with these kinds of parts. So, even though she may not be as talented as Dakota, she could also be very good as Jane. I'd be happy with either one.

[iACTnoodlehead]

I COMPLETELY agree.

[MegghiMorgan95]

Jodelle 4ever!!!!!!!!!!

[synysterjazmyngates]

Dakota Fanning is badass, I pick Dakota

[piffygirl1217]

i know that jennett is 2 old but so is jodelle and dakota fanning

[piffygirl1217]

i just thought of somthing wat if jennette mccurdy was 2 play jane that would be weird yet she dose look kinda young.but i think jodelle would be perfact .

[phinchooo]

JODELLE is the best

[sg68403]

i just think Dakota is tooooo happy .

Whereas Jodelle is like super PERFECT , she's pretty , pure sweet , she has THE JANE FACE & she gives me the jane feeling .

[creamypie1]

JoDeLLe!!!!!

[nickluvk]

OMG JODELLE! Dakota is awful and isnt Jane like a woman not a child i read the books also :

PLEASE COPY AND PASTE TO LOTS OF VIDEOS

<3 <3 TWILIGHT <3 <3 OR

<3 <3 Edward and Bella <3 <3 OR

<3 <3 Paramore <3 <3

[Phoenix5107]

from the image im getting of how people are describing her and the skin tone she had in one of her photos i think I might choose Jodelle, but Dakota can pull off a lot of things in acting and i would love to see her in some thing dfferent with a change of character....

[belanovaddiction]

JODELLE!!!!

LOVE HER

SHE IS PERFECT

[sxyswan]

Dakota!!

I love her!

She seem soo sweet but at the same time soo evil!!!

like in hide and seek!!!

[izzie2535]

SOOO Jodelle, i havn't heard any finalities that Dakota is Jane, but it seems that way... :(

[BruisingMrB]

jodelle ferland for sure

[DimSimToughBitch]

Jodelle! FOR SURE!!!! but they already cast Dakota I was so pissed off they messed it all up by putting in an actress who has been in too many movies over an actress who is used to being a villan and deserves more attention. Dont get me wrong i love Dakota IN ANYTHING BUT NEW MOON I WANT JODELLE AS JANE!!!!!!!!!!!

btw Jodelle's not crazy shes a fantastic actress

[blackcanary123]

there was a petition to be signed to get her the part but i guess its too late if they put Dakota in the movie it ruined 4 ever.

[Plugz91]

definately jodelle, its not fair that she didnt even have a chance, they just GAVE the spot to Dakota! that sucks!! not that i dont like Dakota...but Jodelle would have been a billion times better and she should haev had the chance to audition

[blackcanary123]

I agree totally but did they really give Dakota the part???

[Plugz91]

So I heard. The director was so confident in Dakotas ability that he just offered her to role. I read it on a pole on some entertainment site. I really wish they would have let people compete for the spot, there might have been even better unknown actresses then Jodelle too, instead of adding Dakota whos career is far superior to all of the other actors in the movie combined! To put her big name in as a minor role is a bit of an insult to the other main characters in my opinion.

[blackcanary123]

perfectly put thnx!

[EpicallyCrazzed]

I agree. I don't think they did a very good job when it came to choosing there cast. I'd always pictured Jodelle as Jane. But I think a new face would have been nice. Kristin Stewarts performance in the movie was terrible. The over-all acting in the movies disappointed me greatly.

[XOXheartErin]

@blackcanary123 yeh ages ago but jodelle still got in as bree in eclipse i watched the movie

[ObscureFanatics]

@blackcanary123 Yes they gaved her the part.

[TieneShattuck]

I think right now, Jodelle seems the better choice because of her film history amd on-the-nose looks. BUT, I'm excited for Dakota to grow as an actress and show us another facet of her talents... =D

[EdwardWontYouBiteMe]

I think Jodelle is better, but I heard its already official Dakota is going to play Jane. :(

[iAlecJaneVolturi]

i think Dakota would be a perfect Jane!

[ApplekatzVic]

Jodelle all the way lol! she looks more like wat i thought Jane should look like lol. apparently most ppl think Jodelle is better too cuz they use jodelle in their volturi cast videos...