I think Jay won't bounce back to 20 years ago and he might die away in the old classroom because it is clear in the rule-" the player should play the piano slowly at first. Once the game is over, the player ought to play the piano fast to trace back to his times." However, Jay didn't travel the future, so he couldn't succeed in the end. Actually, this movie is really amazing and thought-provoking!!
@pyromaneak47 Look at the picture you'll see their hair change. And before he played he remembered what Xiao Yu said "That was how fast I played before I got home" -it means Jay went back to 20 past years. He did play the last note. It's just that's the effect in the movie, which makes the dramatic of it. No one else in the classroom maybe because it was not class time, they arranged it like that because "the first sight mark one's destiny". So he can see Xiao Yu first, she could see him too.
@LiverpooLisforLife That's fair enough because his father was the one who told others about Xiao yu's secret and she ended up dying alone.Now he has to pay by losing his son. But well, he didn't die though, it's a happy ending.
And finally, this one i really don't get, how come Jay didn't get bounced back to exactly 20 years ago when he played? If the rule works the same, then he should've gotten bounced back to 20 years ago, which was already after graduation, and he should've never ran into Rain. Or is it because he played it faster than Rain so he was able to get bounced to an earlier time in the past?
@disaznboii19148 I think because if he leaping through time at the point he just went to school but in the past, they will not meet each other yet, and she can't leap through time to see him, because he's not in the present anymore :-?
@disaznboii19148 that simply means the dude can see what the chick wrote but the chick couldnt see what the dude will write ( the chick is in the past when the dude is in the future)
I love this movie, but really there are lots of places that don't really make sense..
#1, the 3rd time Rain came to the future, Jay was eating lunch box in school yard. How would Rain ever know to look for Jay in the school yard, not in classroom, and to spot him at first sight?
#2, why did Rain's mom tell Jay that Rain had asthma and was resting at home, when she was already dead at this point?
#3, how did Rain know to come to piano room at 7:00 to look for Jay? She didn't get the message!
@lovyviv #1 It's possible that she already saw him and then went off somewhere, then came back to him later.
#2 Xiaoyu's mom was couldn't accept her death.
#3 I didn't get this. Xiaoyu read the note, but in the flashback, it was Qingyi that read it?! For some reason, we have to accept that both of them read it.
@nigavagina no.... he safely went back to the past and it properly changed her life which is proved by her graduated picture with all her class mate ^^ i think so....best movie ever ...my second times watched this
@Shorjai she supposed to die in the past because of her asthma attack. But then Jay went back to the past, and saw her, but she doesn't seem to know him. And then at the graduation picture of 1979. You can see they standing next to each other. So that means Jay went back to the past and changed her life, so she never die. Hope it help! :D
The 我 character at 31:34 is different from the one at 7:14 lol
disaznboii19148 2 months ago
hixxxx.hay qá
AloneInTheLove 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
đoạn nhạc ở @2:10 là bản j vậy mọi người ơi!!
who knows the name of songs 2:10 plssssss!!
vuhoanglan 2 months ago
By the way, does everyone else notice the unchangeable things in the background?
runtohightops 2 months ago
I think Jay won't bounce back to 20 years ago and he might die away in the old classroom because it is clear in the rule-" the player should play the piano slowly at first. Once the game is over, the player ought to play the piano fast to trace back to his times." However, Jay didn't travel the future, so he couldn't succeed in the end. Actually, this movie is really amazing and thought-provoking!!
runtohightops 2 months ago
she is beautiful, i love rain...
soledad12691 2 months ago
Hay......Lãng Mạn Quá
MrNhoc2020 3 months ago in playlist Secret (Vietsub) - Jay Chou (2007)
tình hình là cho thêm cái phụ đề vietnamese vào đj bạn duynq110 ơiiiiiii
dtsvtpt8990 3 months ago
hay qua!!!! rat y nghia!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ninjadaica 4 months ago
The movie so great. It love it's song...
LoyalDo04 4 months ago
@pyromaneak47 Look at the picture you'll see their hair change. And before he played he remembered what Xiao Yu said "That was how fast I played before I got home" -it means Jay went back to 20 past years. He did play the last note. It's just that's the effect in the movie, which makes the dramatic of it. No one else in the classroom maybe because it was not class time, they arranged it like that because "the first sight mark one's destiny". So he can see Xiao Yu first, she could see him too.
lhhm19 4 months ago
imagine he went back in time..he can only be seen by xiao yu... he left his father alone.omg sadness overload!
LiverpooLisforLife 5 months ago
@LiverpooLisforLife That's fair enough because his father was the one who told others about Xiao yu's secret and she ended up dying alone.Now he has to pay by losing his son. But well, he didn't die though, it's a happy ending.
lhhm19 4 months ago
mind fuck , good movie tho
thanks you.
Grandmuffinx 6 months ago
I dont get it, how did the retarded old man see her?
jeffreyFUU 6 months ago
And finally, this one i really don't get, how come Jay didn't get bounced back to exactly 20 years ago when he played? If the rule works the same, then he should've gotten bounced back to 20 years ago, which was already after graduation, and he should've never ran into Rain. Or is it because he played it faster than Rain so he was able to get bounced to an earlier time in the past?
lovyviv 7 months ago
@lovyviv This is one of the plot holes that the movie creates.
He's supposed to return to the same time of year that he was in, in the future.
(Xiaoyu went to the future during graduation and went to Xianglun's graduation)
However, for some reason, Xianglun was able to go back BEFORE they even met.
Doesn't make sense, but it doesn't have to :p
disaznboii19148 2 months ago
@disaznboii19148 I think because if he leaping through time at the point he just went to school but in the past, they will not meet each other yet, and she can't leap through time to see him, because he's not in the present anymore :-?
Ivylici0us 1 month ago
@Ivylici0us That doesn't make sense o.O
disaznboii19148 1 month ago
@disaznboii19148 that simply means the dude can see what the chick wrote but the chick couldnt see what the dude will write ( the chick is in the past when the dude is in the future)
trunganhvu 1 week ago
@trunganhvu That had absolutely nothing to do with what I said. o.O
disaznboii19148 1 week ago
I love this movie, but really there are lots of places that don't really make sense..
#1, the 3rd time Rain came to the future, Jay was eating lunch box in school yard. How would Rain ever know to look for Jay in the school yard, not in classroom, and to spot him at first sight?
#2, why did Rain's mom tell Jay that Rain had asthma and was resting at home, when she was already dead at this point?
#3, how did Rain know to come to piano room at 7:00 to look for Jay? She didn't get the message!
lovyviv 7 months ago
@lovyviv because the mom of rain still cannot accept that rain got lost..
TheDjflorax 6 months ago
@lovyviv #1 It's possible that she already saw him and then went off somewhere, then came back to him later.
#2 Xiaoyu's mom was couldn't accept her death.
#3 I didn't get this. Xiaoyu read the note, but in the flashback, it was Qingyi that read it?! For some reason, we have to accept that both of them read it.
disaznboii19148 2 months ago
great !!
2SueAng 7 months ago
cried myself a river.
luckasings 7 months ago
Comment removed
Sky300 8 months ago
what the hell?!
Sky300 8 months ago
great movie! i just lov jay.. very handsome and hot
thnx for sharin with great quality and eng subs!
eshalovessrk1 9 months ago 2
did he die?
nigavagina 11 months ago
@nigavagina no.... he safely went back to the past and it properly changed her life which is proved by her graduated picture with all her class mate ^^ i think so....best movie ever ...my second times watched this
zeroanh 10 months ago
@zeroanh So Rain died in the present?
Shorjai 9 months ago
@Shorjai she supposed to die in the past because of her asthma attack. But then Jay went back to the past, and saw her, but she doesn't seem to know him. And then at the graduation picture of 1979. You can see they standing next to each other. So that means Jay went back to the past and changed her life, so she never die. Hope it help! :D
khoifysh 7 months ago