@SPOOKMEONCE - this vid is the only recording of that performance. If we ever get together and sing it again, which we do once a year or so :) I'll try to bring the digital recorder. ~ Billie rr-bp.com
155 Likes just ignore those 12 chowderheads. The three of you sounds absolutely amazing. Your voices blend so beautifully. My wife's jaw nearly hit the floor when I played this for her. I also like that you put a bit of a country spin on it. Well done!!!!
Nice job! Especially providing the harmonies in some of the passages CSNY backed off from. Many of us sort of provided those harmonies in our mind (especially that upper 7th[?]) when we heard them sing it.
I wouldn't stand in judgment on CSNY for deciding to not to harmonize on every verse (a dramatic decision) but I appreciate hearing what might have been, had they decided to do so.
Good fun, great sound and fidelity to the spirit of the song!
@anon49ymous if Crosby sees the video he will be blown away. I'd like to see Billie team up with Stephen Stills and sing this. It would be like heaven fell on earth
Awesome job! Ignore the critics coz most of them dont know how to go up there play and sing (if they do I would be glad to see there videos). CSN will be proud!!!
What are you fucking tone deaf..or just an idiot? ....or both? I'm going with both. I dont even know these people but this performance is as good as CS&N ever did it. FANTASTIC JOB
I am so fortunate to have heard y'all do this live!! You three really do sound amazing together...there is a whole lot of talent behind those mics. :)
Great job fist full of.., I have played this tune with joe and JJ but couldnt have done it like you three did, awsome, 98,000 views? thats just cool that you have that many hits! congrats.
Nice, but try like CSN, chop up the strumming more, it has more effect. Don't just strum through everything. Too many voices going at the same time. Back off a bit on that. Sing some solo like Stills, Then join in.
Where are you guys from. I have a singing songwriting partner here in Oklahoma City and we harmonize like this. Would love to get you guys to perform with us or maybe our songs. Just trying to get published. Very nice job. You guys are obvious naturals.
You three are unbelievable: amazing harmony and blending. Much better than any live CSN that I've seen. Save this in the "soon to be rich and famous" file.
Thank you so much! No more videos by these people, and yes they all have names... the lead singer is Jeremiah Johnsen. He and Joe - the guy on the right - are "Fistful of Nickels" They also have a band called "Joe Worrel and the Last Free Exit Band" The gal on the left is Jeremiah's aunt Billie. She just sat in for harmony's sake.
Anon...where are they from? anywhere near chicago? would love to see them! They do great on their harmonies. Taped in someone's home or at a "gig". In Chicago, they could be doing "home concerts" if not more....Billie definitely adds to their harmonies...not sure if they would have as good a sound without that top harmony she sings. Thanks for sharing!
Thanks Jim... they all live (we all live) in Wichita, KS. The vid here was taped at a gig Jeremiah and Joe did in Salida, CO. They asked me to sing with them on this song, so I did. I appreciate your comment about what I add to the harmonies. It's what I love to do.
Good performance, always loved this song. However, at about 1:00 you guys seemed to drag it a bit. There is a "nanosecond" delay between you strumming and singing, which, if eliminated, will make this really good. Thanks anyway.
Billy - do not know what music you are really into but I think you guys could get a recording contract as a country music group if the 3 of you formed a band. Your harmony together is perfect. Both guys play good guitar. Have you guys ever tried to get a recording contract?
not too many can do justice to my boys. yours was a little bit country, but I can live with it. If I had been in the audience, you would have received a standing ovation. The female in your group did great justice to Graham Nash, who of course was the glue with amazing talent that held this wonderful group together, though Steven had the best voice and David was the charachter. I don't even know you 3 but I couldn't be more proud of you. Nice to know others appreciate CSN like I do.
Try doing the song "DANCE WITH ME" by the band "ORLEANS" LIVE....we are adding/trying it to our UNPLUGGED set/live show and so far...it is KICKING OUR HARMONY ASS!!!
It is simply one of if not the HARDest as hell song to nail the vocal and acoustic guitar parts live.
Try it and feel my pain:)
Oh yeah, almost forgot...MALE vocal with NO falsetto required on the high part solo line... "I can take you where you want to go.
It's AWESOME...and I posted several posts in this thread months back raving about it... gave it a "FIVE" rating...and added it to 'my favorites' videos as well.
The 'Harmony Challenge' was done out of total RESPECT.
Saw them perform this song almost exactly this way at a bar called the Red Lion in Vail, Colorado circa 1979. This took me right back there -- better harmony anywhere? Not likely.
I just dropped in...to see what condition my condition was in:)
This is a KICK ASS rendition...you're in my "favorites!!!
"I knew that if I had the chance...that I could make those people dance...and maybe they'd be happy....for awhile."
Don McClean
"American Pie"
Everybody sing!
"Bye bye Miss American pie...drove my Chevy to the levy but the levy was dry...them good ole boys were drinking whiskey and rye...saying this will be the day that I die."
Hi - I'm e-mailing from rainy old England and when I heard this, it certainly bought the sun out! Lovely, I looked close at your video and thought Stephen Stills had long hair in his heyday, then I looked closer and saw the lady. Great stuff! This track is absolutely fantastic. I'm sure everyone has favourited it - you give CS&N a run for their money - keep on going!
Best Southern Cross cover on YT. Great harmony!
crookhunter 1 week ago
Ya know...this is just plain "NICE"... love it, simple as that.
rozhawkfan 3 months ago
very nice. Love your version of it.
AntaresInScorpius 6 months ago
Tough song to cover. Nice job.
dbmjrisin 11 months ago
yes man ......you made it well..like it a lot
pics333 11 months ago
Any way to get an mp3 of this ?
SPOOKMEONCE 1 year ago
@SPOOKMEONCE - this vid is the only recording of that performance. If we ever get together and sing it again, which we do once a year or so :) I'll try to bring the digital recorder. ~ Billie rr-bp.com
anon49ymous 11 months ago
@anon49ymous
Love your take on this song (my favorite song). Ignore the 12 dislikes,,, I would love to sing this with ya! (similar styles)
rozhawkfan 3 months ago
155 Likes just ignore those 12 chowderheads. The three of you sounds absolutely amazing. Your voices blend so beautifully. My wife's jaw nearly hit the floor when I played this for her. I also like that you put a bit of a country spin on it. Well done!!!!
AmVetGuy 3 months ago
well done!!!!!!
MrMark4000 1 year ago
well done! love it.
MrMark4000 1 year ago
Good job
dawnjakeleah 1 year ago
i posted a long time ago liking this video and I still like it and listen to it....great job
badge531 1 year ago
wow, great job that version sounds very nice.
dropdoubt 1 year ago
Nice job! Especially providing the harmonies in some of the passages CSNY backed off from. Many of us sort of provided those harmonies in our mind (especially that upper 7th[?]) when we heard them sing it.
I wouldn't stand in judgment on CSNY for deciding to not to harmonize on every verse (a dramatic decision) but I appreciate hearing what might have been, had they decided to do so.
Good fun, great sound and fidelity to the spirit of the song!
Thanks for posting! :)
freedumb2003 1 year ago
@freedumb2003 Thank you so much! Your critique, and its detail is so welcome and encouraging!
anon49ymous 1 year ago
Great Job
roykng 1 year ago
Great cover, better then CSN
crookhunter 1 year ago
I can't believe we have not heard of this chic. Damn shes can sing.
crookhunter 1 year ago
Outstanding! Bravo! the harmony is perfect!
deportwetbacks 1 year ago
Absolutely excellent on all parts (great vocals..!). Nice admendments on the lead guitar.
SaddleCat1 1 year ago
thanks to everyone for the support and encouragement. some day, maybe DC will see this vid and smile... :)
anon49ymous 1 year ago
@anon49ymous if Crosby sees the video he will be blown away. I'd like to see Billie team up with Stephen Stills and sing this. It would be like heaven fell on earth
crookhunter 1 year ago
great harmonies, excellent job on a very difficult tune.
donho1950 1 year ago
Probably as good a cover as the CSN´S tune itself, which is a lot to say!!!!
I know the last commenters said more or less the same, but I am so impressed I couldn´t keep it to myself. CONGRATULATIONS FROM SPAIN!!
apataye 1 year ago
well done folks. i really enjoyed that. what courage to take on CSN harmonies. kudos.
cruptbside 1 year ago
wow,better than c,s,n live versions! your vocals much clearer & harmonized. very nice!
southmoond 1 year ago
Awesome job! Ignore the critics coz most of them dont know how to go up there play and sing (if they do I would be glad to see there videos). CSN will be proud!!!
akkoztikka 2 years ago
thanks so much!
anon49ymous 2 years ago
Love this version, great job guys
buffy5er9er 2 years ago
Great job! Love the harmony! Keep it up, you guys are great.
Lykin13 2 years ago
always loved this song...great harmonies guys
1968baldguy 2 years ago
Very nice. I really like your arrangement. :-)
senn416 2 years ago
Excellent work, guys.
jimincairns 2 years ago
You three ought to get together and do more - this is as good as it gets for two guitars and three voices, Please. more!
cdonline1 2 years ago
Great job guys! (And Billie!) What is the strumming pattern you are using? I love this song and am having trouble getting the strum right.
AndyTulenko 2 years ago
awesome vocal harmonies and a great iconic song....
manemustaine 2 years ago
nice job. just need drums n bass and it would be even better.
kunk28 2 years ago
Sorry guys, this is poor.
whothejames 2 years ago
What are you fucking tone deaf..or just an idiot? ....or both? I'm going with both. I dont even know these people but this performance is as good as CS&N ever did it. FANTASTIC JOB
fatchuk812 2 years ago
thank you so much for standing up for us. certainly is encouraging to read!
anon49ymous 2 years ago
I just call it like I see it. Keep playing with confidence because you guys are great. Take care.
fatchuk812 2 years ago
@fatchuk812 I can't believe you said that! What the heck could they possibly have done better?
rayza121462 1 year ago
@rayza121462
I said they were fantastic? What are you talking about?
fatchuk812 1 year ago
@whothejames Gee..another piss-poor wannabee who decides to be a music critic? Go listern to Britney Spears, you dullard.
jimincairns 2 years ago
Great job on the harmonies...As well as the whole song as well.
doowop1942 2 years ago
I am so fortunate to have heard y'all do this live!! You three really do sound amazing together...there is a whole lot of talent behind those mics. :)
mystikalchik13 2 years ago
I really enjoyed this- you guys sounded awsome!
DawnVanName 2 years ago
Nicely done.
kidcreole77 2 years ago
very good voices and good harmony...great job!!!!
BurnerSoutheast81 2 years ago 2
very good harmony, havin a female it there makes it special. i love it :)
jermy1341 2 years ago 3
Great harmony!
herbiesnerd 2 years ago 3
Really nice version great song
kinsella2008 2 years ago 4
Choice - nice work guys!
mozdickson 2 years ago 4
Hey Bille, its your favorite person ever! lol
Just wanted to say your awesome, and I really good singer, lol, you know that, hahahhaaaa!
- Love Libby
P.S Miss you already!
MagicDust123 2 years ago 5
one of my favorite videos on youtube, very well done
badge531 2 years ago 5
THEY SUCK!!!
BDaviWA 2 years ago
i wanna go to bongo billys!
ludaluc 2 years ago 4
Great jam session!
menonpd 2 years ago 4
good thing the girl came aboard to assist, it wouldn't have been the same
sjkmad08 2 years ago 6
The chick made that one.
hrdrockfarm 2 years ago 9
This STILL rocks!!!!!!!
hartagrm 2 years ago 8
I prefer the version that Prove It, those two kids, did.
ObamaObamaObamaObama 2 years ago 2
Great job! Especially like the high harmony part!
grovefolk 2 years ago 3
Excellent!
PeteyIrish 2 years ago 3
Superb ! Really well done!
tair45 2 years ago 3
NICE
ehswan 2 years ago 3
Well played!
spite6669 2 years ago 3
Props guys and gals. You sing it with the passion it deserves.
kdevine321 2 years ago 2
Great job fist full of.., I have played this tune with joe and JJ but couldnt have done it like you three did, awsome, 98,000 views? thats just cool that you have that many hits! congrats.
nonayou 2 years ago
good job
mick60a 2 years ago
good job !
mick60a 2 years ago
Excellent version!
PUNGOROGER 3 years ago
I thought it was a great cover. Love that song.
sirfleabert 3 years ago
A wonderful rendition of one of my favorite songs. Good job!
rstryker27 3 years ago
Nice, but try like CSN, chop up the strumming more, it has more effect. Don't just strum through everything. Too many voices going at the same time. Back off a bit on that. Sing some solo like Stills, Then join in.
taylor8492 3 years ago
nice harmony though
butty999 3 years ago
wrong key stooge
butty999 3 years ago
???
nursehg72 3 years ago
wrong key?? do you mean the vocals?
Singers should sing in the key they're most comfortable.
nursehg72 3 years ago
there is no such thing as the wrong key.
PUNGOROGER 3 years ago
Amen!
anon49ymous 2 years ago
Parabéns!!!! Execelente!!!!!!!!!
paocomcoca 3 years ago
REALLY NICE!
baggins49 3 years ago
Awesome!
fangjangler 3 years ago
Love this song, whoever does it!!
boreasrift 3 years ago
Absolutely Fantastic!
HymeraBob 3 years ago
Nice, would love to hear them try "Carry On"...
lalbruiz 3 years ago
Magical!! Really soars when Billie does the high harmony. More please.
gaweca 3 years ago 2
great job! five stars! keep it up!
Josip633 3 years ago 2
1st class.i thought i was listening to csn.good job
jakinthegreen 3 years ago
Hey you guys! This was absolutely beautiful...I thought, wow, who can do this song justice...but you guys did a fantastic job...!!! :)
TwistedGrover 3 years ago
Wow. Goosebumps on the neck. Well done!
JohnFromGR 3 years ago
Great job you guys and especially you Billie,you blend in so well.
wakaw1 3 years ago
nice job ....from vancouver bc
the3blindamigas 3 years ago
Wow, great job! Love it. Play on....
dynastychick3 3 years ago
wow, glad i stumbled across this...very nice work! i really enjoyed it.
FOOLBUTTON 3 years ago
nice. really nice.
trixie898989 3 years ago
Nice harmonies. Blended well. I'd like to hear more. Maybe Suite Judy Blue Eyes.
dcman919 3 years ago
great job guys
thetom54 3 years ago
thats actually really good
trebombproductions 3 years ago
got a card?
Mostlyfun 3 years ago
Where are you guys from. I have a singing songwriting partner here in Oklahoma City and we harmonize like this. Would love to get you guys to perform with us or maybe our songs. Just trying to get published. Very nice job. You guys are obvious naturals.
Im inspired by this.
Matt1asH 3 years ago
We're all from Wichita, KS, so we're pretty close. I'll write ya, and we'll figure something out. Billie (the one on the left)
anon49ymous 3 years ago
you made this song great Billie.the dude in the middle needs some singing lessons.help him out ok !
CHEERS1990 3 years ago
that dude in the middle is my nephew, and i think he's the best there is. he don't need no singing lessons.
anon49ymous 3 years ago
AGREED!
dynastychick3 3 years ago
I think they all did am awesome job. Really enjoyed it.
Heliox18 3 years ago
love the harmonization....props!
biggysmalls1100 3 years ago 2
Sounds Great!
alakazam365 3 years ago 2
Absolutely great. I would like to hear and see you here in Germany!! Do you sing some more songs from CSN or Neil Young at your gigs?
Lovely regards from Germany to KS from Gunther
ginneinge 3 years ago
This is beautiful. I went over and picked up my guitar after watching this. Your harmonizing is divine. Props guys, props.
JackDeTar 3 years ago 2
You three are unbelievable: amazing harmony and blending. Much better than any live CSN that I've seen. Save this in the "soon to be rich and famous" file.
asoka2buddhist 3 years ago 2
Man this is spot on! Love it.
robotsandsheep 3 years ago 2
just awesome ! she has a beautiful voice
CHEERS1990 3 years ago
I listen to this more than the original!
tomlikesacdc 3 years ago
just one word: Beautiful!!
matthijsrobers 3 years ago
or roy g biv perhaps?
groundloop07 3 years ago
Love the harmonies! Nice job on this song. Any other videos by these people and do they have a "name"?
jaimzee5482 3 years ago
Thank you so much! No more videos by these people, and yes they all have names... the lead singer is Jeremiah Johnsen. He and Joe - the guy on the right - are "Fistful of Nickels" They also have a band called "Joe Worrel and the Last Free Exit Band" The gal on the left is Jeremiah's aunt Billie. She just sat in for harmony's sake.
anon49ymous 3 years ago
Anon...where are they from? anywhere near chicago? would love to see them! They do great on their harmonies. Taped in someone's home or at a "gig". In Chicago, they could be doing "home concerts" if not more....Billie definitely adds to their harmonies...not sure if they would have as good a sound without that top harmony she sings. Thanks for sharing!
jim
jaimzee5482 3 years ago
Thanks Jim... they all live (we all live) in Wichita, KS. The vid here was taped at a gig Jeremiah and Joe did in Salida, CO. They asked me to sing with them on this song, so I did. I appreciate your comment about what I add to the harmonies. It's what I love to do.
Billie
anon49ymous 3 years ago
hey billie - you made this song - beautiful voice
CHEERS1990 3 years ago
I didnt steal that comment it came from in my head somwhere. most likley a place i was supposed to be keeping birth dates or somthing. peace.
groundloop07 3 years ago
your voices meld together like the colors of a rainbow forming a single beautiful wonder.
groundloop07 3 years ago
outstanding great job
Oldsixtyeight 3 years ago
Good performance, always loved this song. However, at about 1:00 you guys seemed to drag it a bit. There is a "nanosecond" delay between you strumming and singing, which, if eliminated, will make this really good. Thanks anyway.
kuskut 3 years ago
yes, that nanosecond was on purpose. it's ok if you don't like it, but it's probably not going to change
anon49ymous 3 years ago
It means a lot that so many have watched this, and have had a positive response. Music is my life... it's nice to experience this. Thank you!
anon49ymous 3 years ago
Billy - do not know what music you are really into but I think you guys could get a recording contract as a country music group if the 3 of you formed a band. Your harmony together is perfect. Both guys play good guitar. Have you guys ever tried to get a recording contract?
weathermanfsu 3 years ago
You guys are really GOOD!!!
laura060366 3 years ago
Really a great song and well done! Thanks.
fayrelight 3 years ago
WOW great job!!!
stangme65 3 years ago
great job boys and girls, loved it!
hillhopper23 3 years ago
not too many can do justice to my boys. yours was a little bit country, but I can live with it. If I had been in the audience, you would have received a standing ovation. The female in your group did great justice to Graham Nash, who of course was the glue with amazing talent that held this wonderful group together, though Steven had the best voice and David was the charachter. I don't even know you 3 but I couldn't be more proud of you. Nice to know others appreciate CSN like I do.
skoolrlysux 3 years ago 2
Just clicking back by to see if it's as good as I remember. .... yep, still a joy to hear!
TheSanityInspector 3 years ago
Pretty good cover!!Nothing to be ashamed of!
ericnwren 3 years ago 2
best sc cover I ever heard. Bravo
redroaster7 3 years ago 2
I'll bet fifty of the views on this video are mine ... Lol!!
Oh well ... it's a good one !
jimiray1 4 years ago 2
at least that many views are mine!! I love reliving the moment...
anon49ymous 4 years ago
Great to hear a female voice !!
AdrianCamus 4 years ago
One of my favorite songs of all times and I think you guys did an awesome job of covering it!!
weathermanfsu 4 years ago
hey u guys good nice vocals together Aloha
deliveryman59 4 years ago
who are these guys... where playing next
SeaScene 4 years ago
Strange to see one of the 'Supergroups' of the seventies playing such a small venue
trickhoseroff 4 years ago
even looks a little like Nash ...
great job
nlandess 4 years ago
Great job! Like it as much as the original.
ohmycarp 4 years ago
Whew, I have never heard this version, it is so powerful when it's not electric.
Thank you to CSN&Y for all the music.
judiyeats 4 years ago 2
fantastic , great vocals , you really nail this song
bruceberry138266 4 years ago 4
Take the CoZmic Cowboy harmony Challenge...
Try doing the song "DANCE WITH ME" by the band "ORLEANS" LIVE....we are adding/trying it to our UNPLUGGED set/live show and so far...it is KICKING OUR HARMONY ASS!!!
It is simply one of if not the HARDest as hell song to nail the vocal and acoustic guitar parts live.
Try it and feel my pain:)
Oh yeah, almost forgot...MALE vocal with NO falsetto required on the high part solo line... "I can take you where you want to go.
:)
Enjoy.
CoZmicCowboYs 4 years ago
Just curious, did you like this performance?
ohmycarp 4 years ago
Yes ohmycarp I loved this performance!!!
It's AWESOME...and I posted several posts in this thread months back raving about it... gave it a "FIVE" rating...and added it to 'my favorites' videos as well.
The 'Harmony Challenge' was done out of total RESPECT.
CoZmicCowboYs 4 years ago
Thanks, would like to hear your band some time. Love great harmonies!
ohmycarp 4 years ago
Saw them perform this song almost exactly this way at a bar called the Red Lion in Vail, Colorado circa 1979. This took me right back there -- better harmony anywhere? Not likely.
itzqiker 4 years ago
Great sound...I stumbled on this looking for CNS...great playing and harmony
jpcolts 4 years ago
I just dropped in...to see what condition my condition was in:)
This is a KICK ASS rendition...you're in my "favorites!!!
"I knew that if I had the chance...that I could make those people dance...and maybe they'd be happy....for awhile."
Don McClean
"American Pie"
Everybody sing!
"Bye bye Miss American pie...drove my Chevy to the levy but the levy was dry...them good ole boys were drinking whiskey and rye...saying this will be the day that I die."
CoZmicCowboYs 4 years ago
nice!!!!
rbassmanw 4 years ago
Great rendition, keep it up.
Coyote8869 4 years ago
Fine job! I loved the harmonies!
olimpio50 4 years ago
Sounds excellent!
love4talent 4 years ago
wow I love the harmonies
XG5A 4 years ago
baddass..tight harmonies
bigmike616 4 years ago
Yep! Great job!
Greets from Germany
OldPicker
OldPicker 4 years ago
Great Job!
robkuttner 4 years ago
awesome. what is the key? g?
pipernick 4 years ago
My favorite CSN song (and blackbird)
truferblue22 4 years ago
nice
chevymudslinger 4 years ago
I supose that doesnt make it wrong...I just noticed i couldnt play along with it like i can with the studio version :)
manictrance 4 years ago
The COWBOYZ say ....this is frikkin AWESOME!
KUDOS!
Killer Harmonies...GREAT JOB!
Great arrangement and rendition!
EXCELLENT!
CoZmicCowboYs 4 years ago
My conly issue with this is that they are playing in the wrong key. Those guitars need a capo on the second fret :)
manictrance 4 years ago
"wrong key"..... it might be different from the original, but does that make it wrong? :)
anon49ymous 4 years ago
No. The artist has to perform the song in a key that is comfortable for their voice.
demonhoopa 4 years ago 2
EXACTLY.
CoZmicCowboYs 4 years ago
I agree. I am in a band, and we played Crazy Train (Ozzy) and Another One Bites the Dust(Queen), and we do both of those in different keys.
cfreckna 4 years ago
OMG great job man I love this song.
Deadmike007 4 years ago
matty wilkins loves joe worrell
mattiecat70 4 years ago
Hi - I'm e-mailing from rainy old England and when I heard this, it certainly bought the sun out! Lovely, I looked close at your video and thought Stephen Stills had long hair in his heyday, then I looked closer and saw the lady. Great stuff! This track is absolutely fantastic. I'm sure everyone has favourited it - you give CS&N a run for their money - keep on going!
SueHampson36 4 years ago
Ha ! Here I am watching it again and loving it again too. 9,666 views so far (that's a weird number).
Keep the girl around ... she's good. And Pretty too.
Post some more videos .... please !
jimiray1 4 years ago
You guys are really, really good. Please keep at it!
cdonline1 4 years ago
Lovely harmonies.
tony1orourke 4 years ago
Sweet man ... I really enjoyed that.
I save it to favorites too.
You guys are really good.
jimiray1 4 years ago
\/\/()\/\/......awesome harmonies...whoa !!!!!
bladetocry 4 years ago
Nice harmonizing! I'm singing the bass part now. ;-)
amtk019 4 years ago