American Idol 7 Top 10 -Brooke White - Every Breath You Take

[sabrezrule]

love the song but thumbs down for the hottie singing it, booooo

[bigheadedjones]

EW puffy daddy version is way better then this shit.

[Qu3bus]

She butchered that.. not through a lack of talent but by turning it into a radio jingle. The original version is actually a pretty "dark" song. She totally missed the boat...

[ChristineTheHippie]

Yeah, the song is about possessive love or stalking, and this is soft and tender

[Nicktheasianman]

Shes pretty good but the changes she put in suck so bad. At least if your gonna change it don't make it suck. She needs to leave the classics how they are

[bendersgreathaha]

Brooke is an amazing artist.

[prdgy20]

I like her but she messed up

[charliebergy101239]

yes, but she recovered nicely.. how would you have done?????

[lbpfan17]

great

[CGBossi]

I don't think it was as good as sting and the police. I'm not trying to downplay the truckloads of talent it took to do something like this though.

[sweetfb1983]

this was my favorite performance of hers!

[wanghongbo1987]

这首歌唱得太棒了

[GRomance0804]

she is valuable to music. she makes honest vocals

[zhaomichelle918]

Brooke White is so good. :)

[EyepatchRLC]

i was rooting for her to be in the top three with the davids!!! i voted too!! oh well... i still love you brooke!! :)

[joeluvver26]

i love her

[bananaday]

I actually thought the mistake in the initial part enhanced the song's beauty! It makes it real

[rockerzz501]

she has nice voice! original as in nice

[moninblue]

Sounds nice. But soul less

[beto861118]

bitch !

[lightsleeperz]

you don't need to be a psychic to know she's tense right? She's got a voice plus beauty

[AggPapp]

Come on guys! She is a human, too! It's normal to make a mistake!

[showcampfan]

but when you're all famous like this you're not supposed to make a mistake.

thats why miley cyrus is so looked down on now.

[columbustheslayer]

wat miustake did she make?

[Frollophile]

Getting on the stage. =P

[columbustheslayer]

lol but seriously

[sanum91]

LMAO

[sexyshallet]

lmaooooooo u kill meee lol heheh thatz not nicee

[xXlookmeintheeyesXx]

shes human, so she cant be perfect, and your comparing an american idol contestant to a disney star........

[timallenfan92]

love this song! Her voice was good too!

[summerlover30]

were singing this song in chorus hahaha

[sensfan4lif]

not bad, got nothing on the original though

[iStoleYourPC]

Hahaha

Messed on the first part.... xD

Noob.. xD

[sk8forthe1lord]

The beginning was pretty bad. But she made up for it!

[ReRe2188]

she's really mediocre. I can't believe she even made top 24

[cbotten106]

But she is pretty and different and quirky, that is the key to her advancement.

[iluvJordinandBlake]

luv u brooke u rock!!!!!!!!

[nickolas18769]

Dis is actually better den I remember it!

[marykieferfan]

brooke is amazing. people need to shut up. theres all different kinds of talent or singing, if brookes not your thing, don't listen. piss off with your jokes. assholes.

[feliXlovegood]

for the peole who think brooke white sucks, why the f~!@ you haters wasting your time watching her vids?!?! cuz i'm pissed at people doing that,,,well if you have nothing nice to say about her, then don't say anything at all! geez!

**sorry about my sucky grammar i'm from the phil.**

brooke white rocks!!!♥♥

[KristyLeeCookFan24]

Anyone here who hates Brooke, you have really bad taste in music. Brooke is awesome and really sweet!!!

[vulizness]

I always like this performance !!love you brooke!!

[12345678910ginger]

fucking shit but sheed get shagged

[cbotten106]

This is basically a song about an obsessed creepy stalker monitoring somebody's activity.

For obvious reasons, I'm not really buying Brooke White in that role.

In fact, Every Breath You Take almost takes on a kind of quasi-big sister connotation with this cheerful and delivery from Idol's resident Little Nanny Sunshine. Very weird.

[Sadrapa]

its about infidelity, im sure someone could cheat on Brooke.

[ilove80srock1]

i know this song is a stalker song!!!

[vroneeez]

every.....hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

[suzzzz11]

Brooke White is a below average singer.

She is going nowhere with her I'm so pure

folk artist thing she thinks she has going.

She used instruments as a prop, and shouldn't even of made to the top 24. An Embarassment to

AI.

[jazilgirl]

Hi suz, I have to say that I respectfully disagree with you. This was my favorite of her performances and I found her genuine and refreshingly honest. I honestly don't understand your negitivity towards her but understand that what folks like in music is completely subjective.

[bufangel]

her studio version sounds amazing. she's the type of artist that I listen to all the time. folk music isn't exactly "mainstream" but it has an audience if people look hard enough.

[BigBoiJC]

and what do you do in the music industry? are you a producer? engineer, musician????

[abomb83]

butchered a song for some crap show.

[KourtneyKilledKurt]

"Brooke White, if you're reading this, will you marry me???" Darn it, nevermind...

I'm a big fan of the Police and Sting and will always enjoy their music. But I like Brooke's take on this song. I'm not gonna conform my thoughts like others by saying it's "better" because that's not what art is suppose to be. If it moves you to a certain degree, then her take on the song worked. Otherwise, I respect those of you who relate this song with the original version more. So its all good,

[aycockbr]

She is awesome. Wish she would have been the American Idol. She is so unique compared to the other contestants. She has so much talent!

[Shadowstriker1218]

I seriously don't see how you deaf jackasses think she sucks. She's unbelievable and i would have loved to see her get even farther.

[willthereveal2]

love her!

[beckham1221]

dude, im in love

[runnerman550]

i agree with agoodgirlnot except she shouldve been not in the top 24

[runnerman550]

no it's not. brooke white sucks.

[luckygirl00127]

she doesnt suck you do runnerman550

[timm1135]

She killed this song

[luckygirl00127]

let see u do better timm1135

[amberjadeadams]

runnerman550 you just have no taste in music! maybe your even jealous of her! that was the best song she has ever done and it was a love song! keep your MEAN coments to yourself!

[livyrocks317]

i love this song i lover you u rock i was so so so sad when you got voted off i amgoing to buy all youre cds now im not votine for anyone

[puppylovers334]

OMG i am sooo mad she got voted off i luved her!

[xLiveTheDreamx]

i never really liked her that much, but i have to say this is my favourite song in the competition..

x

[BMSbrooklyn]

I love her in this song .This song only

[aomorgan]

Ever notice how she always had the best makeup and hair (out of all the girls) each week? I like this performance despite the false start.

[agoodgirlNOT]

she messed up in the beggining and started over. she shouldve been gone after this.

[runnerman550]

ya. it is. it's like my favorite song

[runnerman550]

brooke was so bad. she shouldn't have been in the top 24 at all. it was only from her looks that she was in. also, i bet she doesn't realize that every breath you take is not a love song. sting wrote it as a stalker song for his ex-wife.

[Lorixoxo]

really? it's meant to be a stalker song? i didn;t know that

[BigBoiJC]

oh get over yourself.

[AkiraMusic]

She definitely has talent, but I don't really like this performance. It doesn't have the haunting quality the Police put into it.

[jennalynn3967]

In my opinion, this was her best performance of the whole season... even with the mess up. i loved brooke and was sad to see her go before Jason... but she can now start her career. She is amazing and is sure to go far! And if you like music.. it should not matter what religion it comes from. i love music and she makes great music. we are all human and will all meet the same fate. Go Brooke!

[444444444271]

Stop talking about religion, as long as its good music its perfect. She's great no matter what religion.

[doggielover365]

yea, i agree. it doesn't matter if she's mormon

[444papaya444]

wow, she has the confidence to start again

[0987654321qazx]

im a catholic too and my aunt liked brooke i still ove carly and my nana likes david cook

[SoulPowyr]

My favourite is Brooke because she is a Mormon =)

[runnerman550]

racist

[queenofgogaba]

excuse me?

[megthesprite]

I love Brook! And I really don't care that she messed up, she's wonderful! I hope she makes it to the top 4!

Is Brook Mormon? I know she's never seen an R movie but, I didn't know she's Mormon. That's so cool! My best friend is a Mormon. I'm Catholic. And I completely agree with Crazy4guys10.

[pooper98765432123456]

soooooo hot!!!!!

[Crazy4guys10]

woah, ur a little bit messed up...brooke has talent. You're just not bright enough to see that...same with all of the other people who think Brooke is a stupid mormon....wow...thats SO not true!

[qg6ff]

she does have talent but she is not good enough for as far as she's gotten!!!! I really don't want her to beat Syesha!

[SupergirlBrookexAntm]

She is amazing!

If I lived in the USA, I would vote for her.

It's a shame I can't...

[raphaeld]

I feel sad, alarmed and disturbed for you. Have you considered seeing a therapist?

[pisoisa789]

brooke white is the best ! you are just jealous !

[chengfei]

whatever, hypocrite.

[mikemonleon]

she RUINED this song!

[heroinerrorbassist]

this gave me goosebumps

[heroinerrorbassist]

this gave me goosebumps

[xL0VEE]

Brooke's my favorite girl!! Even when her perforamnce aren't too brilliant I always see some sort of emotion which makes her reachable+approachable+genuine­..Even though MJ is my favorite she's just genuine whether she delivers or not

[dan014]

she needs to get voted off immediately! you cant screw up like that at the beginning. inexcusable

[crooklynking]

i completely agree can't believe that. how hard is it to start a song!!!

[heroinerrorbassist]

She came in a little to early on the piano u dumb shit! it happens to everyone

[birdsonmywindow]

If she didn't start over, she would have been off-tempo. Learn a thing or two about music before you hate on people, please.

[mookiemay]

Actually, it can be hard to start a song, especially when you didn't hear they key that you're supposed to start on. Brooke sang before she played first... and as soon as she played the piano she realized she was singing in the wrong key. It can happen to anyone...but it would NEVER happen to you, right?

[crooklynking]

nope never

[ctf20]

sure you can screw up...it's happened plenty of times... David A butchered We Can Work It Out, forgot several lines....don't think it hurt him!

it happens. besides one she started - it was great!!! loved it.

[ThatsSoKirby]

This close to my favorite BW performance. She looks AMAZING, and I actually like how the band comes in at the middle...

[heroinerrorbassist]

not even! remember David A? he comletly forgot the words. should he have gotten voted off?

[equitatus]

Another one of her songs that I can listen to all day.

[countrymusicxo]

Good performance but I hate this song...its kinda stalkerish and creepy

[dowds7]

haha, the song is about a stalker. so that's probably why you get that vibe. but yes, it's not too bad of a performance.

[scotpet11]

yep

[jennnnnnn13]

My favorite performance of hers this season. She made the song great but she left out the creepy stalker vibe most people give that song when they sing it. =]

[LuvLolo2218]

She is amazing

[MooshieV]

love her...

[jflores949]

she kinda sounds like madonna

[3605031]

My top 2 is brook and david cook =D they're seriously good

[AZNgamer715]

I love her version of the song. I wish the band didn't have to join her it sounded perfect with just the piano. And I wish the whole song was played.

[jadedgurl86]

I agree...they should've let her play unaccompanied or maybe put some violins but not the band...

[sakurawolf14]

i cant believe we put her in the bottom 3

[Halessayshi]

Gosh she is amazing!!!!! She should win AI. She is so real and pure and her voic is incredible.

[TRAKY16]

aww i love broke so much she is my favorite girl! aww love david A TOO n JASON!n MJ

[aileenjan]

i bet brooke is gonna win the competition!!

[MAnDKpr0ductions]

I think david cook,Brook,and David Archuleta will be the top three.But IDK what would happen next.

[Decinerator]

MY top 2 are David Cook and Brooke White. First It was my top 4 (Danny Noriega, Amanda Overmeyer, Brooke White, and David Cook), but Danny Noriega and Amanda Overmeyer left. So I am left to depend on Brooke White and David Cook!

[sarah29683]

i would be extremely happy if she and michael johns were the final two. i think they are two of the best singers on the show. :D

[ilovestyx22]

YES YES YES YES YES!!!!! michael and brooke are my two favorite. everyone's crazy about the david's but i think michael johns and brooke would be a great top 2!

[shelbypurple]

i agree. i love michael and brooke.

[sarah29683]

i would be extremely happy if she and michael johns were the final two. i think they are two of the best singers on the show. :D

[sarah29683]

i would be extremely happy if she and michael johns were the final two. i think they are two of the best singers on the show. :D

[edithpiaf91]

In my perfect world, top 5 would be Brooke, Syesha, David C, Carly and Jason, with Brooke, David and either Carly or Syesha. Any way BROOKE MUST WIN! THE UK IS BEHIND ORIGINALITY IN AMERICAN IDOL!

[robbiowski]

archuleta is a poser and can't sing...brooke will make it to the top three, but there is no way that anyone but David Cook will win this competition!

[Trib91]

archuleta IS the best in this competition

brooke is good.

but not top 3 good.

[mnj1287]

guys i hate to tell you this david archleta and david cook are top 2

[llSeeingJupiterll]

don't you want to kill the people in the audience waving their hands in the air. *sigh*

[vonser360]

oppps! she did it!

[xxhannah07]

LOVE HER!!!!! the top 2 WILL be David Cook and Brooke White!! [: OHH YEAA!

[ilovestyx22]

she has got IT. whatever IT is. brookes got IT. she is just amazing

[ZiPxzapxZoP]

haha omg thats from scrubs !!!

[soccerbrim11]

The top 3 should definetley be Brooke David and David

[dukenumber21]

michael johns, david cook and carly smithson.

[deazinhahhh]

maravilhosaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

[ctf20]

love her! vote vote vote!! i just love her voice, ready to buy a cd now!

[alves033]

looooooooooooovvvvvvvvvvvvveee­eeeeeeeeee her

she is going to win

[lookamonkey1]

I like her, but I don't think she'll make it further than the top 4 or 5.

[bratas9765]

yes i agree the top to should definately be brooke white and david cook

[bratas9765]

yes i agree the top to should definately be brooke white and david cook

[johnseiple]

I'd buy a CD of her reading the phone book. Love that girl.

[gr8indians]

The Top 2 Will Definately Be Brooke And David Cook..........The Best Of 'Em all..........

[dmhuua]

ChangesRcoming- agreed!

[morgsweets7]

david cook is a douche bag.

he needs to go home. talk about ugly?

that man is disgusting. and she's amazing.

and i like carly, but i don't think she'll be in the top two.

[stormylane]

I wish i could like her... but she bores me.

There is just nothing special about her. Nothing to set her above the rest ya know.

A few of the girls in our church choir sound better then her.

Oh well... America will vote.

[tinytvfan]

I have the same problem! I know I should really love her, but she just leaves me...cold?

[sydandshera]

Brooke and David Archuleta will be the top 2, just look at who everyone likes. Syesha will be third. And stop calling him Chekezie, if you heard Simon called him Jacuzzi, which was hilarious.

[liveinmymusic]

i only like the part with the piano in the beginning

[Saamii1006]

i don't think she's mormon, and whatever she is, you can't fake her personality.

[x3kaylamoox3]

the top 2 will be David Archuleta or David Cook with Brooke

[x3kaylamoox3]

the top 2 will be David Archuleta or David Cook with Brooke

[x3kaylamoox3]

the top 2 will be David Archuleta or David Cook with Brooke

[SarahheartEric]

They are all talented. but i think Shyesha should have been voted off. Chekezie was so much better. =(

[Saamii1006]

syesha should have gone the week she sang 'i got to get you into my life' and after her should have been kristy lee

[middlekid95]

GO Brooke!!!!!! YAY! she is SO talented i think it will be Carly, David, and Brooke in the top 3! =)

[frankareno]

yeah right! lol, NOT EVERYBODY THINKS SHE DOESNT HAVE A CHANCE TO WIN! thats right, just your opinion, lol...and my opinion is that she can and will win the title :)

[daffodil4503]

She is awesome!!!!!!!!

[kepani80]

she is awesome! it looks like she has some haters here. but we all know that haters are only jelous!

[miknge]

i love her hair straight. but i love it curly too. haha. go Brooke!!! <3 ya!

[frankareno]

no talent? lol, thats why she can play the piano and guitar and is a songwriter..yeah your statement is stupid just like you, lol

Brooke is awesome and has a excellent chance of winning AI :)

[wing54]

All the top 10 are great that is why they are called THE TOP TEN .. You American Couch surfing jealous wannabes.

[WestliFerZul]

shes hot..

[jeremybrimhall]

what does religion have to do with american idol. ChangesRcoming your an american idiot. it's a singing competition, not a religion war.

[jeremybrimhall]

what does religion have to do with american idol. ChangesRcoming your an american idiot. it's a singing competition, not a religion war.

[zack453]

brooke is asome i love her to death she wont win or well she TWIST! loll anyway i like her a hole bunch how she sings the song with pasion and her voice is amazing@!! i love her and i am a big fan of her!

[musiclover462]

brooke is so amazing! i lovee herr <3 She'll make it to the top 3 with david cook and david a.

[sballshoxie]

awsome and if u think she sucks ur jealous

[moralwillimprove2]

sballshoxie I highly doubt that anyone would be jealous of someone who has NO talent

[jamtheman554]

brook's vocals aren't bad (or good), but the way she drives her songs makes up for it

[pinkmaddieo3]

brooke is at least different then some of the winners. Kristy is a lot like a carrie underwood wanna be.