Added: 2 years ago
From: sadi3sam
Views: 240,944
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (187)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Miley totally ruined this song! She sounded like crap compared to Taylor

  • Taylors so peacful and amazing. And Miley's a spaz

  • MILEY SINGS THIS AWFUL!! 

  • Miley you singing way to loud for a quiet song and aslo lets just say i wanna gunna b a hater untill i saw "plz no h8ers" lol

  • This is supposed to be a sad song your not supposed to yell Miley! i liked you before but you changed too much just because you're an adult.

  • whats the song at the begining called??

  • @katarzynaaa93 there the same song through it all

  • yeah they dont sound good together 

  • smh! nooooo why did you have to ruin this beautiful song miley gosh know your limits! even your own songs you canteven sing them rite maybe you should just stick to acting you ruined the song

  • this song doesnt go good with mileys voice at all shes a good singer and all but not this song.

  • F MILEY!

  • why miley why why why ??? why did you have to ruin this AWESOME song??

  • @justlooking640 what's your problem!!

  • Miley ruined the song its really calm then all you hear is some bad voice come up sorry that's just what I think

  • @navneeshbath8 shes make perfect the song, Miley is perfect and u a stupid

  • when i was 15 i dident listen to shitty music like this...

  • WOW Miley did more than ruin this song.

    She butchered it up and burned the pieces.

    Miley can't sing! Good job for Taylor she sounded great

  • MILEY JSUT CANT SING AND HER VOICE SOUNDS BAD NEXT TAYLORS

  • both of them have a wonderful voice, but toghether they not sounds good...

  • I didnt like Mileys voice...at all, she made it dramtic sounding, and taylor was calm and sweet (which is how its suppose to sound)

  • I think it's great that two young, talented artists with the same musical interests were fortunate enough to perform together and sound great to the majority of the United States and even other places.You negatives know that you are writing bad things out of jealousy and not of actual, educated opinion. I would like to say that you people wasting your life watching videos of singers you don't even like have talent, but you -unfortunately- do not, beside bashing the talent of these girls.

  • Whoever told Miley she could sing was insane -.- I feel bad for Taylor her song was butchered -.-

  • i prefer taylor than miley voice i truthly felt that miley voice was like disgusting..

  • Both great singers, but i don't think they should sing together, they sound too different.

  • @Plainification  i think is cool!

  • i dont like country, but as a guitarist its obvious to me who has more talent, i doubt miley has the faintest understanding of what a chord even is, let alone how their used in a progression to make a song (something that every 'musician' should know)

  • i have listened 2 this and tried 2 figure out wat is wrong with mileys voice and now i knw its 2 course and rough against taylors i dont wat 2 think anymore

  • i think miley ruined this song. she sounded horrible and tried to take over the song.Taylor was perfect. she sounds like an angel.

  • @xoxocrazy4skittles15 i think miley didn't sounded horrible. both of then are really great!!!!!!!!

  • @xoxocrazy4skittles15 She didn't try to take over her song, it's how her voice is. Taylor cant sing loud, but Miley can.

  • I honestly think that Miley has a bad voice for country singing, Miley should stick to pop songs in stead of country. And Taylor Swift is a good singer for both genres, pop and country. this performance was GOOD but, not great

  • Miley killed the song -_-

  • taylor has an angel voice while miley has a powerful voice.

    and this song is kinda like a lullaby so taylor's voice suits it more

    but miley is just amazing, she sings different kinds of songs but

    i think she should stick to pop songs instead of acoustic, she should leave that to taylor cause taylor rocks it!

  • taylors voice is perfect for this song because its laid back and easy to listen to. miley over powers it too much and the song loses its meaning.

  • Taylor's voice is soft and Miley's is strong. They are both good at singing and I don't give a fuck about miley haters.

  • I think Taylor Swift has great talent as a song writer but miley really outshone Taylor vocally here

  • i lovee thiss songg!!! <3

  • this is a good song, but it could've be better with faster beats, taylor fits this song but not miley.

  • @Blakemaplesmusic Taylor rocks and she doesn't do crapy things like dance on a strip pole she is a terrible role model

  • Omg Miley Cyrus danced on a strip pole she takes nude pics I have been to her concerts Taylor swift is way better miley Cyrus just made that song worse

  • @sierrainluv she didnt pole dance!she was holdin on!!!!!

  • @22yer pole.

  • @22yer i know she didnt. it was an ice cream cart and she didnt wanna fall. maybe she danced a little bit but it wasnt pole dancing cuz pole dancing is like climbing it and getting all up on it. she danced a little bit while holding on cuz she didnt want to look stupid just standing there!!! so i agree miley is innocent

  • i truly think miley outsang her alot lol

  • umm miley shouldnt evan try to attempt thiss and soo what if taylor swift sings to soft shes perfect she doesnt even so get ova it miley cryus sounds like shes screaming

  • Could someone please tell me the song at the beginning?

  • Taylor brings a beautiful n peaceful n amazing voice 2 de table while Miley brings a powerful, beautiful n amazin voic as well wen der along der amazin but wen der together der a power house if dey were a band de certainly wud be de most powerful band der eva was

  • I think Taylor's voice is weaker here than Miley's, softer and a bit calmer

    But as the one who wrote the song, her voice and her style of singing fits the song more:)

  • Miley is some hillybilly bubblegum pop all computer crap, her voice makes me want to die ; she has zero talent she can stick to acting

    Taylor has really good talent for songwriting she's amazing at relating to people through music her voice fits her song

    So miley can stop screeching like an idiot n trying to sound niceee when she just sounds awful

  • @Liveforlove101 I couln't have said it better, Miley ruined this beautiful song. She should stick to the crap that she calls music.

  • @Bittennews no offense to Miley lover it's just that i really don't lke her. Taylor Swift all the way!!

  • i love miley so much in this.

  • they both are horrible live.

  • Both are Great Singers and Songwriters !! Amazing Girls !! Both Just as good as eachother. Their voices completly contrast, so it depends on what style people like more. LOVE them both !!!

  • taylor is so much better!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I think Miley has a stronger voice

  • i actually think miley did better than taylor swift on this song

  • I do not like Miley only taylor

  • miley is actually amazing, she isnt the BEST at this but i still like it :)

  • LOOOOOOVEEEE IIIT<3 <3 <3 <3 <3 <3

  • sux

  • i think it sounds pretty good,but thats just my opinion. :)

  • miley ruined a perfect tayor swift song

  • Miley Cyrus sux

  • Why was Miley screaming the lyrics?

  • Taylor's voice is soft.

    Miley's voice is strong.

    Taylor whispers.

    Miley belts.

    Even though it's Tay's song, I think when Miley sang, she woke people up.

  • @hicecilia totaly agree and also miley has a great , here it's not her song , it's not her style of song, each singer have to found them style who's fit with them voice. Still consider miley as a good singer

  • @hicecilia totaly agree and also miley has a great voice , here it's not her song , it's not her style of song, each singer have to found them style who's fit with them voice. Still consider miley as a good singer

  • @hicecilia she woke ppl up because she was rlly bad!! taylor is sooooo much better than her!! im just saying!! :)

  • they deserve each other. it sucks

  • Miley sux in this

  • Taylor ruined her song when singing it with Miley...

  • Miley is waayyyyyyyyyyyyy better than taylor just sayin....taylor screches to much....for example: you (screech) belong (screech) with (screech) meeeee (double screech)

  • wrong. Miley can't do shit without a god damn auto tune so shut it and learn what talent is. Wana hear talent? Listen to Metallica or some other 80's bands that don't use autotones and rely on a studio to make them sound great.

  • if you have ever heard miley sing not in a studio, then you wouldn't think that, of course this is isn't the best sound for either of them because it was probably recorded on like a 50 dollar camera. If you talk to anyone that has ever worked with her, they would tell you that she does have an amazing voice. and Metallica? last time I checked screaming wasn't considered music. And I'm not wrong. Having an opinion is not wrong.

  • I don't doubt she is a great singer, but did you deny she uses an auto tune? Nope, she uses it in a lot of her songs that you can noticeably hear and it just ruins that part of the song. And for Metallica, you really need to not be so close-minded to metal. Last time I checked Metallica doesn't scream in their songs, and James sings in a softer voice as well as a more intense voice. So.... you are wrong with that, and the drummer has more talent using one leg then Miley Cyrus does. Stfu n gtfo

  • she might use the studio to make her albums, but she still has a great voice without it. Any band or singer that has an album has used it. They just don't on stage. She is awesome and it's your loss that you don't think she's good

  • You are really proving one point, and one point only: your an idiot. Read the first sentence of my last comment. And did you know that auto tune's exist on stage in live performances as well? Goes to show what you know. She is an over rated singer, I personally know three seventeen year old girls that can out sing her anyday and they aren't even professionally trained. Now be a smarty and just walk away.

  • I didn't say miley's voice is awful !

    I just wanted to say that this song is better when sang by taylor! That's all ;) xP

  • this sucks

  • i love you

  • i'm neither a miley or taylor fan but i think that they sing great togheter!!

  • whats the song in the beginning before fifteen comes on? its on the tip of my tongue but i just cant think of it

  • Miley = kathastropiccccccccccccccccccc­c

  • ITS A BIG FAT LIE LIKE YOU BEEP

  • Lol, its funny reading these comments, cause miley cyrus' voice is way better suited for country then for the poppy shit she shovels out. The only reason Taylor swift is considered country is cause of the shitty guitar played in behind her admittedly pretty good vocals

  • totaly true sorry miley but you cant sing country sin

  • shes really good at country lol

  • to be honest...not that i look @ these comments...ur guyz are right, taylor isint that good of a singer!

    now demi lavato...damn right right she can sing!

  • Miley can sing, but I hate the sound of her voice.

    Taylor can't sing as well, but I love the sound of her voice.

    Interesting.....

  • i'm kinda the same! lol

  • miley you can't sing country! you should be quiet all the song and leave Taylor singing alone :)

  • omg do u need a hearing check? because miley is the bomb at pop and country lol

  • @musicbytravis in what world exactly does miley cyrus ever sound good in. ? Oh in a world with lots and lots of Auto tune

  • that makes absoloutley no sense to me

  • I think that Miley kinda destroys the song.

  • @oxtaylorswifthaterxo, Miley's voice doesn't go with the song at all, and on Taylor's CD, which I have, it is Country not Pop, Taylor's Voice is soft, because that goes with the song, not because it is weak, it is not weak. Get your facts straight. And NO I am not hating on Miley, but Taylor's voice goes better with the song

  • She didn't do so good that time and miley cyrus sucks all the time

  • Both are no talent wastes of space. The Dave Matthews Band should have won 'album of the year' hands down

  • Sorry Miley, sounds like your forcing your voice out ...... out of a dying cat

  • I think they both sound like crap right here, but I hate Miley anyways.

    Taylor is NOT good live, at all.

  • i totally disagree.... taylor is too melancolic and noone is having fun at the crowd they just listen...miley's voice cheers you up!! it's much better.....

  • I know!!!!

  • taylor is better at singin the song. shes got the voice and everything.and miley puts too much voice into it.

  • @Heart34Stars That's because for Miley to sound remotely good she has to practically scream.

  • horrible. miley is horrible.

  • i purfer miley even though its taylors song

  • I really prefer Taylor swift.. I think miley suck.. a bit.. much

  • There both awesome dont complain there both talented

  • whats the song that plays at the very beginning?

  • mileys voice messes up the song her voice isnt gentle like taylor and shes like screaming the lyrics her voice isnt sumthing i wud like to go to sleep to

  • theres a very clear version of this on my channel!

  • uhhhhhhh Miley nooooooooooooooo let taylor sing!!!!!!

  • Their both very good xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx

  • guys ! Miley is good and obviously better than all of you since she has come such a long way. just because it isnt her song doesnt mean she is ruining it. they are both really good

  • on which telestation we can watch the grammy awards 2010 ?

  • *done

  • They are both talented. Try going up and saying it to their faces. If you're dissing on Miley and saying hurtful things, how the fuck can you say Taylor's better, when she supports Miley too. They are BOTH good, other wise they wouldnt have dont the duet.

  • AHHHH MILEY NOOOOO!!!! WHYYYY!!

  • I hate miley haters!she doesn't kill the songs she has a different voice and everybody does.They both sound fantastic together!

  • did anyone notice that miley sounds like a lamb and taylor sounds fantastic!

  • Miley Cyrus just fucked up the whole song

  • I agree !! :))

  • what song ws playing at the end like after 15 was over ithink it was miley but whats it caled

  • @laurlaurandranda hey x im not sure what the song is at the end but i dont think it's miley, coz i never made the vid, my mate did but she couldnt upload it, so im not sure sorryy x

  • @laurlaurandranda "i still believe" by hayden pannetiere from Cinderella III

  • @laurlaurandranda "i still believe" by hayden pannetiere from Cinderella III

  • I think both of them is great singers and they both have strong voices. And their voices fit together :D

  • I actually like their voices together...

  • @1tracklover me too i luv their voice together but i hate haters coz they dnt see this was a recording from a tape recorder thts why it sounds bad BUT they actually sound kool

  • this songis beautiful and full of emotion... that is, until miley sings it and killed it... mind u she kills every song she sings...

  • is there no video of them performing?

    i like taylor's voice better. when i heard miley's voice at the chorus, i automatically covered my ears with my hands. xD

    miley cyrus practically ruined it. :/

  • I love them both =D

    they sound really good togehter

  • well yeah connections does help... but thats the same in any industry. Music is just a global thing. However, connections and her dad don't make her fans... her fans genuinely like her so that in itself shows her talent :)

  • Taylor Swift is better than Miley.... why? Because she is a better influence on young girls. She doesn't act like an idiot. Miley doesn't sound bad, but personality wise she isn't that great.

  • i like taylor better

  • Ok, its just a song,get over it, mileys good, taylors good. Its not that hard to say somthing nice.

  • mileys voice is to powerful for this song while taylor is more like a love song type of girl like i could never in my life picture her singing rock or rap though they are both good i kinda perfer miley

  • First off, Miley sounds like a goat... making cheese. lol. Second, miley BUTCHERED the sound.

  • tbh if your all listening to it and Miley must have alot of talent to be as famous as she is, it's okay to be opinionated but don't force it on other people. She brings some edge to the song, it's different yes. Now accept. :)

  • just a lttle bit of talent and a famous dads with connections

  • its crazy that miley, who has such a mediocre voice, could become so famous. i know people who can sing just as good as miley but no one has ever heard of them.

    guess it helps to have a stupid t.v. show

  • not everyone has a famous dad with connectiond

  • How did Miley ruin the song? She just has a more punk rock voice than Taylor does.

    Accept change, people.

  • guys!! miley has a different voice! just like saying black people have a different skin colour noone cares so shut up

  • i HATE miley's voice! taylor is amazing!

  • that i have to agree =]

  • lol

  • miley and taylor singing both beautiful.

  • miley tried to over sing. not knocking her but this isnt hannah montanna. its TAYLORS song. not that loud hannah montnana crap.

  • Miley didn't try to over sing, she has a totally different voice than Taylor, Taylor has this soft voice, and Miley has a very powerful voice, from Taylor being so soft, it sounded like Miley was being loud...and shes not loud on hannah montana? shes not hannah montana, nor is she trying to be, she wants that image gone.

  • I honestly love taylor and don't hate miley (but it doesn't mean i like her) but i think that their voices don't blend.

  • Miley is terrible! She just ruined a perfectly good song! Ugh! I dont hate her but seriously! She cant sing this song!!!

  • BOO MILEEEY!

    TAYLOR ROCKS

    plus taylor is really down to earth,

    original and pretty (:

    go away you goat sounding suckish miley!

    teaam taylor wins everytime!

  • I think they both have amazing voices but their voices dont really go together but they didnt sound that bad and they are both really pretty girls

  • the reason miley sounds "bad" is cause taylor and miley sing differently. different genres. different voices that go with different songs.

  • But i think Miley sounds great tbh!! :)

  • taylor has a true talent..while miley sucsk ass. lmao jk well miley isnt as great as taylor..i mean comon she never does live performances without lip syncing she doesnt want her fans to know that she cant exactly do high pitch and plus she sucks!! lol (dont take this too hard i mean you dont know her)Team Taylor