The cellist is indeed Maynard's son Devo. And as Pahndora commented, Billy wrote the lyrics and music for A Perfect Circle as well as this, and is doing the vocals for Ashes Divide. He also did the vocals on a couple of A Perfect Circle tracks from eMOTIVE.
like someone already said, this band is not a side project. It is a band that has been created by billy, the guitarist of TOOL and apc. he put apc together. he put this band together. everyone including the drummer from apc, the girl bassist, maynards son, devo, plays cello, and billy sings and plays guitar. maynard has no part in this band. hopefully he sings in one of their songs, i miss his amazing voice!!
hey, some other people look at the lyrics for this song. please, if you appreciate this music enough you will. i want to know if anyone else feels that the lyrics are talking about suicide. i dont know if hes talking about suicide in general, or about someone he knows. but someone else reply to this comment, thanks.
its kinda hard not to when Billy was the founder of APC, which was more or less his training ground for this band. Billy used APC to find himself as a musician. But he has his own voice, which deserves to be heard. the two bands will sound very close, mostly because they both share a common element: Howerdel being the key member writing all the songs. Maynard did vocals and lyrics for APC, but all the music was Howerdel. In this band as well, all of it is Howerdel. how can u not compare them?
Maynard reworked most of the core structures and sequences of the songs to fit melodically with the vocals he wrote. He was also responsible for the production and played an active role in the mixing process...
They are of course similar in some respects, because Billy was associated with both bands, so yeah the guitar sounds for one are actually quite similar, notably resonant and heavy on the reverb. Also it's got that sort of progressive metally sound that Tool and APC have, and is in 3/4 time, similar to many songs by the bands. Loads of similarities. Way more than that too.
I love billy so much <3 I am happy about this ashes diVIDE dealy-o :) It's like having new APC, so it's like an early christmas ^_^ Just thought I'd say.
most of the songs off this record didn't live up to APC...i really think that billy could have done better with the guitar work, but this song is pretty good.
Just so you know -- this is not a side band of Tool. Billy Howerdel created A Perfect Circle and was the lyricist. Maynard James Keenan sang in Tool and APC. Billy Howerdel is the front man and singer in Ashes Divide. ^_^
yeah a side band from tool would be puscifer that is maynards little side project, momma sed i would say is one of my fav. songs on v is for vagina. but this is a very good song from billy.
@Pahndora2012 Maynard also was a words man for APC, meaning that he co-wrote most of the songs and where Billy was stuck(like on wording and such.) Maynard helped out.
I love this, the intro...
with the cello and the piano harmony-- it's beautiful.
Murphyani 9 months ago 4
bought this CD 2 days after it released,
this was my favorite one of the album that I really LOVED....
beautiful intro. <3
SoberNostalgia 11 months ago
wow billy's actually really good. i wouldn't know who he was if it weren't for Maynard, but he's an amazing musician.
psno1994 1 year ago
one of my favorite songs of all time.
Rensaur 1 year ago
The cellist is indeed Maynard's son Devo. And as Pahndora commented, Billy wrote the lyrics and music for A Perfect Circle as well as this, and is doing the vocals for Ashes Divide. He also did the vocals on a couple of A Perfect Circle tracks from eMOTIVE.
kyfriedpecker 1 year ago 2
Why is the "d" of dIVIDE little and not big like Ashes Divide ?
Insted its Ashes dIVIDE
Ozren92 1 year ago
3:04 scary...
great song
MorningKillsDawn 2 years ago
love this song, love this band/guy
endnote7 2 years ago
love it.
insecuritykills 3 years ago
Fucking phenomenal song right here.
andrew02248 3 years ago
love this fucking band. im so glad he has another project i adore his voice
RodentQueen57 3 years ago
Comment removed
bugmusk6 2 years ago
Apparently the cellist is Maynards son.
empiredcrow 3 years ago 24
His son is indeed the cellist ... talent just seeps out of that family it seems.
Von2good 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
More like maynard forced his son to play cello.
azteksk 2 years ago
Likely, the man is a perfectionist...vicariously living his own dream perhaps!
exclamation3mark 2 years ago
its good :D
worth watching.
31193JaH 3 years ago
Let Adam sing!!!
Lanzar79 3 years ago
wow this is great
yes billy has done a great job
reminds me alot of apc and that makes me happy :]
lilwoody666 3 years ago 11
my bad, yes babyducksrock is correct, he did not play guitar in Tool.
narlycharl3y 3 years ago 2
like someone already said, this band is not a side project. It is a band that has been created by billy, the guitarist of TOOL and apc. he put apc together. he put this band together. everyone including the drummer from apc, the girl bassist, maynards son, devo, plays cello, and billy sings and plays guitar. maynard has no part in this band. hopefully he sings in one of their songs, i miss his amazing voice!!
narlycharl3y 3 years ago
Billy was Tool's guitar tech, not their guitarist (thats Adam Jones).
babyducksrock 3 years ago 2
he was also nine inch nail's guitar tech from 1990 to 1997 or '99... i forget when he left.
aschen 3 years ago
hey, some other people look at the lyrics for this song. please, if you appreciate this music enough you will. i want to know if anyone else feels that the lyrics are talking about suicide. i dont know if hes talking about suicide in general, or about someone he knows. but someone else reply to this comment, thanks.
narlycharl3y 3 years ago
hey. yes it is about suicide. i would just like 2 tell u that, it is deffinately and quite obviously some1 he knows.
rokrr618 3 years ago
How could anyone compare this to APC? This is a good CD, but it doesn't come close to APC or Tool. Not one bit.
wigglexroom 3 years ago
They compare it to APC because he was in APC... so yeah. i like it. its diff... and pretty awsome sounding
Miiro23 3 years ago 3
its kinda hard not to when Billy was the founder of APC, which was more or less his training ground for this band. Billy used APC to find himself as a musician. But he has his own voice, which deserves to be heard. the two bands will sound very close, mostly because they both share a common element: Howerdel being the key member writing all the songs. Maynard did vocals and lyrics for APC, but all the music was Howerdel. In this band as well, all of it is Howerdel. how can u not compare them?
SycoX17 3 years ago
Maynard reworked most of the core structures and sequences of the songs to fit melodically with the vocals he wrote. He was also responsible for the production and played an active role in the mixing process...
GENERICCEREAL67 3 years ago
do u mean for APC or for Ashes Divide? I wasn't aware that Maynard had any involvement in Ashes Divide.
SycoX17 3 years ago
They are of course similar in some respects, because Billy was associated with both bands, so yeah the guitar sounds for one are actually quite similar, notably resonant and heavy on the reverb. Also it's got that sort of progressive metally sound that Tool and APC have, and is in 3/4 time, similar to many songs by the bands. Loads of similarities. Way more than that too.
enigmaremains 3 years ago 2
You are right my friend.
azteksk 2 years ago
I love billy so much <3 I am happy about this ashes diVIDE dealy-o :) It's like having new APC, so it's like an early christmas ^_^ Just thought I'd say.
deemsy 3 years ago
cool sing
RejectionsPro 3 years ago
wait, i mean song. lol
RejectionsPro 3 years ago 2
luv billy in ashes dIVIDE! every song is my fav! keep makin ur magik howerdel!
66dani99 3 years ago 2
i luv billy on each and every song on this album! ashes dIVIDE 4eva!
66dani99 3 years ago
whoa thanx for this vid, i think ashes divide jus got anouther fan!!!!!
deadlyvicinity 3 years ago
most of the songs off this record didn't live up to APC...i really think that billy could have done better with the guitar work, but this song is pretty good.
Brom24 3 years ago
Thanks Justin, one of the best on the album. Maynard Keenan's son Devo plays the cello on it.
ginamari 3 years ago
Just so you know -- this is not a side band of Tool. Billy Howerdel created A Perfect Circle and was the lyricist. Maynard James Keenan sang in Tool and APC. Billy Howerdel is the front man and singer in Ashes Divide. ^_^
Pahndora2012 3 years ago 9
oh ok thnx
bucketheadandtoolftw 3 years ago
yeah a side band from tool would be puscifer that is maynards little side project, momma sed i would say is one of my fav. songs on v is for vagina. but this is a very good song from billy.
FreedomMovement77 3 years ago 2
@Pahndora2012 Maynard also was a words man for APC, meaning that he co-wrote most of the songs and where Billy was stuck(like on wording and such.) Maynard helped out.
LiliumCruorem 1 year ago
@Pahndora2012 0_o indeed
MrCorporAtebitch 1 year ago