FAR too many people take that statement for granted with any music, but this song actually has it. This performance sets a high bar for songs that have a lot of emotion... that bar will never be reached by the unending horde of popular "artists" that do not deserve their fame.
You know, until I heard this song today, I never really understood why so many TMG fans liked it so much, but after falling in love and doing long distance, I finally really understand and connect to it. I know exactly what John means when he says "the most remarkable thing about you standing in the doorway is that it's you and that you're standing in the doorway". Thank you, John, for being able to put to words every feeling I've ever experienced in my life.
To see him and the dudes perform right in front of you is a necessary life experience. He has so much energy projecting outward that it's fucking dumbfounding. And don't be surprised if you see people weeping like little babies, it's natural.
The line "The most remarkable thing about you standing in the doorway is that it's you and that you're standing in the doorway" sounds like a sentence from a John Green book. As I incidentally explore John Green's life more and more (In addition to listening to the Mountain Goats, I'm looking into Kenyon for college and their literature sounds like his style) I understand what makes him the brilliant man that he is.
This is the first Mountain Goats song I ever heard- hanging out with a new friend, three doors down in Jenkins Hall, drunk and smoking a hookah. I can't remember what that kid's name was, but he had good taste in music.
@balognaofwin Oh, you are in for such a treat my friend. I almost envy you your coming discoveries. I may just go back through all of my old tMG music to rediscover old lost favorites.
Usually, when I find a band I like, I'll buy two or three songs and then forget about them in a month. I have spent over forty bucks on songs by The Mountain Goats. John Darnielle's lyrics are worth every cent.
Hey I do I do.....But I know what you mean, I'm always auditioning them for my friends..I always start with the funy ones like jenny, or the sign or color in....
@RECHAVEZ He only plays three chords in this song, D, A, and G. The A is sometimes "fancy" by leaving the ring finger in the D chord and letting the e ring open as you move the index and middle to the A shape.
My most basic goal in life is to be able to find someone to drive at night with, listening to music like this. Imagining driving along the east-west interstates so that once we hit the end of the road, after a while, we can turn around and do it again. There's a lot to see and hear in the world, it's unfortunate how difficult it can be to find someone to share it all with.
I was there with the little garage door in the back of the shop raised up just a little alcove with a stool and a mic and him playing; this was an amazing place to be. The heckler smelled strongly of bad beer, and eventually wandered out. It was so jam packed in there.
ive never met a person who even knows about the mountain goats let alone listens to them or likes them one day i just want to meet some person somewhere who knows who John Darnielle is and thinks as highly of him as i do. That would make my day.
Lots of Aussies love the Mountain goats... an alternative radio station JJJ picked them up years ago and made them a feature. They have toured here a few times as well
I LOVE this man! have since I was 16. JD can help get you through some of the most difficult times of your life. Some cling to Jesus, I cling to The Mountain Goats.
@justinjrozinek God, me too. Even when I do meet someone who "likes" The Mountain Goats or listens to them, there's always this moment where I get SO excited and clasp their hands in mine and expect basically that they hold John Darnielle in as high esteem as I do (which is like spot #1 in my list of life-changing people) and... they always say something like, "Oh, yeah they're pretty good." Or, "Who's John Darnielle?"
Maybe we'll run into each other someday and make each others' days. :P
@justinjrozinek i finaly spoke to someone today that knew the goats. but it was the first time other than the girl who had originaly put me on to them and the 1 person who I then showed them to. But that's it. I know what you mean. they are a very obscure band.
@justinjrozinek try and make friends with some nerdfighters (look up the vlogbrothers). John Green is a big Mountain Goats fan and i'm sure plenty of nerdfighters are too :)
Do they never come and play in Ireland? I now live in Ireland and have consistently missed Darnielle for a good long while in England before that.We should force the man to play.
unfortunately they don't. but i live in ireland too, and i went to london to see them last september, and i just saw them in manchester three days ago. you should come with, next time i hop off somewhere to go see john.
My name is Lonna Marie and if you like this song you might find some of my music equally intriguing. I'm very influenced by Sara Bareillis, Lily Allen, Ingrid Michaelson and other artists of their nature. If you have a moment, visit my page and take a listen! Let me know what you think :) Thanks for taking the time and hope you can find something to your liking!
"The most remarkable thing about you standing in the doorway is that it's you and that you're standing in the doorway" is one of the most brilliant lyrics ever written.
I can see why he's sick of playing this song but it's so rich with meaning and it means so much to people I don't see how he'll ever be able to stop playing it.
I love the song, but I see his point. He wrote it ages ago, and tMG fans get obnoxious about requesting this at shows. I understand wanting to play stuff you haven't played a trillion times, or wanting to play the new stuff that you're actually excited about playing.
But goddamn, if this song isn't phenomenal, I don't know what is.
That smile, it's so winsome.
amphitritie 1 month ago
MODEST MOUSE MEETS DON MCLEAN
0wnage55885 1 month ago
Going to Georgia.....
miguelcsi 2 months ago in playlist The Mountain Goats
\m/ O_O \m/
psykokimera 2 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for The Mountain Goats
I'll put this simply, This song has Emotion...
FAR too many people take that statement for granted with any music, but this song actually has it. This performance sets a high bar for songs that have a lot of emotion... that bar will never be reached by the unending horde of popular "artists" that do not deserve their fame.
thechad899 3 months ago
@thechad899 Well said darling.
LongviewCovers13 1 month ago
You know, until I heard this song today, I never really understood why so many TMG fans liked it so much, but after falling in love and doing long distance, I finally really understand and connect to it. I know exactly what John means when he says "the most remarkable thing about you standing in the doorway is that it's you and that you're standing in the doorway". Thank you, John, for being able to put to words every feeling I've ever experienced in my life.
sonorpaiste702 3 months ago
This just gave me chills.
eclipticstarsign 4 months ago
I love the live version quite a bit more then the studio version.
KingTutle 6 months ago
Aesop Rock sent me here. I never heard of this guy, and now I cant get enough!!
whitemus 6 months ago 7
So freaking awesome.
iheartyoursoul 6 months ago
Comment removed
tma2290 6 months ago
This is hands down my favourite recording/performance of this song.
The world shines...
k386 6 months ago
5 people don't have two big hands and a heart pumping blood and a 1967 colt .45 with a busted safety catch
Ivellios45 7 months ago
@Ivellios45 That probably a bigger group than your estimate.
masterochicken 6 months ago
I'm from Macon County, GA. It's capable of doing this to one.
32kcollie 7 months ago 2
how the hell does he smile through that song?
whitedronnie 7 months ago
well im Australian and love the Mountain Goats
fearlessfergi 8 months ago
First and still all time fav mountian goats song of the 51+ albums owned.
IAmKMan83 8 months ago
Every song John Darnielle sings feels like having an unforgettable conversation
SergeantCoodles 8 months ago 3
To see him and the dudes perform right in front of you is a necessary life experience. He has so much energy projecting outward that it's fucking dumbfounding. And don't be surprised if you see people weeping like little babies, it's natural.
Bleepbloopd 8 months ago 2
@Bleepbloopd
I have, and I did.
IAmKMan83 8 months ago
AND YOU SMILE AS YOU EASE THE GUN FROM MY HAND I'M FROZEN WITH JOY RIGHT WHERE I STAND
W95thStreetHigh 8 months ago
i motherfucking love the mountain goats
coheedguitarist 8 months ago
I love this song so much...he reminds me SO much of Loudon Wainwright III, which, believe me is a compliment. John Darnielle is AWESOME!!
suesjoy 9 months ago
The line "The most remarkable thing about you standing in the doorway is that it's you and that you're standing in the doorway" sounds like a sentence from a John Green book. As I incidentally explore John Green's life more and more (In addition to listening to the Mountain Goats, I'm looking into Kenyon for college and their literature sounds like his style) I understand what makes him the brilliant man that he is.
annaslater11 9 months ago
This is the first Mountain Goats song I ever heard- hanging out with a new friend, three doors down in Jenkins Hall, drunk and smoking a hookah. I can't remember what that kid's name was, but he had good taste in music.
captainbadd 9 months ago
This man is a legend of a poet. I've only heard three of his songs so far and I can already see that. No question.
balognaofwin 9 months ago 5
@balognaofwin Oh, you are in for such a treat my friend. I almost envy you your coming discoveries. I may just go back through all of my old tMG music to rediscover old lost favorites.
OhGoditsJoshua 9 months ago
he's like a mad scientist of words
wheremybutchesat 10 months ago 4
Usually, when I find a band I like, I'll buy two or three songs and then forget about them in a month. I have spent over forty bucks on songs by The Mountain Goats. John Darnielle's lyrics are worth every cent.
iAmErica1234 10 months ago 2
Hey I do I do.....But I know what you mean, I'm always auditioning them for my friends..I always start with the funy ones like jenny, or the sign or color in....
mirandashields 10 months ago
4 people don't wanna go to Georgia
jallison71 10 months ago
best love song ever
amberfosho 10 months ago
"Going to Georgia"? Haven't you seen the movie Deliverance? Just don't get lost in the woods, and act like you're not a yankee
anothercountyheard 11 months ago
2:35 BEST FACE EVER LOL i love john!
pangodango 1 year ago 3
"and you smile as you ease the gun from my hand and i'm frozen with joy right where i stand"
I love this line, simple yet meaningful.
Best song ever.
jondst01 1 year ago
@slayerxofx1xCA
And that's a terrible thing.
TiniestViolin 1 year ago
Adore
hinessa 1 year ago
All people who have seen John Darnielle in person deserve to be envied.
obermegalutschoar 1 year ago 3
My friend started a TMG cover band.Needless to say I killed him :)
chazfourlife 1 year ago 4
John Darnielle is such a good writer that it actually infuriates me.
razorlikeblue 1 year ago 5
i do.
cactusjoerock 1 year ago
What chords is he playing? All the tabs ive looked up sounds wrong, such A great song though I wish I could play it.
RECHAVEZ 1 year ago
@RECHAVEZ He only plays three chords in this song, D, A, and G. The A is sometimes "fancy" by leaving the ring finger in the D chord and letting the e ring open as you move the index and middle to the A shape.
baraka1408 1 year ago
Thank you very much!
RECHAVEZ 1 year ago
What hole in the ground are you from, justinjrozinek?
bongzuki 1 year ago
One of the best living song writers.
tofubandito 1 year ago
Wow. This man never fails to send shivers down my spine. I wish I was there for this.
adamsayswhat 1 year ago 2
@powerage112 and @haircut74
I could not agree more :)
barefootJoyful 1 year ago
My most basic goal in life is to be able to find someone to drive at night with, listening to music like this. Imagining driving along the east-west interstates so that once we hit the end of the road, after a while, we can turn around and do it again. There's a lot to see and hear in the world, it's unfortunate how difficult it can be to find someone to share it all with.
powerage112 1 year ago 68
@powerage112 you and me both, friend.
haircut74 1 year ago
@powerage112 I think that's every sensible person's dream. I can't see it coming true for me though
Thunderwolf666 5 months ago
I love the audiences' gasps when that smart ass interupted
boiledhooker 1 year ago
I was there with the little garage door in the back of the shop raised up just a little alcove with a stool and a mic and him playing; this was an amazing place to be. The heckler smelled strongly of bad beer, and eventually wandered out. It was so jam packed in there.
ThoughtChild 1 year ago
I'm a big fan of the Atom & His Package take on this song as well! Love the MG's
Comichorrorkaijuman 1 year ago
the passion is breathtaking.
paddybowman 1 year ago 4
he handled that heckler very well
boiledhooker 1 year ago 4
The way he sings really loud is just perfect.
ExoticHex 1 year ago
Sometimes this song makes things easier.
k386 1 year ago 28
Infuckingcredible.
bloodymaria66 1 year ago
Goose Bumps.
All Over.
michaelmooreamhs 1 year ago 3
i looked at someone i love very much and held his hand and looked into his eyes and smiled to this song
<3
ohheyella123 1 year ago 3
THE BEST!
Nic33rd 1 year ago 3
I just love how he talks absolutely nothing like how he sings.
AnAmericanFamily 1 year ago 5
"the most remarkable thing about coming home to you, is the feeling of being in motion again."
...beautiful.
madley16 1 year ago 10
heya, brand new fan loving this
ehustee 2 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This guy looks like Evan Baxter from bruce all mighty
blingbunnyman 2 years ago
haha, when he plays it in this key, it's the same chord progression as Crane Wife 3. I giggled.
thejohnsontreatment 2 years ago 7
I know we have the worst audiences ever, but please come to AZ sometime soon, I missed you the last time.
SpeedWobbleStudios 2 years ago 6
I can't wait for them to come to Georgia Nov 21st. Your always welcomed here Mountain Goats.
somethingnewcxb 2 years ago
What was the name of the song they played on the Colbert Report this week?
mikedowd420 2 years ago
ah i didnt know they were on Colbert Report! what was the occasion, a new album?
NedGayle 2 years ago
ive never met a person who even knows about the mountain goats let alone listens to them or likes them one day i just want to meet some person somewhere who knows who John Darnielle is and thinks as highly of him as i do. That would make my day.
justinjrozinek 2 years ago 167
I love the Mountain Goats. I'm now going to spread the word :)
Guranga22 2 years ago 3
Lots of Aussies love the Mountain goats... an alternative radio station JJJ picked them up years ago and made them a feature. They have toured here a few times as well
Luckylessboy1 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
NO ONE...thinks MORE highly of John Darniellle THEN me..I carried his lyrics around with me EVERYWHERE I went...(I JUST lost the note book) :DDDDD
smoothbebop89 2 years ago
@justinjrozinek I'm on my way.
LunerRyu 1 year ago
@justinjrozinek Dude, just PM my sister, ClemTheTangerine. She listens to them like every day.
Sonny457859 1 year ago
@justinjrozinek That would be my father and me.
TheKiguy 1 year ago
I LOVE this man! have since I was 16. JD can help get you through some of the most difficult times of your life. Some cling to Jesus, I cling to The Mountain Goats.
WEtranceLA 1 year ago 11
@WEtranceLA can't agree more my friend...he's gotten me through some tough times
mikevincedaveEMO 1 year ago
@justinjrozinek Me too.
hithakar 1 year ago
@justinjrozinek you must not get out much
Mrowlshoes 11 months ago
@justinjrozinek God, me too. Even when I do meet someone who "likes" The Mountain Goats or listens to them, there's always this moment where I get SO excited and clasp their hands in mine and expect basically that they hold John Darnielle in as high esteem as I do (which is like spot #1 in my list of life-changing people) and... they always say something like, "Oh, yeah they're pretty good." Or, "Who's John Darnielle?"
Maybe we'll run into each other someday and make each others' days. :P
avocadopye 11 months ago 2
@justinjrozinek hey guy i know who they are and i love em
Pizzaman45157 11 months ago
@justinjrozinek We are out here, friend.
The6stringKid 9 months ago
@The6stringKid indeed
peace4annie 8 months ago
@justinjrozinek i finaly spoke to someone today that knew the goats. but it was the first time other than the girl who had originaly put me on to them and the 1 person who I then showed them to. But that's it. I know what you mean. they are a very obscure band.
kswone1 7 months ago
@justinjrozinek That happened to me, and that person is the love of my life.
Never give up hope.
SenorSlopez 7 months ago
@justinjrozinek try and make friends with some nerdfighters (look up the vlogbrothers). John Green is a big Mountain Goats fan and i'm sure plenty of nerdfighters are too :)
RTown88 6 months ago 5
My Favorite Mountain Goats song!
myndae 2 years ago 2
This just sounds so damn good every time I hear it. Excellent!
OswaldvonWolkenstein 2 years ago 2
this version>studio version
JAPrice91 2 years ago 6
John is the best singer/songwriter of this generation
centralbeaver 2 years ago 12
Great Stuff --- fantastic -- Thanks!!
OswaldvonWolkenstein 2 years ago
Was just reminiscing that we discovered The Mountain Goats through Atom and His Package's cover of this song (and The Seed Song). hee!
barkon 2 years ago
i fucking love those covers!
NedGayle 2 years ago
By Odin's beard, the mountain goats are so freakin' awesome! They're, that is John, are so metal...you know, in their hearts, they're freaking metal!
mnkeyfeetz 2 years ago 2
thanks for all these videos mocarrion, so good to see some good quality live Mountain Goats. probably never get to see em live in Ireland 8(
funkyc9 2 years ago 2
Do they never come and play in Ireland? I now live in Ireland and have consistently missed Darnielle for a good long while in England before that.We should force the man to play.
Kidnap?
DanceToTheRadio 2 years ago 2
unfortunately they don't. but i live in ireland too, and i went to london to see them last september, and i just saw them in manchester three days ago. you should come with, next time i hop off somewhere to go see john.
starlitstarlet 2 years ago
Certainly.Whereabouts are you in Ireland? I'm in Belfast.
It's rocking.
DanceToTheRadio 2 years ago
Me too! Oh man, that's awesome. Hey, you should also check out the video I just uploaded of tMG in Mancs.
starlitstarlet 2 years ago
Thank you so much mocarrion :D This is prob. one of the best live shows I've seen on YT.
delusionaldiminutive 2 years ago 11
lol dude in the front is an asshole
psnapplebee 2 years ago 11
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey everyone!
My name is Lonna Marie and if you like this song you might find some of my music equally intriguing. I'm very influenced by Sara Bareillis, Lily Allen, Ingrid Michaelson and other artists of their nature. If you have a moment, visit my page and take a listen! Let me know what you think :) Thanks for taking the time and hope you can find something to your liking!
Check out my COVER of MGMT!!!!!
Thanks for the support!!!!
Be sure to comment & SUBSCRIBE! :)
Lonna Marie
lonnamarie 2 years ago
"The most remarkable thing about you standing in the doorway is that it's you and that you're standing in the doorway" is one of the most brilliant lyrics ever written.
I can see why he's sick of playing this song but it's so rich with meaning and it means so much to people I don't see how he'll ever be able to stop playing it.
TheMysteriousMrZ 3 years ago 106
Speaking of which, get the fuck out of my doorway. And put down the cat.
NecrosisOfLight 3 years ago 12
Hahaha
TheDeathSage 3 years ago 6
I agree with it being an amazing lyric. It's just fucking awesome. Stuff like this makes me want to simply write
Assaultpredator 2 years ago 8
@TheMysteriousMrZ He played this last week when he was in Atlanta, it made me so happy.
Jokrmein 9 months ago
it brings tears to the eye
WelfareChrist 3 years ago 8
This is the first time I've ever heard this song live where you can actually hear him singing over the audience.
carasmom101 3 years ago
this man loves music
rifleriverkilla 3 years ago 7
goddamn, is there anything better in the world than the music of john darnielle?
STRXKTB 3 years ago 3
Perhaps the music of Bob Dylan, but it's really close :)
But this song really hits home for me because I have a dear friend in Georgia that I really want to go see :(
blithium 3 years ago
beating chelsea 2 nil in the league on sunday, but other than that not much....
fivepointsix 3 years ago
My favorite one is "going to bolivia" from SWEDEN
Backenbart78 3 years ago
If he didn't want to do songs too many times,maybe the man needs to stop writing such damn good songs.
It's simple really.
DanceToTheRadio 3 years ago 4
*sigh* I'd love to go to Georgia right now to see an old friend of mine. *sigh again*
blithium 3 years ago
i think he often looks like crispin glover.....especially at this set.
P.S. is there a just audio recording of this
floating around the web?
stwongbad85 3 years ago
you can rip the audio from this. just google 'rip youtube audio' and pick a website
drfredjones 3 years ago
He looks so pained when he's starting off the song! Like 'Oh god, I have to play this song *again*'
Great song, but I'm sad that he's so sick of playing it.
meghequalscool 3 years ago
he once said he wished he'd never written it - except that people love it so much
zander019 3 years ago
I love the song, but I see his point. He wrote it ages ago, and tMG fans get obnoxious about requesting this at shows. I understand wanting to play stuff you haven't played a trillion times, or wanting to play the new stuff that you're actually excited about playing.
But goddamn, if this song isn't phenomenal, I don't know what is.
meghequalscool 3 years ago 2
this song makes me cry
hyperform2 3 years ago
There are very few songwriters who can pull off the "Standing in the doorway" line. John is one of them.
MrDelirious 3 years ago 5
best f'in living songwriter
trappermark 3 years ago 9
i agree
SpeedWobbleStudios 3 years ago
Looks like my old communications/media teacher. That guy was rad.
KimJongSick 3 years ago 2
John Darnielle bears a remarkable resemblance to Brian Wilson crossed with
Brian Ferry of Roxy Music.
He also looks a little like that Irish actor in the movie with Kaiser Soshei, or something like that.
Sincerely,
The Legendary Danny O'Doul
dannyodoul 3 years ago 2
You rock butt for posting this. Weehoo!
jimmyslaysdragons 3 years ago 4
Amazing. I love that man.
mmcglenn 3 years ago 4